Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 16

Appeal Sustained

I drove to Larkspur Landing at twenty-four miles an hour, which I had never done on purpose, with Mateo asleep against the passenger window and Councilman breathing on the back of my neck.

It was five-thirty on Sunday morning. The township was gray and empty, and the road, now that I had no powers to protect me from it, felt like a creature that had been told to behave and was thinking it over. At Fenwick and Maple, Hank the pedestrian looked at my car, and then at the speedometer, which I had been warned not to look at, and nodded once, and let me go by.

Larkspur Landing announced itself with a hand-painted sign: LARKSPUR LANDING, A LAKESIDE COMMUNITY, EST. 1962. The lanes were gravel and narrow, with cottages tucked under oaks, and in nearly every driveway sat a Hauler, rust and amber, parked the way cattle are parked in a pen at dawn. Nine of them. I counted twice. At the end of Landing Lane, outside a small white house with a porch, a flatbed idled with its lamp turning, and on the porch an old man in a canvas coat sat in a lawn chair with a thermos on his knee, looking at his own truck.

It was a very good truck. It was green, or had been, with a wooden stake bed and a hood the length of a rowboat, and across the door in hand-lettered white it said WREN & SON, TREES.

“Mr. Wren,” I said.

“Morning.” He did not look away from it. “They gave me till seven.”

“Seven-oh-four,” said Corinne Vasko, from behind me. She was holding a clipboard in both arms and had a pen behind each ear and one in her mouth. She took the one out of her mouth. “I’m sorry. I didn’t sleep. I think I’m supposed to say welcome.”

“Mrs. Okonkwo?”

“In the boathouse. She’s been rearranging the chairs.”

She had. When we came in, the boathouse had been turned from a place that smelled of kayaks into a hearing room, with a long table, a card table for the clerk, and two rows of folding chairs filled with thirty or forty people in coats. Mr. Abernathy was in the front row in his jacket. Mrs. Okonkwo stood at the lectern, a paddle rack, with her binder open and her reading glasses on her head, and she looked like a woman who had slept in a chair and would not mention it.

At six o’clock, a man in a gray windbreaker walked in and sat down at the head of the table. He had a lanyard. His pen clicked once, like a tongue.

“I know him,” I whispered to Mateo.

“Everybody knows him,” said Mateo. “Nobody can describe him.”

[Hearing: Appeal of T. Wren, by Ombudsman A. N. Okonkwo. Respondent: Larkspur Landing Cottage Association, Governor C. Vasko. Hearing Officer: the Inspector.]

It took forty minutes, and I will give only the parts that mattered.

First, Mrs. Okonkwo read Section 12.3 aloud, in her kitchen voice, slowly. No penalty shall be imposed without notice and an opportunity to be heard. She asked Corinne whether the Association had given Mr. Wren notice. Corinne said no. She asked whether an opportunity to be heard had been offered. Corinne said no. She asked whether the form the Association had adopted contained a provision for a hearing, and Corinne, who had read the form three times, said, “It was in the Master Declaration. Not in the form. I didn’t know the Master Declaration applied.”

“It always applied,” said Mrs. Okonkwo. “That is what ‘bound’ means.”

“The Association concedes,” said Corinne, and sat down very fast.

I should have felt relieved. The Inspector, however, was not finished. His pen clicked. “The penalty may be cured by hearing,” he said, in the phone-company voice. “The Board may now proceed.”

“Then I ask that it do so,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, “with a variance request under Section 20.2 on the ground of heritage.”

She had arranged a table of evidence, all of it paper. A truck in front of a church in 1974 with twelve trees roped on. The same truck in 1991, painted. The same truck in 2019, with a small wooden reindeer on the hood. The church secretary had sent a letter. Mateo read it aloud and notarized it, and said, in a small voice, “It didn’t ring. Every word of that is true.”

“Of course it is,” said Mrs. Okonkwo. “That is why we are doing it this way.”

At the back, a woman stood up. She was sixty or so, in a gardening jacket, with a face that had been through a bad year and was still in it. “I’m Janine Hollis,” she said. “I voted yes. I don’t want him towed. I just want it gone.” Her mouth moved. “It’s the first thing I see every morning. It was there when my husband was. It’s the only thing on the lane that hasn’t changed, and I can’t stand it.”

Nobody breathed. The Inspector’s pen did not click.

Mrs. Okonkwo took off her glasses. She said, “How long ago, Mrs. Hollis?”

“Fourteen months.”

“Then it is not a reason to tow the truck,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, very gently. “It is a reason to sit on his porch with a thermos. He has a second chair.”

Mr. Wren, on the other side of the room, lifted his thermos an inch.

I thought that was all, and then I remembered that I had a part. I stood. Nobody had asked me to. I stood in the back of a stranger’s boathouse, a man with no power, and said, “May I address the Hearing Officer?”

“You are the Sponsor,” said the Inspector. “State your interest.”

“I wrote the form,” I said. “It did not have a warning on it. I should have written one. I’d like to apologize to Ms. Vasko, and to Mr. Wren, and to everybody at this Association, for handing you a tool without the instructions. And I’d like to ask whether you would help me write them.”

There was a long silence. Corinne put a pen behind her ear. Janine Hollis sat down.

The Inspector clicked his pen. “Appeal sustained.”

[Appeal sustained. Penalty vacated for want of hearing. Section 6.2(f) suspended pending hearing. Heritage Variance: Lot 41, Section 6.2(f). Granted by the Board, 9 to 4.]

Out on the gravel, the flatbed put itself in reverse. The amber light went out, and the Hauler on Mr. Wren’s lawn, which I had not noticed was there, gave a long creaking exhale and collapsed into a heap of rust and went down into the ground. All down Landing Lane, I heard doors close, engines die, nine small sighs.

Mrs. Okonkwo was packing her binder, tab by tab, the way you pack a suitcase after a long trip.

“Thank you,” I said.

“I was in training,” she said, and shut the clasp. “Thirty-one appeals. I was merely waiting for a worthy case.” She did not smile. She did something more like a person deciding not to. “Noted.”

I spent the rest of the morning at a card table in the corner with Corinne and Janine Hollis and Mr. Wren, writing a page. Corinne held the pen. Janine, it turned out, had been a paralegal. Mr. Wren contributed one sentence, about daylight. By noon we had a draft of what we called Form R-2: notice to every Member, fourteen days of comment, a hearing before any enforcement, and a sunset. Any amendment adopted in the first year would expire in twelve months unless it was ratified a second time. A rule you have to vote on twice, said Janine, is a rule you have thought about.

“That’s good,” I said. “That’s very good.”

“It’s your section number,” said Corinne. “I just changed the font.”

I drove home at twenty-four. At the Stone my mouth filled with warm paper, and the number came back into the corner of my eye, a clean 9, and every porch light on Willow Bend Court but five was on, and I could have wept.

The fifteenth door was open when I got to the Kiosk. It had been waiting for me, I think. Inside was a single envelope on cream-colored paper, addressed in a hand I had once been able to read in the dark. RIVERSIDE TERRACE CONDOMINIUMS. FROM THE GOVERNOR. In the upper corner, in the small, plain print she had always used to write the word Dennis, it said: L. Reyes.

I did not open it for a long time. Mateo, who knows a number of things he has never been told, stood beside me and kept very quiet. At last he said, “Is that—”

“My ex-wife,” I said.

I opened it. There were two lines. Dennis, I think we have a problem, and I think it began with you. Under the signature she had drawn a small sparrow, as she had on every note for twenty years, and I had forgotten about the sparrow until that moment.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!