Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 5

Pie

By Wednesday noon the parlor was the quietest room Hannah had ever stood in.

She noticed it the way you notice a refrigerator stopping. No cold spot. No hum under the boards. The plaster had cured to a flat pale gray, and when she laid her palm on it, it was just a wall, which she found she wanted to cry about, and did not.

She also noticed that her husband was not in the house.

Cal had been gone since a little after five. His truck was gone, too. On the kitchen counter there was a note in his square engineer's capitals: COFFEE RUN. BACK SOON. It had been a very long coffee run.

At 12:15 someone knocked on the front door with the flat of a hand.

Dot Gallagher stood on the porch with a covered dish and a folded newspaper under her arm. The quilted vest had been replaced by a quilted coat. She had, Hannah saw, put on lipstick.

"Hon," Dot said. "May I come in? I only want to sit down."

Hannah took her to the kitchen, because the kitchen had chairs and the dining room had sawhorses, and because she did not want Dot to see how badly she wanted to know what the woman knew.

"I knocked on your door yesterday," Hannah said.

"I saw." Dot lowered herself into a folding chair with the care of a woman who had been doing it since 1960. "I wasn't up to company. Cal came by this morning, did he mention it?"

Hannah kept her face very still. "No."

"He was a gentleman. He stayed twenty minutes." Dot turned the pie dish a quarter turn on the table. "Peach, this one. Last of the freezer. I'm sorry, I assumed he'd said."

"He said coffee run."

"Well, I do make a good cup."

It was a courtesy, a small knife folded into a napkin. Hannah noticed it and let it be noticed. Then she sat down across the table, and she said, as evenly as she could:

"Dot, what's in my house?"

Dot didn't flinch. She unfolded the newspaper and slid it across the table. It was the Marrick Falls Courier, brittle and yellow, a reprint from 1941: HISTORY OF COBB STREET'S SEVEN SISTERS.

"Ansel Verrill built seven houses on this street in 1889," Dot said. "A house for each of his children and one for himself. Number forty-one was his. They were the grandest on the river. Then, in the winter of 'ninety-three, the youngest, a little girl, Pearl, got out into the cold. Went through the ice on the footbridge. They carried her home, but she did not live. And that same morning her mother walked down to the river and went in after her."

"That's the legend."

"That's what the paper says. That's all the paper knows." Dot's eyes were very clear. "Ansel sealed some rooms, and he stayed on in the house for eight years, and the neighbors said that every night at three in the morning you could hear him on the stairs. Counting."

Hannah did not move.

"Counting the household," Dot said. "Like a ship's master. One, two, three. He'd count them every night, and every night he'd come up one short."

"And now?"

"Now it counts whoever's there." She tipped her head. "What did it count last night?"

"Four," Hannah said, before she could stop herself.

Dot closed her eyes. For a second the older woman's face looked its age, every year of it.

"Hon," she said, "listen carefully. I'm going to say it once, and you can think what you like of me afterward. The thing on the stairs will call a roll. First it counts, and then, when it's ready, it calls names. When it does, don't answer. Never answer for anyone but yourself, and never answer to a name that isn't yours. Not for the dog. Not for your husband. Not for a stranger. If it asks where somebody is, you say nothing. Because whatever you say, it believes. And whatever it believes, it keeps."

"That's a rule."

"It's the rule."

"Dot." Hannah put both hands on the table. "Why are you telling me this? What do you get out of it?"

"I get to sleep, some nights."

"That's not an answer."

"It's the only one I've got today." Dot stood. She smoothed the front of her coat. Her knuckles were swollen and her wedding ring, a thin worn band, was loose on her finger. "Eat the pie. And ask your husband where he's been going, because it's not my place."

She was gone before Hannah got up.

At two, Dale Pomeroy, the municipal inspector, came to look at the electrical rough-in. He was sixty, dry as chalk, and said "unfortunately" the way other men said "well."

"Unfortunately," he said, in the kitchen, with a flashlight, "I can't pass anything in here until that floor is dealt with. You've got a rotted sill under the west wall. See that?" The flashlight showed a dark seam in the subfloor, spongy, mottled with white fungus. "You open that up, replace the sill, sister the joists, then I come back. I can do the twenty-eighth. After that, unfortunately, I'm in Harrisburg for a week."

"The twenty-eighth," Hannah said. "That's ten days."

"Yes, ma'am."

"And the final is December 3."

"If the rough-in passes. If it doesn't, you don't get a final, you don't get a certificate, you don't get an Open House." He clicked off the light. "Unfortunately."

She walked him out. She watched his Buick go up Cobb Street and she stood on the porch with her arms folded and thought: a floor. A sill. A week. Of everything that was wrong with her life this week, a rotten sill was the first thing she knew how to fix.

Cal came home at four. He had coffee, and he had flowers from the gas station, and he had the look of a man who had spent the day rehearsing.

"Dot came by," Hannah said.

"Oh."

"She said you stayed twenty minutes."

Cal put the flowers on the counter.

"I needed to ask her something about the house," he said. "About the watch. I'm sorry I didn't say. She asked me not to tell you until I'd heard everything."

"What did she tell you?"

"Lots." He rubbed his face. "The roll. The rule. I was going to tell you."

"When?"

"When I knew what I thought."

"We're married, Cal."

"I know," he said. "That's why it's so hard."

She did not shout. She would have liked to. But she was a woman who had hidden a fifty-eight thousand dollar loan for a month and had very little moral ground, so she took the flowers and put them in the sink, and he took the evening's leftover pie, and they sat at the folding table and ate in silence, and the house made no sound at all.

At 3:07 she woke already listening.

The bed was warm. Cal's breathing was slow. Pickle was a hard small weight against her ankles, trembling.

A stair took weight.

"One," said the voice. "Two. Three." A pause. "Four."

Hannah waited for it to stop. It did not.

"Ansel Verrill," said the voice.

Silence.

"Lenore Verrill."

The old, patient pause.

"Lenore," the voice said again, warm, hoarse, and very close, as if the man were standing in the doorway of their room with his hat in his hands. "Are you here?"

Hannah was half asleep. She would swear to that, afterward. It was a question, and she was a person who answered questions, and her mouth had formed the first sound of the word before the rest of her had caught up.

A hand closed over her mouth.

Cal's palm, hot, firm, from behind. His whisper was against her ear, urgent and low.

"Don't. It's not your name."

She went rigid. His other arm came around her waist. She felt his heart against her spine, going like a hammer.

"I know the rule," he whispered. "I'm sorry I didn't say it last night. Dot told me what happens if you answer wrong. She told me why she knows."

Below them, the voice waited.

"Somebody answered for her brother, once," Cal breathed. "A long time ago. And nobody's seen him since."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!