Entry in the Book of Losses, Sunday, February 1, 11:52 p.m., in Hollis Penney's square hand: Three, night one, opened. Clerk of Records present. Door unopened since 6:04. Nothing to report. (Corrected below.)
We made ninety miles in an hour and forty minutes, because Teo drove and Teo does not apologize to roads. I held the folder with the filed joinder on my knees and counted mile markers until I understood I was counting them to keep from counting anything else.
"I change late," Teo said, somewhere past the reservoir. It was the first thing either of us had said in forty minutes. "On the first night. Never before one. The Pass calls it the Clerk's grace. My father said it was just spite."
"How long do we have?"
"Until about one."
It was eleven-thirty when we pulled into the fire hall lot. The big door was shut. A single window glowed on the second floor, where the Book lives during the Three, in a room Hollis calls "the vestry" and the firefighters call "the room where you take your boots off."
Brice's truck was already there, chains hanging. He had gone ahead after the courthouse and left me the receipt.
Hollis was at the long table under the green lamp. He was sixty and square and gray, and he wore his usual cardigan, and he stood when we came in, which he never did. He did not say hello. He turned the Book around on the table so it faced me.
It is a tall ledger, bound in black cloth, with a red cloth spine that has been rebacked twice. The Roll is in the back half. The pages are ruled in columns: Present, Not Present, Pending, Released. Marian's line was there, in a brown ink that had gone the color of tea. Under it, one line more.
Dane Pell. Present.
The ink was blue. It was a bright, bruised, ballpoint-and-fountain-pen blue, the blue of a school form. It had not dried at the edges. Where the loop of the P began, it still stood in a tiny wet ridge that caught the lamp.
I did not touch it. I want that noted. I stood with my hands in my pockets and looked for a long time, because that is the job, and the room told me three things.
One. The hand was old. It was a copperplate hand, the kind taught with a ruler and a slap, with long looped capitals that nobody under seventy writes. Hollis writes in capitals like fence posts.
Two. The line sat exactly on the ruling. It had not been squeezed in. Whoever wrote it had known where the line would be before opening the page.
Three. The Roll had been turned to this leaf and no other. Every other page was flat. This one was open as if someone had held it down a long time with a palm.
"When?" I said.
"Tonight." Hollis's voice was dry as a cracker. "I opened the Book at 8:40. I made the first entry at 8:48. I made the second at 9:20, when the lodge reported Kasper secured. I did not look at this leaf until Teo asked me to. At 9:41 I turned to it, because I wanted to see Marian's name, and the line was there."
"You were in the room."
"I was in the room from 8:30 to 9:41."
"Did anyone come in?"
"Nobody opened that door."
I looked at the door. It was the original, oak, with a deadbolt Teo had once replaced for the fire marshal and a window of pebbled glass. Brice came up the stairs behind me with a flashlight and a small gray camera in his fist.
"I put a door camera on this stairwell Thursday," he said. "Motion triggered. It has twelve events since six o'clock tonight." He thumbed the screen. "Hollis in. Mick, 7:15, with the lodge key tags. Mick out. Priya, 7:50, with a sack of bandages. Priya out. Hollis alone since 8:30. Nobody on the stairs. Nobody on the landing. Nobody at the door." He looked up. "There's a second way up?"
"The fire pole," said Teo.
"Teo."
"It hasn't worked since the nineties. It's a decoration. It has a plaque."
"Then we have a man who wrote a line in a locked room in a hand like an engraver," said Brice. "In wet ink. While the Clerk of Records sat there."
"I don't know that it was a man," said Hollis.
"Do you know that it was a woman?" I said.
"I don't know that it was anyone," said Hollis, and folded his hands.
I have been lied to by experts. Lying has a texture: extra detail, sudden vagueness, a little eagerness at the corners.
Hollis had none of that. What Hollis had was a flat, careful cleanness, like a freshly wiped counter. I noted it. I did not know what I was noting.
"Where's the pen?" I said.
"What pen?"
"The one that wrote this. Is it on the table?"
"There are four pens on the table," said Hollis. "All four black. I checked."
Teo had gone to the window. He stood with his back to us, with his shoulders high, looking down at the lot where the snow was blowing across the floodlight in fine slanting lines. He had his hands on the sill. I saw the first tremor go through his forearm, the cut-and-stitched one, a small deep shiver like a tuning fork.
"It's twelve-twenty," said Mick's voice from the stairs. He had come up behind Brice with a key ring in one hand and a flashlight in the other, and his face was white. "Teo, the drying room's ready. I put the lift cable on it myself. It's a very good latch for twenty twenty-six."
"Thank you, Mick."
"I added a second one."
"Thank you."
"I added a third, in case the second has opinions."
Teo turned. He looked at me. His eyes had begun to go a shade lighter, a thin clear amber at the rim, and his hands were not entirely steady.
"I'm sorry," he said. "I'd have liked to be here for this."
"Go. I'll sit with the Book."
"You'll sit with Brice."
"I'll sit with Brice. I'll be extremely careful."
He did a thing then that I did not expect and that I replay more than I will admit. He crossed the room in three steps, in front of Hollis and Mick and the man with the camera, took my face in both hands, and kissed my forehead, hard, like a man signing something. Then he let go and went down the stairs with Mick behind him, and I heard the drying room door, and the first latch, and the second, and then, after a pause, the third.
I stood in the vestry and listened to my own pulse.
Brice cleared his throat. "He's a good man," he said, to the ceiling.
"Noted."
"I'm going to look at the pole." He went out.
That left Hollis, the lamp, and the line. I sat down in the chair across the table. I did not take out my notebook. I took out my phone, which had one bar and a battery at nine percent, and I photographed the page from four angles with the ruler beside it.
"Hollis," I said. "In the Book, what does a Present mean?"
He took a breath, a long one. I had the feeling that he had been waiting two hours to be asked a question he could answer exactly.
"The Roll has a key," he said. "I read it to you on January first. A name is entered under Present when the member has answered the Roll, aloud, to the Clerk, in the presence of the Book. Not by mail. Not by proxy. Not in the member's absence. The Clerk writes what is answered. The Clerk does not write what he guesses."
"Aloud."
"Aloud."
"To the Clerk."
"In the presence of the Book."
"So someone said that name aloud in this room tonight."
Hollis did not answer. He looked at the lamp. Then, very gently, in the voice of a man putting down a very heavy tray, he said, "I did not see anyone enter."
"That's not what I asked."
"No," he agreed. "It isn't."
Down in the drying room something struck the door, once, a soft heavy thud, and the cable sang, and was still.
I looked at the line again. It was 12:41 a.m. The little ridge of blue at the loop of the P was gone, dull and dry as any other mark in the Book.
Wet ink does not stay wet for four hours. Somebody had told me the line was fresh. I was beginning to wonder who had been wet, and who had wanted me to believe it.

