Teo Skell had warned me that they would not shake hands, and he had been right, and it was almost the only thing he got right about them.
"They are not a gang," he said, in the Lamp's upper room on the fourth of Gleaning, standing in front of a very small, very shabby crowd of persons as a keeper stands before his animals. "A gang has a captain. They are more of an old Guild, which has no charter and no dues and meets by accident at funerals. Mistress Voss, this is Mags Tillotson, who can take the red out of a Mother Hazel heart with a bent pin, and has done. This is Whistler. He has seven fingers and an opinion about all of them. This is young Fennick, who is nineteen, and who should not be here, and who will tell you he is not nervous."
"I am not nervous," said Fennick, going green.
There were five of them. They sat on the Lamp's good chairs with their hats on their knees and their hands out of sight, in the way of people who have been asked to stand in front of a magistrate and have not yet seen the magistrate. Mags Tillotson was a square grey-haired woman in a man's waistcoat with a face as shut as a purse. Whistler was a thin old man who, as promised, whistled, a soft tuneless draught through his teeth that went up and down as he breathed. The others I did not catch. They had the look I had seen on Teo himself, the first morning, in the cellar, when I asked him a question he did not wish to answer. It was the look of people who have been very good at a thing that is against the law.
"I shall be plain," I said. "I am the Acting Deputy Keeper of the Reserve. The Court has authorized me to hire assay hands, for the Reserve's inquiry, at four marks a day, paid from the Court's fund. I have read the Annex Rules. There is nothing in them that says an assay hand may not have been, in a former life, a person who cut a good deal of grafted wood."
"There is nothing in them that says she may," said Mags.
"No. I have thought about that."
"We would be the first." Her voice was flat. "You would be putting a name of mine in a Court's book, miss. Beside a sum in marks. And in nine months there will be a different Deputy, and a different Court, and I shall be a woman who once cut for the Reserve, in the Court's own roll."
"You would be a woman who once found its graft."
"That is a very pretty way to put it."
"It is the true one." I looked at her. "I can promise you nothing. I can only say that there is a vault in Ledger Row, and in it are several hundred tallies that I believe to be cut by a hand like yours, and I cannot tell it from an honest one. I have a good tooth. I have a very good friend with a lens. I do not have the eye. You do. I should like to hire it."
There was a silence. Whistler's tune went up, and down.
"Four marks a day?" said Fennick.
"And your dinner."
"Where?"
"Hennessy's Bank," I said. "On Ledger Row. With a warrant."
There was a distinct change in the atmosphere. Whistler stopped whistling.
Hennessy's vault was forty feet below the street, at the bottom of a spiral stair so narrow that two persons could not pass, and it smelled of damp stone and floor wax and the faint, sour, expensive breath of a great many strongboxes. We went down at ten in the morning on the sixth, in file, with a lantern at the head and a bailiff at the rear. Lord Brandt led us, in his black gown, with the Court's warrant in his fist and the look of a boy who has been sent to knock at a headmaster's door. Ansel came behind, with the Court's book. The Cutters came behind him, one by one, with their hats pulled down. At the bottom Abel Prynne stood waiting, with a key on a velvet cushion.
He was a long, soft, pale man of fifty, with a bank clerk's stoop and a bank clerk's grey side-whiskers, and he held the cushion out to Brandt as one offers a tray of sweets. "The Bank is entirely at the Court's disposal," he said. "We have of course nothing to hide. I should merely mention that the stocks held on behalf of Hallam and Rook are by the nature of their trust confidential, and that it would give me real distress if the Court were to handle them roughly."
"They will be handled by experts," said Brandt.
"Of what?"
"Of wood," said Mags Tillotson.
I will not forget what happened then. It was like watching a person walk into a room she had been told was shut for good. Mags went into the long, low, lamplit vault, between the racks of tied bundles, with her hands at her sides. She did not touch anything. She walked the length of the first aisle, slowly, turning her head, as a cook walks through a market. At the ninth bundle she stopped. She put out one blunt finger and tilted a tally toward the lamp, looked at it for the space of three breaths, and put it back.
"Cold wood," she said. "Graft joined at the pith. A good join. Done in the winter, with a pitch-knife, by a man who learned in the Grove. It is not Pike's. It is someone better." She moved on. "And that bundle. And that. And that one, that is sound." She did not stop walking. "Those four, no. That rack is mixed. The Master has been salting it."
"Salting?" said Ansel.
"A true one for every three false. It gives the heft to the bundle, so the clerk's hand is deceived. It is a very old trick. I was taught it myself, in a back room in the Eelgate, by a woman who did it for a living." She did not look round. "You will be wanting the numbers."
"If you please."
"Three hundred and eleven, in this vault. At a glance. I will give you a better count by dinner."
"The Bank," began Abel Prynne, in a voice like a bruise, "is of course shocked."
"Of course," said Brandt.
It took them five hours. It was the most remarkable five hours of work I have ever watched. They moved through that vault like a team of surgeons, in silence, with a few whispered words, Whistler soft-whistling under his breath, Fennick going green and then pale and then absorbed. They did not use a lens. They did not use a tooth. They looked, and they felt, and a bailiff wrote it down. I stood at the end of the aisle with my arms folded and thought of nothing at all but a girl in a bench room, calling out dead, dead, dead, with her lens, in a voice that sank to a whisper.
It was Fennick who found the crate.
He found it at three o'clock, in the last aisle, behind a bank of old hogsheads, and he did not say a word. He stood in front of it with his hands hanging. It was an ordinary pine crate, with rope handles, such as a grocer might use for apples. On its lid, stencilled in black, were the words: RESERVE. REPLENISHMENT. LOT 12.
"Madam," he said, in a cracked voice. "Miss. It is new."
I went. Mags was there before me. She had the lid off with her own bare hands. Inside, packed in clean wood shavings, were forty tallies, bound in bundles of nine, the cut ends sealed with fresh white wax, and when she lifted the first, the wax was still faintly soft. They were sound-looking. They were exquisite. The grain was perfect; the notches were clean; I could not have told them from the best of the Reserve's own stock. But Mags turned one in her hands for a long time, and her face did a thing I had not seen it do, which was to go slack.
"These are not old," she said. "I have been working for forty years and I would have said no one living could do it. But the sap is not dry. This was cut in the last month. After the Count." She raised her eyes. "Madam, this is a lot for the Reserve. These were meant to go back into the racks."
"Before Lantern Night," said Ansel softly.
"Before whatever it is that you are all afraid of." She turned the stick again. "I would know this hand anywhere. It is a left hand. It cuts the downstroke of every notch in a little spiral. Look. There. It is the neatest I have seen, and it is shaking."
"Shaking?"
"At the end of each bundle. It grows shallow. As a hand tires. As a person does who has been at it for twelve hours and does not want to be doing it at all." She had taken the stick to the lamp. "And there is a mark. Here. On the tail, where nobody looks. I should not have seen it, but I am a cutter, and we look at the tails."
I bent over her shoulder.
It was a tiny thing. It was no larger than a grain of barley, cut into the wood at the very end of the tally, where the wax would have covered it, and then covered over in a smudge of resin so that nobody but a person with a glass and a grudge would have seen. It was a nine, with a small curling tail.
"She did not wish to do it," said Mags, very quietly.
"No."
"She has put her name on every one. I do not mean her name. I mean her mark. As a person writes, I was made to." She put the stick down in its shavings, and wiped her hand on her waistcoat as if it were not clean. "I have cut for people who did not wish to be seen. I have never cut for someone who did not wish to be doing it. It is a different hand."
Nobody answered. In the lamplit vault, Abel Prynne, a long soft shape at the end of the aisle, said, with perfect courtesy, that he did not know the least thing about the crate, that it must have been placed there by a customer, and that the Bank would of course give every assistance.
I did not hear it. I was looking at the nine, and thinking of a hooded face at the top of a ladder in a cloud of cinnamon, and a soft flat whisper, and the words: It is a kindness.

