Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 98

The Dam

Westerly Acres has a clubhouse, and I want to put on record that I was not prepared for it.

It stands at the end of Lakeview Drive, forty miles up the road from Orchard Row, a low cedar-shingled building with a stone chimney and a flagpole and a sign over the door that reads WESTERLY ACRES LAKE ASSOCIATION, EST. 1962, and it has been standing since 1979. It has a porch. It has a bulletin board under glass. It has a kitchen with a window onto the water. It is, in every particular, the clubhouse in Section 2.9 of my Declaration, the one proposed in 2009 and never built, and I stood on its porch steps on Friday morning with my hat in my hand like a man visiting the house he might have grown up in.

“It’s nice,” said Mateo, beside me. “Right? Mr. K? It’s really nice.”

“It’s adequate,” I said.

“You’re doing the face.”

“Noted,” said Mrs. Okonkwo, and went in.

The Association met in the main room, on folding chairs, forty-one of them, which was the number of households currently speaking to the other twenty-one. The president was a retired schoolteacher named Roberta Fenn, seventy, short, in a quilted vest, with a gavel she did not use. She shook all of our hands and Councilman’s paw. She did not ask who we were. She had, I saw, a stack of paper on the table in front of her three inches thick, bound with a green rubber band, and she laid her hand on it as people lay a hand on a Bible.

“Thirty-seven years of minutes,” she said. “We never stopped meeting. The first Thursday of every month.”

I had expected resentment. I had come with a speech. What I received, over the next two hours, was the single most dignified presentation of a grievance that I have ever been party to, delivered in a series of quiet statements by people who had waited so long they had stopped expecting to be answered. In 1988 a Notice had come for Westerly Acres, on a Tuesday, in a brown envelope slipped under the clubhouse door. Retired in good standing. They had read it aloud. Nobody had understood it. For two weeks they had thought it was a tax matter.

“We wrote,” said Roberta. “We wrote three times. We wrote to the Master Association at the only address we had, which was a post office box in Toledo. The first time we asked what we had done. The second time we asked what we should do. The third time, in nineteen ninety-four, we asked whether anyone was there.” She took a breath. “It was returned in a stamped envelope. It said, Per our records, this Settlement is not on the Register. I believe it was meant kindly.”

I looked at Gault’s name on the minutes pinned to the board. It was not on them. But I knew whose hand had stamped the envelope, and I did not look at Mrs. Okonkwo, because she had stopped writing.

“We’re still a community,” said a man at the back, in a plain voice. “I want that said. We don’t need a Declaration to talk to each other. We’ve fed each other through eleven winters. But we haven’t got a dam.”

“A dam,” I said.

“Come and see,” said Roberta Fenn.

We walked down to the lake in a line, forty of us, in a thin gray wind. The lake was a long, still, black-green water about a mile across, held in a shallow hollow at the foot of the Acres by an earth embankment forty feet high, with a concrete spillway at the north end and a gravel path along the crest. I should say that I am a claims adjuster. It is the thing I know. I have stood on a thousand lawns and measured the distance between what was and what is. I took out my tape measure, which I carry in my coat as other men carry a rosary, and I walked the crest alone.

I found it eighty feet from the spillway.

It was a crack. It ran across the crest at a slant, thirty-one feet from the downstream shoulder to the upstream face, and it was, at its widest, three-eighths of an inch. I got down on my knee on the gravel. Water was weeping out of the downstream face about a third of the way down. It was clear. It was a thin bright line like a wire. I put my hand in it and it was cold, and when I took the hand away I saw that I had left a clean print in the silt.

“How long?” I said, without looking up.

“Since March,” said Roberta Fenn. She had come out on the crest beside me. “We measured it, with a ruler. It was an eighth.”

“It is three-eighths now.”

“I know.”

“The damage is not cosmetic,” I said. I had said that sentence many times. It had always meant that someone would have to be told. I had never said it in a place where I was the one who would be asked. “It will hold the winter. I would not bet the spring thaw on it. If the water finds the seam, it will not give notice. It’ll go in a night.” I stood. My knee hurt. “How much?”

“An engineer from Fort Wayne said one hundred and eighty-four thousand dollars, and he said it quietly.”

“Sixty-two households. That’s about three thousand each.”

“That’s about three thousand each,” said Roberta Fenn. “We have forty-one who have paid, voluntarily, since the first of the year, out of savings. We have twenty-one who cannot or will not.” She put her hands in her vest. “We have no covenant to bind them. We have no lien. We have no shall. Mr. Wozniak says he moved to Westerly Acres to not be told, and I have thought, for thirty-seven years, that this was the most reasonable thing a man ever said, and I would like to put the question to you, as a representative of the Association that retired us. What do I tell him?”

I looked at the dam. I looked at the lake. I looked at forty people in coats along a gravel path, who had never stopped being a Settlement, and I thought about a woman in a flannel shirt who said it was a mercy.

I do not want to be the kind of man who says everything has two sides. It is a thing said by people who are about to do nothing. But I stood on that crest, with three-eighths of an inch of daylight at my feet, and I understood that the same notice, in the same brown envelope, with the same politeness, had been a mercy in one orchard and an abandonment on one lake, and that nobody had asked either of them which it was.

“I don’t know,” I said. “I’m sorry. I’ll find out.”

“We are not asking you to be sorry,” said Roberta Fenn. “We are asking you to come back.”

We drove home in the dark, at twenty-four miles an hour. Mateo fell asleep with his head against the window. Vera, who had been very quiet, said at last in the back seat, “I have been Declarant for sixty-three years and have never once been asked to come back to anything,” and then, hastily, “I do not mean that as a complaint.”

It was past ten when we turned into Willow Bend and I put the car in park in front of Mrs. Okonkwo’s blue door. She did not get out. She sat with the binder in her lap and looked straight ahead through the windshield at the Settlement Stone, which glowed faintly in the dark.

“Mr. Kowalczyk,” she said.

“Yes.”

“I am going to file something. I should like you not to tell me what Mrs. Strand said. I heard it. I heard both.”

“What are you going to file?”

“Appeal No. 1.” She opened the binder to a clean page and took the cap off her pen. “Under the Ombudsman’s power. Against the acts of the Community Manager, as instructed by the Declarant. Sections 5.2 and 12.3. I have thirty-one appeals against you on the books, and I have won about forty percent, and I have never in my life filed one against the thing that was above you.”

“Imogene asked to be asked,” I said. “She asked us to ask.”

“I know,” said Mrs. Okonkwo. “That is what I am doing. I am asking.” She wrote the word Appeal at the top of the page in a very steady hand. Then, with her pen above the paper, she said, more quietly, “It is possible that I will not like the answer.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!