"I don't know," said Dessa, for the fourth time. "I'm sorry. I don't know who baked me."
"That is the right answer," said Mother Brigid Tunn.
They were in the old woman's pantry, a long, cool, narrow room behind the great hall, lined with crocks and strings of dried peppers and shelves of jam jars labeled in a hand like a spider on a bender. Brigid had shut the door, sat Dessa on a flour barrel, and put a cup of hot spiced cider into her hands without being asked. Lucan had been sent back to the scrubbing with a firm hand on his shoulder and the words, "She'll be an hour, dear, and you'll want to keep your gauntlets wet."
"It is?"
"It's the only one that doesn't cost you anything." The old woman sat down on the opposite barrel with a grunt. "When I was a girl of nine, my mother used to bake ten loaves for Longest Night. Nine for the Courts. One for the empty chair."
"The empty chair?"
"At the table of every Host, the night the year turned. One chair and one plate, set at the door end, with a loaf on it. Nobody sat there. Nobody asked why. It was whoever might come." She turned her tankard. "I asked my mother once who it was for. She said, 'For the one who isn't here.' When I asked who that was she said, 'Eat your supper, Brigid.' I thought it was a poor sort of answer."
"And now?"
"Now I think she was telling me the truth, in the only way that wouldn't get her hanged." She looked up. "The year I turned forty-one, they stopped. All nine Courts, the same night, no discussion. No more empty chair. No loaf at the door. The Registry sent round a notice. A matter of economy."
"The Snuffing," said Dessa, before she knew where the word had come from.
Brigid went very still.
"I don't know where that came from," said Dessa, in a small voice. "I've never heard it. It just—"
"Don't say it again." The old woman's face had gone gray under the red. "Not in my house. Not where the Registry's ears can reach. Put it in your pocket, girl. Keep it there."
"What does it mean?"
"It means I have a hundred things I would like to tell you and a Rule that will only let me answer you if you ask me three times in a row, and I am sixty-six years old, and I am tired." She wiped her mouth. "So I will do the other thing. The thing I can do. I will give you a coal."
Dessa lifted her head.
"For Ember," said Brigid. "You need a living fire to light a dead one. You have under a month and a Seneschal who looks as though he's been dug up. I won't have it said that Kettle watched a hearth die for want of a spark." She slid off the barrel, crossed the pantry, and took down from a high shelf a squat clay pot with a lid and a loop of cord. "One coal. From the great fire. A coal for a coal, as the old law says. Lent, not given."
"And the Claim?"
"I waive it."
"You can't. The law says the lender—"
"The law says the lender may hold a Claim." The old woman's eyes glittered. "May. I read it as well as you do. A Claim the lender waives is no Claim. I'll put it in your witness-ash, if you like, in my own words, with my seal. Kettle will have no say in Ember's fire."
"Then what's the price?"
"There's always a price. I have a hearth to keep." Brigid set the pot down on the barrel between them. "A Favor. One. I will ask it, someday, in a place of my own choosing, and you will give it. You will not know the shape of it until I speak. And you will answer. True. Whatever I ask. As I answered you."
It was the cleanest bargain Dessa had ever heard. It was also the most terrible. A thrice-asked question was a power only Kettle held. If it was owed her, one day, by a woman who could not lie to her, it was the closest thing in the world to a hold on a person's soul.
"That's a very large Favor," she said.
"It's the only price I'll take." Brigid's voice was gentle. "I'm not trying to cheat you, child. I'm trying to buy a tool for something I do not understand yet. I think there is going to be a time when someone has to answer a question, and it won't be me. I would like it to be you."
Dessa looked at the pot.
She was a notary. She knew a bad bargain when she saw one. She knew a clause with no ceiling, no term, no named occasion. She had talked a dozen clients out of the same thing. And she knew, with the strange cold certainty that had begun to settle under her breastbone over the last week, that if she said no she would never get another chance.
"The spoon," she said.
"The spoon."
She drew it out. The crack ran bright along the pale bowl, and the open door gleamed on the handle. She held it in both hands.
"I, Dessa Rook," she said, "owe to Brigid Tunn, Host of Kettle, one answer, to one question, asked at a time and place of her choosing, which I will give truly and in full. Let the spoon hold me to it."
The pearwood went warm. The crack, which she had thought would split under the strain, only hummed, a long low note like a bell heard across water. When it stopped, the hairline fracture had not grown. But it had gone from white to gold.
"Witnessed," said Brigid, softly, and put the pot in her hands.
It was warm, and heavy, and alive.
She did not tell Lucan until they were halfway up the stair.
"You did what?" he said.
It was the first time she had heard him raise his voice in anger. It went up on the second word and cracked, like a boy's, and he stopped on the step above her and stared down with his gloved hands clenched at his sides. The coal-pot swung gently from her fingers on its cord.
"I paid," said Dessa. "It was the price."
"You paid alone."
"It was my question. It was my mother. It was my spoon."
"It was Ember's hearth." He was white to the lips. "It was my Court, my Footing, my forty nights. You walked into a pantry and signed away a Favor of no limit to the Host of Kettle, a woman who cannot lie to you, who can ask you anything, and you did not think to fetch me? I was forty feet away. I was washing a pot."
"You were doing something useful."
"I would have paid it."
"That's exactly why I didn't ask."
The stair rang with it. Neither of them moved.
"I need to tell you something," said Dessa, "and I'm not going to enjoy it, and the pot is going to make me say it anyway."
"The pot?"
"No lie told on the road. That's the Lending law. Anyone who carries a coal, or walks beside the carrier, tells no lie until it's lit." She lifted the little pot. "That means neither of us can say anything we don't mean. All the way home. I'd forgotten. I think you'd better know before we start."
He opened his mouth. He shut it.
"Oh," he said, in a very small voice.
"Yes."
They stood in silence, one stair apart, with a living coal between them.
"I was frightened," said Lucan, abruptly.
She stared.
It had come out of him as if pulled with a hook. He looked as astonished as she was. He put his hand over his mouth, took it away, and went on, with the dry flat precision of a man reading his own death sentence aloud.
"I was frightened that you would pay a price I could not pay for you. I was frightened that you were doing it so that you would not owe me. I do not like owing you. I cannot stand it. But I would rather owe you than watch you owe someone else." He drew a ragged breath. "That is the worst thing I have ever said in my life, and I cannot take it back."
"Lucan."
"I find that I am extremely angry, and extremely grateful, and I do not know which of them I mean."
"Both," said Dessa. Her voice shook, because it had to. It was true. "It's both. I'm angry at you too. For being so used to carrying everything alone that you didn't notice I do it as well. And I'm grateful. And I'm scared stiff." She laughed, wetly. "That's a very honest road."
"It is a dreadful one."
"We could not talk."
"I do not think I could manage that."
They began, slowly, to climb.
It was the strangest walk of her life. Every sentence cost something. They could not make small talk. They could not say I'm fine, or it's nothing, or never mind. They could say a thing was true or say nothing, and after the first ten minutes of silence it became easier to say it. He told her he was terrified of the cellar. She told him she had never once, in her whole life, been invited anywhere without a reason. He said he had loved the Dowager like a mother and been angry at her for dying. She said she had wanted to scream when Sill held her wrists. He said, with great care, that he thought she was the bravest person he had ever met, and then, in a rush, that he could not stop looking at her hands.
They did not say anything for a while after that.
The terraces fell away below them. The long stair wound up toward Cinder Hill, through a late-afternoon haze of smoke, past shuttered houses and washing lines and a stray cat on a wall. The pot was warm against her ribs. In the dusk the coal glowed through the vent in its lid like a small, patient star.
They were two hundred paces from the Ember gate when the cat on the wall stood up.
It was not a cat. It was a tall man in a drab gray coat, and he dropped from the wall without a sound, and the pot was gone from her hand before she had finished turning her head.
"Sorry," said the man, politely, already running. "It's nothing personal. She did say please."

