At eleven fifty-six and forty seconds, I did something I had never done in thirty-six years. I threw away a thing I loved.
“Four Units,” said Jo. She had the clipboard in one hand, a flashlight in the other, and the look of a person doing arithmetic on a sinking boat. “Mags. Everybody pat your pockets.”
They did. A dime. A button. A vending coupon. Dr. Fitch produced a gum wrapper with a certain solemnity, and Rennie produced a lucky coin from 1998 that the Buyback slot weighed, sniffed, and rejected as “COMMEMORATIVE, NOT CURRENCY.”
The wallet number, in the corner of my eye, read five hundred and ninety-six, in a calm green font, like it had nothing to apologize for.
“We have two minutes,” said Marcus.
“We have two minutes and twenty seconds,” said Jo.
“I can run to the concession stand!”
“And do what?” said Bev. “Sell them a pretzel?”
“How much for a pretzel?”
“Three dollars, baby, and it’s dollars, not Units.”
I stood in the middle of it, with the stairwell echoing and the countdown ticking in the air over my head like a bomb that had learned to read. TIME REMAINING: 00:02:20. I had a head full of arithmetic and a hollow place where a minute of my memory used to be, and I thought: This is how it ends. Written off the roll, all of it, because of four Units and a pretzel.
Then the mimic bumped my knee.
Duffel had followed us all the way down. He shuffled across the concrete like a sleepy dog, zipper curled in a half-smile, and he pressed one side of himself against my leg and made a noise like a suitcase being gently opened.
“Not now, buddy,” I said.
He did it again. This time, a flap rose and the zipper parted, and from the dark inside, like a magician’s rabbit, came one single, small, grimy item.
A hockey puck.
I Counted it. I didn’t want to. My hands did it by themselves.
PUCK. DURABILITY 100. VALUE: 11 U. HISTORY: Pinegate Herons home opener, game one, the night they won. Signed on the side in marker. OWNER: A. TOLLIVER. FLAW: none. Held onto for twenty-eight years.
I knew it before the line came up. I know the handwriting. It’s a loop that curls over the T like a small, sloppy wave.
My mother signed my first puck. I was eight years old, in the stands, in a snowsuit the color of a traffic cone. She wrote, TO MARGARET, WHO COUNTS. She laughed. She bought me a hot chocolate and let me finish her pretzel.
Three weeks later, no one in Pinegate could tell me her name.
“It’s eleven Units,” said Jo, reading over my shoulder. “Buyback pays forty percent. That’s four and change.”
“I know.”
“Mags, it’s only a puck. Your face is doing something.”
“Yes, I know,” I said. I looked at the countdown. 00:01:19. I looked at the puck. Any sensible person would have told me to hold on to it. Thirty-six years of counting would have told me to hold on to everything.
My hand did not want to open. I made it, one finger at a time, the way you pry a kid off a pool ladder. Then I knelt, and I fed it into the Buyback slot.
The slot hummed. It coughed. It paid out four Units and a little gold sticker that said THANK YOU FOR YOUR BUSINESS.
“Four,” said Jo. “Exactly four.”
“Rounding,” I said. “It’s the only thing I’m good at.”
BALANCE: 600 U. FLOOR RENT: PAID. NEXT DUE: FRIDAY 11:59 P.M. THE FRANCHISE REMAINS IN GOOD STANDING.
The countdown blinked out. Something in the stairwell exhaled, a long cold breath I felt in my teeth, and the whole basement relaxed.
For about five seconds nobody said anything. We just listened to the building not trying to kill us.
Marcus whooped. Dr. Fitch gave me odds on being proud of myself, and said they were remarkably high. Rennie cried and called it allergies, and the Book of Record scratched, and Jo laughed so hard she sat down on the stairs. I was sitting there too, somehow, my back against a green wall, my hands shaking, trying to remember when I’d last done something that wasn’t for the arena.
The team drifted upstairs in a cloud of bad jokes. Bev squeezed my shoulder and went with them. Duffel curled up against my hip and made a small, apologetic noise, and I realized he was sorry. He had given me the one thing he had.
“It’s okay,” I told him. “It was just a puck.”
The pen on my clipboard scratched.
Margaret Tolliver: “It was just a puck.” FALSE.
I shut the clipboard. Jo stayed.
She sat two steps above me with her wrench across her knees and didn’t say anything for a while. The compressor hummed overhead. Somewhere up in the rink, the resurfacer started its midnight lap.
“Mags,” she said. “I’ve known you twelve years. Where did you get an eleven-unit puck with your own name on it?”
“It was my mother’s.”
“Your mother.” She said it carefully. “Mags. I thought... your parents were never...”
“My mother,” I said, “ran this arena’s franchise before anyone had heard the word. Twenty-eight years ago, Jo. She was an Operator. There was a dungeon in this basement when I was eight years old.”
I heard how it sounded. I hadn’t said it aloud to anyone since I was nine. At nine I’d said it to a school counselor, and I’d watched her write something on a pad.
Jo didn’t write anything. She turned the wrench over once.
“Say her name,” she said.
“Anneliese. Anneliese Tolliver.”
Jo’s face went through something like a very slow storm. I recognized the look. I’d seen it on every adult in my life, from the school counselor to my aunt in Duluth, who still sends me a card at Christmas that never mentions a mother. It’s what happens when a person looks for a memory and finds a smooth wall.
“I don’t remember her,” she said at last. “I’m sorry. I really, really don’t.”
“I know.”
“But you do.”
“I do.” I put my hand over my mouth. “I always have. And I count every single thing she ever touched, because it’s the only way I know that it happened.”
The Book of Record, on my knee, said nothing. It had not logged a lie. It was the first time all week that it had nothing to say.
From the top of the stairs, a small, rough voice said, “Anneliese sold programs.”
We both looked up.
Bev Sandoval stood in the doorway in her hairnet, with her cardigan sleeves pulled down over her hands. She was holding the rail with both of them. Her face looked as if someone had turned a light on in a house she’d locked up for decades.
“At the south gate,” she said. “With the yellow scarf. Baby, I don’t know why I never said. I’ve known that name my whole life, and I don’t know why I never said.”

