Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 11

Chalk and Cho

The FBI agent had brought Dess a clean sweatshirt, which was how she knew she was in trouble.

It was 3:40 in the morning, Day 7, in an interview room at the Harlow Cove police headquarters that smelled of burnt coffee and radiator dust. Dess sat at a steel table with a paper cup of tea she had not touched. Somebody had washed Walter Pruitt's blood off her hands, but not out of the cuticles. The green dress had been bagged as evidence. She wore a borrowed pair of gray jail-issue sweatpants and nothing on her feet but a pair of paper slippers.

The sweatshirt landed on the table in front of her with a soft thump. It was navy, soft, and said HARBOR CREDIT UNION 5K FUN RUN across the chest.

"It's mine," said the woman who had thrown it. "It's clean. I figured you'd want something that wasn't evidence."

"Thank you," Dess said, and meant it, and hated how much she meant it.

"Don't thank me yet." The woman sat across from her, set down a manila folder and a second cup of coffee, and crossed one ankle over her knee. She was about forty, small and compact, with straight black hair cut at the jaw, a charcoal pantsuit and a face that had spent its adult life listening to people lie and had forgiven all of them in advance. "Renata Cho. Special Agent, FBI, Boston field office. I'm told you've had a long night."

"Somebody died in my arms."

"I know. I'm sorry." And the awful thing was that she sounded it. "Walter Pruitt was a decent judge. We've watched him for six years and never found a thing. That's the problem with decent men. They're the best liars."

Dess pulled the sweatshirt over her head. It smelled of laundry soap and, faintly, of someone else's apartment. She was shivering and had not noticed until the warmth reached her.

"Am I under arrest?"

"No."

"Am I free to go?"

"Yes. Detective Ivers will walk you out whenever you like. Mr. Draycott's been sitting in the lobby since midnight with a very large lawyer, and I would prefer you didn't leave with him." She let that sit. "Not before you've heard me out."

"I told Detective Ivers everything I saw."

"You told him the Judge asked to speak with you privately, that you talked about the courtroom ruling, that a shot was fired from the pier, and that he died." Cho flipped the folder open. "I've seen the video from the atrium. The terrace camera was broken, which I find interesting, but the interior one shows you for six minutes with him. A lot can be said in six minutes. Did he say anything else?"

Dess looked at the paper cup. A lie was a small thing and she had told so many tonight that one more would not weigh on her.

"He was frightened," she said. "He said Strand had made him rule against the Draycotts. That's all."

"That's what I assumed." Cho wrote something. She did not look up. "Ms. Whitlock, I'm going to be direct, because you've had a bad night and I respect people who tell the truth in rooms like this."

"Please."

"The Draycott family has been the subject of one of the longest racketeering investigations in the history of my office. Thirty-one years. Four agents have retired on it. We have never indicted a Draycott for anything. Do you know why?"

"Because they never lent anyone a dollar."

For the first time the agent's face moved. It was a small, dry, delighted movement, the face of someone who has found a book on a shelf she had given up on.

"Who told you that?"

"Elias Draycott."

"Then he's told you more than he's told me in ten years." She closed the folder. "We know about the Registry. Not everything. We know there's a room, we know there are lots, we know that people in this city do favors for the Draycotts they have no reason to do. We've never had a witness. Everyone who's ever passed through that house has been too frightened or too well protected to testify."

"And you think I'll testify?"

"I think you're the first outsider they've let in since 1921." She leaned forward. "I think you've seen the Cabinet. I think you've seen the Letters. I think you know where it all is, and what it says, and who it'd destroy. I'm not asking you to betray anyone you like. I'm asking you to testify to a spreadsheet."

"A spreadsheet."

"Of lots. Dates. Consignors. The hammers. A ledger of every favor ever called in this city." Cho said it with an odd, patient tenderness. "You can walk out of this room with immunity from every charge connected with the Cabinet, plus protection, plus relocation, plus a very large settlement from a fund I have been quietly nursing for eleven years. You can go back to Boston. You can have your shop back, a better one. And Walter Pruitt gets something in the end besides a cold stone and a eulogy."

It was very persuasive. It was so persuasive that Dess felt, for an unguarded moment, the pull of it, the warm bright door at the end of a long hallway.

Then she thought of Teddy telling a joke about her bad tea. And Marcus asking for a croissant. And Elias, in the car, telling her what it cost him.

"I can't," she said.

"Can't or won't?"

"I signed a contract."

"People break contracts."

"Not this kind." She heard herself and was surprised. "It's not that I'm loyal. I'm not. It's that I haven't finished the job. If I testify now, half of the lots are unverified. People would be accused of crimes on the strength of a fake. Ten of them are already fake. I can't build your spreadsheet on that."

Cho watched her.

"That is," she said at last, "a remarkably honest reason."

"I'm a remarkably honest person."

"Then let me tell you one more honest thing." The agent pushed a single photograph across the steel table. It was a grainy, old-fashioned, black-and-white shot of a man at a lunch counter: fifties, gray cardigan, one big hand wrapped around a coffee cup. A loupe was pushed up on his forehead like a second eye.

Dess did not breathe.

"Raymond Whitlock," said Cho. "Your father. I've known his name since 2014. We nearly caught him with that painting, you know. Pure luck. I was a very junior agent. I testified at his sentencing." She tapped the picture. "That's from a surveillance file. It's dated 2015. When he was, officially, in a cell at Carver Hill Correctional."

"That's a mistake. That's a different man."

"Could be." Cho's voice was very gentle. "He's on my list, Ms. Whitlock. It's a long list, a private one. People who died and kept filing paperwork."

"I don't understand."

"A man named Raymond Whitlock renewed a driver's license in a Rhode Island town last spring. The paperwork was good, the address was a motel, and the photograph was one of the best I've ever seen." She tilted her head. "The clerk said he told a very funny joke about coffee."

Dess sat motionless in a stranger's sweatshirt.

"I'd like to find him," said Cho. "I think you would, too. And I think the person who killed Walter Pruitt would like to find him a good deal more."

Dess finally stood. She did it carefully, like a woman unfolding something fragile.

"I'm going to go home," she said.

"To Cooper's Hill."

"To wherever Elias drives me."

"That's a very specific kind of home." Cho got up, too, and extended a small white business card with a number in blue ink. "You'll call when you're ready. Not if. When."

"You sound very sure."

"I've been watching the Draycotts for thirty years." The agent smiled, quite warmly, and it made Dess feel more alone than any threat. "People don't stay in that house. They either die in it or leave it. It's only a question of what's left."

She walked Dess to the door of the interview room and stopped with a hand on the knob.

"One more thing. Tell Elias Draycott I said hello."

"Why?"

"Because I'd like to see his face." Cho opened the door. "He'll know."

The lobby was gray and fluorescent and nearly empty. A uniformed officer slept with his chin on his chest at a desk. On a plastic bench along the wall, with his coat folded across his knees and his hands clasped between them, sat Elias.

He had not changed out of the tuxedo. His collar was open. His bow tie lay in his lap like something he'd forgotten he was holding, and there was a tiny dark smear on the white of his cuff, the exact size of a thumb.

He stood the moment he saw her. He did not say anything. He crossed the lobby in six steps, stopped a respectful two feet away and looked at her face. She watched him take inventory: the sweatshirt, the paper slippers, the eyes.

"Are you hurt?" he said.

"No."

"Are you—"

"I'd like to go home."

He took off his overcoat and put it around her shoulders. His hands lingered at her collar for a fraction of a second, long enough to adjust a fold that did not need it. Then he stepped back and held out his arm.

"The car's outside," he said. "Marcus is driving."

Behind him a very large man in a very good coat rose from the bench, nodded to her with grave courtesy and said, "Miss Whitlock. Gideon Pratt. I am the family's attorney, and I am going to pretend I did not hear anything said in that room." He had the voice of a church organ and the build of a retired linebacker. "Please don't tell me what you told her. It's easier for everyone if I can say I don't know."

"I told her nothing," said Dess.

"That is the correct amount." He bowed. "I'll see myself out."

When he had gone, Elias spoke very quietly, looking at the door instead of at her.

"Did he say anything, Dess? Before. On the terrace."

It was the second time that night someone had asked her, and the second time she heard the answer arrive in her mouth, smooth and ready. She had stood on that terrace with a dying man's hand on her wrist, and she had been given a name that belonged, in some terrible way, to her.

She had promised this man no lies about the drawers.

This was not a drawer.

"Only that Strand had been leaning on him," she said. "He was very frightened."

Elias looked at her. His eyes, in the lobby's flat light, were an almost colorless gray.

"All right," he said.

It was not belief. It was not disbelief. It was a door he was choosing not to open, and she felt it close with a small, precise click she would remember.

"Elias."

"Yes."

"Agent Cho says hello."

Something went across his face. It was quick and old and tired. It was not surprise.

"Of course she does," said Elias Draycott, and opened the door to the cold, gray dawn.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!