“I’m not on your side,” I told Dale. “I’m not on anybody’s side. I’m on the side of the page. Give me the man’s name, or don’t.”
He gave it to me. His shoulders went down as he did, the way a man’s do when he has been holding a door shut for years and somebody else leans on it.
“Lyle Strommen. Strommen Riverfront Partners. He’s the one with the nice shoes.”
“And if I tell the state he’s been blackmailing you?”
“He hasn’t. Not yet.” Dale rubbed his face. “That’s the thing about Lyle. He’s very, very polite.”
I wrote the name down and underlined it twice, and went to find out where the money went.
Here is the secret of auditing, for the record. Everyone thinks it’s about numbers, and it isn’t. It’s about gravity. Money behaves like water. It runs downhill toward the thing it loves, and if you stand still long enough and look at where the wet spots are, you will see what a person cares about. A man’s credit card tells you his week. His wire transfers tell you his whole life.
I spent three nights in the front office with the Herons’ bank records, a bag of pretzels, and a legal pad. On the second night Ward came in at nine with two boxes of cold sesame noodles and put one in front of me without a word.
“You don’t have to stay,” I said.
“I’m the general manager. If the general manager goes home, who’s going to be accountable?”
“Ward, the general manager is the thing I’m auditing.”
“Exactly. Somebody has to watch me.” He sat down on the floor with his back against the safe and his legs crossed, and took off his cap, which I noticed he did when he was telling the truth. “Ask me anything. I’ll answer what I can. I’ll tell you plainly when I can’t.”
“That is the least evasive thing you have said to me.”
“Don’t get used to it.”
I asked him, over the course of two hours, about the rain checks. And he told me, in a plain, flat voice, the thing I had half-guessed from the receipts. Every rainout, the Herons announced a refund. Most fans took it. A few did not. The rain checks that nobody redeemed, thousands of dollars each moon, went into a fund called Rain Check, held in a separate account, which had never once been shown to the state.
“That’s the money for the meat,” I said.
“That’s the money for the Away. The barn, the fences, the doctor, the food. The pack’s a hundred and twelve people, Cilla, and there isn’t one of us who can hold a regular job for more than a few years. We can’t take sick days. We can’t take a flight. Nobody can explain the gaps in our résumés.” He smiled slightly. “So the ballpark is where we work. It’s the one place that lets us be what we are for twelve nights a year.”
“It’s also tax fraud.”
“Yes,” said Ward, simply. “Yes, it is.”
That was the first time anyone had said it out loud in that building. I felt the room tilt slightly. I picked up a noodle and put it down again.
“Don’t be nice to me,” I said. “It makes this harder.”
“I didn’t know I was.”
“You brought me noodles.”
“That was just noodles,” said Ward.
We ate in a silence that was almost comfortable. At eleven he stood, collected both cartons, and wiped my side of the desk with his sleeve, which I pretended not to see. At the door he stopped.
“If you do have to write it up,” he said, “write it plain. Don’t soften it for us. Gran says a family that gets caught with a soft report just learns to hide better.”
“I never soften a report.”
“I know,” said Ward. “That’s why we’re all so scared of you.”
He left. I sat in the glow of the monitor and understood, with a feeling like a missed stair, that I had begun to look forward to him knocking.
On the third night I finally found what I had been circling.
It was not in the Book, which I had never opened, and which still sat in the safe behind Ward’s back like a sleeping cat. It was in the bank statements, hiding in plain sight, the way the best secrets do. Every month, on the fifteenth, the Rain Check Fund sent a wire of nineteen hundred and fifty dollars to an outside account.
It had done so, without missing a month, for as far back as the account’s records ran, which was twenty-two years, one month, and a handful of days.
I knew the amount before I knew why. Some numbers get under your skin when you are eleven.
I pulled the routing number and called the bank at eight the next morning with a story about a transposed digit. It took forty minutes, and a transfer to a very patient woman named Carol, to find the name on the account.
It was not a person. It was a foundation, a small one, at a state university two hours north. The woman at the other end said it with the careful, official tone of someone reading a script. “That’s the Tallow Creek Friends of the Game Memorial Scholarship. A donor-advised fund. We disburse it, as the donor directs, to one recipient per year.”
“Is it a scholarship for something? Sports? Baseball?”
“It’s for an undergraduate in accounting or business administration, from the Tallow Creek area.” A pause. “Ma’am, I’m not supposed to say who the recipients were. I can tell you it’s only ever had one at a time, and it covered tuition and housing and a small stipend, and they sent a check to the recipient’s family for the mortgage during the last two years of school.”
I held the phone very still against my ear.
I had gone to the state university two hours north. I had studied accounting. I had always been told, by a smiling woman in a cardigan who came to my high school graduation, that I was the first recipient the fund had ever chosen in the county, that it came from “a few friends of the community,” that I should never feel indebted to anyone.
My father’s mortgage had been forgiven in my sophomore year. The bank had called it an administrative error.
“Thank you, Carol,” I said. “That’s all I need.”
I put the phone down. I looked at the legal pad. I had written Rain Check Fund at the top, and a long arrow, and at the bottom of the arrow, in my own handwriting, I had written, like a prophecy, the name of my own scholarship.
It took me a long moment to stand up. My arm itched where Gus’s bandage was. I walked out through the ticket office and down the hall to the general manager’s door, and I did not knock.
Ward was at his desk with a mug of coffee and a stack of invoices. He looked up, and I watched his face change, from tired to guarded to something that I can only describe as the look of a man who has been waiting a very long time for a train and has just seen its light.
“You found it,” he said.
“The money goes to me.”
“Cilla.”
“Twenty-two years. Nineteen hundred and fifty dollars a month. It paid for my degree. It paid my father’s mortgage.” My voice was very level, which is how I know when I’m about to break something. “You knew.”
He did not answer. He looked at his hands.
“Ward. Did you know?”
“Yes,” he said.

