We read it at Walt's kitchen table on Saturday morning, nine of us around a table meant for four, with the notice flat in the middle under a jar of pickled beets.
Item: Walt, in his cardigan, with the clipboard. Item: Jo, with a pencil behind each ear in a bad imitation of Pim. Item: Rennie, Iggy, Fitch, Bev, and Priya Nandakumar, who had driven a hundred and eleven miles overnight and was drinking coffee as if it owed her money. Item: Pim, at the end, with his Review Rules open to a page of tiny print. Item: Duffel on his own chair, with a napkin.
Oz joined by telephone. Hattie had put him on a line she called the party pipe, and he came through the kitchen wall in a rattling tin whisper, clearing his throat every few words like a man in a barrel.
"Read it out, Tolliver," said Walt.
I read it. It was four pages and I read every one, in the flat voice I use for inventory. When I got to the end the kitchen was quiet except for the refrigerator.
"It's a form," said Rennie, finally.
"It's a form."
"A really nice one. Cream paper."
"There's a watermark," said Pim. "It is a pencil."
"Operator," said Oz, from the wall. "Say the thing again. The bit on page two."
I turned the page. "Collection of a Reserved Item requires the consent of the Item. Refusal shall be heard before the Referee of Record. The Item may not be compelled."
"Not compelled," said Priya, softly. She had put down her coffee. "Say it once more."
"May not be compelled."
"That is not boilerplate." The dentist leaned forward. "I have read a great many consent forms. They say a patient may withdraw at any time, and then they build a hallway with no exits. This one says may not be compelled. In a document like this, those words cost something. Someone fought for them."
"Anneliese," said Walt.
"Perhaps." Priya touched the paper. "I'd like to see the clause history, if the Office keeps one."
"It does," said Pim. "I have a call in to a cousin. I mean a colleague. Possibly a cousin."
I looked at the cream paper. For three days I had been telling myself I was angry, and it was true, but under the anger was the thing my mother had written on the plate: COUNT ME LAST. I had read it as an order. I understood now it was also a plan. A woman who knows the Bureau is going to collect her daughter does not write count me last. She writes it because she has found the one place in the machine where a person can still say no.
"I want to ask Harrow something," I said.
"Mags." Jo put down the pencil. "She can't lie. But she can leave things out."
"I know. That's why I'll ask one question at a time."
The Office of Continuity has a telephone. I do not know how I knew its number. It was in the Count, in a small gold line at the bottom of the notice. I dialed it on Walt's landline, in the hall, with the cord stretched to the end of its length, and a woman answered on the first ring with the voice of someone who had been waiting beside the phone.
"Continuity. Harrow."
"It's Tolliver."
"Ms. Tolliver. I am glad you called. I would have been worried otherwise."
"One question."
"Of course."
"If I refuse collection, does the Referee decide whether I'm collected?"
"No." A pause, brief and clean. "The Referee decides whether the refusal is properly heard. If it is, the Item remains. The Referee cannot compel consent. No one can, in the Bureau's scheme. It is the only point on which Corporate and the Referee have never disagreed."
"Then why does Corporate ask?"
"Because most items consent." The voice was kind. "Nearly all. They are tired. They are offered a garden. They are told that someone they love will be spared. It is not coercion, Ms. Tolliver. It is merely the shape of the offer."
"What happens to the pipe?"
"I do not follow."
"Pipe 3,908."
Silence. For a moment I thought the line had dropped. Then Harrow said, with great care, "You have been to the Plant."
"Yes."
"I would ask you to understand that I did not tell you of the pipe, because you did not ask. I would never have lied." Another pause. "If the item refuses, the pipe continues as it is. The cold continues, the cost continues. It is a drain. It was designed to be one. It is the reason the Bureau wishes you collected. A collected Dependent can be held without cost. A reserved one cannot."
"So it's costing me. Every day."
"It is costing you a very small amount every day. You have been paying it for twenty-eight years. You did not notice because it was small." Her voice dropped. "That is the cruelest thing I know, Ms. Tolliver. It is a good machine, and it is cruel because it is gentle."
I leaned on the wall. The plaster was cold against my back. I said, "Thank you."
"You are welcome. May I say one more thing, which you did not ask?"
"Go ahead."
"I did not wish to be the person who brought you the notice," said Harrow. "I asked for another. It was refused. I have never failed to be useful. I am sorry to have been useful to this."
I put down the phone. My hands were steady.
When I went back to the kitchen, they had stopped talking. They were all looking at me, and it was Walt who spoke.
"Well?"
"I can refuse," I said. "It's allowed. It's heard in front of the Referee, and the Referee can't overrule it." I sat. "The pipe keeps draining me. It's been doing it all along. It's why the Bureau wants me. A collected Dependent is free to hold."
"And if you refuse?" said Rennie.
"The Floor Rent. The pipe. The Notice. It all keeps going."
"It's a penalty kill," Rennie said slowly. "You're down a man and the clock's running. You don't win a penalty kill. You survive it. You clear the puck, you burn the clock, you wait for the whistle."
"What's the whistle?"
"The Final Inventory." Priya's voice was very quiet. "That is the time at which the last item chooses. It is the only moment at which she may elect. Until then, the answer is not a consent. It is a refusal. And the Referee must hear it."
"Then it's simple," said Jo. "You refuse."
"It's not simple," said Walt. He had been quiet, watching me with his old, wet, tired eyes. "Tolliver. You've been counting forty-one hundred pipes and thirty-nine hundred spines in your head for three weeks. Do the arithmetic."
"What arithmetic?"
"What's it cost? To refuse? For however many years of this it takes?"
"Walt."
"I'm asking. Because it's not free. It's a little a day. It's a little more every year. I'd like to know what the little adds up to."
I did not know. It was a good question. I opened my mouth to say so, and the kitchen door banged open.
Pim Ostrander stood there, hair on end, holding his phone like a live fish.
"Operator," he said. "My colleague called back. About the clause history. She says it is on file, and it is in your mother's hand, and she says that is not the thing." He swallowed. "She said to tell you that in the Roll, behind the last shelf, behind the lamp with the green shade, there is a door that is not on any plan."
"A door?"
"Marked ANNEX B." Pim's voice shook. "And she says the Referee will not hear your refusal until you have read what's inside."

