Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 39

Aloud

By Wednesday the whole ward knows there is a hearing, and the ward, being a ward, has opinions.

The opinions arrive in order of rank. The night nurses want to know if it will be loud. Harlan Pike, from 7-02, wants to know if he should wear a tie. Wade Loomis, who has now lost two Thursdays and is rationing the rest, wants to know whether the thing that is going to judge the House can also be asked about contracts for custody.

Cody, doing his homework on a cot in the corridor because nobody has had the heart to send him home, wants to know what happens to the people in the building if the Water wins.

I tell him the truth, which is that I do not know. He nods, writes it down in his math notebook, in the margin, and underlines it twice.

“That’s okay,” he says. “Dad says that’s the best thing a grown-up can say.”

The one person who does not ask me anything is Ansel Rudd, because Ansel has been talking nonstop for two days and the nurses have run out of ways to say, again, tell it slowly. He has been giving his piece of the memory to anyone with ears. I have heard it six times, and each time it comes out a little more worn, like a coin. The lake froze flat. The man in the cap walked out.

The lake said, in a girl’s voice, in my voice: you will have to come and get the rest.

“The rest of what?” says Imogen Vance, on Wednesday afternoon, turning her pen over and over. “What did it mean? The rest of the loan? The rest of her?”

“The rest of me,” I say. “I think I was lent back in pieces.”

I have been thinking about it since the cap, with the part of my mind I keep for things I cannot afford to feel. Eight scars with no memory of the injuries. The eighth, the coin under the collarbone. A hand that went numb and white when I sat at the door. The taste of coffee I lost on a Tuesday I paid for.

Here is the thing about a loan with security: the lender does not have to take the whole principal on the day. He can leave you with a mortgage and let the interest accrue.

“Item one,” I say, in the empty office, to nobody. “I have been paying on this since I was nine.”

It is a long way to travel to a decent sentence. But I like it better than the other one, the one that says I am a debt, and I put it on the wall of my head beside the cap and the Landing and the sixty seconds and do not look at it again.

Agnes holds court on Thursday.

She does it in the chapel, because the chapel is the only room in the building that still belongs to the Order. The old altar is a plywood box under a dust sheet, but she has had Hollis carry in the oak chair stenciled 13 and set it on the floor where the altar rail stood, and she sits in it, wrapped in two blankets, with the House’s counterpart open on her knees.

The rest of us sit on records boxes. Imogen has brought snacks. It is the least formal courtroom in the history of Michigan.

“Three rules for the hearing,” says Agnes, “and then I will tell you a thing that is not a rule.” She holds up one yellow nail. “One. The Sisters did not go before him alone. The one who asks stands up, and the one who stands beside her holds her wrist. Not her hand. The wrist. It is the pulse that is a witness.”

Elias, on a records box beside me, goes quiet.

“Two.” A second nail. “He asks the question once. If the answer is true, he accepts it, and it binds. If the answer is false, he does not accept it, and you will know, because he says nothing, and the silence goes on until you speak again. If you speak quickly, he has the first word. If you speak slowly, you may cross it out.”

“Cross out,” says Imogen, writing.

“Three.” Agnes lowers her hand. “The answer may be spoken by two voices, if two voices are bound. Mother Aurelia and Sister Rose answered together in nineteen thirty-one, at the handing over of the account, and the account was never lighter than it was that day. I have always thought it was because neither of them tried to keep the other’s share.”

She looks at us over her glasses. “That is the thing that is not a rule. They did not ask what the other would not give. They each answered for herself, in order, and neither of them went first for the other. The Sisters called it the Courtesy of the Door.”

“Courtesy,” I say.

“It was the name of a hymn.” She smiles with half her mouth. “The question is not what you will not give for the one you love. That is a bargain. He does not want bargains. He is asking what you would not give, and he is asking you, and you are the only one who knows.”

On the records box beside me, Elias has put his hands flat on his knees, as if they might move.

“What did you answer?” he asks. It is the first thing he has said since we sat. “In nineteen sixty-one. When you took your vows. Did you answer him?”

Agnes looks at him for a long moment, and the milky eyes are sharper than I have seen them.

“I was not asked,” she says. “I was nineteen, and a novice. The question was put to the sisters who held the account. I was not one of them.” She folds her hands. “But I have been asking myself for sixty-five years. I would tell you what I found, Dr. Hale, but it would be mine, and you would only borrow it.”

We argue about it that night.

It is the first real fight, and I have been waiting for it, with the strange composed dread of a person who knows the test is on Monday and has not studied.

It starts in 7-13 at half past eleven, with the door shut and the lamp on and the Ledger on the bed between us. I have a legal pad. He has a pen. We have each been told to find the answer on our own, and we have each, I understand later, found it on our own, and neither has said it aloud.

“I only want to understand,” Elias says, “how you propose to prepare an answer to a question you have decided not to rehearse.”

“I’m not rehearsing. I’m thinking.”

“It is a distinction without a difference.”

“Don’t,” I say. “Don’t do the voice.”

“I do not have a voice.”

“You have the voice you use on residents. The one with no contractions.” I put down the pad. “You’re going to say it yourself. Aren’t you. You’ve made up your mind. You’re going to stand there, and the minute he asks, you’ll say it fast, because you’ve decided that if it costs somebody, it should cost you, and you don’t want it to be me.”

“That is not what I have decided.”

“What have you decided?”

He does not answer. In the lamp his face is very tired, and the gray at his temples has begun, in the last two weeks, to spread, a quiet silver, and I think, I do not want to be the reason it moves.

“I have decided,” he says at last, very precisely, “nothing. Because there is nothing in me I would keep, and I have gone looking, as I told you, and I have not found a thing. I do not say that to be noble. It is a defect. I was shaped around a bill, Juno.”

“I have been paying since I was a boy, and when I try to think what would not be given, I find a room with nothing in it. You asked me to take it slowly. I am taking it as slowly as a man can. And it is a very empty room.”

“There is something in the room,” I say.

“What?”

“Me,” I say. “And you know it. You just don’t think it counts, because you don’t think you’re allowed to keep a person.”

He flinches. It is a very small flinch, and it goes through the tether like a plucked string, and I feel my own ribs answer it.

“It is a good answer,” he says, after a time. “It is a true one. And it would bind me for all time.”

“Maybe,” I say. “Maybe that’s what he’s for.” I get up. I am shaking, which is stupid, because I have not even raised my voice. “Elias. Listen to me. My father said nothing. And he was ground into a basement for twenty-two years. You’re going to say the thing that is true, and the thing that is true is the thing he’ll take, and I will hold your wrist and watch you do it. I’ve read the charter.”

“Nobody gets to keep the thing they name. That’s the whole shape of this place. If you tell him you would not give me, he takes you at your word, and then he puts me on the table.”

“Then what would you have me say?”

“I don’t know!” It comes out loud, cracked down the middle. “I don’t know. I have a list and none of it is any use. I would not give up my mother, and she’s got three bad years left that she cannot even remember. I would not give up the ward, and the ward is a thing that eats people. I would not give up you, and I’ve no right to, because you are not mine.”

“I’m a woman who sat on a floor for six years looking for a ghost, and the one thing I thought I was good at was knowing what I would give for the truth. And I do not know what I would keep.”

There is silence. The lamp hums. Somewhere under us the House’s great quiet, the quiet that has not lifted since Friday, leans against the floor.

Elias is looking at me. The anger has gone out of his face and something much worse has replaced it: understanding.

“Then we are in the same room,” he says, softly. “Both of us.”

“Both of us,” I say.

“It is an interesting thing to share.” He tries to smile. It does not entirely take. “Item one, if I may borrow it. Whatever we answer, we answer in the same breath, and we do not decide it in advance, and neither of us goes first for the other.”

“That’s the Courtesy of the Door.”

“It is a hymn. I would like to hear it sung.” He holds out his hand across the Ledger, palm up, and the pulse in the wrist is a quiet thing, steady, shared. “Sit with me. We are not going to solve it tonight. But I would rather not have it between us.”

I sit. The Ledger is a green cloth hill between our knees. We say nothing for a long time, and it is better than words, and then Hollis knocks.

He has a thermos and a pair of knitting needles and the look of a man who has made a decision and does not intend to discuss it.

“Brought you something,” he says. “Not coffee. Sit, sit. It’s not a long story, and I’ve never told it to anyone, and I’m too old to be careful.”

He lowers himself onto the second oak chair, the one stenciled 13, and for the first time since I have known him he does not reach for the radio.

“Hal and I,” he says. “Nineteen seventy-four. You know that much. Two brothers, one account. You know there was a door. What I never said is that there was a question.” He turns the thermos in his big weathered hands. “I stood in the passage behind him. I was a boy. Hal went to the door and knocked, and a voice I won’t describe said, ‘Ask first.’ And Hal said, ‘I’m asking.’ And the voice said: What would you not give?”

“What did he say?” I whisper.

“He said, ‘Anything.’ Not nothing. Anything. He thought it was the same, and it isn’t. Nothing is a wall you haven’t got. Anything is a promise to be taken from.” He is looking at the floor. “Three days. He had a month, in the end, but he was gone in three days in every way that counted. And me.”

“The voice turned to me, in the passage, and it said, ‘And you?’ And I stood there in the dark and I did not say a word. I could not. I was too scared to lie and too scared to tell the truth, so I stood there, and I let it be quiet.”

“And it let you go,” says Elias.

“It did not let me go. It stopped asking.” Hollis lifts his eyes. They are very pale, and very old. “That is the difference, Dr. Hale. I never answered. I have not answered in fifty-two years. The question is still open in my account, and I have been sitting on a loading dock every night of my life waiting to be asked again. That’s why I’m here. That’s why I never left Pell Harbor.”

“A man who doesn’t answer is not free, he’s just not been billed.”

The lamp does something at that, a very small flicker.

“So you’re telling me,” I say slowly, “that the only way through is to say it.”

“I’m telling you,” says Hollis, “that it’s a question with only one wrong shape. Fast. Everything else is allowed.” He stands, creaking. He puts the thermos on the Ledger as if it were a table. “And Elias.”

“Yes.”

“He’ll want you to say something big,” says Hollis. “Nothing, anything, everything. That’s the shape the old fear takes. You say something small and true. A thing a person could actually hold in his hands. That’s the one he can’t use.”

He goes out. The door closes. We sit in the quiet with a thermos of coffee neither of us is going to drink.

I fall asleep at two, against Elias’s shoulder, in the oak chair, with the lamp on.

I wake at three-ten with the blanket over me and the other chair empty.

The tether tells me before I know I am awake. It is the faint wrong pull of a string with a weight on the far end, and the weight is below me. I am on my feet and in the stairwell before the thought has finished, in my socks, down sixty-one steps with one hand on the rail, and the amber light on the landing clicks on to meet me.

Elias is in the Cold Room, on the brick, on his knees in front of the low door.

He is not touching it. He has his hands on his thighs and his eyes shut, and he is talking, very softly, in the steady voice he uses in the operating room, the one he uses to tell a team what will happen next. I hear it as I reach the arch. I cannot make out the words. I know the cadence. It is a man rehearsing.

“Elias.”

He does not turn. He says, in the same level voice, “I have not said the first word. I want you to know that. I have gone to it, and stopped, forty-one times, and I have said nothing. I am only learning the shape of it.”

“Come away from the door.”

“I will. In one moment.” He opens his eyes. “Juno. I think I have it. Not all of it. The small true thing Hollis said. I think I know what I would not give, and I do not think it is you.”

“Elias.”

“I think it is the—”

The iron ring on the low door turns.

It turns by itself, a full quarter, slow, with a small sweet sound like a latch lifting for a person who has been expected.

The door, which has not moved in a hundred and fifteen years, opens the width of a hand, and out of the gap comes the smell of cold water and old wool, and from somewhere beyond it, beyond the dark, perfectly courteous, in a voice I have never heard but that I know the way I know the shape of my own name, comes a single polite sentence.

“*Not yet,*” it says. “*But thank you for coming early.*”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!