On the evening of Day 174, forty-one Declarants of the Master Form stood in a motel banquet room that was not on any map and said the word Nay to a dog.
“Again,” I said. “With conviction.”
“Nay,” said Art Brzostek, in the voice of a foreman at a safety meeting.
“Nay,” said Vera Lindqvist-Hale, who had learned it in the gloves and kept it in the pockets.
“Nay!” cried Chip, the way a nineteen-year-old does when someone has asked him whether he cleaned his room, and eleven people applauded.
Councilman lay in front of the dais with his head on his paws and watched them with the grave detachment of a man at the end of a long shift. He had given up barking. He had given up everything but his tail.
We had come to the Inn at four. It had been waiting for us at its usual exit, gray under a gray sky, with its sign still dark and its ice machine still humming somewhere in the walls, and when the trailer rolled up with the Stewards’ cars behind it the front door opened by itself, with a faint, polite chime. The Ring had followed. It stood in the lot, in its rows, white to the shoulders, and the heated tent had been put up again beside it, and Janine Hollis sat inside with a thermos, taking her shift.
“Why do we practice?” said Hortense, of H-3. “It is a one-syllable word.”
“Because the first time you say it out loud you’ll want to explain,” I said. “Don’t. Don’t explain. If you’re going to object, say Nay, and stop. It’s the hardest thing in the world.”
“It is,” said Ottoline Brandt, from the dais. She stood behind the lectern with her gloves off and the ebony gavel at her elbow, small, upright, and entirely composed. “I have been practicing in a kitchen for two weeks. I assure you, I have never been so tired.”
They went around the room. They did it in roll order, forty-one times, and every one of them said it, and each of them said it differently. Halloran Ames said it apologetically, like a man who has been given the wrong coat. The beehive woman said it, and a bee, quite visibly, flew out of her hair, circled the dais and left through the vent. A. Delacourt-Finch’s empty gray chair stood in the second row, and somebody had set a folded sweater on it.
When it had gone all the way around, Brandt tapped the gavel, once, very lightly.
“Thank you,” she said. “I believe that is the first time in fifty-one years the Council has had a rehearsal.”
I stood at the back of the Ambassador Room and watched an old woman look at a room full of people who had once been afraid of her, and then I went out into the corridor to write.
I had been putting it off for three days. I write like a claims adjuster, which is to say precisely, in the passive voice, with every date and number in its place. It is not a good style for a plea. I sat down at a folding table in the corridor with a legal pad and four pens and wrote Dear Members of the Executive Session. I crossed it out. I wrote To the Executive. I crossed it out. I wrote Pursuant to Section 3.2(c).
“Mr. Kowalczyk,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, behind me. “May I?”
She took the pad. She read what I had, which was two paragraphs and eleven section numbers, and she handed it back.
“It is very accurate,” she said.
“Thank you.”
“It is also written to be filed, and not to be read.” She sat down opposite, with her binder on her knee. “You are not going to be in the room, Dennis. Mr. Pike will be, and Mateo, and I do not think that any of them will have occasion to read a footnote. They will say what you have asked them to say, in the words that you gave them.” She laid a finger on the pad. “What do you want them to say?”
“That we object to the retirement of Form P-3.”
“Why?”
“Because it’s—” I stopped. I heard it coming, and I let it come. “Because it’s a lot of people. Nine thousand nine hundred and thirty-one. Because they came out in the cold and signed in ballpoint, and they didn’t have to. Because a girl in a pink coat has a number on a Roll and she thinks it’s small.” I looked at the pad. “Because nobody asked them. It’s their house, and nobody asked.”
“Then write that.”
“It isn’t a legal argument.”
“Mr. Kowalczyk,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, “there are two persons in that room who have been waiting for fifty-one years to be asked a question. I do not believe that they require a citation.” She took out a pen of her own and put it in my hand. “Write it as you said it to me.”
It took me an hour. I did not use a single section number. When I had finished it was six sentences, on a single sheet, in my own bad handwriting, and I gave it to her, and she read it standing up, in the light from the old brass fixture over the corridor. When she had finished she folded the paper in thirds and tucked it into the binder.
“Noted,” she said.
“Is it all right?”
“It is the best thing you have ever drafted.” She regarded me over her glasses. “I have told you that I would never say that. I find I am tired of the policy.”
Abernathy had come at dusk, in the sedan, with the last envelope on the seat beside him. He came down the corridor at a quarter to seven in his uniform coat. He walked to the end, where a brass slot had opened beside the Ambassador Room door, nine inches wide, with the hinged flap. He put the envelope into it. It was a single sheet, cream, with a signature, in a very slow, very proud hand, that went a few degrees uphill.
The slot gave its soft sound, like a page turning.
[Written requests under Section 3.2(c): received, 9,931.]
[All Members of the affected Settlements have asked. The session of Day 175 will not be closed.]
[Standing: +2.]
Eleven. I stood quite still. The taste in my mouth was warm paper, and under the paper, faintly, something I had not tasted in a month. It took me a moment to find the word. It was cold water.
“Beg pardon,” said Abernathy. “Delivery is complete.”
“Thank you, Walter.”
It was not until I had walked to the end of the corridor with him, and we stood together, in the half dark, looking at the plate, that I noticed the hum.
It was very faint. It came from the wall beside the Ambassador Room door, a long, low, continuous note, below hearing, in the bones of the jaw. It had a texture. It sounded like a very large machine, a long way underground, running a little ahead of schedule.
“Mr. K,” said Mateo, from the doorway of the banquet room, white-faced. He had the tuning fork out. It was not humming. It was vibrating so hard that it blurred. “Mr. K, it’s Wednesday. It’s Tuesday tomorrow.”
“I know.”
“It’s not supposed to hum till seven fifteen.”
“I know.”
“What time is it?”
I looked at my watch. It was 7:14.
I looked at the wall clock over the dais, through the open door. It said 7:14. I looked at Abernathy’s pocket watch, which he drew out of his waistcoat and held up in the lamplight, and it said 7:14. Forty-one Declarants stood in the Ambassador Room with their wrists raised, one by one, and not one of them said anything, and in every watch and clock in that building the second hand had stopped.

