Judge Walter Pruitt wore a gold watch chain across his vest, and there was nothing on the end of it.
Dess noticed at 9:04 that morning, from the third row of Courtroom 4B in the Harlow Cove County Courthouse, where she was sitting in a borrowed navy suit beside Elias Draycott with her hands folded like a girl at a recital. The chain looped from one vest pocket to the other and dipped in the middle, and the little pocket on the right hung flat and empty.
He kept touching it.
Not looking. Just touching, the way you touch a tooth you've lost. His fingers went to the empty pocket every time he finished a sentence, patted once, and moved on.
"He's been doing it since the opening statements," she whispered.
"I know," said Elias. He did not turn his head. "Watch him in the hour. It gets worse."
"Does he know it's a fake?"
"He knows it's gone."
It was a very ordinary courtroom for an extraordinary morning. Pale oak, fluorescent lighting, rows of benches with the glassy shine of a hundred years of nervous trousers. On the left, the lawyers for Draycott Marine Services, a gray-suited woman with a legal pad and the controlled expression of someone who'd seen the outcome in her dreams. On the right, a pair of attorneys from a Boston firm in suits that cost the same as her entire retainer, representing a lender who held a lien on Marcus's tugboats and wanted eleven million dollars by the end of the week.
Marcus sat in the front row in a suit that did not fit his shoulders. He had been told not to speak. He was visibly dying of it.
The Judge was sixty-six, thin, ruddy, with a clipped white mustache and a way of sighing before every ruling. He had a reputation for being fair, bordering on boring. He had read the briefs twice and made notes in the margins. He asked three questions of the lender's attorneys, each brief and each pointed.
And for forty minutes, it looked like Draycott Marine was going to win.
"I want you to see this," Elias had said in the car, in the voice he used for things he'd rather not be true. "He's honest. He's not a crook. Whatever we did for him, whatever he pledged, he's spent fourteen years trying to be worthy of it. He rules on the facts. In fourteen years, we've called his hammer exactly once, for a postponement, and he did it with an apology."
"So why do you think he'll rule against you?"
"Because he's already decided to."
Dess had not understood. She understood now.
At 10:12, the Judge removed his glasses, rubbed the bridge of his nose and put them on again. He looked at no one. His voice, when it came, was clear and level and utterly dead.
"The court has reviewed the briefs and the testimony of the parties. The lien is valid and enforceable. Draycott Marine Services is ordered to satisfy the judgment in full within thirty days, failing which the vessels held as collateral will be liquidated at public auction."
The lawyer for the lender rose with a small, stunned breath. The lawyer for Draycott Marine did not move.
In the front row, Marcus went white.
"Thank you, Your Honor," said the lender's lawyer, with the dazed courtesy of someone handed a winning ticket in a lottery they hadn't entered.
"Court is adjourned." Pruitt lifted his gavel. It was a small, plain wooden thing. His hand trembled so badly that the first strike nearly missed the block.
Then, for the first time, he looked up.
He looked straight at the third row. Not at Elias. At Dess.
She had met no judge, had never been to this court, had been in town four days. And yet, for a long, awful second, the old man's gray eyes locked with hers across fifty feet of pale oak, and she saw the plea in them as clearly as if he had shouted it.
He knew who she was.
He was asking her something.
Then he looked away, picked up his papers and went out through the door behind the bench like a man walking into the sea.
"Dess," said Elias quietly. "Let's go."
She followed him out into a corridor that smelled of floor wax and wet coats. Marcus was already there, pacing, one hand pushing back his hair, and the lawyer for Draycott Marine was talking in a low and hopeless voice about appeals.
"Eli," Marcus said hoarsely. "That was my tugs. That was my men's jobs. That's forty families."
"I know."
"He's never done that. Never. Fourteen years, and he's never once ruled against this family. He's the reason my mother can sleep."
"I know."
"Then—"
"Strand called his hammer." Elias's voice was very low. "He has the real watch. He called Walter this week. Whatever he asked for, it was this."
"Then call yours."
"I can't. My lot's a fake." His jaw tightened. "I can't call a hammer on a watch I don't hold."
Marcus swore, quietly and thoroughly, and hit the wall with the flat of his hand. A guard at the end of the hall looked up.
"Go to the bar," Elias said. "Get some coffee. Don't hit anything that can sue us."
"What are you going to do?"
"Walk Dess to the car. Then I'll find out."
The parking structure was gray, damp and echoing. Elias walked beside her with his hands in his coat pockets, not touching her, not speaking, and the quiet felt almost courteous after the corridor. His black sedan sat on the third level, in a corner. He opened the passenger door and she got in, and he went around, and then, instead of starting the engine, he sat with his hands on the wheel looking straight ahead.
"I'm sorry," he said.
"For what?"
"I brought you to watch a man be destroyed. I wanted you to see it. It's easy to say 'blackmail' about an object in a drawer. It's harder when you're sitting behind someone it's happened to."
"Why did you want me to see it?"
"Because I'd like you to be able to hate us accurately." He turned his head, and the gray eyes met hers. "It seemed fairer."
She did not know what to say to that. It was the most honest thing anyone had ever said to her about a crime.
"You said you wanted to tell me what the Registry cost you," she said at last.
"I said I'd tell you tomorrow, and I told you about your father. I owe you one more." He looked at the dashboard. "It cost my grandfather his marriage. It cost my father most of his friends. It cost my mother a very long, very quiet illness she never told anyone about, because she wouldn't have it said that a Draycott had a weakness."
"And you?"
"I'm still counting." He gave a short, dry laugh. "When I was twelve, I was allowed into the Cabinet Room for the first time. My father put his hand on my shoulder and said, 'Every drawer is a person, Eli. You do not get to forget it.' I haven't. I wish I could."
The garage hummed around them. Somewhere on a lower level a car alarm chirped twice and gave up.
"I'm trying to end it," he said. "Quietly, without anyone being hurt. That's the plan. I haven't got a better one, and I'm told it's naive."
"By whom?"
"Everyone I trust."
"I think it's a very good plan," said Dess. "I think it's a terrible plan to try inside the Hundred, with a thief in the house."
"Yes." He smiled, very faintly. "That's the part I haven't solved."
"When was the watch swapped?" Dess asked. "If I knew the date, I could work out who had the key."
"The Condition Card says eleven days ago. The drawer was last opened by a witness in August." He drummed two fingers on the wheel. "Which is to say, either the card is a lie, or the August witness was blind. I'd like to believe the card is a lie."
"But you don't."
"I've known Mr. Ambrose all my life. He's not blind." A pause. "I'm told the dead sign nothing. It would be convenient."
Her phone buzzed in her bag. She looked at it. A text from an unknown number, a single line:
You'll want to look outside the car.
She stiffened. Elias had seen her face. He was already scanning the garage, his hand moving in the oddest way toward his own coat pocket. And then she saw it: a figure at the far end of the level, in a camel coat, leaning against a pillar with a cigarette he was not smoking.
Anders Strand lifted a hand.
He walked toward them, unhurried, until he was ten feet from the car. He stopped there and held something up. It was a stiff cream-colored envelope.
Elias rolled down the window. "Anders."
"Elias. I was in the neighborhood." Anders smiled. He did not look at Dess. "I'm sorry about the ruling. It's an ugly business."
"That's a bold thing to say to me."
"It's a true thing. I don't enjoy it." He held out the envelope, not to Elias but past him, to the passenger window, to Dess. "My father's holding a benefit tomorrow night at the Cold Storage atrium. Black tie. The Harlow Cove Maritime Museum. It's very dull, the shrimp are good. He asked me to extend an invitation to the Draycott family's independent appraiser."
Dess took the envelope. The paper was thick, almost velvety.
"What's the occasion?"
"Silent auction. One of the items is a very fine antique pocket watch." Anders smiled again, small and apologetic and entirely unembarrassed. "Waltham. Circa 1891. Lent by an anonymous collector. My father is eager to have a professional look at it."
The car was very quiet. Elias had gone perfectly still.
"Is he," he said.
"He says it needs a second opinion. He'd hate to have anyone think it was a fake." Anders touched two fingers to his forehead in a mock salute. "Come in black tie, Miss Whitlock. And Elias, I'd wear the good cufflinks. It's going to be a long night."
He walked away. She heard his shoes on the concrete for a long, long time.
"Don't open it," Elias said.
"It's an invitation."
"It's a threat." His knuckles had gone white on the wheel. "If we don't go, he tells the Table we were afraid. If we go, he shows the room the real watch and dares us to say it's a fake."
"What are you going to do?"
He started the engine. For the first time since she'd met him, his voice was not quite level.
"We're going," Elias Draycott said. "Both of us. And you're going to look at it very closely."

