Minutes of a Special Session of the Pell Pass Mutual, Saturday, February 7, church basement. Chair: D. Okonjo. Clerk of Records: H. Penney. Quorum: 163 members present of 211. Refreshments: pie (four), coffee (urn). Adjuster of Record: seated at the back, with a sandwich.
I will say for the record that it was a very good sandwich. Turkey, on rye, with a slice of Dot's pickled onion, wrapped in wax paper. I ate three bites in front of a hundred and sixty-three people and I have never in my life tasted less.
Dot ran the meeting with the rolling pin. She set the rules in a voice that carried to the folding chairs: the Mutual would inquire into the entry on the Roll, the Clerk of Records would testify, members could put questions through the Chair, and no one was to speak of Ms. Lindmark's character, her motives or her cousin, who was not present and had not been invited.
"I have no cousin," I said.
"You do now," said Dot. "Ernestine is eighty-one and she's coming Tuesday."
There was a small laugh. It was the last of the evening.
Hollis took the stand, which was a folding chair with a microphone. He wore the cardigan. He laid his hands flat on his knees. I noticed that he had cut himself shaving, a tiny nick under the jaw, and I noticed that I noticed, which is what I do when I am afraid.
"Hollis," said Dot. "State the facts of the entry."
"On Sunday, February first, I opened the Book at 8:40 in the vestry of the fire hall. At 9:41 I observed a line on the Roll, under Marian Pell Lindmark's name, reading Dane Pell, Present. The ink was blue. I did not make it with a pen on the table."
I sat up. A man behind me stopped chewing.
"You did not make it," said Dot.
"I did not make it with a pen on the table."
"Did you make it?"
"I did not see anyone enter the room."
"Hollis. Did you write the line?"
"I am the Clerk of Records. I write what is answered."
Dot looked at the rolling pin as if it had spoken. A long pause went through the room. In the third row, a woman in a green coat whispered something to her husband, who nodded, grim.
"That's not a yes," said Teo, standing, from the side aisle.
"The Clerk is recognized," said Dot, "and then he will sit down."
"I'm not a witness. I'm asking." Teo took a breath. He was thinner than he had been a week earlier, in the way that a man gets thinner when his body is spending money. "Hollis, in thirty-one years, have you ever entered a line in the Book that you did not hear answered?"
"No."
"Have you ever entered a line in the Book in a hand other than your own?"
"No."
"Did you hear the name answered on Sunday night?"
"I'm the Clerk," said Hollis, "of Records."
"That's the third time you've said it."
"It's a true sentence," said Hollis.
Somebody laughed, a short horrified bark, and clapped a hand over their mouth.
I stood. I want it noted that I had agreed with Dot, in advance and in writing on a cocktail napkin, that I would not stand. I did it anyway, because it is the only discipline I have, and that is to ask the second question.
"Madam Chair, may the Adjuster of Record put a question?"
"The Chair doesn't recognize the Adjuster."
"Then may the Chair put it for me?"
Dot closed her eyes. Opened them. "Go on."
"Hollis. Did anyone, in the vestry of the fire hall on the night of February first, speak the name Dane Pell aloud?"
For a moment, nothing. The urn clicked. The overhead fluorescent lights hummed, and a child in the back of the room dropped a spoon.
"Yes," said Hollis.
The room did not gasp. It leaned.
"Who?"
"I'm not able to say who."
"Were you in the room?"
"I was."
"Did you see the person?"
"I did not see anyone enter."
"Did you hear the person?"
"I heard a name."
"Hollis," said Dot, very softly, "did you promise someone you wouldn't say?"
Hollis folded his hands. The light on his glasses hid his eyes.
"The Mutual's rules," he said, "provide that the Clerk of Records may decline to identify a source for a period not to exceed three days where disclosure would, in the Clerk's judgment, endanger a member's safety. Rule nineteen. Subsection B. I have been the Clerk since 1994. I have never invoked it. I invoke it now."
Nobody spoke. It was the quietest moment I have heard in a room of that many people.
"It's been six days," said Mick, from the back. He sounded almost tender. "Hollis. It's been six days since Sunday, and you're still sitting on it."
"I made the invocation on Sunday night at 9:42," said Hollis. "It's a rule. It's twelve days, not three, if the Clerk files the invocation with the Chair in writing. I filed it. Dot has it."
Every head turned. Dot, with her rolling pin, with her gray bun and her reading glasses on a chain, opened the cash-box she keeps on the lectern and took out a single sheet of folded paper.
"I have it," she said, and her voice shook. "Filed Sunday, 9:43. I didn't know what it was. I put it in the box with the pie money." She put on her glasses. She read it. "Under Rule Nineteen B, the Clerk of Records invokes the twelve-day protection for a member's safety. Disclosure will be made on the twelfth day. H. Penney."
"The twelfth day," I said, "is Thursday."
"Thursday the twelfth, at 9:43 p.m.," said Hollis. "Until then I may say nothing about who. But I may say what I did not do. I did not forge the line. I did not instruct anyone to forge it. And Ms. Lindmark had no part in it." He turned his head, and for the first time looked at me directly. "She was ninety miles away in a church basement with a cup of tea. A hundred and forty people can say so."
A murmur went up like surf. It was relief, mostly. I will not pretend I was not part of it.
"Chair recognizes the motion," said Dot.
"There's no motion," said Teo.
"There's always a motion," said Dot. "Mrs. Braddock, you had your hand up for ten minutes."
Mrs. Braddock, ninety years old, stood in the second row. "I move that the Mutual find no cause to suspect the Adjuster of Record of the entry in the Roll, and that Hollis Penney be thanked for his service, and also that he be given a talking-to."
"Seconded," said sixteen people.
The vote was 138 to 21, with four abstentions. I have been through many votes in my life, and I have been voted on by none. I sat very still and watched the hands go up and down, and I counted them, and I did not count wrong.
"The motion carries," said Dot. "Hollis, you may step down. Please sit near the pie."
He rose. He walked down the aisle between the folding chairs, past the men who had known him since boyhood, past the ones who had cursed him in 1996, past Teo, who touched his sleeve. At my row he stopped. He did not look at me. He said, so softly it might have been the heating system, "Thursday."
"Hollis."
"Eat your sandwich, Jo."
He went. I sat with the wax paper in my lap and I thought, for the first time, with the cold clarity that comes before an apology you didn't know you owed: every answer he gave tonight was true. Every single one. And every single one was built like a jar with the lid screwed on.
"He's protecting someone," Teo said, sliding into the chair beside me.
"He's protecting someone who's alive."
"How do you know?"
"Because the Clerk does not invoke a safety rule for a dead man." I folded the paper. "Rule Nineteen B is for the living. Hollis has known where Dane Pell is for a week, and he has been so careful not to tell me that he has told me everything."
"What do we do?"
"We wait until Thursday at 9:43." I looked across the basement at the man by the pie table, sixty years old, with his hands behind his back, saying nothing to nobody in a perfectly friendly way. "And we do not, under any circumstances, ask him a third question."
"Why not?"
"Because I would find out I'd been right," I said, "and I'd have to feel something about it."

