Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 11

Claimant’s Attachment

Claims Handling Standard 11(c): On written request, a claimant is entitled to a complete copy of every document in his own claim file, attachments included, within five business days. The insurer may withhold only privileged material, and must say which.

I typed that sentence into a hundred denial letters. It was the polite part. You sent the claimant his file with a cover note and a smile in the typeface, and then you waited for him to read it and discover the reasons. At 6:41 on Monday morning I stand in a livestock trailer outside Hollis Junction, Nebraska, and decide to use it for the first time on the side of the person it was written for.

First I have to wake him.

Soren is asleep in the fourth pew of the Chapel of the Open Road under one of Ruth’s quilts, with his gray coat on over his clothes and his shoes lined up on the cinder-block step beneath him, toes together. Somebody has put a space heater at the end of the pew. The CB on the altar murmurs to itself, a trucker in Ogallala describing a deer in the road to nobody. A stripe of blue light comes through the plexiglass window and lies on his face.

He sleeps like a man filing something. I watch him for a full minute, which I would not do to a stranger, and then I do what I practiced on the ride over from Birdie’s office. I write the card first, so I can’t change it.

It is an index card from the lost-and-found shelf, with a pizza stain in the corner. In block capitals, the way I’d write a claim number, it says: MONDAY, NOV. 16. YOU ARE SOREN LINDQVIST. YOU ARE ILL. YOU ARE SAFE. I AM JOANNA PRUITT. I AM NOT KIND. I AM EXACT.

I sit on the end of the pew and say, “Mr. Lindqvist.”

His eyes open. They are gray and clear and the first second in them is the best second of the day, because he doesn’t know yet. He looks at the roof of the trailer, at the cross-braces of a cattle hauler holding a church up. Then he finds me, and I watch the courtesy arrive.

“Good morning,” he says. “I’m so sorry. I don’t believe we’ve been introduced.”

“We haven’t,” I say. “Not this morning. It is 6:41. It’s Monday. I’m Joanna Pruitt. Jo. I work for no one, which is relevant later. You are Soren Lindqvist, you are thirty-seven years old, and you are in a trailer in Nebraska that is also a church. You are safe. I’m going to tell you five more things, and then you can ask me anything, and I will answer all of it truthfully, and I won’t soften any of it.”

He sits up slowly. He takes the card I hold out. He reads it twice, with his lips, the way a man reads a menu in a language he used to know.

“Five more things,” he says.

“You have a disease that takes your memory. You will forget me many times today. You have a key, sixty-four words, and some people want it. I’m the one helping you keep it. And you asked me, once, not to be kind to you out of pity.” I stop. “I’m trying to keep my side of that.”

He lowers the card. He turns it over, looks at the pizza stain, turns it back.

“Is it bad,” he says. “The disease.”

“Yes.”

“How bad?”

“You’ve lost two of the nine rooms, the attic in August and the basement yesterday morning. You have good hours and bad hours. This is a bad one. In my notes you had forty-seven minutes of good hour yesterday afternoon, and ninety the day before.”

“Your notes,” says Soren. “You keep notes on my good hours.”

“I keep notes on everything. Don’t take it personally.”

Something happens in his face. It isn’t quite a smile. It’s the place where a smile would go. “That is the first thing anyone has said to me this morning that was not a kindness,” he says. “Thank you. It is easier.”

“It’s not meant to be easier. It’s meant to be accurate.”

“Yes. That is what I meant.”

I take the paper boat out of my coat. It’s the pie-box one, the one he left in my pocket on Wednesday and put back into his own fist on the plowed shoulder, and which I took out of his hand while he slept, because it seemed to me the most important document in the state of Nebraska.

It’s gone soft at the creases. I unfold it flat on my knee, and on the inside, in pencil, I print a few lines. Then I fold it again, crease, crease, tuck, and hold it out.

“Open it when you lose track,” I say. “Not before.”

He opens it at once, because he is who he is. He reads the inside. I can’t see the words, but I wrote them, and I know them. It is Monday. Joanna Pruitt is your adjuster. Ask her for the kitchen.

“Ask you for the kitchen,” says Soren.

I close my eyes, the way I do, and I give it to him. The kitchen, the north window with frost on the glass and a ladder drawn in it with one rung missing, the clock over the stove stopped at ten past four. Seven oranges in a blue bowl. I hear his breath change at the oranges.

“The third from the left is bruised,” he says.

“I ate it. Saturday night. For the record.”

“Then the record has changed,” says Soren gravely, and I understand that I have made a joke he can’t find the beginning of, and that he is laughing at it anyway, a small cracked sound, because he can tell that it was one.

He doesn’t know me. I knew he wouldn’t. I put my hand flat on the pew to hold it still, and I stand up, and I say, “Breakfast is in the Skillet. Birdie will tell you her name. She’ll tell you again if you lose it.”

“And you?”

“I’ll be the one with the legal pad.”

The Skillet at 7:30 is the hour of the long-haul men with coffee in both hands, and most of them have heard something. They look at me the way you look at a woman who put forty trucks in a ditch on a Sunday for a man in a good coat.

Nobody says anything. A trucker I don’t know sets a slice of coconut pie in front of my empty stool without being asked and walks away. Birdie, behind the register in a cardigan the color of pea soup, tips her head at the back.

“Your father’s in the dish pit,” she says. “I told him if he stole a fork I’d weigh him.”

“Did he take one?”

“Counted forty-one.” She meets my eyes over her glasses on their beaded chain. “Be easy, baby. He’s been up since four. He asked me for a mop, and he’s never in his life asked anyone for a mop.”

Dale is up to his elbows in gray water, in a Prairie Star apron over a shirt a size too young. He’s whistling. He stops whistling when he sees me, because I have the face I use on kitchen tables, and he knows it from the other side.

“I want to talk to you about the vault,” he says.

“You don’t know about the vault.”

“I know there’s a vault.” He takes his hands out of the water and wipes them slowly on the apron. His knuckles are red. “Walk in last night, they were all talking about it. Jo, listen. Closed-claims records. You know how those rooms work? Nobody guards them. Nobody guards boring paper.

“A man in a gray jacket with a clipboard and a face like a bad tooth walks past a counter at 4:50 on a Thursday and nobody looks up, I’ve done it in four states. I get in there with a coffee, I find the shelf, I walk out, and by the time they see the gap I’m playing cribbage in Council Bluffs.”

“No.”

“Here’s the beautiful part.” He stops. He puts his tongue in his cheek, like a man who has bitten it. “Strike that. The part where I said that.”

“You’re getting better at it,” I say.

“I’m getting caught earlier.” He looks at his wet hands. “I could do it clean, Josie.”

“There’s no such thing.” I lean on the steel counter. The dish machine hisses behind us. “Listen to me. Four days ago I deleted fourteen seconds from a recording because I believed it would help a man. It did. And a man in a cashmere coat took my badge, my license and my phone for it, in front of three hundred people, and I deserved it.

“You know what I do with a piece of paper that arrives by theft? I throw it out. It’s tainted, and it doesn’t matter what it says. A judge won’t look at it, and Pike’s lawyers will say we forged it, and they’ll be right about how we got it. If those last two rooms come out of that vault, they come out the front door, with a signature, and a receipt.”

“A receipt.”

“A receipt. It’s the only thing I trust.”

He looks at me for a while. I’ve known his face for thirty-two years and I’ve seen it do every trick it has. This one is new. He just looks tired, and old, and a little hurt, and he doesn’t try to make it into a pitch.

“All right,” says Dale. “No theft.” He nods slowly. “But I’ll tell you something for free. Records rooms always run on one person. Never the boss. Some woman in the basement who’s been there nineteen years and has a sick mother and a mortgage. You want that vault open, you don’t pick the lock. You find the clerk.”

It’s good advice. That’s the unfortunate part. I thank him, which costs me something, and go to find a fax machine.

Birdie’s fax is a beige thing with a handset, older than Kayla, which lives on a filing cabinet in the back office next to the feed-store calendar. It takes eleven seconds to warm up. I use the time to do the part I’m best at: I think like the other side.

A request under 11(c) goes to the closed-claims desk at Harrow & Pike’s Omaha tower. It will be date-stamped, logged, and copied to Legal, and Legal will copy it to Cyrus Pike within the hour, because Pike reads everything that has Soren Lindqvist’s name on it. I know this. I do it anyway. I promised to be silent about page 18.

I never promised to be silent about my own claim. And a request that Pike refuses is a different animal from a request he doesn’t know about. It’s a letter, and a letter has a date, and a denial letter is a gift. Every one he signs goes in a folder for a judge.

I write it out in block capitals on the yellow pad. Claimant, Soren A. Lindqvist. Claim 4471-C, Mercy Willows Care Center, Aurora. Request for the complete file including the attachments referenced at items 8 and 9 of the contents list, under Standard 11(c).

Under my own name I write: Prepared by Joanna Pruitt. Not an agent. No authority. Then I take it to the window and read it back, and it looks like what it is, which is a plain request from a woman who has stopped being a professional.

The problem is the signature. I can’t sign for him. He can’t sign in a bad hour, because Pike’s counsel will stand up in some courtroom and say that a man who didn’t know the name of the woman bringing him eggs could not knowingly request a claim file. There is one way to do this, and it is slow. I wait for a good hour.

It arrives at 11:05.

I’m at the counter with the legal pad when I hear the stool beside me creak. He has been eating pie slowly and deliberately for twenty minutes, folding the paper napkin into smaller and smaller squares, and I have been watching his hands and not him. Now they stop. They lie flat on the counter, and he says, in a voice I haven’t heard since Sunday, “Jo.”

I don’t look up right away. I write down the time. “It is 11:05,” I say.

“It is 11:05,” says Soren. “I know it is. I’m here. How long has it been?”

“Since Sunday night. I’ll tell you all of it, but I need your signature first, and I need you to read what you sign. We have about forty minutes. I don’t know how many.”

He reads the request. He reads it all the way down, and then he takes my pen and strikes out three words, Prepared by Joanna, and writes above them, in a quick upright hand: This request is the Claimant’s own. Then he looks at the clock over the pie case and writes the time and the date, and the words in a lucid interval, and underneath that he writes, I understand what I am requesting and why.

“Mr. Pike’s counsel will say I could not have written that,” he says.

“Yes.”

“Then we need people who watched me write it.”

I have been in this business for nine years. I have taken a thousand statements from a thousand liars, and I have never once had a claimant tell me how to build the evidence against his own incapacity. I call it across the diner. “Birdie. Ruth. Augie.”

They come. They don’t ask. Birdie signs first, Bernadette M. Tolliver, owner, in a hand like a stamped receipt. Ruth leans on the counter to write, and I see her knuckles white around the pen, and I see her take a breath before she lets go of the counter edge.

Ruth Ann Beaumont, she writes, and under it, because she can’t stop herself, Mother Goose. Augie, with one hand, braces the paper with the stump of his sleeve and signs Augustus Brandt in letters the size of road signs.

Soren thanks each of them gravely and by name. He has Birdie’s, and Ruth’s, and Augie’s, and he says them as though he is setting them on a shelf. I do not point out that it’s 11:19 and the shelf is going.

I send the fax myself. It’s eleven pages with the cover sheet, because I attach his handwritten page and the witnesses’ page, and the number I dial is from memory. It’s the closed-claims desk in Omaha, a number I dialed forty times a year for nine years and never wrote down.

The machine screams its long dial-up scream, and Soren, standing at my shoulder, watches the paper go into the slot and come out the other side, unchanged, and says, with real wonder, “It is an extraordinary machine. It is a telephone for paper.”

“It’s 11:31,” I say. “Confirmation sheet’s coming.”

“Is this what you do? Send people paper that makes them uncomfortable?”

“It’s all I’ve ever done.”

He nods. The confirmation sheet slides out, a strip of thermal paper with OK in a little box. I fold it and put it in my breast pocket, next to his boat. I put the time in the log: Monday, 11:31 a.m., Request 11(c) transmitted, Omaha closed claims.

“Jo,” says Soren.

“Yes.”

“I’m going to lose the rest of the day.” He says it the way he’d say it was going to rain. “I can feel it. It is like a tide. I thought you should know before it comes in, so that you don’t have to wonder what you did.”

“You don’t have to—”

“I would like to say it.” He turns from the fax machine. His eyes are very clear. “Thank you for coming. I want you to know that I didn’t ask. I should have asked. You are paying for everything, and I never asked.”

“For the record, I’m not in a mood to be thanked.”

“It is 11:52,” says Soren. “For the record, I thank you anyway.”

He keeps his dignity until about 11:55. He walks back through the diner. At the counter he stops, and I watch him look at Birdie, who is slicing a pie, and I watch the look go through her like a man checking his pockets for a key he knows he had.

“Excuse me,” he says. “The lady with the glasses. I’m so sorry. I seem to have lost your name.”

Birdie puts the knife down. She comes around the counter in her cardigan and her good shoes and she takes both his hands in her big red ones, and I have seen her do it to eighteen-year-old boys who’ve lost their jobs and seventy-year-old women whose husbands didn’t come home from the road. “Birdie,” she says. “Bernadette Tolliver. Birdie. I run the place.”

“Birdie.” He says it carefully. “Thank you. I’ll lose it.”

“Then I’ll tell you again, baby. It’s free.”

I turn my face to the window. A truck is pulling out, a reefer with a painted rooster on the door, its stack throwing a clean line of exhaust at the sky. I count to nine, because that is a number that settles me, and when I look back Soren is sitting at the counter with a fresh napkin in his hands, folding it, with a polite and puzzled expression, and he glances at me and nods the nod you give to a woman in the next seat.

Birdie doesn’t ask me what I need. She hands me her key to the office.

The afternoon is the part of this job that nobody tells you about, the long flat dead stretch between a thing you did and the response. I have no phone. I have a landline in the back office with a cord like a pig’s tail, and a legal pad, and six hundred and eleven dollars in a checking account at a bank I have not dared to look at. I sit at Birdie’s desk because it’s the only place with a door.

Under the rubber-band can, folded in thirds, is a letter I’m not supposed to read. It’s from a lender in Lincoln, on cream stock with a heavy engraved letterhead, and the first line says NOTICE OF INTENT TO ACCELERATE. I read it. I read everything.

The balance on the Prairie Star Travel Plaza’s note is four hundred and twelve thousand dollars. The payment history is a column of late dates that tells the whole story of a woman who has never sent a hungry man away. The cure date is the thirtieth.

I fold it back in thirds and put it where I found it, under the can. I think about the three-year-old claim I paid, against the quiet instructions of a company that wanted to find a reason not to.

I think about the thing nobody says out loud in my business, that most of what I did for nine years was look for the reason an old woman’s kitchen wasn’t covered. Then I pick up the pad and start a new page, headed OPEN LOSSES, and I begin to write a list.

I am on item six when the landline rings.

It rings once, and then not again, because I pick it up so fast that I knock the can of rubber bands onto the floor. I say nothing. It’s 4:50 p.m., and the plow light is moving in the window, and I hold the receiver to my ear and don’t say hello. I’ve sat on enough interviews to know that the first one to speak is the one with the weaker position.

“Is this Ms. Pruitt?” says a voice. It’s a woman’s, in her fifties, small and dry and very carefully pitched, a voice that has spent decades saying nothing above the volume of a filing cabinet. “This is closed-claims records. This is Lorraine Teague. I’m the clerk. I have your fax.”

“Thank you for calling back, Ms. Teague.”

“It came in at 11:34. Mr. Pike’s counsel had it at 11:40.” Her breath catches. “I pulled the file index on 4471-C, like you asked. There are two attachments listed under items 8 and 9. They’re logged to shelf 4471, level two, the sealed section. They’ve been under a hold since Sunday afternoon.” She stops. “I can’t release them. I want you to understand that I can’t.”

“I understand,” I say, and I do, because I’ve said exactly that sentence into a phone to widows. “The hold is Mr. Pike’s.”

“It’s initialed C.P. It’s an executive hold. Only a signature from the chairman’s office lifts it, in writing.”

“Ms. Teague—”

“Ms. Pruitt, please.” A pause. In it I can hear a room behind her: a rolling cart, the soft hum of a ceiling light. A basement. A woman in a basement, nineteen years in the same chair. “I’m not supposed to call you. I want to tell you something, and then I’m going to hang up, and I’d like you not to call this number back.”

I put my pencil down. “All right.”

“I have a mortgage,” says Lorraine Teague. “I had a mortgage. I was eleven months behind, and the bank had sent the last letter. And a woman came to see me last spring, a very nice woman in a cardigan, who said she was a nurse. She said she’d heard I had trouble. And three weeks later the whole note was paid. I never asked for it. I never signed anything.”

I don’t say a word. My pulse is going in my ears.

“She came to see me again on Saturday,” Teague says, and her voice thins out to a thread. “She asked me to do her a very small favor. She asked me to say yes to you, if you called, and to tell her the day and the hour. I said yes. She asked me to tell you something too, if I could bring myself to.” A breath. “She said to tell you that she was sorry.”

The line clicks. The dial tone arrives like a door.

I stand with the receiver in my hand and my own handwriting on the desk in front of me, OPEN LOSSES, one through six, and I do the thing I always do, the arithmetic. The clerk has been owned since spring. The vault has been listening since before I touched a fax machine. Every road I could take into that building ends at a woman who has already paid for it, and the only thing I can’t work out is why Teague called me to say so.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!