Tolliver Hardware has a bell on the door that goes off like a small, discouraged cow, and at 4:46 on a Wednesday evening it announces me to a store that smells of linseed oil, galvanized pipe and a hundred and seventeen years of men saying they’ll be right back.
There are two people in it. At the register, on a tall stool with a cardigan buttoned to the neck, is a very old man whose face has folded in on itself like a map. At the back, on a stepladder, putting washers into a drawer marked in pencil 3/8, is a man of about sixty in a canvas coat with the name WES stitched on the pocket.
“We close at five,” says the old man, without turning his head.
“I know. I was told.”
“By who?”
“A gentleman in a camel coat.”
“Ah,” says the old man. “The one with the camera.” He swivels, a painful degree at a time, and looks me over: boots, vest, a face I haven’t slept in. “Wes. It’s the other one.”
“What other one?”
“The one who comes after the one with the camera.”
Wes Tolliver climbs down. He has the clean, careful hands of a man who does one thing every day for decades and has never once done it badly, and he wipes them on a rag as he comes.
“I’m Wes,” he says. “That’s my dad, Harlan. He’s ninety-one, and he thinks he’s still in charge, and he’s right about half the time.” He nods at the stool. “What can we do for you, ma’am, in thirteen minutes?”
I’ve thought about how to say it for the whole length of Main Street, which is one block. I’ve decided on the truth, because I know what a small town does with a lie.
“I’m trying to find a woman who did a kindness for a stranger nine years ago, in the ice storm. I’m not allowed to ask her about it. I’m not allowed to ask anyone about her.” I put the legal pad on the counter. “I’m only allowed to ask about a stove.”
---
It takes Wes Tolliver about a minute to understand me, and half of the minute is Harlan.
“It’s a gas range,” I say. “From the nineteen-forties, I think. It has a pilot light with a copper feed line, soldered, and the flame has a green tongue at the root where the copper’s warm. The kind you don’t replace because it never breaks.”
“A Chambers,” says Harlan Tolliver, at once. “A forty-eight Chambers. With the well. You don’t see them.”
“You see them here,” says Wes, slowly. He’s looking at me with an altogether different face. “I know what you’re asking. You’re asking who in Ellery still has one.”
“I’m asking about a stove, Mr. Tolliver. I’ll write it down that I only asked about a stove.”
“That’s a very lawyerly distinction.”
“I was an insurance adjuster for eleven years. We invented it.”
He laughs, once, in spite of himself. Then he goes to a wall of gray steel filing drawers at the back of the store, behind a curtain of hanging brass keys, and takes out the third from the bottom and sets it on the counter.
“The town has a gas department,” he says. “I’m it. Since 1991. I’ve a clipboard and a van and a fitter’s license from the state of Iowa. The cards are the department’s, not mine, but the department’s in the back of my father’s store because the town stopped paying for an office in nineteen eighty-eight.” He opens the drawer.
It’s full of buff index cards, each one the size of a recipe, thousands of them, filed by street. “Every time we set a meter, or changed a regulator, or relit a pilot, a card went in. Address, date, appliance, what we did. No names. Names change. A house is a house.”
“No names.”
“None. And I’ll tell you, ma’am, because you were honest, that if you’d come in here and said the word ‘person’ I’d have shown you the door. Gas department is the gas department.” He puts a finger on the drawer. “Which addresses?”
I give him four streets from the log: Linden, Church, Cedar, Division. I leave the household names off, because I’ve promised I wouldn’t say them, and I read him the streets in the radio man’s order while he flips cards with a thumb as fast as a bank teller.
“Church Street,” he says. “The house I think you mean converted to electric in ninety-one. I did it myself. Cried the whole time. Cedar.” A card. “Never had gas. They heated with a coal furnace until eighty, then oil. And Division.” He stops. “That’s Gus’s old house. Burned. A pan fire, oh-three. The whole kitchen. They rebuilt it with a modern range, two thousand and four.”
“And Linden?”
He doesn’t say anything for a moment. He’s holding a card in his hand, the yellowest in the drawer, and he doesn’t give it to me.
“Two-fourteen Linden,” says Wes Tolliver. “Chambers, 1948. Copper line, soldered, with a well-burner. Pilot relit January 1971, March 1983, the winters of ‘ninety-four, ‘oh-two, ‘oh-nine and ‘sixteen. Regulator changed twice. Never replaced the range.” He sets the card on the counter, face up, and turns it with one finger so that I can read it, and I read it, and I’ll remember it for the rest of my life without any effort at all.
“It’s the last one in town, ma’am. The only house in Ellery, Iowa, with a flame that color.”
“Thank you.”
“I haven’t told you anything about a person,” he says. “I’ve told you about a stove.”
“I wrote that down.”
“See that you did.” He puts the card back in the drawer and shoves it shut with his hip. It’s 4:58. The bell goes at the door, and nobody comes in, and a gust of cold, as if the weather has been waiting, comes in and stands in the aisle.
“Do you know who lives there?” I say. I can’t help it. It comes out in a whisper.
Harlan Tolliver, on his stool, with his hands on the counter, looks at his son.
“Young woman,” says Wes, gently, “I said I’d tell you about a stove.”
“It’s the kind of question a person has to ask twice before she’s allowed to hear it.”
“I know.” He takes a ring of keys from a nail. “I’ll say this. It’s a small town. The woman at Two-fourteen has had that house since seventy-one. She’s fed more people in this town than the church has, and she’d be deeply put out to be asked by a stranger why. If you want to find out about her, you’ll want to be somebody she’d have fed.”
He turns the sign on the door to CLOSED. “That’s all I know. It’s all I’ll say. And Pell, I’ll tell him tomorrow at seven when I open, because it’s the law and it’s what I do, and I’ll tell him exactly what I told you. Not a word more.”
I look at him. At seven.
“I don’t suppose you open at six?”
“I don’t suppose I do,” says Wes Tolliver, “not for the Queen of England.” He locks the door. And through the glass, on the other side of Main, in the last smear of dusk, under the one streetlight, I see a gray sedan at the curb with its lights off, and a man in it with a thermos, who raises one gloved hand to the store, politely, as if to say that the arithmetic is the same for everyone.
---
We take rooms at the Ellery Motor Court, which has nine units in an L, a vacancy sign with one dead neon letter, and a manager named Pam who gives each of us a key on a green plastic diamond and says, “It’s an ice town, kids. You’ll want to leave the water dripping.”
Achterberg phones at 6:31, from a gate in Denver.
“I’m boarding,” she says. “I land at Sioux City at 9:40. There’s a car. I’ll be in Ellery by 11:30, I’ll sleep, and I’ll be at whatever door you tell me at six forty-five.” A pause, a loudspeaker saying something about Group B. “I’d like to say that I’ve changed my mind, Jo. I wanted to say it before I saw you.”
“About what?”
“About the thing I told you in the hallway of the Omaha tower. That I couldn’t take sides.” The voice is thin and level. “I’m not taking one. But I’ve come to understand that the examination Mr. Pike has prescribed is the only honest part of the policy. I intend to do it honestly. I’ll want to see him in the room where it happened.”
“It’s a kitchen. It’s a woman’s kitchen, and she may not even want us.”
“Then we’ll see what she says,” says Achterberg. “As a clinician I’m in the habit of letting people say what they will.”
---
At 8:30, in unit six, with Kask in the next room doing his own paperwork with the door open between us out of what I understand to be professional scruple, the phone rings, and the number is one I’ve been dreading since Lincoln.
“Joanna,” says Hartley Grosz. “I hope I’m not intruding.”
I put it on speaker and set it on the bedspread, and Kask, in his doorway, turns his lanyard face-down on his chest, which is how he tells me he has begun to listen.
“You’re always intruding, Mr. Grosz. You do it so nicely.”
“I’ll take that as a compliment.” The voice is the same as it was at the soup supper: warm, regretful, a voice with a hand on your arm. “I’ve had a long day. Mr. Pell’s told me what he’s found, and I’ve told him it’s wonderful, and I’ve told him to be gentle. I’ve asked him to be gentle with an elderly woman. He’s very good at it.”
“He’s very good at accuracy.”
“He’s very good at both.” A cough, a cup set down. “I don’t want to knock on a door at six-thirty in the morning, Joanna. I don’t want to ask a widow whether she remembers a boy. I’d like, very much, for all of us to be somewhere else.”
I’d like it noted that I don’t say anything.
“I’ve a proposal,” says Grosz. “You withdraw the cure. Not the Notice, the cure. You tell Dr. Achterberg tomorrow that you’ve no declaration to make. The Notice stands, the Committee takes custody of the Key in the usual way, and Soren goes to a very fine place in Colorado with a garden. In return, I’ll see to it that Dorothea Voss keeps her bed in Marquette, from my pocket, through the spring.”
He lets it settle. “I’ll see that nobody knocks on a door in Ellery. I’ll withdraw Mr. Pell tonight. It’s not a threat, my dear. It’s a kindness. It’s what I’ve wanted all along.”
It’s a good offer. That’s the thing I’d tell anyone who asked: it’s an excellent one. It buys a woman a bed and a stranger a quiet street. It keeps my father out of a lie and my client out of a courtroom, and it requires nothing of me but a sentence I’ve said to a hundred claimants. We regret that we are unable to proceed.
“Mr. Grosz,” I say. “Are you recording this?”
“I’m not.”
“I am.” I hold up my own phone beside the first one. “And so is Mr. Kask, in his way. And Dr. Achterberg is going to hear it by morning. I’d like to say, for the record, that you’ve offered a thing of value to a custodian of record in exchange for abandoning a duty. I’d like to say it twice, so that it’s said.”
A silence. It’s a very long one, about the length of a man deciding which face to wear.
“You’ve misunderstood me.”
“I don’t think so. I think I’ve understood you very well.” I look at the legal pad. “The bed in Marquette is Mrs. Voss’s. It was never yours to bargain with. She’s paid for three months of it already, and the money’s in a Michigan account at a billing office, by wire, as of 4:00 p.m. today, in my name. You can’t buy what’s been paid.”
“Joanna—”
“And I’ll tell you what you’ve told me, which is the best thing I’ve learned in a week. You don’t know where the word is. If you did, you wouldn’t be offering to pay for my silence about a door in Ellery. You’d have knocked.” I draw a breath. “Good night, Mr. Grosz. Give the felt hat my love.”
I hang up. My hand, I notice, is steady. It’s my heart that is doing something complicated.
“That,” says Kask, mildly, from the doorway, “will be in my report.”
“I thought it might.”
“I’m obliged to file a supplement. I’ve already filed the day.” He takes out his pen. “I’ll send it at ten-fifteen, before the eleven o’clock cutoff, to chambers, with the address of the unit, the persons present and the purpose, which I’ve written as ‘Respondent’s inquiry into a prior residence.’ I haven’t named the street.” He looks, very faintly, apologetic. “Mr. Whitcombe’s clerk reads the docket at six every morning. By seven, he’ll have it.”
“By seven the gas man will have told Pell where to go, too.”
“Yes,” says Kask. “I’m afraid the town of Ellery is going to be quite crowded tomorrow.”
It’s the cost, I think. It’s the plain, bookkeeping cost of doing something properly. I’ve bought honesty with a court officer, and he’s paid it back in the only coin he has: a fact, in a file, that a lawyer will read before breakfast. Somewhere in a hotel in Lincoln or Omaha, Dennis Whitcombe’s clerk is eating a sandwich and has no idea that tomorrow, at six, he’ll know where we’ve gone.
---
At 10:40 Dale takes the wagon down Linden Street, once, slowly, with the headlights dipped, because I ask him to.
It’s a street of small, square, plain houses in the dark, with a porch light every third door and the shapes of parked cars in front, under a half-inch of frozen snow. Number 214 is white clapboard with green shutters and a screen door. A path is shoveled to the steps. There’s a light on, a single yellow one, at the back, where a kitchen would be, and a thin line of smoke going straight up from the chimney into the dark.
“Don’t stop,” I say.
“I’m not stopping,” says my father, in a whisper. “I’m a man driving by a house.”
In the back seat, Soren sits upright with his hands on the paper bag. He’s been quiet for an hour. At supper, at the Ellery Dinette, a bowl of soup had come in front of him, and he had looked at it a long time, with something like grief, and said, “It is not the same,” and eaten it anyway.
“Dale,” he says now, in a perfectly level voice. “Would you stop?”
Dale stops.
It’s 10:44. The wagon idles. A dog, somewhere, says its piece. The yellow light at the back of the house stays on, small and steady, and the line of smoke goes straight up, and I realize I’ve been holding the dash with both hands since Main Street.
“It is Joanna’s decision,” says Soren. “I wish to say that first. I will do whatever she says. But I should like to say a thing about knocking.”
“Say it.”
“It is sixteen minutes to eleven. I have, I think, an hour, perhaps a little more. I am going to give up some of it now so that I can have the rest tomorrow.” He’s looking at the window, at the yellow square. “When I came to this town I could not have said a thing to a stranger.
I did not know what I wanted. I did not know I was crying. A woman who had not been introduced to me sat me down and gave me a plate. She did not knock on a single door in my head.”
“Soren.”
“Do not knock,” he says. “Please. Not on this one. If it is her, she will not wish to be asked. She will wish to be found at the curb, as a thing in the cold, and to decide for herself. She has done it before.” His voice does something I haven’t heard it do.
“It is the only way I know to be fair. We shall sit in the car, at the curb, at half past six, in front of her house, like a person who has broken down. And if she wishes to, she will open the door.”
“And if she doesn’t?”
“Then we shall leave,” says Soren Lindqvist, “and I shall be very sorry, and Mrs. Voss’s sister will lose a bed at Christmas. And I should rather that than knock.”
It’s the sort of thing I could write a clause about. I’d put it under Condition 14(c), in a paragraph no one would ever read. The source shall not be solicited. I look at the yellow light, and at the dead white field of her yard, and at a man I’ve known for three weeks who has just made a policy by looking at a window.
“All right,” I say. “We sit at the curb. We don’t knock. We don’t ask.”
“Thank you.”
“Dale,” I say. “Back it up to the corner. We’ll sleep in the units. We’ll be here at six.”
“Here’s the beautiful part,” says Dale, putting the wagon in reverse, very softly, like a man handling a loaded pie. “I’m going to be up at five.”
---
At 11:12, I stand at the window of unit six with a motel blanket round my shoulders and look out at the lot, at the dead neon letter, at the ribbon of Main Street going up the hill to the library and the red mast. At the far end of it, half a block down, under the single streetlight, a gray sedan has parked at the corner with its lights off, facing the turn onto Linden.
There’s a man in it. I can see the small hot point of a thermos cup as he lifts it. For a second I take him for Pell, and then I see that Pell’s rented sedan is gone, that this one is a darker gray, and that the shoulders under the felt hat are broader and in no hurry.
I can’t see the face. I only see the feather, small and black in the lamp, a feather like a comma, and the long unhurried shape of a man who is in no hurry at all, because he’s had the whole of his life to learn that the one thing he needs to do tomorrow morning is to be there first.
At the other end of the street, at a curb, a white house with green shutters keeps its one yellow window lit, like a lamp that has been left on, I think, for exactly this.
It’s 11:12. I write it on my wrist. Thirteen hours to the minute.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!