A loan agreement is a love letter written by a lawyer who expects to be betrayed.
I read this one at the long table in the Herons’ front office on Tuesday, with Dale Tuckerman across from me, a pot of coffee between us and a stack of documents the thickness of a brick. It had arrived by courier that morning with a cover note on cream stock: NOTICE OF ASSIGNMENT. Strommen Riverfront Partners, LLC, successor to Tallow Creek Savings and Loan. Please direct all future correspondence.
“It’s a hundred and eighty pages,” said Dale. “I read the first four and went to look at the freezer.”
“What was in the freezer?”
“Same as yesterday. I just wanted to check.”
He had shaved. That was how I knew he was frightened. Dale Tuckerman, who had taken a month to go from a resentful concessions manager to the pack’s deputy and an honest witness, had a way of cleaning up when things got bad, as if he could be the person he wished the situation were.
“Start from the top,” he said. “I don’t understand it. We pay on the note. We’ve paid every month for twelve years.”
“That’s the first thing I want to know.” I uncapped a green pen. “Why twelve years?”
“My dad died in 2011. The note was to cover the estate and the roof on the third-base side. Bea signed. Interest only for ten years, then a balloon. I always thought we’d refinance.”
“We’ll start at the balloon.”
I found it on page thirty-one. I read the paragraph, then read it again with my finger under the words, because a lawyer’s sentence will hide a number in a subordinate clause the way a cat hides in a laundry basket.
“The principal balance is two million four hundred thousand,” I said. “Due in a single payment on the thirtieth of November. There was an extension option in the original. It required the lender’s consent, in writing, no later than ninety days before maturity.”
“That’s August thirty-first.”
“Which is the day Bea collapsed at the peanut stand.” I did not look up. “The bank, as it then was, didn’t send the extension notice. Nobody noticed. Mr. Odell, the loan officer, retired in June. The file sat. And the file’s been bought by the one man in this county who would know exactly what to do with it.”
“We can pay it,” said Dale. “Can’t we? We’ve got the reserves.”
“What do we have?”
He didn’t know. He looked at the wall. Behind him, on a corkboard, were pinned eleven years of Fan Appreciation Day flyers, each one a little more faded than the last, each with a clip-art heron holding a pretzel.
“Three hundred and ten thousand in operating cash,” I said, for him. “Ninety-one thousand in the Rain Check Fund, which is for meat and cannot be used for anything else, by Bea’s own bylaw, which I respect. Call it four hundred, rounded up. You would need two million more by Thanksgiving.”
“Okay.” He breathed. “Okay. That’s bad.”
“It isn’t the worst of it.”
I turned to page sixty-eight and put the green pen down on the paragraph. It was headed COVENANTS OF THE BORROWER. Section 9.4(c). I read it aloud, because I wanted him to hear it in a voice that was not a lawyer’s.
“The Lender or its agents may enter upon the Premises and inspect the Collateral at any hour, day or night, upon not less than twenty-four hours’ written notice, and the Borrower shall afford full and unrestricted access to all structures, grounds, and outbuildings. Failure to afford such access shall constitute an Event of Default, upon which the entire unpaid principal shall become immediately due and payable.”
Dale sat very still.
“Any hour,” he said. “Day or night.”
“Yes.”
“On a moon night.”
“On the twenty-seventh of October, at nine p.m., or two in the morning, with twenty-four hours’ written notice. If we refuse, the note is in default and the balloon comes due the same afternoon.” I closed the binder over my pen. “Do you see what this is? It isn’t a loan. It’s a key to the front door.”
“He bought the bank to get the key.”
“He bought the bank’s loan book. Eleven hundred loans and a lot of farmland and a small cheese plant. The Herons’ note is one line. But it’s the line he wanted.” I took off my glasses and pressed the bridge of my nose. “This clause was in the original in 2011. Mr. Odell never enforced it. It was boilerplate. But it’s perfect for a man who wants to be standing on your infield on a night the park holds a hundred and twelve wolves.”
“Nobody will tell him the date.”
“He knows the date. He has the same calendar I have.” I put my glasses back. “He’s known the moon table for years, Dale. He told me so in July. He says he’s a student of the Herons.”
Dale stood up. He went to the corkboard and straightened a flyer that didn’t need straightening, which was the way he showed fear, and then he turned around.
“My dad signed the first page of that,” he said. “Rafe. I was thirty, and he’d been in the ground three weeks, but his signature was on the draft. Bea said it was a power of attorney. He’d signed it earlier. I never asked.”
“Why not?”
“Because he was my dad,” said Dale, simply, “and he never did anything wrong that I was told about.”
I let that stand. In my experience, nothing improves a sentence like that by being answered.
“There’s a legal path,” I said. “I haven’t found it. There might not be one, but I’ve been surprised before. Under a covenant like this the borrower can sometimes argue the clause conflicts with another legal obligation, a permit or a statute. If I find a legal duty to keep the premises closed at night, he can’t demand access without asking us to break a law. I’m going to read every paper we filed this summer.”
“The sanctuary stuff?”
“The sanctuary stuff. Marjorie’s permit. The state wildlife registration. It could be nothing.” I looked at the brick on the table. “Or it could be the first clean break we’ve had.”
“You’re enjoying this.”
“I’m terrified,” I said. “It’s the same face.”
He laughed, and then sat down and put his hand over his mouth, and for a minute the only sound was the radiator knocking in the corner, as it had knocked since before the lights went in.
“Dale,” I said.
“Yeah.”
“I’ll need a desk.”
He lowered his hand. “You’ll need what?”
“I’m the bookkeeper. Ward announced it to the council on Sunday, and Bea nodded, and I am told that I’m now on the payroll at nineteen dollars an hour, which is about forty percent of what I was making and the first money I’ve earned in eleven years that I’m not ashamed of. I’ll need a desk and a lamp and a lock on the drawer. I’d like the corner by the window, if nobody’s using it.”
“That’s the corner where my dad’s desk used to be.”
I looked at it. It was a gray steel desk, dented at one leg, with a rolled blotter and an empty bottle of ink.
“Is that a problem?”
He took a long time. Then he walked across the room and put his palm flat on the blotter, and for a moment he looked like a boy at a door.
“No,” he said. “No, it’s about time somebody used it.”
By four o’clock I had read a hundred and forty pages of the note, and drawn eleven green arrows, and made a list headed THINGS THAT ARE NOT YET TRUE, which I pinned to the corkboard next to the clip-art heron. Number one: The Herons will lose the park on November thirtieth. Number two: Strommen can enter on any night he likes. Number three: this is the whole plan.
The third one I wrote small, because I didn’t believe it.
At four-twenty the front office door opened, and a young man in a bicycle helmet put a cream-colored envelope on the counter without a word and left. I did not recognize him. I crossed the room and opened the envelope with my pen.
It was a notecard. Heavy stock, thick as a coaster. The handwriting was beautiful.
Dear Ms. Aldersey. I hear you’ve gone into private practice. I’d be delighted to take you to lunch on Saturday, the seventh, at the Riverbend Club, one o’clock. I have an idea I think you’ll find generous. No wolves, I promise. Warmly, L.S.
I read it twice and put it in the middle of my desk, which was a dead man’s desk.

