The carriage-house door opened four inches, and a conservator's eye looked out over a chain.
"Dess," said Teddy. "Hi. Good morning. It's very early. I'm having a normal morning."
"You're holding a fire poker."
"I am not."
"There's a fire poker. It's right by your elbow."
Teddy glanced down. A black iron fire poker was, in fact, gripped in her right hand, held loosely behind her back like a schoolgirl hiding a note. She looked at it with an expression of deep betrayal and set it on the floor.
"I thought you were Cordelia," she said.
"Do I look like Cordelia?"
"No, but I'm very tired and she gets everywhere." Teddy slid off the chain. She stood in the doorway in her overalls with her braid half down and a smear of cobalt on her cheek, and her round, cheerful face was the color of paper. "Is Marcus with you?"
"He's in the van."
"He's what?"
"We followed you from the post office." Dess said it gently. She had rehearsed several versions on the walk across the lawn, and had abandoned them all. "I'm sorry. I'd like to come in and talk. Please. I'm not going to hurt you, and I'm not going to tell Elias until you've had the chance to."
Teddy closed her eyes.
"Oh, Madonna," she said, quite quietly. "I knew it. I told him. I knew someone would see."
"Who?"
"Come in," said Teddy. "Come in, come in. I'll make tea. I can't do this without tea."
The carriage house was a vast, sunlit, glass-roofed room that smelled of linseed oil and turpentine and beeswax. Brushes in jars, rows of them, hundreds, arranged by size. Easels. Tubes of pigment like a spilled rainbow. A big oak table covered in cotton wadding and a half-restored Dutch portrait of a woman with a very surprised hat. In the middle of the floor, near the stove, lay the remains of a shelf, a heap of splintered wood and scattered glass jars, with a spill of white powder across the boards like a small blizzard.
"That was me," Teddy said. "I panicked. I dropped the lead white. It's fine, it's a very old pigment, I'll just never have kids."
"Teddy."
"I know." She filled a kettle at the sink with unsteady hands. "I know. Sit down."
Dess sat on a paint-stained stool. Teddy stood with her back against the counter, arms folded tight across her middle, staring at nothing.
"Fourteen months ago," she said, "I got a parcel."
"At the post office."
"No. Here. Left on the carriage-house step, early, before anyone was up. Brown paper, string, no stamp. I almost threw it away." She laughed shakily. "Inside, wrapped in cotton, was a Georgian snuffbox. Silver. Chased. It was beautiful. I thought it was a gift."
"Do you know what it was?"
"Lot ninety-six." Her voice dropped. "I didn't know that then. I only found out later, when I looked at it under my loupe, and there was a number scratched very small under the lid. And a note. Do you want the note?"
"Please."
Teddy crossed to a locked flat-file cabinet near the north window, unlocked it with a key from her overalls and drew out a manila folder. She held it for a moment against her chest.
Then she gave it to Dess.
The note was on a single square of plain cream card. The hand was small, careful, forward-leaning, and unmistakable. Dess had seen it on three hundred and twelve letters, and an eleven-day-old condition card. It was her father's.
Please keep this safe. Do not tell Elias. He cannot lie to the Table, and he must not have to. A friend.
Her eyes burned.
"I thought it was Papa," Teddy said. "At first. I thought it was Gus, being clever. He does that, he sends things, he's always been the kind who'd rather hint than talk. I put it in the cabinet and told myself I'd ask him. And then he fell ill, and I didn't. And then another one came."
"How many?"
"Eleven. Over fourteen months." She opened the flat file. "Five I've sent on. Six I'm holding."
Dess looked into the flat file. Six small shapes lay in cotton: a Georgian snuffbox, chased silver, with a number scratched under the lid; a mourning brooch of braided hair gone soft with age; a bridal veil comb; a brass key to a house that no longer existed; a pair of tiny wire spectacles. And a violin case, which Teddy had wedged vertically behind the cabinet like an umbrella.
"The brooch is Lot 44," Dess said.
"Is it?"
"I found its fake three days ago. The hair was dyed. This one isn't." She touched it with one gloved fingertip. "It's the real one. All of these are real."
"I know. I checked the date on the silver. I'm not an idiot." Teddy's voice cracked. "I'm only a coward."
"You are neither," Dess said. "You are the best-kept hiding place in Massachusetts, and nobody had the sense to look under the paint."
"Sent on where?"
"I don't know! They tell me. There's always a card." Teddy hunched her shoulders. "Every two or three months, a card, in the same writing, says to put a particular lot in the Cabinet Room drawer by a certain night. I take it up through the garden. I've got a key to the side door, I'm family, nobody checks. I put it in the right drawer."
"You've been putting real lots back."
"Yes."
"Which means someone swapped a fake in first."
"I thought they were replacing broken ones. I thought it was restoration." The words tumbled out. "I do restoration! It was the only reasonable thing! I'd never opened the Cabinet unwitnessed, I'd have died, but the cards said it was safe, and Mr. Ambrose was always, always looking the other way. Like he knew."
"Teddy," said Dess.
"And then the last one." She bent and pulled open the bottom drawer, and lifted out a small bundle in brown paper, tied with white string. "It came the night of the shooting. After the shooting. Before I even went to bed. I haven't opened it."
Dess held out her hands. Teddy put the bundle in them.
It weighed almost nothing. She turned it over twice. The string was tied in a bow, double-looped, the way her father tied everything. She slipped the knot, folded back the paper and opened the cotton wadding inside.
A silver pocket watch lay in the white fluff.
She did not need the loupe. She took the glove from her pocket anyway, and the penlight, and the loupe, and held it up. She turned the hunter case to the window. She opened the dust cover.
The screws were hand-cut. The tarnish lay evenly in a hundred years of thumbs. The patent date on the winding stem was 1889. And under the lid, in a ring of old Boston hallmarks, so tiny and so true that she had to hold her breath to see them, was a signature she could not read, because it had worn away to nothing.
"It's real," said Dess. "It's the real Lot 17."
"Walter Pruitt's."
"Yes."
"He's dead."
"I know."
"Then why did they send it?"
Dess turned over the wrapping paper. There was a card tucked in the fold. Same hand. Same square of cream. Three lines.
Walter's hammer is Alison's now. Let her hold it, not Strand. Tell your brother the hammer's still his.
She stared at it for so long that her eyes swam.
"What does it mean?" whispered Teddy. "Tell your brother. I haven't got another brother. Do I have another brother?"
"I think it means Elias."
"But he said I couldn't tell him."
"That was before." Dess lowered the card. "Now it's telling you that you can."
The kettle began to whistle. Neither of them moved.
"I should have said," Teddy said. "I should have said at the very first. I'm a coward. I'm a bad liar and a worse secret-keeper, and I put real lots in a flat file in my own studio because a dead man told me to."
"He's not dead."
"What?"
"I'm fairly sure he's not." Dess's voice shook. She set the watch down on the table with great care. "The Judge told me. Before he died. And I've been lying to your brother about it since the benefit."
"Oh, Dess."
"I know."
"That's terrible. That's exactly my kind of terrible." Teddy came round the table and flung her arms around her, quickly and hard, smelling of linseed and tea. "I'm so sorry. We're both horrible."
"We're both terrible."
"We could start a club."
Dess laughed, once, a damp, shaky noise into Teddy's shoulder.
The door crashed open.
"I am here," announced Marcus, "with a bat."
He was brandishing, with admirable commitment, a broom handle. He looked from Dess to Teddy, from the wreckage on the floor to the tea kettle screaming on the stove, and lowered the broom.
"This isn't what I thought it was," he said.
"It isn't," said Teddy, sniffing. "You can put the stick down, Marco. It's not a bat. It's a broom."
"It was the only thing in the van."
"I appreciate the gesture."
He propped the broom against the door. He walked slowly into the room, hands open, and for a moment his big, easy face was stripped of everything but concern. He looked at his cousin and said, with a gentleness that startled Dess, "Teddy-bear. How long?"
"Fourteen months."
"By yourself?"
"Yes."
He nodded, and swallowed, and nodded again. Then he turned and went to the sink and turned off the kettle with a gentle click.
"Okay," said Marcus. "Okay. We'd better go and tell Eli. I'll carry the watch."
"He's going to do the face," Teddy said, in a very small voice.
"He's going to do the face," Marcus agreed. "And then he's going to hug you. And then he's going to do the face again. And that's the best we can hope for."
Dess picked up the watch, the real watch, the one a dead man had pledged his life on, and folded the cotton back over it.
She was already thinking of the hand on the card. The small, careful, forward-leaning script that looked more alive on that cream-colored square than it had any right to, eleven days or fourteen months or nine years since a man in a gray cardigan had last put a pen to paper.
Then Teddy picked up the other note, the old one, from fourteen months before, and held it out.
"There's a second line," she said. "On the back. I never read it. I thought it was part of the stain."
Dess turned it over.
In a tiny, slanting hand, in pencil so pale it had nearly gone, someone had written: For Dess, when she comes.

