Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 83

The Pattern

Dennis Whitcombe opens on Friday morning with a theory so good that for the first eleven minutes I find myself nodding.

It’s 9:03 in Courtroom 3. The gallery is half full, with the three reporters in the back row, and a cluster of Night Watch drivers in their good flannel, and Ardis Brandt, who has driven up from Ellery again with a thermos and an air of settled disapproval.

Judge Cho has her mug. Kask has his clipboard. At the petitioner’s table Whitcombe stands alone with his leather folio, because Peter Ley’s chair is empty and Sunita Rao’s is empty and the third chair, where a paralegal used to sit, has been pushed back against the rail.

He looks tired. He looks, I think, like a man who has been told he is brilliant by someone he no longer respects.

“Your Honor,” he says. “This is a very simple motion. I’ll be brief.”

“I’d appreciate it.”

“The Petitioner Gray Heron Holdings seeks a finding that the respondent, Mr. Lindqvist, lacks the capacity to execute the Instruments of Keeping which he’s signed since the tenth of December, on the ground that each was procured in a pattern.” He lets the word rest. “I’ll call three witnesses. I’ll ask each of them one question. And I think the Court will find that the pattern speaks for itself.”

“What pattern?”

“Generosity, Your Honor. Unprompted, unreasoned, indiscriminate.” He turns a page. “A man with a progressive condition has, over a period of years, been offering money to people he barely knows. We’ll show that it began before the diagnosis, which we don’t dispute, but that it accelerated after.

We’ll show that every person on his list has been offered, and every one has said no. And we’ll invite the Court to ask a simple question. What is the nature of a *refusal,* in a courtroom, if not the second half of an offer?”

It’s the sentence Fenn used in Denver. I feel it go through the gallery like a draft.

---

Ellis Tarr is first.

He walks to the stand in his gray cardigan with his left sleeve pushed to the elbow, so that everyone can see the steel and the plastic and the two small hooks, and he does it without self-consciousness, with the stooped courtesy of a man who has spent forty years opening a window for strangers. He takes the oath with the right hand. He sits. He puts a hook on his knee.

“State your name.”

“Ellis Gordon Tarr.”

“Occupation?”

“Retired. I was a parking attendant. Twenty-one years at the Ninefold tower.”

“Mr. Tarr.” Whitcombe is courteous. “I’d like to ask you about the night of the third of November, at about ten past eleven, on the third level of the ramp. You were on duty?”

“I was.”

“You saw the respondent?”

“I did.”

“Was he, in your judgment, in a state of mind to make decisions?”

“I’d say,” says Ellis Tarr, “that he didn’t know me.”

There’s a stir. Whitcombe lifts his chin a fraction.

“He’d greeted me by name every night for nine years,” says Ellis. “That night he looked at me, and I saw he’d no idea who I was. And I saw that he knew it.” The long hound’s face is quite still. “I’ve thought about it a good deal. I’d say it’s a different thing from not being able to decide. A man who knows he doesn’t know a thing is the most careful there is.”

“Mr. Tarr, I’d ask you to confine yourself—”

“He asked me a question,” says Ellis. “That’s what I saw. He came to my window. He said, *Is there a woman on this level who was dismissed? Is she kind?* I said I thought so. He said, *Then she’ll do.* And then he said, *If it goes badly, will you tell her I tried?*”

He turns, and looks across the courtroom, for a moment, at me. “I’d say, Your Honor, that’s the most lucid sentence I’ve ever heard a man say in a car park.”

Whitcombe closes his folio. It’s a small gesture. It makes a small flat noise.

“No further questions,” he says.

“Mrs. Sjoberg?”

“None, Your Honor,” says Ingrid, with great restraint. “I think the witness has said it.”

---

Dr. Imogen Achterberg is the second.

She’s a tall, fifty-year-old woman with a long jaw and short gray hair and half-glasses on a cord, in a gray suit, with the air of an examining physician who has seen every excuse a human mind can offer. I’ve known her three months. I’ve learned to read her as one reads a chart, by the places where the line holds.

She takes the oath. She sits. She folds her hands.

“Doctor,” says Whitcombe. “You were retained by the Underwriter to give a medical opinion of the respondent’s capacity.”

“I was.”

“In the course of that retention, did the respondent at any time offer you a payment?”

“He did.”

“What was it?”

“Twelve thousand dollars. By check, in an envelope, on the first of October. It was described as a bonus for my trouble.” Her voice is dry as a cracker. “I returned it by return post with a note that I’d have to disclose it to my client and that it would impair my opinion. I did disclose it. It’s in my first report.”

“So he offered you money.”

“He did.”

“To influence your opinion?”

“I’d say not.” She meets his eyes. “I’d say he offered it to the one person in his life he thought would refuse. It’s not the same thing.”

“I’d ask the witness to answer the question.”

“I have,” says Dr. Achterberg. “If you’d like me to speculate, I will, but I’ll say, as a clinician, that I’ve seen a number of people with his condition give away their possessions. They do it in a scatter. They give to the nearest hand. The person who gives to a hand that has to be *selected* — who writes a note, who dates it, who calculates how much it would take to be convincing, and then *adds a line saying she’s free to send it back* — is not scattering.”

She takes off her glasses. “I’d call it a design.”

“You’d call it—”

“I’d call it the behavior of a man testing a bridge before he puts weight on it.”

---

It’s Teague, third, who breaks my heart, and she does it by being exactly what she is.

She comes in on Gene’s arm, which is to say he comes in on hers, in the wheelchair, with the oxygen tank and the plaid blanket, and she wheels him to the end of the front row and sets the brake. She kisses the top of his head. She walks to the stand in the good blue dress with her round hands clasped, like a woman about to read the lesson in church, and she takes the oath with her eyes closed.

“Mrs. Teague,” says Whitcombe. His voice is gentler. “You’re employed, or were, at Harrow and Pike.”

“I was a clerk for nineteen years.”

“In the course of your acquaintance with Mr. Lindqvist, did he at any time offer you money?”

“He did.”

“How much?”

“Thirty-one thousand dollars.”

“And what was it for?”

“A mortgage,” says Lorraine Teague. “The last of one.”

“Did you accept it?”

“No.”

“You returned it?”

“I did.”

“Why?”

She hesitates. I see her look at Gene. I see her look, for a second, at the ceiling tile, which is stained, in the shape of Ohio.

“Because it was the first thing anyone had ever offered me,” she says, “that I couldn’t pay back.” The round face is quite calm. “I’d been paid for a good many things. I’d taken money to say a word, once. I’d taken it because I was afraid. And I thought, with the check in my hand, with a pen: *this man’s the first who’s asked nothing. And I’ll be damned if I’ll let him be the one I cheat.*”

The courtroom is silent.

“No further questions,” says Whitcombe, in a very low voice.

“Your Honor,” says Ingrid, rising. “I’ve a few.”

---

She does it in eleven minutes. I’ve watched her do a good many things in the last six weeks, and I’d like to say it was the best.

She’s seventy and small and gray. She walks to the lectern with a single page. She doesn’t raise her voice. She asks Tarr one question, and it takes ten seconds.

“Mr. Tarr. When did Mr. Lindqvist first leave you a Christmas envelope?”

“The first December I was on the booth for him. Five years ago.”

“And did he leave one every year?”

“He did.”

“And every year you returned it?”

“Every year.”

“Thank you.” She turns. “Dr. Achterberg. The first diagnostic note on this respondent. What’s the date?”

“The ninth of December last. A screening, in Denver. I wasn’t his physician then. I was consulted later, on the file.”

“And the earliest sign of impairment, in your clinical judgment, from the history?”

“I’d put it eighteen months before the diagnosis. Perhaps two years.”

“Mrs. Teague.” Ingrid doesn’t look round. “Mr. Lindqvist’s offer to you, the check. What was the date on the postmark?”

“The fourteenth of November. Of this year, I mean. This past November.”

“Thank you.” She takes the single page from the lectern. “Your Honor, I’d like to offer the Court a document. It’s an account book. It has been lodged under seal with the Representative, and she’s agreed that I may refer to a portion. It’s headed *Ledger of Returns.* The first entry is dated the thirty-first of January, in the year the respondent engaged a private investigator in Denver. I’ve counted back. It is nine years ago, almost to the day.”

“What’s your point, Mrs. Sjoberg?” says Cho.

“That the first entry in a record of the respondent’s generosity predates, by about seven years, the earliest sign of any impairment. That for seven of the nine years the pattern, if it’s a pattern, was the work of a competent man.” She lets the sentence fall into the room.

“Dr. Achterberg has called it a design. I’d ask the Court to consider that a design requires a designer. And that the designer was, at the time, a man whom nobody has ever suggested was impaired.”

I look at Whitcombe. I see something go across his face like the shadow of a bird. It’s not anger. It’s the dull shocked look of a man who has been given an elegant proof and discovered, three lines from the end, a mistake in the first.

---

Judge Cho takes eight minutes. I know because Soren, at the table, with the pencil mark on the back of his hand, asks me three times how long it’s been, and each time I tell him.

She comes back with the mug and her glasses on, and she doesn’t sit. She stands at the bench with her hands on the wood.

“I’ll be plain,” she says. “The motion’s denied. I find that the evidence does not support the proposition that the Instruments were the product of an incapacity. I find that the pattern proffered by the Petitioner is, if anything, a pattern of the respondent’s *caution.* I’d add that I’ve sat on this bench twenty-two years, and I’ve never heard three witnesses describe, with such unanimity, the experience of being offered something and declining it.”

She looks over her glasses. “I’ve a suspicion that is what he was after.”

There’s a rustle, from the back, like a held breath let go.

“But I’m not finished, Mr. Whitcombe.”

“Your Honor.”

“I’ve been told there’s a book.” Her gaze moves to the Representative’s table, where Priscilla Odum sits in her good wool coat with her hands folded on a green cloth cover. “I’ve heard it referred to three times this morning. It’s apparently dispositive on the question of seven years.

It is also, I gather, a list of thirty-one persons who have, in the respondent’s judgment, passed a test.” She taps the bench. “It’s the foundation of a custody arrangement for assets I’m told run to hundreds of millions. I’m not comfortable having it in a Representative’s briefcase.”

“Your Honor,” says Priscilla, rising. “It’s in my custody under Condition 9.”

“I’m sure it is, Mrs. Odum, and I’m sure you’ve kept it beautifully. It’s the principle.” Cho lifts her chin. “I’m going to order it lodged with the clerk by Monday at noon, under seal, for in camera review. I’ll examine it myself. And on Tuesday, if I think there’s anything in it which bears on this matter, I’ll release it to counsel.”

“All counsel?” says Ingrid.

“All counsel.”

I feel it land. It’s a small, cold, quiet sensation, as of a stair that isn’t there.

“Your Honor,” I say. I’ve risen without meaning to. “May I be heard?”

“You’re not counsel, Ms. Pruitt.”

“No, Your Honor. I’m a payor of record. I know the rule.” My heart is going like a fist. “I only want to ask the Court to consider, before Tuesday, that a book of names is a list of people who’ve been asked to be brave. And that thirty-one persons have not been told they’re in it.”

Cho looks at me for a long moment. The silver hair, the calm ironic face. The mug.

“It’s a fair point,” she says. “I’ll consider it. It doesn’t change my order.” She lowers her gaze. “We’re adjourned.”

---

It’s Soren who speaks, as the court empties, as the chairs scrape and the reporters shuffle out and the Night Watch rises as a body. He’s turned in his seat and he’s looking at me with an expression of faint, polite inquiry.

“I beg your pardon,” he says. “Was that favorable?”

“It was.”

“Was it a victory?”

“It was a *no* to a *no,*” I say. “It’s the best kind.”

“I should have liked to be present.” He looks at his hand. “I’m told I was.”

“You were.” I take his arm. “You sat very still. You didn’t say a word. You didn’t have to.”

“It is a great comfort,” says Soren, “to be defended by people who’ve no idea what I’m like.” He rises, with that courteous slowness. “I think I should like some pie.”

We walk out. It’s 10:51. In the corridor, under the beige fluorescent light, with the Night Watch parting like water, a small round woman in a good blue dress catches my sleeve. It’s Lorraine Teague. She’s holding a small leather folder, and her face is working.

“Ms. Pruitt,” she says. “I’ve something to tell you, and I’ve waited a day to do it. I thought you ought to hear it from me.”

“What is it?”

“My Gene’s had a call,” says Lorraine. “From a hospital. At seven this morning, while I was getting ready. It’s a bill. They say the insurance has disallowed the last operation. It’s forty-one thousand dollars.” She swallows. “It’s the sum I’ve been trying not to think about for a month.”

“Mrs. Teague—”

“And a man telephoned at eight. Very polite. A gentleman from a foundation.” She looks at the folder in her hands. “He said they’d heard we had a difficulty. He said they’d like to help.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!