Ardith had a good morning on Saturday, which Trish reported at 9:40 with the particular flat voice of a woman trying not to hope aloud.
It was Day 85. The lighthouse print had been rehung. Tea had been taken, and toast, the crusts left on the saucer like a rule. When I came into the front room of Lot 9 with Mrs. Okonkwo and the binder, Ardith was in the armchair in the robin’s-egg cardigan with her glasses on their chain and a legal pad on her knee. She had written something on it. She looked at us the way a teacher looks at a class she has been waiting for.
“Sit,” she said. “Mrs. Okonkwo says you have a woman who reads Article One as aspirational.”
“A Governor,” I said.
“A person who reads a ‘shall’ as a ‘would be nice’ is not a reader,” said Ardith. “She is a reviewer.” She tapped the pad. “I wrote down what I remember. Don’t interrupt. It will not last.”
I will give it as she gave it, which was in order, because she had written the numbers in the margin and ticked them off with a pencil.
“One. It was March 1974. The client came on a Wednesday without appointment and Lorraine put him in the small room. He sat with his hat on his knee for forty minutes. He said that he wished a Declaration of Covenants for a very large community of indefinite duration, and I said, ‘Florida,’ and he said, ‘Possibly.’” She smiled at the pad. “Two. We went through the Form article by article. He had no opinions about assessments. He had no opinions about setbacks. At Article One he stopped me. I had typed ‘The Declarant may hear Petitions.’ He asked me to change it.”
“To ‘shall.’”
“To ‘shall,’ and then he asked me to add ‘in person.’ I said that was impractical. He said that it was the only thing in the document that he cared about.” She took off her glasses. “I said that no one has the time to hear every petition. He said, ‘Then say, as long as the petitioner requires, and I will make the time.’ I typed it. I thought it was a very sentimental client.”
Mrs. Okonkwo, in the other chair, took a note.
“Three,” said Ardith. “The office of record. I had typed ‘c/o the Declarant’s principal office, Toledo.’ He said no. He said the petitions must be received where there is nothing else going on. A place with nothing in it, so that nothing could get between. I said, a field?” She laughed, a small dry laugh. “He said a field would be ideal. Then he said a trailer, because a trailer can be moved if the field is ever wanted. I thought it was a joke.”
“Moved,” said Mrs. Okonkwo.
“Moved,” said Ardith. “That is not in my writing. It is in his. It is a thing he said.” She turned a page. “Four. I would like to say that I was asked to go to the field with him, in the spring of 1975. I declined. I said I had a brief due. I have been sorry about it for fifty years, and I do not intend to be unclear.” She looked at me. “It is the one place in the whole business where I might have gone and I did not go. It is why I would like you to read the section as it is written. Read it as written. Shall means shall.”
“Is it dinner?” she said, quite gently, to Trish. Her eyes had gone to the window. I saw it start to go, the lamp turning down, and I was ashamed of how quickly I leaned forward.
“Ms. Pomeroy,” I said. “Did he say why? Why the hearing in person?”
She looked at me for a while, in that new, patient half-light.
“He said that he had been told every petition he would ever receive would be addressed to a person,” said Ardith. “And that if nobody was there when it was opened, it would be addressed to nobody.” She lifted her glasses on their chain, set them on her nose, and looked at the print above the mantel. “It is a very pretty lighthouse. I never did see where it goes.”
We left her with Trish and the quiet, and the light of the afternoon came into the room like a thing that does not know it is leaving.
Mrs. Okonkwo wrote the contest in eleven minutes, on the hood of the sedan, in the driveway of Lot 9, with Mateo holding the binder and the dog’s lead.
I will give the text because it was the finest brief I have seen. It cited Article One, Section 1.4, and the phrase shall hear every Petition in person as long as the Petitioner requires, and the 1974 Form’s Section 1.8, uniform enforcement, which reads, as written, that the Association shall enforce the Declaration uniformly or not at all. It invoked the Ombudsman’s power to contest a ruling by citing a section. It said, in a single sentence which I have memorized, that the Declarant is a Governor of the Master Declaration within the meaning of the Form, and that a Governor’s ruling that disposes of a Petition without hearing it is a ruling within the meaning of the section. It asked that Order Number One be stayed. It requested a hearing at the office of record. It was signed, in an upright hand, A. Okonkwo, Ombudsman, Lot 4.
Mateo notarized it on the roof of the car. He asked her whether she understood. “I have understood this document,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, “since 1974.” It did not ring.
Abernathy took it by the corner. He carried it the eleven miles to the Field himself, in his jacket, on the back seat of Brent’s car, with his rubber stamp in his lap. At the gravel pad, outside the trailer, in front of a hundred or so Eastgate Lakes staff in polo shirts who were carrying folding tables, he said, “Beg pardon,” in the voice he uses for a piece that matters, and offered it to the new Declarant with both hands.
I was not there. I had it from Ms. Gault, who had gone with him with a clerk’s notebook and said afterward that the Governor of Eastgate Lakes read it standing in the sun for four minutes without any expression on her face.
“She did not refuse,” said Ms. Gault. “A woman who refuses delivery has already lost.” She turned her pencil over. “She took it, and she signed the receipt, and she said, ‘Well put.’” A pause. “She said it exactly as she wrote it on your card, Dennis. As though she meant it.”
At 7:04 that evening the sky above the Stone printed in the gray font. I was in my own driveway with a cup of tea. Councilman was on my shoe.
[Contest of Ruling filed by the Ombudsman, Lot 4. Accepted. Section 12.3. Order Number One: stayed pending inspection.]
[Inspector assigned. The Declarant (Interim) is a Governor within the meaning of the Form.]
I do not know what I expected. I have never seen a man in a gray windbreaker go out of a Settlement at a run. The Inspector came down Willow Bend Road past the Stone at 7:11 p.m., with his clipboard held against his chest and his pen clicking like a tongue, on a quick, unpracticed jog, and he looked at me as he went by with a face so completely without expression that it looked, for a quarter second, like something else.
He was very nearly eager. It was the only time in his whole existence that he had been asked to do what he was for.
“An inspection,” I said, to the dog.
At 8:19 p.m. the sky printed again.
[Inspection: Declarant (Interim). Office of record. Section 1.4. Nonconformity: 1. Order Number One disposes of Petitions without hearing them in person. Cure: hearings in person, as long as the Petitioner requires.]
[Section 1.8: The Association shall enforce the Declaration uniformly or not at all. The Declarant is bound.]
Then, in the same small gray type, smaller, as though someone had remembered a thing at the last moment:
[Notice of Hearing, Petition 4,402-A. Office of record. Tomorrow, 7:04 a.m. Petitioners present: 0. Petitioners en route: 1.]
“Four-four-oh-two-A,” said Mateo, from the porch rail. He had the pizza box. He had stopped writing on it. “Mr. K. That’s the water. Who’s en route?”
I knew before I looked. I looked anyway, down the long dark of Willow Bend Road, to the crosswalk at its far end, where a refrigerator-sized figure in a raincoat was holding a yellow taxi at the line, and taking off his hat. In the back seat, small and upright in a quilted vest, with a cane across her knees, sat a woman who had not gone home.

