There are three kinds of silence between two women in a small attic at two in the morning, and I learned all of them that night.
The first is the one you hold when you are deciding how much to say. The second is the one the other woman holds, waiting to see whether you will lie. The third is the one that falls after you have told the truth, or the part of it you can bear, and neither of you yet knows what to do with it.
"Sit down," I said. "Please. This will take longer than you want."
Octavia remained standing. "I have all night."
"Then I would rather you were comfortable."
"I would rather you were honest." But she sat. She sat on the edge of the narrow bed, since I was occupying the chair, and she held her gloves in her lap as if they were a pair of small dead birds. The candle flickered between us. A cold wind came in under the window frame and moved the pages of my notebook where I had left it on the washstand, face down, with a blessed ordinary look.
I took a breath.
"I can feel cold wood," I said.
She waited.
"It's true. I've always been able to. It isn't a trick, and it isn't a talent I can teach. A true tally hums against my palm. A forgery doesn't. When I put my hand on the thirty-first stick in the Assay I felt nothing at all, and I knew." I made myself look at her. "Bram says my father had it. A little. He never used it."
"Is that how you found the graft?"
"Yes."
"And at Eelgate?"
"Pike's roll was silent. I felt it when I hugged my brother." My voice was steady. I was surprised. "Jory is a good man, Octavia. He is also a fool, and the one man in this city a clever liar could use without his knowing. I could not let him walk that thing across the bridge."
"So you had it swapped."
"For a true stock cut to look like a graft. Yes."
"And the real forgery?"
"Is in safe hands. A friend's."
"Skell's."
I said nothing. It was an answer.
Octavia nodded slowly, like a clerk adding a column. "The flood," she said. "The barley. The ladder. Mr. Oakhollow's Penhallow error. The clock." She raised her eyes. "They are not the work of a woman who has a good palm for wood."
"No."
"What are they?"
I had been afraid of this question for three months. I had imagined it a hundred ways, in a hundred rooms, and in every version I had a speech. I had no speech now. I had a cold attic, a guttering candle, and a woman across from me who had lost her key that night because of me and had come anyway to ask.
"I can't tell you yet," I said.
"That is not an answer."
"It's the only honest one I have." I felt my hands close on my knees. "I can tell you that I am not working for anyone. That I do not wish the House of Aldermere harm. That everything I've done since the third of Thaw, every move, every bet, every lie, has been to keep a few people I love from being hurt."
"Including me?"
"I didn't know you well enough."
"That is an honest answer," said Octavia, so dryly that I almost laughed. "Go on."
"And I can tell you something else. I think I know where the forgeries are made."
She went entirely still.
"The Reserve," I said. "The stamp on that roll was R-9. The twine was yours. The ninth rack, Octavia. I think somebody is making silent tallies in the heart of the Reserve, or has found a way to bring them in. And I think they are being sold into the city by the hundred, by a company in Lamplight Row that is paid from your family's bank."
"Hallam and Rook," said Octavia.
I stared.
"You are not the only one who reads ledgers." She took off one glove, slowly, and smoothed it on her knee. "I have seen the drafts. Hennessy's has been drawing cash for a company I do not know for six weeks, against an account in the name of a trust. I assumed it was the Speaker's. My father has a hundred small charities."
"Whose trust?"
"The C. A. Trust." She said it very quietly. "I have not dared to read the initials."
We sat there. The candle spat.
"I did not look at the Reserve," said Octavia, "for two years."
It was nothing like what I had expected. She said it like a confession in a church, flat and low, to the floor. "I knew something was wrong. I had known since my third audit. The ninth rack's count did not match the book. Not by much. A hundred tallies. Then three hundred. I went to my father, and he said it was a bridging account, that the Speaker had asked the House to carry certain obligations until the harvest, and that I need not trouble myself." She drew a breath. "I did not trouble myself. It was very easy."
"You trusted him."
"I loved him. It is not the same, but it passes for it." Her mouth twisted. "He was a better father than I deserved. He taught me to read a ledger at five. He taught me that a debt is a kind of loyalty. And when I found something that did not add up, I put it in a drawer, because the alternative was to ask what it meant."
"Octavia."
"Don't be kind." She said it fiercely. "I did not come to be forgiven. I came because I saw you on the parapet with a stick in your hand and I recognized your face. It was my own, three years ago, with the ninth rack in front of me and a pen in my hand." She put her glove down. "I am tired of being afraid of arithmetic."
I did not know what to say. I reached out and, to my surprise, so did she, and we sat there on the narrow bed with our hands clasped in the dark like two children who had found a door in a wall.
"I want to see it," said Octavia.
"The Reserve?"
"The inside. The ninth rack. With you, with your hand on the wood. I cannot go alone. I have no key. And if I go alone I will find nothing, because I will have decided in advance." She lifted her chin. "If the Reserve is real, then you owe me two hundred marks and a very handsome apology. If it is not—"
"If it isn't."
"Then I shall owe you a father," said Octavia Aldermere.
I did not answer. I could not. I looked at her in the thin gold light, a tall woman in a slate coat with a face like a closed door, and knew that I was looking at something I had lost once and had no right to find again.
In the old life she had testified against me.
She had stood in the witness box in a black dress, with her hands folded, and said in a clear voice, "I regret that I must confirm the signature." I had seen her face then. It had not been closed. It had been a stone in a stream, worn smooth by the water.
I had never forgiven her. I had not known, until this moment, that I had been mistaken about what I was forgiving.
"All right," I said. "How?"
"You will need a key."
"You haven't one."
"I have an impression." She reached into her coat and drew out a small flat tin, the kind used for lozenges, and opened it. Inside, pressed into a layer of grey wax, lay the clear sharp print of nine teeth and a bow. "I made it in my first year as Deputy, in case I lost the original. I am a very careful person. I have never told anyone."
"A cast."
"A cast, yes. It requires an iron-cutter. Someone who can work in steel, and who will not ask." She closed the tin. "I know no one like that."
"I do."
She looked up.
"Teo Skell," I said, "has a cellar full of men who can cut anything. One of them used to work for the Mint."
"Is he discreet?"
"He's been paid to be since birth." I gave her a small, crooked grin. "He'll want a favor."
"A broker from Lamplight Row," said Octavia, with great delicacy, "in my father's cellars."
"Not in them. Near them."
"I have been taught from the cradle that a woman does not owe favors to a man who keeps a cat on the ledger."
"The cat is called Quorum, and he is the best-informed animal in the city." I let the grin widen. "Octavia, you stamped thirty-eight thousand tallies and never once looked at the wood. I think you can afford to be introduced to a man with a bad reputation."
"That," she said, after a moment, "is the first thing you have said tonight that I find entirely unanswerable."
"I'll put it in writing."
"Do. I shall file it. And he will want a favor, naturally." Octavia put the tin on the washstand. For a moment she hesitated, and then she did something that astonished me. She laid her hand flat on the blanket beside mine and left it there. "The Greening, then. The fourth. The Annex is empty on Friday nights; Mrs. Quint goes to her sister's. The night watch walks the Row at midnight and one. We shall have about forty minutes."
"Forty minutes in the Reserve."
"Do you think you can do it?"
"I think," I said, "that I would like to see your face when I'm right."
"That," said Octavia, "is not the way to win my confidence."
"It's the only one I've got."
She almost smiled. It was the smallest thing, a twitch in the corner of the mouth, there and gone. She put on her gloves, one finger at a time, and stood, and at the door she turned.
"One more thing. You said you were not working for anyone."
"Yes."
"Is that true?"
I thought about a small tally in my pocket, and a man in a grey coat who did not yet know he held its twin.
"I'm not sure," I said slowly. "I think I may have been sent."
She took that in. She did not ask by whom. At the door of the attic she stood very straight, in the thin light, and then she nodded once, like a Keeper closing a book.
"Then I hope," said Octavia, "they pay you better than we do."

