Idris had promised to pass the salt, and on the fifth of January, at half past six in the evening, with the harbor black and glittering under a rim of frost, he did.
It was Dagny’s doing. She had announced on the third that there would be a dinner. She did not say why, and nobody cared to ask; Dagny Oake, announcing a dinner, has the manner of a woman declaring a siege. She had commandeered the wardroom of Mercy Pending, scrubbed the long table till the grain stood up like corduroy, and borrowed seven chairs, two of them from the harbor chapel.
At the head of the table, on a folded sailcloth where the captain would ordinarily sit, she set a soup tureen with a lemon in its lid, a plate in front of it, a knife and a fork, a glass of water, and a napkin.
It was a table laid for one. It was exactly the table in the Underhall. I stood in the door and looked at it for a long moment, and I understood what she had done and why she had not said so.
Then she went back to the galley and returned with a second plate, a second glass, and a second chair. She set them down at the Prince’s elbow with a thump.
“There,” said Dagny. “Now it is laid for two. If the Admiral wants to talk to a tureen he can do it with his supper in front of him like a Christian.”
“I did not ask for a chair,” said Idris, who had come in behind me.
“No. You asked for nothing. That is the trouble with you.” She wiped her hands on her apron. “Sit down.”
---
There were nine of us, and a cat.
Odette sat at the foot, in her gray coat with its empty sleeve pinned, and Mercy at her right hand, wearing a borrowed blue jersey and a look of intense concentration. She had been shown the fork twice. She did not need to be shown. I think that she wanted to be shown, and Odette, who understood this before I did, had done it again without a word.
Tuck was on the bench by the bulkhead with his log, which Dagny had permitted at table on condition that he did not write in the stew. Hale sat opposite, stiff as a plank, with the Pen laid beside his knife.
And at the end of the table nearest the stove, in the chair that had been brought from the chapel, sat Corvin Ashgrove with his hands in his lap, a napkin tucked into his collar, and a faint look of apology on his round pink face as of a man who has been invited to a feast in his own honor and does not feel that he has quite earned it.
“It is very kind,” he said, for the fourth time.
“Eat your stew,” said Dagny.
“I am so sorry. I will.”
It was a very good stew. I will say that; it was lamb and barley, with a great many onions, and it had been simmering since noon. The wardroom was warm, and smelled of onions and pipe smoke and wet wool, and the lamp swung a little on its chain with the ship’s easy motion at her mooring. For the space of a quarter of an hour, nobody spoke of anything that mattered.
Tuck told Ashgrove that the cat’s name was Debit, that it had been decided by vote, and that he, Tuck, had abstained. Mercy ate her barley seed by seed. Odette watched her do it, and her face was something I had not seen on it before, and have no word for.
It was the Prince who spoke first.
“I should like to say,” said Calloran, in the voice of a man delivering a speech that he has rehearsed in the bath, “that I have not been given a meal since the year of the old Queen’s coronation. I do not know how it is done. I understand that one ordinarily has a mouth.”
“You do not have a mouth,” said Tuck.
“I am aware.”
“Then it is just company.”
“I find that I do not mind.” The lemon dipped. “Admiral. If it is not a trouble.”
Idris put down his spoon. He looked at the tureen for a moment, with the lamplight on his face. Then he reached across the table with his good hand, took up the little pewter salt-cellar by the bread, and held it out, over the cloth, to the plate that had no food on it.
“Salt, Your Highness,” said Idris Brand. “I believe that I was holding it for you.”
Nobody said anything. In the stove, a log settled.
“Thank you,” said Calloran, very quietly. “That is exactly what I wanted.”
---
It was after the stew, over a plum tart of Dagny’s that nobody dared to refuse, that I asked.
I had been turning it over since the ebb. I had meant to wait. I had meant to let them have the tart, and the lamp, and the cat in Mercy’s lap, and let one evening go by in which the sea was not in the room. But I looked at the card in my pocket, the small stiff white one that Hale had given me, with its four words in a leaning hand, and I found that I could not make myself sit still.
“Your Highness,” I said. “May I ask you something?”
“You may always ask me something, Miss Keel. It is the answering that I have found to be difficult.”
“What else were you never asked?”
The wardroom had gone quiet. I had not raised my voice. But I think everybody there had been waiting for it, in the way one waits for a bell that has been silent a long while, and Hale took up his Pen and looked at it as if it might do something.
“You said that you omitted the child,” I went on. “Because nobody had asked about her. You said that it was the rule of the court. You never lied; you simply did not say. I should like to know what else is in the part you did not say.”
“That is a fair question.”
“Is it a hard one?”
“It is the hardest that I have ever been asked.” The lemon was very still. “I have had three hundred years to think about the answer, and the trouble is that it was not any one thing. It was a manner. I was a prince. I was told that the proper behavior of a prince is that he does not volunteer.
He is consulted. He answers what is put to him, exactly, and no more, and a great deal of harm is done by what is never put.” He gave the small dry sound that was his laugh. “I do not think that I ever once said a false thing. I thought that it was a kind of honor.”
“It was a kind of cowardice,” said Odette. She said it in a low, level voice from the foot of the table. “I have been told by a clerk that I am not permitted to apologize. I will say it nevertheless. It cost my daughter thirty-eight years.”
“Yes,” said Calloran. “It did.”
Hale cleared his throat. He had been trying to do it for some minutes, and the Pen had gone round and round between his fingers. “I am obliged to remind the table,” he said, “that the Court’s notice runs out at the spring ebb of the eighth. That is three days. I have written to Mr. Venn for an extension, and he has written back that the form for an extension has been signed by nobody but Seal-keeper Greaves’s deputy.”
“Three days,” said Tuck, and wrote it down, and underlined it.
“I have been counting them since the notice came,” said Mercy. She laid down her fork, with great care, parallel to the knife. “I count as the sea does. It is the one habit I mean to keep.” She looked at her mother. “I should like it not to be spoken of tonight. I should like to have one supper first.”
“Then we will have one,” said Odette, and pushed the tart toward her.
“Do you wish me to say that I forgive you?”
“I would rather that you did not, if you do not mean it. I am only just learning what it is to be given the truth.” The tureen shifted on its sailcloth. “I should like to give it. Not as a favor. Not as payment. I should like to give it because I am sitting at a table and it has been put in front of me, and I find that I am hungry.”
---
“There is a vault under the Tallyhouse,” I said. “It holds ninety-three drawers that no foundling accounts for. Ninety-two are blank. The ninety-third has a label, and on the third a card was tied to it by a clerk who knows the lock. It says, NOT TO BE CALLED.”
Calloran did not move.
“I have it here.” I laid the card on the cloth between the tart and the cat. “It is the same. Word for word. The sea says that it did not write it. It says that the drawers above are not its. I believe it. I think that if the sea had made them it would have been quite open about it, and told me that it had thought about it.”
“The drawers above,” said Calloran, and his voice had changed. It had gone very flat and distant, like a man reading a name on a stone. “I had hoped that it was only a rumor.”
“Then you know them.”
“I know of them. I have never seen them.” The lemon turned toward Ashgrove, and back. “Mr. Ashgrove. You were raised on the Foundling Stair.”
“I was.” Ashgrove had turned the color of the tablecloth. “I was found there. I am so sorry. I did not know that it mattered.”
“Do you know what it is for?”
“It is for the foundlings, Your Highness. For the children who are left. It is a place to put them so that they may be seen.” He swallowed. “It is a kindness. I always thought that it was one of the few that the Quay had.”
“It was built the same winter as the Drowned Stair,” said Calloran. “The year of the Founders’ first loan. It was cut by the same masons, with the same iron, to the same measure. I remember the masons, because they asked me to lay a stone. I did not. I was told that it was a charity.” He paused. “I have never been down it.”
“No one has, but Mr. Ashgrove,” said Idris slowly. “And that was only the lowest step.”
“No. Someone has.” Calloran had begun to speak very precisely, like a man who is carrying a full bowl across a room. “Someone has been writing in it, in a left-leaning hand, for a very long time. I would give a great deal to know who. But I think that I can tell you what it is for.”
---
I want to set down exactly how he said it, because I have thought of it every day since.
He did not say it at once. He asked, first, for something. He asked to be put down on the floor, on the planking beside the stove, where he could feel the ship’s motion under his base; and Idris did it, kneeling, with the tureen held in his one good arm, and set him on the boards with the lemon straight. He asked for the lamp to be turned down. He asked Mercy to take the cat out, and she said no, and he said, “Quite right.”
Then he said, “I have given my word to say what is. It has a price. I had not understood that.”
“What price?” said Hale.
“I am the host.” The lemon dipped, slowly, as a man might touch his hat. “That is what I have been for three hundred years, sir. The Prince’s Chair is not an empty seat. It is a place for the host of the Stair. I make the rules of a visit. I hold the door. I say who may come, and in what manner, and when they must go.”
His voice was dry as paper. “It is the one thing that I have kept. And it is a thing that was never given to me. I took it, in the first year, because no one else was there to say. It was my one illegality.”
“And you wish to give it up.”
“I wish to be a guest.” The Prince’s voice shook very slightly. “I wish to sit at a table and be passed the salt. It is not a thing that a host may do. A host is the one who passes.”
“Calloran,” I said.
“The price is the Chair. I give up the host’s place. I do not know whether the sea will accept it.” He drew breath, if a tureen can be said to. “I find that I should rather have one supper at a table than be master of a house with no one in it.”
And I felt it then, under my chair, through the soles of my boots, in the keel of the ship: a long, slow, enormous shift, like a great animal turning over in its sleep. The water in the glass at his place trembled. The cat in Mercy’s lap put up its bald head.
“I accept it,” said the sea. It was the child’s voice, but it came from the glass, very small. “I did not know that it could be given. I should like to say that I will pass the salt.” There was a pause that was almost shy. “I have never passed anything.”
Calloran made a sound that I can only call a sob, in a tureen, with a lemon on its lid. Nobody looked at him. Nobody was able to.
---
“Tell me what the Foundling Stair is for,” I said. I said it very gently.
“It was built to return.” He said it in the voice of a man at the top of a long fall. “That is the first thing. The Drowned Stair receives. It goes down; the sea comes up it; it takes what it is given. The other goes the opposite way. It is a stair that is built to give back.”
“To give back what?”
“Children.” The word fell on the table. “The Founders were afraid. It was in the first generation, when the loan was new, and the Pyles had a first daughter, and the sea had asked for the first daughter. A Pyle could not give her. It was against all that they had sworn. And so they made a second stair, above the first, and they put the children of nobody on it.
They left them there, in the cold, with a heel of bread. And at the turn of each generation they sent the nurse down, with a lamp, to see which of them had been taken back.”
“By the sea.”
“By the sea. By the one who was owed.” He said it very softly. “It was a tithe. The Quay called it a charity. It was the cheapest sum that the Founders ever did. They found a way for the price to be paid in children that no one would ask after. And the sea, which is exact, took them as it was given them, and did not know that anything was wrong.”
I felt Mercy go rigid, across the table. I felt Odette take her wrist.
“It stopped,” said Hale. His voice was high and cracked. “It must have. The Black Collecting was the last. The Court said so.”
“The Black Collecting was the last time the sea took a child from the Quay.” The lemon turned, slowly, toward the lamp. “It was not the last time it was offered one. I do not think that the Foundling Stair ever stopped. I think that someone has been keeping it open. I think that someone has been keeping the drawers.”
“Drawers for what?” said Tuck.
I knew that the question was not for me. But I answered it, because I saw that he had already understood, and that he was holding his log in both fists, so tightly that his knuckles shone.
“Ninety-three,” I said. “A drawer is made when a child is chosen. Not when a child is taken. They are not empty. They are reserved.”
“Yes,” said Calloran. “That is what I am afraid of.”
“And the ninety-third?”
“Is yours, Miss Keel,” said the Prince, in the dark, with the whole wardroom listening. “It was opened sixty days ago. I think that someone has been waiting a very long time to say that you were not to be called, and a very short time to find out what you would do when they did.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!