Cubicle six was at the end of the row, against the wall, under a light that buzzed at a note somewhere between B and a headache.
It had the standard Bureau furniture: a gray desk, a gray chair, a gray partition with a pinned corner where something had once hung. A beige phone. A tray with three drawers on the right. A nameplate bracket, empty. Nothing about it said a person had ever sat there for even a minute, which, by the end of the evening, I understood was the entire point.
I put Duffel on the floor. It zipped itself shut and went still, the way a dog does in a waiting room.
"Okay," I said. "Let's count."
I sat in her chair. It was a little low. I adjusted the lever, and it went up, and I sat there with my knees at a different angle than hers and my hands on the desk, and I let the Count open.
DESK, STANDARD ISSUE. DURABILITY 91%. HISTORY: 28 YEARS 3 MONTHS IN CONTINUOUS USE. OWNER: A. TOLLIVER (ASSIGNED). OCCUPANT: A. TOLLIVER (INTERMITTENT). ITEMS CLEARED: 61.
Sixty-one. I counted it again, and the Count did not budge. I opened the top drawer.
Empty. I mean empty the way a drawer is empty when a very careful person has cleaned it. Not a paper clip. Not a crumb. I ran my thumb along the bottom, and the Count said DRAWER, CLEARED, and a number: 61 TIMES. Once per audit, I thought. Sixty-one audits. Each time, the clipboard wiped, the desk wiped, the Inspector sent upstairs to be a person with no past, and then sent down again.
I opened the second drawer. Empty. The third, the deep one, had a lining of green felt, and under the felt there was a small square of cardboard, folded to fit, and I almost missed it because it had been placed so that a drawer would close over it. I took it out and unfolded it. It was the back of a legal pad. On it, in pencil, in a small square hand that leaned a little to the left, someone had ruled a grid.
It was a tally. Rows of marks, in groups of five, four strokes and a slash, down the page and over, in a neat discipline that I knew in my own hand, because I do the same thing to boxes of tape. At the head of each column was a date. They were all different. And at the foot of each column, in the same pencil, there was one line, the same line every time, in a hand that did not change over decades.
Short by one.
I put the paper on the desk, under the light, and smoothed it flat with both hands, and the Count opened on it with a gold edge.
TALLY. 61 ENTRIES. AUTHOR: A. TOLLIVER. MATERIAL: PENCIL, GRAPHITE, STANDARD. NOTE: HAND-HIDDEN. SELF-CONCEALED TWELVE TIMES. SELF-DISCOVERED SIXTY-ONE TIMES.
"Self-discovered," I said aloud. "She found it every time."
I understood. It was not hidden from the Bureau. It was hidden from her. Each time she was cleared, she lost the page; each time she came back down she found a desk that felt familiar and a drawer that wanted to be opened, and she opened it, and there was a tally in her own hand, and she picked up the pencil, because she could not help it, and she kept counting.
What was she counting?
The columns were headed by dates, and under each date was a list of tick-marks, and next to each tick-mark was nothing, no name, no label. A number only. Forty-one, forty-two, fifty-eight, sixty. And then, in the last column, the newest date, a week after the Findings I had stood through, one stroke different.
I Cross-Checked the page against the only other numbered list I had. In my bag, folded small, was the headcount sheet the Bureau had given me with the badge, a list of every person currently on Floor Seven by function. Inspectors. Clerks. Candidates. I read the totals. Then I looked at her last column.
Her number was one less than the total of Inspectors on the floor.
Every time. Every column. The number of people who answered to the title Inspector, and her count, one fewer. She had been counting Inspectors, from this desk, for twenty-eight years, and every time she got one short.
It was not the Roll of the Written Off. It was something else. She was counting the people the Bureau used, the Written Off ones who had been turned into clerks and inspectors, and every time she did, there was one more than she could account for. Or one less. I did not know yet which.
"Who is the one you can't find?" I said.
The bag zipped, softly. A window opened. The first word was ANNE, and I put my hand over my mouth, because I had not heard it said in this room, and the second word, a moment later, was not a word at all but a small icon, a pencil, and then HER.
"Her what?"
HER PENCIL, said Duffel. And then, after a pause: BOTTOM.
I got on my knees. I looked under the desk. On the underside of the center drawer, where a person with a left hand in a left pocket would reach without looking, there was a small groove, like a notch in a ruler, and in the groove there was a pencil. A short one. Chewed. Yellow once, gone to the color of weak tea. There was a name on it that I read with my thumb before I read it with my eye. In faded gold stamping: PINEGATE ARENA, GIFT SHOP.
I sat down on the carpet of the Bureau of Franchise Compliance, in the dust under my mother's desk, holding a pencil I could have bought for forty cents the year I was born, and for a good long while I did not count anything.
I put the pencil in my pocket. The lift, which had taken my own pencil on the fifth floor, was behind me, and the Bureau does not search for pencils. It was a small, mean, satisfying thing.
Then I climbed back into the chair. I took the badge off my lanyard and slid the tally into it, behind the photograph, so that it lay flat against my chest.
"Item," I said, quietly. "One tally. Item, one pencil. Item, one cleared drawer that was never cleared of everything."
A voice said, behind me, "Candidate Six."
I did not jump. I want that on the record. I turned in the chair with my hand on the desk, with the look of a woman who has been entirely alone for an hour and would like very much to go on being so.
It was Pim.
He stood at the end of the row in his gray cardigan, with the Audit binder against his chest and the particular posture of a man who has run down four hallways and is trying to look as if he did not. He was white. His glasses were crooked. He had not sneezed, yet, which I took as a bad sign.
"Pim. What are you doing here?"
"I'm, I work here," said Pim. "I mean, I'm assigned to Seven. It's my floor. I was told you'd arrived. I came to say hello, and also," and he looked down the row of cubicles, and then up at the ceiling, where a small black dome sat in the corner like a drop of ink, "also to give you this."
He held out a form. It was a Bureau form, cream stock, black and gold at the head. It was the same paper as the Notice. He didn't let go of it at once. His hand was shaking enough to make it hum.
"It was in the outgoing tray at the Inspector's station," he said. "I wasn't, it isn't my place, I'm not supposed to carry things out of the tray. But it has your name on it. I thought you should see it before anyone else."
I took it. It was one line, in a typed grid, a field in a file. A field I knew, because I had seen it once in the lobby at Pinegate on a different form with a different date, in a hand I knew better than my own.
TOLLIVER, MARGARET. SITE 4471. DEPENDENTS: none. REVISED: PENDING. EFFECTIVE UPON COMPLETION OF TRACK.
I looked up at Pim.
"Someone is about to change it," Pim said. He was whispering. His whole face was crumpled up with the effort of not lying and not telling me too much. "That's all I can say. I'm sorry. I can only say true things. That is a true thing."
He sneezed, twice, and fled.

