The question hangs in the gray light and does not echo.
What would you not give?
I have been asked worse. A lawyer once asked me whether I believed in what I did, under oath, with a camera on. A man in Toledo asked whether I would take his dead wife’s ring or his living brother’s debt. I have stood in kitchens at four in the morning while families asked me to make a sound stop. I have always had an answer. It was always fast, and it was always a performance.
I have never had a question that was waiting for the truth.
“Take your time,” the Third Party says again, kindly, and on the floor in front of the table the square letters write it down. TAKE YOUR TIME. THE ASKED MAY BE SLOW.
So I am slow.
Item one. Hollis said the first word is the one it hears, and that something big is the shape the old fear takes. Hal said *anything* and was gone in a month. My father said *nothing* with two children in his arms and a lake in his lungs, and it was true, and it was the best answer anyone in this family has ever given, and it is the reason he has been sitting in the dark for twenty-two years.
Item two. I am not going to say it fast.
I look at the floor. The sheet of water at the foot of the low door lies flat as glass, and under it the pool is still there, tile and drain and lane lines, a ribbon of blue that goes down and down. The child’s footprints have stopped. She is waiting, too. I have never been so aware of being watched by something that has the manners of a very patient dog.
Elias’s thumb moves on my pulse, once, a small steady stroke. It is the thing he does to a patient who is about to be told something.
I do not look at him. If I look at him I will say his name, and his name is the wrong answer, though I did not know that until this second. A person is not a thing you can refuse to hand over. A person is a thing you hold, and what you hold you can lose, and what you say you would never give is exactly what a hearing will find a way to ask you for.
*Say something small and true. A thing a person could actually hold in his hands.*
I try *my mother.* It is true. It is also enormous, and I feel it go off in my mouth like a coin that is the wrong denomination. I put it back.
I try *my life.* False. I would give it. I have already given years of it, one way or another, and I would give the rest tonight for a good enough reason, and every person in this room knows that about me, including the one with his hand on my wrist.
I try *the hour.* The time said aloud, the lock on every account in this building. It is the one thing I own outright. But when I turn it over it has no weight. I would give it up, if I had to. I would hate it, and I would give it.
The water waits.
The candles are cold. Somebody behind me is breathing through their teeth. I think it is Priya. I think she has stopped saying *okay.*
What I want, I think. Not what I would not give. What I want.
I want my father to walk out of the chair. I want a Tuesday with no sixty-second limit. I want Margo to say my name twice in a row. I want Elias to live to be old, and it is the first time in my life I have wanted that for someone without arguing with the want first. These are enormous. They are also, every one, requests for somebody else to pay.
And that is the thing.
I stand there with the cold coming up through my boots and I see it, not all at once but the way you see a number on a chart after you have been staring at the wrong column. Every deal I have ever struck in this building has had a second signature.
Every deal anyone has ever struck for me has been struck behind my back. Dolores wrote my father into a ledger as my payee, and I was nine, on a table, with a tube in my throat, and nobody asked me. My father said *nothing* to the lake and gave the lake himself, and I was nine and nobody asked me.
Elias, at fifteen, told a window to take care of me. For twenty-two years he has been paying down a debt of mine in years, alone, in the dark, and he has never once asked me what I thought of the terms.
I did not get to sign any of it. I have been a *payee* since I was nine years old.
I am so angry that for a moment I cannot see the candles.
“Juno,” my father says, very low, from the oak chair. “Junebug. You don’t have to—”
“Daddy,” I say. “I’m going to need you not to help.”
It is the first time I have ever talked to him like that. He shuts his mouth. In the chair, the wet stitch of his sleeve drips once on the brick. His eyes are wide and bright, and something in the lined, exhausted face does a thing I have only seen on Hollis, a flinch that turns into something nearer pride.
I breathe in.
I count it. In, four. Out, four. The way I tell a nervous patient to.
“I have an answer,” I say, “and it’s a small one, and I’d like it to be written down exactly as I say it, because I think the fee is the exactness.”
“The fee is the truth,” says the voice from the empty chair. “The exactness is a courtesy, and I accept it.”
THE ASKED WILL BE RECORDED VERBATIM, say the letters on the floor, in their patient square hand.
I look at the nothing in the chair.
“I would not give,” I say, “my half of the pen.”
A long silence.
It is not the silence of a false answer. I know that one now, the dead, flat refusal Agnes described, the silence that answers a lie by being nothing. This one has weight in it. It has the particular settling quality of a drawer sliding shut on something that fits.
“Be so good,” says the Third Party, “as to say more. Not to the room. To the record.”
I say it more slowly.
“The pen is in the amendments. Clause one: both Keepers write, or neither does. Fifty-fifty. Item one of the stairwell rule: any fee is spoken aloud by both of us, in front of witnesses, before anyone’s hand moves.” My voice is steady and I do not know where it is coming from.
“Elias has been stealing the pen since the day we drafted it. He thinks it is a kindness. He is paying me out in installments so that I never have to sign for anything that hurts. He has done it all my life. My father did it.
The woman who wrote my father’s name in this book did it, and called it per policy. I am thirty-two years old and I have never been allowed to be the one who paid.
“I would not give that up. Not for him, not for Daddy, not for a clean book. If somebody has to be hurt, the pen goes to both of us, or it goes to neither. I will not be rescued by one hand. I would rather drown with my half than be saved with someone else’s whole.”
I hear myself, then. Drown. The room hears it too.
There is a small, dry scratch from the floor.
JUNO FALK, say the letters. WOULD NOT GIVE: HER HALF OF THE PEN. ENTERED. BINDING UPON THE ASKED.
“Is that your answer?” says the voice.
“Yes.”
“You may amend it once, before the question is closed. It will cost you nothing.”
I think about it for a full breath. I think about a version of me who says *and also Elias,* or *and also my father,* who loves more loudly and answers worse.
“No,” I say.
“Then it is closed,” says the Third Party, and, drily, with the satisfaction of a man who has watched a student pass: “It is not the answer I expected. It is better. It is a thing that can be held to.”
Beside me Elias lets out a breath I think he has been holding since Friday.
“What does it do?” he says. “Exactly. Counsel.”
“It is not my place to explain a binding to the bound,” says the voice. “But I will tell you what it does to you, Dr. Hale, since it is also yours.”
I turn my head. Elias is looking at the chair, white around the mouth. He has the face of a man who has just found that a stair is not where he left it.
“Hers is a refusal,” says the Third Party. “A refusal protects. What Miss Falk will not give, no party at this table may take from her, and no party may take it from her by arranging for someone else to give it. Her half of the pen is now outside the reach of the House, of the Water, and of every well-meaning person present.
She may not waive it. She may not be relieved of it. And,” a pause, as exact as a surgeon’s, “no one may now pay her account alone.”
I hear Elias’s breath catch.
“Not on her behalf,” the voice continues. “Not in her stead. Not in secret and not in love. Whatever is owed in her name, she will stand beside whoever pays it, and she will pay her share in the same coin. That is the shape of what she has refused. It is a handsome shape. It will also be inconvenient to her, soon.”
“Soon,” I say.
“The Ground is disputed,” says the voice. “The loan on Juno Falk is secured on the Ground. If the Ground is disputed, the loan may be called. You have had your answer. It was a good one, and a true one, and it is now a fact of this room.”
I do not like what the room seems to be doing with it.
On the floor, in front of all of us, the sheet of water shivers.
It is a small movement, a ripple that runs from the low door out to the edges, the way a pond shivers when a stone is thrown a long way off. The pool inside it goes out of focus. The footprints on the brick, the dry ones, the ones the child left behind, fill all at once, each one brimming.
And the child’s voice, the nine-year-old’s voice, the one that sounds like a girl who has won something, says, from the air about three feet in front of me:
“Then the Water calls the loan.”
“On whose account?” Imogen says. She is on her feet, pen in her fist. Her voice cracks on the second word. “I’m sorry, I know I’m not supposed to speak, but on whose account, that has to be stated, for the—”
“The borrower’s,” says the Water.
My father is out of the chair.
I did not see him move. Out of the chair, on his feet, huge in the gray light, wet to the knees, one hand out toward me, and the voice that comes out of him is not the sixty-second voice, the careful one. It is the voice of the man who stood at the edge of a pool in 2004 and went in. “No. No, no, it’s me. It’s the Ground. It was always me, it says it right there, secured on—”
“You may not,” says the Third Party, and for the first time the courtesy has an edge. It is not harsh. It is a hand laid flat on a table. “Daniel Falk. Sit.”
He does not sit.
“I said it,” he says. “I told the lake. I said anything. I said nothing. I said take me and I meant it, and there is no entry in any book that says my daughter—”
“Your daughter has refused,” says the Third Party, “in the plainest terms, to be paid for by you.”
My father looks at me.
It is the longest look I have had from him since I was nine. I stand there with my hands cold and my pulse going under Elias’s thumb, and my father looks at me across ten feet of damp brick and understands, all at once, that I have just taken away the one thing he has had for twenty-two years: the right to pay for me.
He does not say anything. Something goes out of the line of his shoulders, and something else comes in, and I do not know yet whether it is grief or relief or both, in the tight, awful way that both can sit in a single face.
“Okay,” he says, quietly. “Okay, Junebug.”
He sits.
The water is at my shoe.
I look down. It has crossed the floor in the time it took me to look at him. It is not a flood. It is a bright sheet no deeper than a coin, quiet as paper, and it has reached the toe of my left boot and stopped, politely, the way a cat stops at a threshold.
But the cold is real. The cold climbs the leather and gets in at the lace and the seam, and my foot, from the arch to the ankle, goes to the dull sleeping ache of a limb that has been in a river.
“Elias.”
“I see it.” His voice is level. His hand has closed on my wrist so hard that it hurts, and I do not tell him. “Do not move.”
“It’s not moving,” I say. “It’s just—it’s up to the bone.”
“I know.”
“Counsel,” says Imogen, shrill, “is the Water permitted to, to touch the—”
“The Water is permitted to collect what it is owed, from the one who owes it, in the presence of the parties,” says the voice. “It is not permitted to take more than the loan. It has said what the loan is.” A pause. “It has not said what the loan comes to.”
The child’s voice answers. It is, I think, a little puzzled. It is the voice of a creature that has been told to say a number and has only ever learned the word for *one.*
“The Water lent a girl her breath,” it says. “The Water lent a girl nine years and nine months. The Ground has paid interest for twenty-two years, in the dark, one minute at a time.” The child’s voice stops. In the pale sheet at my feet the pool bottom swells upward and I see the blue cap on the tile, dry as bone. “The principal was never paid.”
“Name it,” says the Third Party. “For the record, and for the ones who are afraid.”
I do not have to turn to know that every person in this room has stopped breathing.
“The rest,” says the Water.
The water rises past my ankle, as slowly as a thought, and a single bell-clear drop falls from the vault into the exact center of my palm, which I did not know I had held out.
It is not cold at all. It is warm. It is the temperature of blood.
“Juno,” says Elias.
I look at the clock on Imogen’s stopwatch, which she has finally clicked. I do not need to. I know the time, and I say it, quietly, to the record, because it is my lock and the only one I own.
“Three forty-one,” I say. “I’m not going anywhere.”
The water, at my shin, does not agree.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!