Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 59

The Recipe Tin

Roz Pickett kept the truth in a recipe tin.

I had been in her kitchen twice and had assumed the tin held recipes. It was a black enamel box with a rose on the lid, which sat on top of her refrigerator beside a jar of pennies and an empty cat carrier. She took it down on Tuesday night, set it on the table between a plate of lemon bars and my cold tea, and said, without looking at me, “Strommen was right.”

“About what?”

“I never asked what the tenth name was.” She sat down, heavily, in her robe. She was sixty-two years old, and I had never seen her without her lipstick. “I said I didn’t ask. That isn’t true. I never asked because I already knew.”

Ward was beside me. He had come in without being asked, and had stood a while in the doorway like a man at a graveside, and then taken the chair by the wall. I felt it as a kind of weather: warm, steady, unspeaking.

“Roz,” I said.

“Let me tell it in order.” She folded her hands. “It was July 11. I had the radio booth. Orrin and Rafe and Hollis Vane were in the press box. Mo was there. Dennis Wray came in about eight with the weather certificate. I typed the lineup card at four in the afternoon, because Mo had a headache and her hands were shaking and she asked me to. That’s the thing I didn’t say to anybody. I typed it.”

“You typed the card.”

“From her dictation. She read the names off a list in her head. Nine names that night, new ones, for a night when the park would be full of wolves who’d never been Called by a stranger. Nine. She’d been planning it for a month. We typed it on the Herons’ own typewriter, an old Remington, in the radio booth, with the carbon.” She gave me a look. “You’ve been looking for a typewriter. I’ve got one. It’s in the basement.”

“A Remington,” I said.

“With a lowercase e that rides high,” said Roz. “Your note, Cilla. I knew the minute Wray described it. I’ve been trying to decide for nine days whether I’m a coward.”

Ward’s chair scraped. “Roz, that’s the note under the door.”

“I know what it is.” She did not look at him. “Nobody’s used that machine in a decade. It’s in the basement under a sheet. It was in the press box until Orrin’s renovation, and then it was in the radio booth, and then it was in my cellar. And last Thursday, I went down for the Christmas lights and the sheet was off.”

I put down my cup.

“Somebody’s been in your house?” said Ward.

“Somebody’s been in my house.” Her voice shook. “And I’m the one who’s supposed to know who’s lying to her. That’s the only gift I have. I’ve never been wrong about it. And I was in my own basement and I couldn’t tell you whose feet had been on the stairs.”

“Roz.” I leaned over the table. “The tin.”

“I’m getting there.” She lifted the lid. Inside lay a stack of papers, softened at the edges, held with a green rubber band. “When I typed the card for Mo, I typed it with a carbon. Two sheets, one on top of the other. Mo took the top copy up to the booth. I kept the carbon in the machine. I’ve kept it twenty-two years. I didn’t know why.”

She laid it on the table.

It was a thin gray sheet, the kind of tissue that comes out of a typewriter and turns the color of wood smoke. The names ran down it in blurred violet capitals. I counted ten lines. Under each name a small box had been marked with a tick. And at the bottom, the last line, the tenth, was empty.

“Line ten is blank,” I said.

“It was blank when I typed it.”

“Mo dictated nine.”

“She dictated nine names and said, ‘That’s the lineup.’ It was a short night. I typed a tenth line out of habit, because the form has ten, and I left it blank, and Mo said, ‘That’s fine, it’s for a late arrival.’ And she took the card up the stairs.” Roz’s mouth worked. “It was blank in my hand. At 4:30. It was blank in hers.”

“Then who wrote it in?”

“Somebody who had the card between 4:30 and 9 p.m.” She pressed her palms to her eyes. “I thought it was Rafe. I thought it was Orrin. I thought for twenty-two years that a tenth name had been added by a Tuckerman, to protect somebody. And I never asked, because if I asked, I’d have to hear the answer. And now it’s Cal’s hand, and you’re telling me Cal was nineteen and wrote in pencil.”

“It’s not proof,” said Ward.

“No.” She dropped her hands. “It’s the carbon.”

I picked it up. I held it to the lamp, tilted it, and ran my thumb across the lower margin.

“Roz. Is there a second page behind this?”

“There was only the one.”

“There was a sheet under it. A backing sheet. A typist always puts a plain page under a carbon, to protect the platen.” I turned it over. On the back of the tissue, along the bottom, faint as a bruise under a bandage, was a scoring: tiny, feathery, a ghost of pressure from a hard pencil on the sheet above. “Someone wrote on the top card, with a heavy hand, in this exact spot. The pressure went through the card and the carbon and printed on the tissue. It’s backward. A mirror.”

“Can you read it?”

“Give me a mirror.”

Roz got one. It was a round shaving mirror that had belonged to her late husband, with a bamboo handle. I held the tissue up in the lamp and angled the mirror, and I read the indentation line by line, as I had read a thousand soft pencil traces in a thousand audits. The top line was the tenth: not a name. A number.

“It’s not just ‘Ward Tuckerman,’” I said slowly. “That’s the name. I can see it. Ward T. in boy’s loops. But above it, there’s something else. It’s been erased. Something written first, then erased, then written over.” I tilted the mirror. “A telephone number.”

Nobody breathed.

“Can you read it?” said Roz.

“The area code’s ours. The exchange is 555.” I pulled a pad toward me. “555-0143. And a name beside it. Not Ward’s.”

“What name?”

I looked. The letters had been scraped out with an eraser and the pencil had cut through the fiber, so that all that was left was a groove, and the groove was clear.

“It says O.T.,” I said. “And under it, a time. 8:50 p.m.”

“Orrin Tuckerman,” said Ward.

The word landed in the kitchen like a dropped plate. Roz put her hand on her chest. In the stove light she looked, for the first time since I had known her, older than the lines on her face.

“Orrin’s desk phone,” she said. “Extension forty-three. That’s the old ticket office line. It rang in the press box.” She swallowed. “They’d call up the card. If there was a late arrival, you called the booth. It was how you got a name added.”

“Somebody called the booth,” I said, “at ten to nine, from Orrin’s phone, and told the person with the pencil what to write.”

“Cal,” said Ward.

“Cal wasn’t in the booth,” said Roz. “Cal was on the field with the lineup. He was the apprentice, he was supposed to be with Hollis, he was handing Hollis the card—” She stopped. Her hand dropped. “My God. He was the one who read it. He read the tenth name aloud. Over the speakers. Because Mo was in the stairwell.”

“The voice on the tape,” I said, “wasn’t Orrin and wasn’t Rafe.”

“It was a nineteen-year-old with a cold,” said Roz. “It was a boy’s voice. And all of us have been thinking for twenty-two years it was a Tuckerman, because they sounded the same on a bad tape.”

We sat very still. The refrigerator hummed. A moth was batting at the kitchen light.

“It’s still not proof,” said Ward.

“No.” I laid the tissue on the table. “But I know where to look for the rest of it. It’s on Orrin’s desk.”

“Orrin’s desk is the front office,” said Roz. “We’ve been sitting at it for six weeks.”

“Not that desk,” I said. “His old one. The one in his study at the house. The one Bea hasn’t let anyone open since July.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!