Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 10

Penalty Box Arbitration

At ten fifty-eight on Friday night, I walked onto the ice in street shoes, holding a clipboard and a pretzel, to meet my landlord’s lawyer.

The rink was dark except for the penalty box. It glowed at the far boards like a fish tank. Beyond the glass, a figure in black-and-white stripes sat very straight on the bench, white-gloved hands on its knees. It had no face I could see. Only a smooth, polite blank, like a mannequin that had been to law school.

I had walked this ice a thousand times with a skate guard in my hand. Never once had it felt this far to the other side.

Behind me, the whole Herons roster sat in the stands in a loose, nervous row. Rennie had worn her good jacket. Jo held a thermos and a wrench. Walt sat in the front row with the cane, and a blanket over his knees, and an expression that dared anyone to say a word. Bev handed out nachos to the people who needed them most.

Marcus waved. I waved back with the pretzel.

At exactly eleven, the whistle blew.

“COURT IS IN SESSION,” said the figure in the box. Its voice was a stadium announcer’s, warm and bored and a hundred feet tall. “BEFORE THE REFEREE OF RECORD: THE MATTER OF SITE 4471. OPERATOR TOLLIVER, ON NOTICE. RESPONDENT QUILL, APPEARING PERSONALLY.”

Quill walked out of the tunnel at the other end.

He wore the gray suit, a little more wrinkled, and a lanyard that had gone crooked. He carried the three-ring binder against his chest as if it might stop a bullet. There were gray smudges under his eyes. For the first time since I’d met him, he did not smile.

“Ms. Tolliver,” he said.

“Mr. Quill.”

“This is an extraordinary waste of time.”

“It’s a hockey rink. Time is the only thing we waste.”

The Referee raised one white glove. “OPENING STATEMENTS. THE OPERATOR MAY PROCEED.”

I did it the way I do a purchase order. I stood at the boards and read the entries, one by one. Four, in gold. The first night. Quill’s own words, in his own voice, in my own handwriting.

“Standard form, nothing unusual,” I read. “False. It’s completely free to start. False. It’s absolutely standard. False.” I looked up. “Very few have missed a payment. Hardly any. False.”

Quill’s jaw tightened. “Those are subjective characterizations,” he said. “A form is standard if it is commonly used.”

The pen scratched.

Bartleby Quill: “A form is standard if it is commonly used.” FALSE.

The stands made a noise like a long breath. Quill looked down at the clipboard, which he could not see, and then at me. I saw a thought cross his face and close its coat.

“The book is not reliable,” he said. “It’s a... novelty class skill.”

FALSE.

“It’s a class passive,” I said. “It’s in the manual. Page fifty-eight, clause c. It says any admissible record of the parties.”

“That’s an interpretation.”

“You wrote it.”

“I didn’t write it, I memorized it!” Quill’s voice cracked. “Do you know how long I’ve been on this region? Do you know my quota?” He pressed the binder against his chest. “Eleven signatures a quarter. Eleven. You are my ninth. I have a performance review in nine days and a very fine family, a mother in a care home, and a cat, and if I don’t make my number, I’m going to be...”

He stopped. The Referee turned its smooth face a quarter inch.

“Written off,” I said.

He didn’t answer. In the stands, someone dropped a nacho.

I’ll tell you something I hadn’t expected. I felt sorry for him. A man in a suit carrying pizza and a pen, a man whose smile was a job, who had walked into a stranger’s equipment room at midnight and lied three times before the ink dried, because the alternative was to be erased from the world. I knew exactly what that felt like. I’d been counting since I was eight years old.

But I also knew where the knife had come from.

“Mr. Quill,” I said. “Clause twenty-two.”

His eyes flickered. “I’m not familiar with...”

“No agent of Lower Management shall interfere with an Operator’s equipment or personnel, directly or through a third party.” I held up a plastic bag. Inside it was a chinstrap severed cleanly across the middle, and a utility knife with a gold stamp. “Marcus Bell’s helmet. Cut two hours before a delve. The blade has your signature. And the man who held it told me you gave it to him.”

“That’s hearsay,” said Quill, a little too fast.

“It’s a Count,” I said. “And I’m told it’s admissible.”

A silence the size of a hockey rink settled over the ice.

“I did not authorize anything,” said Quill at last, in a voice so small that I almost couldn’t hear it. “I told Marchetti’s people they could tour. I never told them to cut anything. I only said...”

The pen didn’t move. He was telling the truth.

“I said it would be helpful if the Pinegate delvers had an obstacle,” he whispered. “That’s all. A small obstacle. An incentive for them to take the buyout.”

The Referee lifted a white glove. The entire arena went dark and silent.

“THE REFEREE HAS HEARD ENOUGH.”

The ice seemed to inhale. A spotlight came down on the penalty box, white and hard. I could hear my own pulse. Behind me, Jo said something under her breath that was probably a prayer.

“FINDINGS. FIRST: THE BOOK OF RECORD IS ADMISSIBLE UNDER CLAUSE 58-C. SECOND: THE RESPONDENT HAS MADE FOUR FALSE STATEMENTS MATERIAL TO THE FORMATION OF THE AGREEMENT. THIRD: THE RESPONDENT, THROUGH A THIRD PARTY, HAS INTERFERED WITH THE OPERATOR’S PERSONNEL, IN VIOLATION OF CLAUSE 22.”

My knees went to water. I held the boards.

“RULING. CLAUSE 12, FLOOR RENT, IS AVOIDED FOR ONE QUARTER, THIRTEEN WEEKS, EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY. THE OPERATOR’S GOOD STANDING IS CONFIRMED. THE RESPONDENT IS ISSUED A WARNING.”

The stands exploded.

I don’t remember the next thirty seconds. I remember the noise, a wave of it, rolling down the rows. I remember Rennie bellowing like a woman who’d just scored a goal. I remember Bev crying into a pretzel, and Duffel doing a victory lap across the boards, and Walt standing slowly at the front with his hand on his chest, breathing the deepest breath of his life.

And I remember the pen, dancing across the page, with a line of gold I had never seen.

FLOOR RENT: VOID FOR 13 WEEKS. FRANCHISE RATING: ELIGIBLE FOR REVIEW.

Quill was still standing on the far side of the ice, small and gray, clutching his binder. I caught his eye. I made a small gesture that I think meant, I’m sorry, and I think he understood.

Then the Referee spoke once more, and the stands went still.

“A NEW FINDING. THIS MATTER HAS NEVER BEEN HEARD BEFORE. THE REFEREE FINDS THAT THE FRANCHISE IS ELIGIBLE FOR AUDIT. AN INSPECTOR WILL ARRIVE AT SITE 4471 ON MONDAY, AT NINE IN THE MORNING. THE OPERATOR WILL HAVE ALL INVENTORY READY.”

“An inspector?” said Rennie.

“It’s fine,” I said. “It’s an audit. I count things. I’m a professional.”

The pen sat still. For once, it didn’t have a word to say about it.

Monday, at nine, I was standing in the lobby of my arena with the clipboard against my chest, Walt at my shoulder, Jo and Bev behind us, Duffel at my feet. The front doors opened on a cold white morning.

A woman came in out of the light.

She was tall. She wore a long gray coat and a plain gold pin, and she carried a battered black clipboard that matched mine. Her hair was silver now, cut short, and she walked the way someone walks when she’s in a place she has been before. She looked at the walls, the old banners, the banner of a heron with its wings out.

She looked at me.

Her face did nothing. It was perfectly polite. It was the face of a stranger who’d never seen me in her life.

The badge on her lapel was white, with plain black letters.

INSPECTOR A. TOLLIVER. FLOOR SEVEN.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!