Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 210

Reasons

The Compact defines the word place at Article 1(h), in eleven words, and in forty-four years nobody on any Committee had thought to read the definition aloud.

Roz read it. She stood at the Clerk's table with the typed pages in her hand and her ruler laid across the ledger, and in the quiet of the tent, with the Tellers counting in fours behind her, her voice had the clear flat sound of a person reading a bus schedule to a congregation.

"Place. Wherever a person is heard by one who did not already know."

Nobody moved.

"That is the whole of it," said Roz. "There is no roof in it. I have read the page three times."

"Section 3.1 has a roof," I said, and then, remembering where I stood, "I beg the Chair's pardon."

"I know it does," said Walter. "That's Willow Bend's. This is the Compact's. They've got different ideas." He took off his cap and turned it in his hands. "I said I had three. That was the third. I wanted to know if you'd built a place or only a tent."

"And?" said Beale.

"It's a place," said Walter. "I'd say it's the only one I've ever sat in."

He put the cap on his knee. And then, in a very plain voice, with his good ear to the room, Walter Abernathy gave his reasons.

I have the text. Roz took it down, every word, in the ledger, and it runs to a page and a half. I will give the substance, for the record, because I think it is the best piece of judging I ever heard.

"One. It's a Settlement. Fifteen thousand and seventy-four is more than ten thousand, and the neighbors weren't told. The Notice is sustained as a matter of fact. I'm not going to say it isn't.

"Two. Nobody can tell a neighbor about a thing in a box they haven't been shown. The Compact was locked in 1974 and the keys were spread among four people who didn't know each other. That's not a Committee's fault. It's whoever locked it. So there's no penalty. Not a fine, not a removal, not a day.

"Three. They've been told now. They're sitting in a tent in front of the neighbors. I'd say that's notice. I'd say that's more notice than most people get.

"Four. Mr. Beale says three of his people are on the list. The Committee of Form L will look for them. With Mr. Beale. Not alone. I don't care how long it takes. Mr. Lyle, you'll keep the book.

"Five." Walter hesitated. He lowered his hand. "I'm told I've got to say what I'd want done in my own case. It's in subsection (g). It was stuck to the back."

"The Chair need not—" said Kuhl, rising.

"Sit down, Mr. Kuhl. It's the rule." Walter looked at the paper. "I'd want to be told. That's all. If I'd gone off on a Friday and been put out of a place for a thing I'd done years before, I'd want somebody to come up the road and say my name, and tell me what I was being put out for, and ask me if I wanted to come back." He raised his eyes. "Not a letter. Not a notice on a kiosk. Somebody at the door. In person."

He did not go on. He did not need to. Somewhere to my left a woman began to cry, and then stopped, as one does in a church.

"So I order it," said Walter. "The Committee of Form L will send a person to every one of the four hundred and twelve. In person. With the name. Beginning with the three. And I'd like Mr. Beale's Committee to go with them. And Mrs. Okonkwo's Settlement." He looked at me, very slightly. "If they've time."

"We shall find the time," said Mrs. Okonkwo.

"That's my ruling." He sat back. "I don't know that I did it right."

"You did it correctly," said Kuhl, rising, very pale, with his briefcase against his chest, "and I should like to say that you did it fair."

There was a silence. And then, from the benches, a sound I had heard once before, in the Hall in Hartford, at the vote on the minutes. It was the sound of a great many people drawing breath, together, as a sail does.

"The Committee of Form M," said Beale, rising, "accepts the ruling." He put his hand on the blanket where the fork lay. "And I should like to add that we should be glad to notify our neighbors. As we are, I believe, about to be a Settlement ourselves."

"Beg pardon?" said Walter.

"We are nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-eight," said Wystan Beale, "plus three."

He did not smile. He glanced at Tamsin Eccles, and she lowered her head. I realized, in the slow way of a man adding a column of figures, what the second impression of the seal had meant. It had not been a complaint. It had been a confession, set down by a Committee that could not say it, and it had been waiting for someone to ask.

"It is correct," said Kuhl, faintly, "and I think it is fair."

"The Chair will note it," said Walter. "The hearing is closed."

The sky above the peak of the tent wrote, in the plain grotesque of Willow Bend, and in the thin violet face of Form M, and in the Committee's gray, three lines, one under the other, as if the three Forms had at last agreed on a pen.

[NOTICE OF CONCERN No. 1: HEARD. Sustained in fact. No penalty. Respondent to notify.]

[Compact, Art. 5(g): reasons stated. Filed.]

[Compact, Art. 9. The First Seat.]

I looked at Roz. She had gone quite still. She was reading, in the ledger, in her small straight hand, the last line of the last page of the Compact, which had been stuck to the back of the sheet that Walter turned over. She had copied it that morning, and had not said.

"Article 9," said Roz, in a voice I had not heard from her. "The First Seat. At every meeting held under this Compact, one chair shall be left empty at the head of the table, for the Fifth Party. If any person occupy the chair at the close of the hearing, that person shall be the Fifth Party's proxy-holder, and shall carry its voice."

"Whose voice?" said Mrs. Okonkwo.

"The Client's," said Roz. "It says it holds one vote."

I turned. I could not help it. I turned to the green form lying on the notary's table, with the blank in the line for the proxy-holder, and the plain firm narrow hand at the foot of it, dated the third of September 1974.

At the end of the dais, at the head of the long table, where for three days no one had thought to look, stood an empty chair. It was a plain wooden chair of the Chautauqua pattern. I did not know who had set it there. It had a gray blanket folded over the back.

The aisle had parted. The old man in the gray coat, with one button missing, had come the whole length of the tent, with his hand on Voss's arm, and he stood now at the foot of the dais, looking up at the chair. He was very tired. He had the face of a man who has been carrying something for a very long time and has been told, at last, to put it down.

"Mr. Pell," said Marguerite Voss, quietly. "You may sit."

"I should like to," said the old man.

He climbed the step. He turned. He lowered himself into the chair, in front of nine hundred persons, with his hands on his knees, and the blanket slid from the back of it and lay on the floor. In the same moment the four Tellers at the table stopped counting.

The sky wrote.

[PROXY: the Declarant's seat. Holder: PELL, J. Accepted, 7:41 p.m., Day 364.]

[The Client has one vote. It will be counted in the election now in progress.]

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!