Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 49

The Moot

“You are answering too fast,” says Plimpton.

It is Thursday, Day 168, twenty minutes to six in the evening, and I have been answering for fifty minutes. The probate stand has been turned into a courtroom of a very small and ill-tempered kind: the long table pushed against the window, two folding chairs set side by side behind it, a jar of pens for a gavel, and the one ceiling bulb turned up to a hard white glare that makes everyone look like a person caught in a photograph of themselves.

Plimpton sits behind the table in the Examiner’s place. She is the county liaison, a tall, narrow, brisk woman of fifty in a good navy suit, and she has agreed to do this on the single condition, stated in the doorway, that she would be unlike the real Examiner in every respect. She has kept to it. The real Examiner, Greer tells us, is quiet. Plimpton is a drill.

“I asked whether the Officer intends to say the name aloud in the forenoon of the fourth of March,” she says. “Tell me what you answered.”

“I said I would try.”

“You said, *I intend to, in accordance with the terms, which provide.* You said it in under a second. I counted.” She taps the table with a pen. “Why would a woman answer a question about a fortnight that has not happened in under a second?”

“Because I had the answer.”

“Because you had been *given* it. By Mrs. Okafor-Pruitt, at four o’clock, in the kitchen, in a very nice sentence. I can hear that it is a very nice sentence. It is smooth. It has no snags.” She leans back. “The Examiner reads a rush.

“She has read ten thousand of them, I am told, across twenty-three counties, and she will read yours. A thing that arrives ready is a thing that was prepared for. And a thing that was prepared for is a thing you thought she would ask about, which is a thing you thought was dangerous. Do you see?”

“She takes anything ready for a thing I hid.”

“She takes anything ready for a thing you hid,” says Plimpton, with the air of a woman who has been waiting a long while to be understood. “Which, in this case, you have. I am not criticizing. I am reporting.”

At the corner of the room, in the bulb’s hard light, the Witness lifts its pen and writes.

---

That is the point of the evening. That is why we are here.

Dee has designed the moot in four parts, in her round clerk’s hand, on a legal pad she has taped to the wall: *A. The Motion to Stay (Docket 14,207). B. The Term. C. Tender. D. Any other matter touching the Officer’s yield.* It is the order of the Examiner’s Order of Proceedings, as Greer sent it to us in a photocopy gone grey at the edges, and Part D, the fourth line, is the one that has put nine Officers out of business.

We are not rehearsing Part C.

We are rehearsing the stand of it. We are rehearsing the weaker argument, the decoy: that Tam may tender the Term by a tape and a card and a dead man’s hands, that the pour of March the fourth is enough, that the Lender should stay its collection of Walt’s Estate until the keeping is said. We are doing it in front of the Witness, with its pen, on the record of its report, because Dee has made me understand that the Examiner will read it.

The real argument is not on this stand. I do not carry it in the notebook, or on a card, or in a pocket. It is a single sentence, which I have learned by heart in six sittings at the kitchen table with my eyes shut and the dog’s head on my foot. I will not say it near the Witness. I will not write it. I know only that it is the last line of Tab C, and that it is as short as a latch.

“Again,” says Plimpton. “From the top of B.”

I breathe. I begin.

I give it slowly this time. I make myself wait before I answer, as I have heard Walt wait, though I do not remember it; I take the pause as it is taught on the tape, which is a held breath and a turned head. It comes out ragged. It comes out nothing like Dee’s sentence. It comes out the way a person talks who has been asked a hard thing in a quiet room.

“I do not know that I can say it,” I say. “I know my hands do. I’ll try.”

Plimpton says nothing.

I wait. The silence stretches. The wall clock, an electric one from the 1970s, ticks off a second and another. I feel the old, bad, ready answer rising in me like a cough: *the terms provide, the tape records, the card was delivered by the Clerk.* I do not give it. I let it stand in my mouth. I let the silence do what it does.

And behind me, very low, I hear a knuckle tap the table.

*One.*

It is Mags. She is sitting in the back row on a folding chair with her work gloves in her lap, a thick, tidy woman of sixty-three in a grey sweatshirt that says PELL COUNTY ROAD CREW, and she has been there since the first question, saying nothing. She taps the second knuckle on the wood. *Two.* The third. She is counting the pause on her hand as she counts a crew into a truck.

*Three.*

“Thank you, Officer,” says Plimpton, quietly, in a voice that is not the drill. “That is a considerably better answer.”

“I didn’t say anything.”

“No,” she says. “That’s what makes it better.”

---

It is an odd thing to be taught by a woman who dislikes you. I had thought I understood Plimpton. I thought her a clever tool of the county, a woman who stood in the doorways of rooms and read the room, and who wore her right cuff buttoned when she lied and her left cuff buttoned when she told the truth and not enough of it.

I find that she has, under the drill, a patient and unsparing love of the thing she is doing. She has sat in front of nine Examiners. She is the only person in this room who has watched one read.

“She will not interrupt you,” she says. “That is what you must understand. She will not say a word. She will let you finish, and then she will say nothing, and the nothing will go on. You will want to fill it. The nothing is the question. The nothing is *what is she going to say next,* and every person who has stood in front of her has answered it. Do not.”

“What do I do?”

“You hold the silence as if it were a cup,” says Plimpton. “Hold it level. Do not drink it.”

Cal, in the second row, in his school sweatshirt, has gone very still. He has been taking this in. He is taking it in the way he takes everything, with his whole face, and I see his lips shape *level,* and then *don’t drink it,* and I know that it will be on the whiteboard by morning.

“She will see you alone,” I say. “She will see Cal first.”

“If it comes to that,” says Plimpton.

“It will.”

“Yes. I rather think it will.” She looks at him. It is the first time all evening that her expression has changed. “Mr. Halloran, you will want to speak. You will want to speak at once and loudly and in your good voice. Don’t. Hold it level.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

“I’m not *ma’am,*” says Plimpton. “I’m Plimpton. Dee, I would like a glass of water.”

---

At twenty past eight we stop.

It has gone, I think, as well as such things go. The Witness has written a very great deal. Dee has taken off her glasses and is pinching the bridge of her nose; Mags has put on her gloves and is stacking the chairs; Cal has fallen asleep sitting up, with his chin on his chest and his pen in his hand, and Biscuit has laid his whole length against the boy’s shins like a draught-stopper.

I carry the garbage out to the lot because it is a thing I can do with my hands.

It is a clear, bitter night, the sort that goes through wool. The gravel is hard as iron. Overhead there are more stars than I knew a county had, and at the far end of the lot, lot five lies silent and pale, with its small stake, and a card on it, under snow. I put the bag in the can and put the lid on. When I turn around, Plimpton is standing at the stand’s back door in her navy coat with her gloves in her hand.

“I have something to say,” she says. “I have not decided whether I will.”

“You can say it.”

“That is not what I said.”

I wait. I find I am good at it now. I stand with my hands in the pockets of Walt’s coat and I let the nothing go on. Somewhere to the north a truck downshifts on the state road and fades. Plimpton looks at me, and I look at her, and she is the first to break.

“Damn,” she says. “You are very good at that.”

“I’ve been taught.”

“By me. An hour ago. I am a fool.” She breathes out, a long white plume. Then she lifts her left hand, the one with the glove in it, and with the other she very slowly unbuttons the cuff of her coat.

I have seen it a dozen times. Right cuff, false. Left cuff, true and not enough. It is a thing she does without knowing, and I have read it as a deaf man reads lips. She has the left cuff open. She does not button it back.

“I was given an instrument,” she says. “Four weeks ago. By the county. I will not say which office. It came in an envelope with a clip, and I was told to keep it ready. Not for you. For after.”

“After what?”

“After.” She reaches into the coat and takes out an envelope. It is long and white and plain, the kind a bank uses, unsealed. She does not hand it to me. She holds it between us at arm’s length, like a thing that might go off.

“I have not signed it,” she says. “I should like that noted. I have been asked to, and I have not, and I should very much prefer not to be asked again.”

I read it by the light over the stand door.

It is a single sheet. It is typed, with a line of fine black rule at the top, and a seal in grey wax at the foot, and it is cold to the touch. It says:

*COMMISSION.*

*ACTING OFFICER, PELL COUNTY.*

*Name: ______________.*

*To take effect upon a vacancy in the office of the Collections Officer for Pell County, from the moment of such vacancy, with all fees, margins, and Collections then in her keeping.*

*Effective: Day 181, 2:00 p.m.*

“It’s blank,” I say.

“The name is blank. That is the only thing that is.” She is looking at the paper, not at me. “It is a blank commission. It is typed for a vacancy, with the hour already written in. I was told that it was a precaution. That Officers do not often come through an Examiner’s hearing. That, in the circumstance of a vacancy, the county should not be left without.”

“A vacancy.”

“You.”

I do not say anything. The cold is in my teeth. A wire hums somewhere above us. I think, for no reason that I can find, of the face of Ellis Rosen on his ramp, saying *I’ve got a good pair of hands.*

“I have not signed it,” says Plimpton again, with a flat, dreadful dignity. “It is not a thing I would do. I have thought, in the last four weeks, about what a person is who does the thing she is asked and not the thing she wants. I have been, for nine years, the first. I would like, if the Lender permits, to see what it is to be the second.”

I would say something. I find I have only one thing, and it is not a thing for the gravel.

“Thank you,” I say.

“Don’t.”

“I mean it.”

“Don’t say it. It sounds like a *fee.*”

It does. I see it a half-second before she does. She looks at the paper, and then at the sill of the stand’s back window, where the Notice has come. It is cream. It has grey wax and a scarred thumbprint, and no blue-black margin, and I have time to read the head of it, from where I stand, before she turns.

*LIAISON, COUNTY OFFICE. FEE: DISCLOSURE OF AN INSTRUMENT. ONE REMEMBRANCE.*

“Ah,” says Plimpton.

It is a very small sound. She does not step back. She does not put out a hand. She holds quite still, with her white-gloved hand at her side and her unbuttoned cuff and her long narrow face lifted, and I watch her take the loss. It goes through her like a draught through a door.

“I was saying something,” she says.

“You were.”

“I was in the middle of a sentence. I was, it was about the, I had a thought about the water.” She puts a hand to her temple. “Mrs. Okafor-Pruitt’s water. I’d asked for a glass of it. I was going to say that, that the glass had a chip, and I was going to tell her, and then I was going to say a thing about a, a woman. No.” She breathes. “What was I going to say?”

“I don’t know.”

“No. You wouldn’t.” She laughs, dry and appalled. “It is the oddest thing. It is not a memory at all. It’s a *sentence.* It’s only a sentence I was in. One minute I had a whole room of it and the next the room is gone. It is like climbing a stair that isn’t.”

“I know.”

“I suppose you do.” She looks at me, and I see that her eyes are bright and quite dry. “Do you have a book?”

I do. I take out the green notebook, and a pen, and I stand with it against the stand’s back wall under the light and I write, in order, with the date and the hour and the sum: *Day 168, Thursday, 8:34 p.m. Plimpton, in the lot, said: “Mrs. Okafor-Pruitt’s glass has a chip.” Then she lost the end of the sentence. She does not know what came after. I wrote the first half. I will not write the second; I do not have it.*

I tear the page out and fold it twice and hold it toward her.

“Keep it,” I say. “It’s yours.”

She takes it. She does not read it. She puts it very carefully in the pocket of her coat, in the same pocket as the Commission, which she has put back in its envelope, and which she does not take out again.

“That is a better answer,” says Plimpton, in a voice that is trying to be dry. “To a stranger. Than I gave.”

---

She is gone before I have the lot gate shut. I hear her heels on the gravel and then a car door and then nothing at all.

I stand a while in the dark.

I think about the envelope. I think about the typed hour, which I have read three times and now cannot stop reading: *Effective: Day 181, 2:00 p.m.* The hearing opens at ten. It is expected, according to Greer and the Order and the Clerk’s best estimate, to end near half past four.

I do the arithmetic on the gravel, with my fingers, as Mags would.

Ten o’clock to two o’clock. Four hours. A hearing that has not reached its fourth line.

The vacancy is not feared. It is not drafted against an accident, a heart, a road. It is typed in at a time before the hearing is done, in a precise hour, on a Wednesday, in an instrument carried by a liaison who has been told it is *a precaution,* by a county that has not asked her what she thinks.

It is *expected.*

Inside the stand, through the glass, I see the grey figure of the Witness. It has put down its pen. It is looking at the back door, not at me, with the patient, formal air of a clerk who has received a form, and has stamped it, and is waiting to be told where the form goes.

On the sill, the Notice has gone. In its place, set exactly in the centre, is a single slip of cream paper, folded in thirds, with a deckled edge. I have seen the paper. I have seen the hand. It is blue-black, and slanted, and in a hurry.

I unfold it in the light of the bulb.

*Two o’clock is not when she ends you. It is when she finds out whether she can.*

There is no signature. There doesn’t need to be.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!