The proxies arrived on Monday morning in a banker’s box, which is how you know the Master Association had been told to comply.
Brent had filed the inspection demand himself, in his blazer, under Section 15.5(b), which says that any Member may examine any proxy held on any Settlement’s behalf. He had filed it at the Kiosk at 7:00 a.m. At 7:04 the fifteenth door clicked open and a cardboard box came out of it. It should not have fit in the door. It was labeled in beige marker, PROXIES, DORMANT. 1,611.
“Per our records,” said Brent, in a very good Gault, “this is a lot of paper.”
Mateo took the box without a word, and carried it to the card table in the garage, and sat down.
It was a bad week to need a sixteen-year-old. It was midterms. He had a chemistry exam on Tuesday and a history paper due Wednesday. Renata worked nights, but she came off shift on Monday morning, took one look at her son and the box, and said, “Mateo. How many pages is that?”
“Sixteen hundred and eleven.”
“How long does a page take?”
“It depends if it rings,” he said.
“Then it’s going to be a long box,” said Renata. She went home, and came back at four with a thermos of tea, and sat on the step of the garage with her stethoscope in her lap, as she had sat on Ardith’s porch, and did not say anything else.
Each proxy was one page. At the top it said, in the System’s unhurried type, PROXY OF A SETTLEMENT. Beneath it ran a line for the Settlement’s name and a line for the signer’s name, and between them a sentence, the same sentence on every page: The undersigned has read this proxy, appeared before the notary, and understands it. The signature was in a ballpoint pen, a different name on every sheet, in a hand that looked, when I held two pages next to each other, remarkably like the same hand. At the bottom was the stamp. NOTARY PUBLIC, MASTER ASSOCIATION. There was no name.
“Dude,” said Mateo quietly, picking up the fortieth. “It’s the same guy. He’s signing for all of them. He just changes the slant.”
“Can you tell?”
“I can tell when it’s true.” He held the page against his chest, with his eyes shut, the way a person holds a shell to an ear. “This one’s not.” He put it on a pile. “Next.”
I had always thought of Mateo as a skipper, a boy who read the first page of everything and the last and never the middle. In the first hour he dealt the pages like cards. By nine o’clock on Monday night he had slowed to almost nothing. By Tuesday he sat with each sheet for as long as it took, perhaps twenty seconds, perhaps a minute, and put it down in one pile or the other with a care I had only seen in surgeons and in Mr. Abernathy handling a certified letter.
“You could just stamp VOID on the whole box,” I said, on Tuesday night. I said it to be helpful, and I regretted it immediately.
“I could.” He did not look up. “Technically it would be a lie, though. There’s like four hundred of them that are clean.”
“Clean?”
“There’s a real person on the other end. Somebody a guy in a beige jacket got to sign. They didn’t understand it, probably. But they signed. And they said they did, and they weren’t lying.” He turned a page. “That’s the thing I didn’t get before. If I void them I’m doing the same thing he did. I’m deciding what somebody meant.”
I said nothing. I got him a glass of water. I thought of a hearing in my own garage, the false finding, and the spoon on the wineglass, and I did not trust my voice.
By Wednesday afternoon the pile that rang was higher than the one that did not. Twelve hundred and eight to four hundred and three. Mateo’s hands were gray from the paper, and he had a pencil behind his ear that he had put there on Monday and forgotten.
“There’s one more thing,” he said. “It’s the guy.”
The notary of the Master Association stood at the Easement, one inch outside the Stone, where Ms. Gault’s officers had stood on the first night. He was not one of the five. I had never seen him before. He was a beige man of about forty with an ordinary face, a stamp in a brown leather case at his belt, and a sad habit of looking slightly to the left of things. He stood very straight, like a lamp in an empty house. Beside him was the Inspector, with his clipboard and his pen.
“Under Section 15.5(c),” said the Inspector, “a proxy is valid where the grantor appeared before a notary, and the notary inquired, and the grantor answered, whether the instrument was understood.” He clicked the pen. “The Notary of the Association has certified one thousand six hundred and eleven. A Notary of Willow Bend has challenged the certification.”
Mateo stood up with the box in his arms. He was shaking, with exhaustion and cold and two nights of other people’s signatures, and I thought: do not step in. I took my hands out of my pockets and put them in my coat. It was Mrs. Okonkwo who touched my sleeve, once, to remind me it was his chair.
He walked to the Stone. He stopped at the line, because the notary could not cross it, and he said, in the voice I had heard in Lot 9 and the garage and the cemetery gate, quite low, quite level, and not unkind:
“Sir. Do you understand what you’re certifying?”
The beige man looked slightly to the left of Mateo.
“I was asked to stamp,” he said.
“That’s not the question.”
“I was given the stamp. Per the instruction.” His mouth moved a little. “I was not given the part where I understand it.”
“Then it’s not a notary,” said Mateo, gently, “it’s just a stamp.”
And I heard it. Not in my ears. It went through the soles of my shoes into the ground, a long clear sound like a spoon touched to a very large glass, and it went on and on. Three doors down, all the windows hummed. In Lot 14, the concrete heron fell off its pedestal. Across the township, on every route, in every house with a signature in a stranger’s hand, the paper in a drawer, I think, sang once, and it sang flat.
[Notary of the Master Association: certification not made in accordance with Section 15.5(c). 1,208 proxies stamped without inquiry are void.]
[403 proxies attested by a living signer: valid.]
The beige man stood in the sound for a long time. Then he unbuckled his stamp case, set it neatly at the base of the Stone on the Fenwick side, and walked away down Willow Bend Road at an even pace, with his hands loose, like a man leaving a very long shift. Nobody stopped him. The Inspector wrote something down and, I thought, did not click.
Mateo sat down on the curb. He put his head in his hands. “I’m so tired,” he said, “I don’t think I can feel my fingers,” and I sat down next to him on the curb, which I had not planned to do, and said:
“That was yours.”
“I know.”
“No. Listen. I didn’t do it. Mrs. Okonkwo didn’t do it. You asked the question, and you didn’t skip it. That was yours.”
He didn’t say anything. After a while his mother came and sat on his other side with the thermos, and gave him tea, and said, “Chemistry is tomorrow, mijo,” and he laughed, with his face still in his hands.
It was twenty-eight minutes past five. At 5:31, the sky over the Stone turned pale and printed, and for the first time in a week it did not sound polite. It sounded careful.
[Annexation, Phase Two. The corrected disclosure of the Master Association is deemed accepted by every Settlement that has not refused it in writing. Rescission windows under Section 15.7 close Sunday at 7:04 a.m. Annexations then become final. Please remain in good standing.]
Brent had joined us at the curb. He read it twice, in the reading glasses, and he took them off.
“That’s Walter’s rule,” he said. “Delivery is complete only upon acceptance. They took it and turned it inside out. Silence is acceptance.” He looked at me. “It’s a good move, Dennis. I hate that it’s good.”
“How many Annexed?”
“One thousand nine hundred and eighty-eight,” said Mateo from his hands. “Technically. And we’ve got until Sunday.”

