Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 39

Grace

Pastor Dee Anders says grace at 6:44, and it is the longest forty seconds of my life.

She stands at the head of the third table in her collar and her snow boots, with her hands folded over a soup ladle, and thanks God for the peas, the ham, the hands that made them, the roads that were plowed, the babies that were born, and, in a pause I could have driven a truck through, “the stranger at our table, whom we are commanded to feed.”

She doesn’t look at Hartley Grosz when she says it. She doesn’t have to. A hundred and twelve people say “Amen” with a unanimity I have only ever seen in a jury room.

Then they eat. And I understand, a little late, what Edith has done.

She has not thrown him out. She has done something much worse. She has made him a guest.

You cannot serve a petition on a man who is being handed bread. You cannot ambush a woman whose hands are full of a roaster. Every civil procedure I know assumes a room full of people who are waiting to take sides; Our Savior’s basement is a room full of people who have been taught since the age of four that you do not, on any account, make a scene before the pie.

Grosz knows it. He bows his white head over his bowl and tastes his soup like a man who has been told a secret and is pleased with it.

“It is very good,” he says, to the woman across from him. “What would you say is in it?”

“Marguerite’s ham,” she says, with a sniff, “and mercy.”

I sit down where I can see all of it. Theo on my left, Calloway on my right, the banker box under the table with its seal against my shin. At the far end of the third row Soren has been moved, by Pa Houa Vang, one seat further from the stairs. Dale sits at his shoulder with his hands on the table, in plain sight.

For three minutes nobody says anything that matters.

Then Hartley Grosz sets down his spoon, and takes a folded handkerchief from his breast pocket, and wipes his mouth with the care of a man who has dined in better rooms.

“Ms. Pruitt,” he says, from three seats away, in a voice that does not need to be raised. “I understand there is a rule against business over soup.”

“There’s a sign.”

“I’m a guest. I respect signs.” He smiles, and folds the handkerchief. “May I observe, without business, that you are a very difficult woman to find an hour with?”

“You found one.”

“I had a great deal of help.” He glances round at the hundred and twelve with an appreciation that is nearly sincere. “I flew to Minneapolis this afternoon, and a young man at the rental counter told me that if I wanted to find the people who were being difficult, I should go to the church with the loudest parking lot.”

“That’s a Minnesota answer.”

“I thought it was a very good one.” He lifts his glass of milk. “I wonder if I might say one thing before the pie. Not to you. To the table.”

A hundred and twelve people look at Edith.

Edith, at the pass-through, with a dish towel over one shoulder, considers it. “One thing,” she says. “No longer than grace.”

“I’m obliged.” He stands. It takes him a moment, with the cane. He doesn’t use it as a prop. It is a thing he leans on. “I am Hartley Grosz. I chair a company in Denver that holds some very large things for some very ordinary people. Pensions. School districts. A children’s hospital in Wichita, which I shall return to.”

He does not look at me. “A man I have known for twelve years, and loved a good deal longer than he knows, is sitting at this table, and does not know me. I should like to say that I am sorry he is ill. I should like to say it where he can hear it, and where you can.”

Silence. Somewhere in the kitchen a pan is set down very gently.

“That’s all,” says Grosz. “I wished to say it before anyone told me I couldn’t.” He sits.

At the end of the table, Soren has looked up.

He has been eating an egg roll with a seriousness that no one has interrupted. Now he sets it down and gives the speaker his full attention, in the way that always undoes me: the head a little on one side, the courteous frown of a man who has been addressed by a name he doesn’t know and is willing to be told.

“I beg your pardon,” says Soren. His voice is perfectly clear. “I am afraid I did not catch it. Are you a friend of mine?”

I can hear the basement breathe.

“I was,” says Hartley Grosz.

“Then I am sorry that I have forgotten you.” Soren says it exactly as he says everything, without hurry or flourish. “I should be very glad if you would tell me what I did well. I am told that I did some things well. I am not able to say what they were.”

It is not an act. I know the difference now; it takes me a half-second and costs me nothing. He is perfectly sincere. He is a man who has met his oldest friend and is offering him, with real warmth, the only thing he has left to give, which is an opening.

And Grosz, with his camel coat and his cane and his forty-six years of being refused by no one, does not answer at once.

“You were,” he says, “the only man I ever knew who counted everything and was not afraid of what he found.”

“That sounds like an excellent quality.”

“It was a very inconvenient one.”

“Ah,” says Soren, pleased. “Then it was probably mine.”

Somebody laughs. It is a small, helpless, wet sound from the second table, and it runs outward, like a stone’s rings, until half the room is laughing and the other half is pretending to blow its nose. Grosz doesn’t laugh. He puts his hand flat over his eyes, as a tired man might, and holds it there for four seconds.

When he lowers it his face has gone back to its place. But I have seen the four seconds. I write them down, in the notebook I keep behind my eyes, next to the pale band on Pike’s wrist and the nine seconds of a scowl in a truck stop chapel. Everyone I am afraid of has one real moment. I am not afraid of those. I am afraid of the ones who don’t.

---

Edith gets him pie.

I would like it on the record that this is not generosity. This is strategy, executed with a pie server. She gives him a slice of sour-cream raisin, with a fork, on a paper plate with a cross-stitched border, and she sets it in front of him with the air of a woman laying down a tripwire. And then she leaves him there.

He eats three bites. He says it is the best raisin pie he has had in thirty years. Then he puts the fork down and looks at me for the first time since he sat.

“Ms. Pruitt. I have one question, and I’ll tell you what it is before I ask it, so you may decline.”

“That’s very courteous.”

“I’m a courteous man. It is generally an expensive habit.” He lays his hands on the table. “I should like to know whether you’re going to deliver the Foundation file to the Committee.”

I do not move. At my left Theo has stopped breathing. Calloway’s pen, which had been moving, stops at the end of a line.

It is such a quiet question, asked in such an ordinary tone, over pie. He has not said “the file you have.” He has not said “Denver.” He has said: the Foundation file. He has said, in one phrase, that he knows what the box contains and where it came from and who has counted it.

Of course he does. He has known since Tuesday at 2:14, when two guards were instructed to log an unscheduled entry into the nonprofit records cage. He has known, and he has flown to Minneapolis, and he has sat in a church basement and eaten soup, because he is a man who prefers to ask a question rather than to be told.

“Yes,” I say.

“When?”

“Monday, nine o’clock Eastern. In writing. To you, and to the Underwriter, in the same hour, in the same words.”

“I see.” He nods, slowly. “You might have delivered it to me tonight.”

“I might.”

“You’d have gained a day.”

“I’d have given you one,” I say. “That’s the cost. Everybody has to have the same copy.”

Something moves behind his eyes. It might be amusement. It might be a very cold respect. “That is the Rule,” he says. “Rule 11. I’ve read it a good many times. I never thought that anyone would act on it.”

“He wrote it on a Sunday night.”

“Yes. I was there.” He glances at the end of the table. “I was the one who told him it was excessive.”

I wait.

“You’ve counted a ward in Wichita,” says Grosz. “Forty-one children, at the last census. The oncology wing. The gift was nine million dollars in 2019, a woman’s whole estate, from a family that lost a son. It earns about four hundred thousand a year in interest, and that was the thing I borrowed.” He says it plainly.

He is not a man who flinches at a number. “I borrowed a year’s interest from a children’s ward. I put it into a note. It’s a loan with a rate of eleven percent and a term of sixty days, and it was collateralized by a promissory note on a truck stop in Nebraska.”

“You lent a restricted gift to your own shell company.”

“I did. It was wrong. I knew it was wrong and I did it at two in the morning from a kitchen table, and it is exactly what you’ve said.” He holds my eye. “And on the twenty-fourth of December, when the Key Loss Event is declared and the policy pays, the loan is repaid in full.

“With interest. By the Committee, out of the very first dollar, before a single fee. The ward gets back what it lent, plus eleven percent. The pension funds are made whole at par. Every client who has a dollar in that vault gets it back on the twenty-fourth.”

“If I’m silent.”

“If you are silent,” says Hartley Grosz, “and the policy pays. I’m not asking you to lie. I’m telling you what happens to a ward in Wichita if you are not.”

“And if the treaty is canceled?”

“Then there’s no policy, and no payment, and no Christmas. There’s a children’s ward in a custody cage with a missing four hundred thousand and a company that cannot pay it.” His voice has dropped, a little, so that only the first four seats can hear. “You’ve a very clean hand, Ms. Pruitt. I admire it. I have never owned one. I’d like you to be very sure, before nine on Monday, whose hands you are cleaning it on.”

It lands. I would not be honest if I said it didn’t. I have a page in front of me that says a man who loved a friend, and honored a rule, and lied on a form, can be right about the arithmetic. It is the thing I have feared since the first day. A good argument is not the same as a good man, and a good man is not the same as a good argument.

I make myself breathe.

“Mr. Grosz,” I say. “You said it was wrong. You said it twice.”

“Yes.”

“Then you know that what happens to the children’s ward is not my decision. It was yours, at two a.m., in a kitchen. I’m not cleaning my hands on it. I’m counting it.” I put my palm flat on the banker box. “I’ll deliver it Monday at nine. I’ll deliver it in writing, to everyone. And I’ll tell the court on Tuesday, if I’m asked, what I read. Nobody’s going to make me lie about a ward. Not you, and not a kind reason.”

“A kind reason?”

“I don’t believe in a lie told for the best of reasons,” I say. “I’ve watched what they cost. Somebody has to pay for them, and it’s never the one who tells.”

There is a very long pause.

Hartley Grosz folds his napkin, once, into a square. He sets it beside the pie plate. He looks, for a moment, extremely tired, and a hundred years old, and far from home.

“I have a thing to tell you,” he says, “and I’d like you to hear it as a gift, because I don’t expect you to believe it. It’s about the sixty-fourth word.”

I go cold. I don’t move. I hear Theo’s breath stop, and, down the table, the small flat sound of Calloway setting down her pen.

I have not told him. I have told no one. The count is sixty-three and sixty-four; it is binder page four, insuring clause, and the only people in the world who have read it as I read it are a dead woman, a living man, and me.

“I beg your pardon,” I say.

“It’s in the policy,” says Grosz mildly. “The insuring clause. ‘Sixty-four words.’ I drafted the first version myself, in a hotel in Chicago, with Soren in the next chair, nine years ago. He told me it was nine rooms. I said seven words a room is sixty-three, and he said, ‘Yes. The sixty-fourth is not in the House.’” He tilts his head. “I asked him where it was. He said he’d given it to someone.”

“Who?”

“He wouldn’t say.” The blue eyes are bright and steady. “He said he’d given it to the one person who would never ask him for it. He said that was the only safe place for a thing like that.” He lifts the paper plate, and sets it down again. “I have thought about that sentence for nine years. I thought it was a joke.”

My mouth has gone dry. In the Custody Book at Denver, tier nine, a pencil margin: Withdrawn. S.L. 11 Aug. 4:12 a.m. A boat inside: the one person who never asked me for anything.

“It’s not a joke,” says Grosz. “I’ve come to believe it’s a plan. And I’d ask you, as a woman who counts, to consider the shape of it. A man with a failing mind gives the one piece of a key, the only piece that cannot be reconstructed from a house, to someone he trusts absolutely.” He stands, with the cane, and takes his hat. “And that person has never once, in nine years, come forward and said, ‘I have it.’”

“What are you saying?”

“I’m saying he trusted someone who isn’t you,” says Hartley Grosz, gently. “I’m saying that you’ve spent three weeks holding the house, and a man has been walking around with the front door in his pocket. And if you ask yourself why a man who gave you everything else would give that to a stranger, I think you’ll find the answer is the one I came to Duluth to say.”

“Which is?”

“He doesn’t trust the Walk. He doesn’t trust you, either, Ms. Pruitt. Not with the last of it.” He puts on the hat. “He trusted her.”

I find that I’m on my feet. I didn’t decide to be. Down the table Dale has risen too, and Pa Houa Vang, and Tomas Berglund at the foot of the stairs with his ice cleats in his hand, and I think, with total clarity, that if I say one word in the next ten seconds Hartley Grosz will have won a round he did not even need to fight.

“Thank you for the soup,” says Grosz, to Edith. “And the pie. It was an honor.”

“Come back for Kettle Night,” says Edith, flatly. “First Tuesday. Bring a dish.”

“I should like that very much.” He looks at me once more, and for one flash I think I see the thing in the four seconds, the pale grief of a man in a tan. “Monday at nine. I’ll be waiting for your report, Ms. Pruitt. I hope it’s as clean as you are.”

He goes up the stairs one step at a time, with the cane, and a hundred and twelve people watch him go. It is 7:41. The door at the top opens on a cold that I can feel from the third row, and shuts.

Nobody speaks. Then someone, at the back, says in a clear Minnesota voice, “Well, that was awkward,” and the room lets out its breath.

I sit down. My hands are shaking and I let them.

“He’s lying,” says Theo, very low. “The sixty-fourth word. He’s seen the insuring clause. It’s a lever. He wants you to think Soren didn’t trust you.”

“I know.”

“It could be a lie.”

“It could be.” I look at the end of the table, where a tall pale man in a coat buttoned wrong has resumed his egg roll with a perfectly peaceful face. “It’s a very good one. It has the one thing a lie needs. It’s built from something true.”

“Which part?”

“That there’s a person,” I say. “That he gave it to someone who isn’t me.”

Somewhere, in a drawer in a house in Duluth, or in a freezer under the dumplings, or in the pocket of a woman in a brown car, or in a hotel in Omaha, or on a pier at the very end of a lake, there is a word. And I have been told by a man who has every reason to lie that I am not the person who holds it.

It is 7:44. I write the time on my wrist, in ink, the way a person does who has stopped being sure of anything else.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!