Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 27

The Hearing

Docket, Pell County Courthouse, Courtroom 1, Friday, December 12, 10:00 a.m. In the matter of Harborline Casualty, commercial property book, Pell Pass Cooperative Lodge and Lifts. Presiding: Examiner I. Reyes. Appearances: the Department; Harborline, by counsel; the insured, by a woman on unpaid leave, in the same suit as before.

The pass had reopened on Thursday. Kasper walked back into the lodge at dawn on Wednesday, before the plows.

Nobody had gone looking, because everyone had been busy with the fire. He simply came up the front drive in the first gray light, in a gray sweater and a man's work coat that did not belong to him, with snow in his hair and his bare feet wrapped in strips of tablecloth. Teo met him at the door. They did not say anything. In the coat's pocket was a single sheet of cream paper.

It read: The truce was honored. The fire was Mr. Strand's. The door was mine. I wanted to know whether he would come back. O.V.

I read it five times. I still do not know whether it was mercy or an experiment. Kasper would only say, hoarse, with his brother's arm around him, "He opened it and he stood there. And I walked out, and I could have kept walking. And I came home." Then he slept for eighteen hours in Mick's chaise.

The courtroom was paneled in light oak and smelled of floor wax. By ten o'clock it was full: members of the Mutual in their church coats; Dina Penrose, in the back row, with her hands in her lap; Brice Quillan, with a laptop; my father, in his best jacket, two seats from mine, with his hands folded and his chin up like a man waiting to be called to the front of a class.

At the other table sat Harborline's general counsel, a heavy man named Gerald Fitch, flown in on Thursday. Connie Vogt sat beside him with her lips pressed very flat. And behind them, in the gallery, in a charcoal topcoat with a velvet collar, sat Colby Reeve. Beside him sat Hale Strand, with his hands in his lap and the expression of a man at a charity auction.

"We are here," said Imogen Reyes, "because the Department has reason to believe that Harborline Casualty failed to act in good faith in the handling of this account. This is not a trial. It's an informal examination. Mr. Fitch, you may begin."

Mr. Fitch spoke for eleven minutes, in the soft, regretful tones of a man explaining a tragedy to a child. Harborline had acted on information. Its adjuster had exceeded her authority. The Endorsement was ambiguous. The insured's losses were unverifiable, as the original records were unavailable.

"The original records are unavailable," said Imogen. "To whom?"

"To the Department."

"The Department has a Schedule of Losses, sworn by a county officer." She glanced over her glasses. "Mr. Penney. You may come forward."

Hollis Penney walked to the front of the room with his knitting under one arm, took the oath and sat down.

"Mr. Penney, is this schedule a true copy of a record in your custody?"

"It is."

"Is the record kept in the ordinary course by the Mutual?"

"It's kept in pencil, madam."

"Does it match the claim dates in Harborline's own files?"

"I wouldn't know," said Hollis. "I don't read Harborline's files. But I read the dates in Ms. Lindmark's report. They match." He considered. "I file what I'm handed. I keep what I'm asked. I have never once been asked to lie."

Imogen nodded, slowly.

I testified for forty minutes. I told the story as I had written it, in numbered paragraphs, with exhibits. The pre-signed memo. The mailing date. The Protective Safeguards Warranty and what had been done to it. Endorsement Fourteen, in a cookie tin. Mr. Fitch asked whether I had any personal interest in the outcome, and I said yes, three. He asked me to name them.

"I'm romantically involved with an insured. My father's name is on a denied claim. And I would like, for once, to sleep badly for a good reason."

Somebody in the gallery laughed. Imogen did not smile, but her glasses slipped.

My father testified next.

He did it standing. Imogen had told him he might sit. He did not. He gave his name as Walter J. Lindmark and his occupation as retired adjuster, and he said that he wished to read something into the record.

He read the margin note. "'Deny. Reinsurer request, not negotiable. See R.S. letter. Don't discuss with the Pass. H.'" He read his own letter of protest, dated September 30, 1999. He read the cream-paper letter from R.S., which said that the reinsurer's participation depended on a "prompt and unambiguous resolution." He laid each of them, one by one, on the clerk's table, as he had in the conference room, as if setting a place.

"I signed the denial," he said, to the room. "I want that understood. I was told to. I'm not offering that as a defense. It was a coward's reason, and I have had twenty-six years to hear it back." He looked at Connie Vogt. "I recognize the pattern, Ms. Vogt. I've seen it before. It's the same memo, with a different date."

"Objection," said Mr. Fitch.

"Overruled," said Imogen Reyes. "It's an informal examination. I'm very informal."

Connie's memo came last.

Imogen Reyes picked it up in both hands, as one lifts a document that has already told the truth once. She read it aloud, every line, in a voice that never rose. When she reached the date and the time, she paused.

"'October thirteenth, four fifty-two p.m.,'" she said. "The same date and time as the eleventh loss was first reported by telephone. By a person who has not been identified."

She put the memo down.

"Mr. Fitch," she said. "I'm going to ask you one question, and I'd like you to consult your client first."

"I have consulted my client."

She took off her glasses. "Is Harborline prepared to stipulate that the nonrenewal notice was untimely, that Endorsement Fourteen is in force, and that the eight losses in the Schedule are covered?"

Gerald Fitch turned his large head and looked at Connie Vogt for a long, long moment. She stared at the table. He turned back.

"Harborline," he said, in a very small voice, "is prepared to discuss a settlement."

A sound went through the courtroom, soft as wind in dry grass. I did not breathe.

"That isn't what I asked," said Imogen.

"We will stipulate," said Fitch heavily. "To the notice. To the endorsement. To the eight."

"Thank you." She wrote something. "For the record, the Department will recommend a market conduct penalty, and the question of individual discipline is referred to the carrier. The examination is adjourned." She looked up. "Ms. Lindmark. You have one more question."

"I do?"

"I can see it on your face."

I got to my feet. My knees were not entirely steady.

"The loss on the east wing of the Lodge," I said. "Three rooms. The fire. Under the Protective Safeguards Warranty..."

"The warranty is a defense for the carrier," said Imogen. "It's not a defense if the impairment was caused by a third party, without the insured's knowledge or consent, with intent to defraud the insured. That is, if the insured did not impair it." She tilted her head. "Counsel?"

Mr. Fitch, with the air of a man being slowly lowered into water, said, "We would not assert it."

It was over. I knew it, as I'd known it in the diner, with that cold flat clean feeling in the chest. My father put his hand on my back. In the second row, Dot Okonjo was weeping with her whole face, unashamedly, into a handkerchief. Teo, beside her, did not move. He sat with his hands on his knees, looking at the clock on the wall.

I thought we had won.

It was in the corridor outside, among the coats, that I felt a hand on my elbow. I turned.

Hale Strand stood at my shoulder, with his hat in his hand. He was smiling. His face was calm and pleasant, and his eyes, I saw, were the eyes of a man who had not for one instant lost anything he cared about.

"Congratulations, Ms. Lindmark," he said. "Truly. It was beautifully done."

"Mr. Strand."

"You've defeated a bank, a carrier, a vice president and an arsonist, who I assure you was not mine. A remarkable record." He put on his hat. "I only wish to say, as a friend, that I am the smallest of the creditors."

I did not understand him. I said so.

"No," said Hale Strand, gently. "You wouldn't. But you will. Ask your father who held the Pass's paper in 1952."

He walked away down the marble corridor. His heels made a small, dry, unhurried sound.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!