I keep a binder labeled OPEN ITEMS. For eleven years it has been the thickest binder on my shelf, and on the morning of Day 167 I carried it out to the cul-de-sac and set it on a card table in the sun.
“Mr. Kowalczyk,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, from a lawn chair. “That is not a binder. That is a confession.”
“It’s a docket.”
“It is thirty-nine items. I counted on Sunday. Nineteen of them are marked Continued, and fourteen of those are in your handwriting.” She turned a page of her knitting. “I am merely observing that you have held a great many hearings since October and not one of them was your own.”
“I know.”
“Noted,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, kindly.
She was right. I had held hearings in a trailer, in a motel, in a community room in Ohio, and not once in my own cul-de-sac. It is easier to be fair to strangers. They have no history with your lawn.
At nine o’clock I rang the Settlement bell, which is a brass cowbell Walter Abernathy found at a yard sale in 2013 and which hangs from a hook on the monument. It does not sound like authority. It sounds like a cow. Fourteen lots came out onto the circle in coats and slippers, with coffee. Lloyd set the green notebook on the table. Mateo sat down with the register. Councilman took Seat 3, which is now a lawn chair with a plaque.
“Open business,” I said. “Willow Bend Court Association, regular session, in daylight. Item one. Violation #77. Lot 11. A fence.”
The Dhillons stood up. They are a tall, courteous couple in their sixties who have been fined for a fence by me in every one of the last nine summers, and who have paid, in checks, on time, with a note each year that says, in the same flat politeness, Thank you for the reminder. The fence is six feet four inches. The covenant says six feet. It encloses a rose garden that Mrs. Dhillon’s mother planted and it hides nothing. I had continued the hearing thirty-eight times.
“I’m hearing it,” I said. “Say what you’d like to say.”
“The fence is four inches over. We could cut it down. We have the saw.” He looked at his wife. “We would prefer not to.”
“Why?”
“Because it is where my mother-in-law’s roses stand,” said Mrs. Dhillon. “The extra four inches is for the wind.”
I looked at the roses, which in March were a wooden tangle of canes, and I tried to remember what I had been afraid of. I had been afraid that if I granted one, I would have to grant them all.
“I move a Heritage Variance under Section 20.2 for Lot 11, Fence, six feet four inches, in perpetuity,” I said. “For the roses. Lloyd?”
“Second,” said Lloyd.
“Councilman?”
The dog lifted his head from his paws. He considered. He thumped his tail once, hard, against the lawn chair.
“Carried three to nothing.” I wrote it down. It took eleven seconds, and it was the first one that I had finished in my own handwriting in two years.
[Variance granted: Lot 11, Sec 4.3 (Fence Height), Heritage.]
[Violation #77: closed. Standing: +1.]
It was a very small number. I felt it anyway, like a coin dropped into a jar I had not known was mine.
We did the flagpole at ten. It was nine inches above the permitted height, and Mr. Haldane said so himself, apologetically, with his cap in his hands. I cured it with a notch in the pole. I did Brent’s shed, and the Whelans’ hot tub, which I finally and formally approved, with a rider that Marcy Whelan must let Abernathy use it Thursdays for his knee. By noon the OPEN ITEMS binder had gone from thirty-nine to eleven, and every lot on the court was standing in its own driveway, talking.
[Violation #81, #82, #84: cured. Standing: +1.]
[Violation #90: withdrawn by the Association. Standing: +1.]
It was ten to twelve. I turned the page of the binder, and my hand stopped.
Lot 9.
I had kept it for last, the way a man keeps a bill for last. It was a single sheet, and it ran for seventy-two lines. On the first line was a date in the spring of 2019 and the number $15. On the last line was a date in the first week of October and the same number. Beside every line there was a tick in my own pencil, and a note in the margin, in handwriting that had grown, over six years, noticeably smaller. Paid.
“Mr. Kowalczyk,” said Mrs. Okonkwo.
“It’s Item thirty-one,” I said. “Violation #96. Lot 9. Failure to file a Vacancy Registration.” I heard my voice go. “Seventy-two months. Fifteen dollars. One thousand and eighty.”
Nobody spoke. Trish Whelan, at the edge of the circle, took off her cap.
“She paid every one,” I said. “By cashier’s check. On the first of the month. I thought, when I started, that it was a way to make her come. To make someone come to a meeting.” I stopped. “I don’t think I thought that. I think I was angry that nobody came, and she was the only person who didn’t have to. And I took it out on her. And she paid. She never once wrote a note. And I resented it. I resented that she paid.”
“You did,” said Mrs. Okonkwo.
“I’d like to have the hearing,” I said. “Is the proxy here?”
“The proxy,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, putting down her knitting, “is me.”
She stood, which took a moment, and she walked, with her cane, to the card table, and she did not say anything at all. She picked up the sheet. She read the whole thing, line by line, as she had read thirty-one of my notices and thirty-one of her own replies, and when she was through she laid it down very precisely, in the center of the table.
“I find the Respondent,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, “not in violation. I find the Association in violation of Section 12.3, uniform enforcement. A Vacancy Registration was not required of Lot 9 under the 2019 amendment. It was required of lots that were unoccupied. Lot 9 is occupied. It has been occupied for fifteen years by a woman who is merely not in the house.” She looked at me over her glasses. “I would ask the Association for restitution.”
“Granted,” I said.
“One thousand and eighty dollars.”
“Granted. Lloyd, please cut a check.”
“Already did,” said Lloyd, and he had. It was in an envelope. It had her name on it, in the green ink of the notebook. He had written it in the middle of the Dhillons’ hearing, I think, and I had not seen him do it.
“And the Respondent’s direction as to disposition?” said Mrs. Okonkwo. “I believe that I may take her instruction, as proxy, on small matters.”
“What would she want?” I said.
“I do not know,” she said. She considered. Then, quite suddenly, she smiled, a small, quick, private smile, the one I had seen once when Linda called her Adaeze. “I believe that I know. The sunroom has one fish. It has been a great sorrow to the residents. I believe that she would like it to have two.”
I laughed. It came out of me in a great, undignified bark, and the dog answered, and for a moment the whole circle laughed with us.
[Violation #96: closed. Association in violation of Sec 12.3. Restitution ordered.]
[Standing: +1.]
[Standing: 9.]
I checked it twice. It stood.
“Beg pardon,” said Abernathy.
I turned. He had come down off his porch in his uniform coat with a letter in his hand, and he held it out to me at arm’s length, between thumb and forefinger, the way one holds something that might be later than it looks.
“Postmarked,” he said, “the fifth of November, 1974. Postage due eight cents. It was in the last slot of the Kiosk, behind the panel. I have been carrying the route fourteen years and I have never opened that slot.” He cleared his throat. “It could not be delivered. The street was not on the route. The street was not built. It has been waiting for the address to exist.”
I looked at the envelope. It was cream. It was addressed in a tidy, level hand, on a manual typewriter whose e dropped below the line.
*Miss Ardith Pomeroy. Lot 9. Willow Bend Court. Fenwick Township, Michigan. By hand, when she is able to receive it.*

