Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 2

The Books Behind the Books

I said yes. Of course I said yes. But I said it with conditions, which is the only way I know how to lose my mind.

“The audit is not for sale,” I told Bea Tuckerman, on the dugout steps, with two hundred mourners pretending to eat. “If I find fraud, I report fraud. If I find nothing, I report nothing. The bet only decides what you tell me. It doesn’t decide what I write.”

“That’s the most honest thing anybody’s said to me since Orrin died,” said Bea. “Deal.”

“In writing.”

“She wants it in writing, Ward.”

Ward closed his eyes, the way a man does when he hears a smoke alarm in his own house. Then he took a pen from the pocket of his funeral jacket and wrote the terms on the back of a hot-dog wrapper, and all three of us signed it. For the record, I have never been prouder of a legal document, and it was greasy.

The next morning I walked into the front office at seven-fifteen.

The front office of the Tallow Creek Night Herons used to be a ticket booth, and in some ways still was. Three desks, one window, a framed photo of a team from 1961, and a coffeemaker that sounded like a man clearing his throat. Someone had left a tray of muffins on my desk with a note that said AUDITOR in block capitals. I put the muffins in a drawer. One does not eat the evidence.

Ward appeared at eight with two folders and a face like a man who had slept in a lawn chair.

“The Show Book,” he said, sliding the first one over. “Everything the state asked for. Bank statements, ticket reconciliation, payroll, sales tax. All clean. All true.”

“And the second folder?”

“Is lunch. Nothing in it to audit.”

I opened the first folder. It took me forty minutes to see what was wrong with it, and what was wrong with it was how right it was. Real books have grease on them. Someone’s coffee ring. A tax payment that is three days late for a reason nobody remembers. The Herons’ books were so tidy that I felt I was reading an apology.

“This is a clean-room set,” I said.

“It’s an organized set.”

“There are no mistakes in it.”

“We’re careful people.”

“Mr. Tuckerman. Nobody is that careful. A real set of books has a receipt somebody lost and reconstructed in July. This looks like it was written by an honest person who has been very hurt.” I tapped the Grounds line. “Where’s the meat?”

“Concessions,” Ward said, and then, because I only looked at him, “the hot dogs are good.”

“The hot dogs are three dollars. Your wholesale meat invoices, from a place called Marrow Creek Packing, are thirteen thousand dollars a month in the summer. If every person who ever came to a Herons game ate eleven hot dogs, you’d still lose money.”

He opened his mouth. Then, in the pause, he picked up the stapler on my desk and began to fix a stapler that was not broken.

“Ward.”

“I’ll get you the invoices,” he said, to the stapler.

I spent that day, and part of the next, in a fog of beautiful, boring detail, which is where I live.

Here is what the invoices showed. Marrow Creek delivered, on twelve dates last season, a pallet of ground beef and lamb trim and something labeled “organ blend,” forty-one pounds a head for a number of heads I could not determine. Each delivery went not to the ballpark but to a place called the Away, a four-hundred-acre parcel upriver that the club listed as a “parking and overflow lot.” Nobody had ever parked a car there. The tax file said so.

The deliveries came the day before each rainout.

I did not like the pattern. I did not like that I was starting to like it.

At two o’clock the second day I walked up to the radio booth, where Roz Pickett, fifty-two, announcer, weather certifier, and the single most cheerful woman I have ever met, was eating pickles from the jar and rehearsing “Welcome, baseball fans” in seven different voices.

“Audit!” she said. “I love an audit. Pickle?”

“No, thank you. Ms. Pickett, you’ve certified twelve rainouts for the Herons in the past season.”

“I certify what I see.”

“What did you see?”

She put a pickle down. She looked at me for a long, delighted moment, as if I were a present she had been hoping for.

“A lot of moon,” said Roz. “Honey, I’m going to tell you something for free, because you’ve got a nice face and I’ve known your family since you were in a stroller. Don’t ask me again. If you ask me again, I’ll lie, and I’m very good at it, and then neither of us will feel like a person.”

Before I could ask how she knew my family, a man came through the booth door with a clipboard and an expression I recognized from every audit I have ever done. It was the face of the man who wants me gone.

“Dale Tuckerman,” he said. “Concessions. Your car’s in a fire lane.”

“My car is in a space marked Visitor.”

“The visitor is you, so that’s technically the fire lane.” He was forty or so, built like Ward without the kindness, with a lanyard and a grievance. “Look. I’m going to be honest with you. This place costs more than it earns. My cousin is a sweetheart who can’t say no to anyone, and my grandmother thinks she’s running a charity. If you could, I don’t know, just finish quickly. Write what you have to write.”

“I’ll write what I find.”

“Sure,” said Dale. He smiled with half his mouth. “Sure you will.”

He left. Roz was already humming something. I went back down to the office, and in the passenger seat of my car, because I never leave home without one, I opened my father’s old farmer’s almanac, the one he buys every December and annotates in green pen.

I had a column of twelve dates on the back of a napkin. The almanac had a column of moon phases printed on every page.

I read them against each other. Then I read them again, slowly, with my finger, like a child.

Every one of the twelve rainouts fell on a full moon or on the night right after one. I checked the last date three times, hoping to catch myself in an error. I couldn’t.

Six full moons in a baseball season, two nights each. Twelve dry nights. One pack of reasons.

I did not believe what the napkin said. I believed the napkin.

When I got back to the office, Ward was standing at my desk with the second folder in his hands and a smile that had not been there at breakfast. It was not a happy one.

“I’ve been thinking about your working rules,” he said. “Anything in this building, anything on the books, any person, any time. Except one. I want to ask you for one thing, and I’m asking, not telling.”

“Go on.”

“Don’t be at the park on a rainout night. Not this month. Not any month. Please.”

The next one was in seven days. I had already circled it.

“No,” I said.

“Cilla.”

It was the first time he had used my name. It did something unfair to the air in the room.

“Counter-offer,” I said. “I’ll tell you which of your answers I believe, and you tell me which of my questions you wish I hadn’t asked.”

Ward put the folder down on the desk between us. It was, I noticed, the Book. I did not touch it.

“All of them,” he said. “I wish you hadn’t asked all of them.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!