Since the Town Hall roof came in, the land records of Larkin Notch live in the back room of the fire hall, in a gray steel cabinet that Opal Strand guards like a dragon guards a very dull treasure.
“Tuttle strip,” says Opal on Thursday morning, without looking up. She’s sixty-six and wears her reading glasses on a beaded chain, and she speaks mainly in dates. “Sixty feet by a quarter mile. Hiram Tuttle, 1949. His heirs, 1986. Sold last June to Birchwater Land Partners for eleven thousand dollars, which I remember because I thought it was a joke.” She pulls a heavy ledger onto the counter. “I’ll save you the afternoon. There’s no easement.”
“There has to be,” I say.
“Josie. I’ve looked. Your family has driven across it every day for fifty-five years, and nobody ever wrote it down.” She turns the ledger around and puts a finger on a column of dead names. “Nobody in this town writes anything down. They shake.”
Connie, beside me, takes off her glasses and rubs the bridge of her nose. “A license by permission can be revoked,” she says heavily. “That’s what the letter relies on. If the Bells crossed by Hiram’s leave, not by right, then the owner can withdraw the leave.”
“Could we claim right? Fifty years is longer than the law needs.”
“It is. Unless the use was permitted. In which case it’s neither.” She looks at me with real pain. “Section fourteen, Josephine. Evidence.”
Anders has gone very still beside me. It’s his thinking face. I’ve come to recognize it: the jaw sets, and the eyes go to the middle distance like Dewey’s used to.
“Can I ask a question?”
“Always,” says Connie, which is a first.
“Did anyone keep a record of what Hiram actually said?”
I almost laugh. Then I stop, because I’m looking at Pearl.
My grandmother has not said a word all morning. She’s been sitting on a folding chair by the cabinet with her handbag on her knees, the way she sits at funerals. She opens the handbag now and takes out a binder. It’s fat, blue, and labeled in her handwriting: THE WALL. ROWS 1-22.
“I told you,” she says, “I kept everything.”
She turns to row nine, lower right, and slides her finger down an index in blue ink to a line I can read upside-down. 1974. H. Tuttle. Not a note about cheese. A note about a road.
The card, when she has it out of its plastic sleeve, is lined, yellowed, and written in pencil in a hand that leans like a fence in March. Walt, drive it as long as there are goats on it. I’ll hold you to the goats. H. T. April ’74.
Nobody speaks. Opal takes her glasses off her chain and puts them on, as if the card might read differently through them.
“That’s not a license,” Connie says slowly. “That’s a promise with a condition.” She turns it over. “It’s on the wall of a cheese shop. It is not recorded. It is not witnessed.”
“Hiram wasn’t a man for witnesses,” says Pearl.
“Moses was,” I say.
I don’t know how I know it. It’s the kind of knowing a farmer has about weather. Moses Tillotson was twenty-seven in 1974, working his father’s herd next door, and he has been in every important conversation in this valley since the winter of the great ice storm, with his hearing aid set to the volume of his convenience.
Moses is in the milking parlor when we find him, Friday at four, with a bucket and the radio on, doing his evening string alone since his son’s knee went. He switches off the pump when I say the word “Hiram,” and he switches on his ear.
“He said it at the north gate,” Moses says. He doesn’t have to be asked. “I was holding it. It was April, mud to the hubs. Hiram had a toothpick in his mouth, and he moved it to the other side, which was what he did before he said something he meant.” He looks at the cow in front of him. “He said, ’Walt, you drive it as long as there are goats on it.’ Then he said it again, because I was on the bad-ear side and he thought I’d missed it. Then they shook. Walt said, ’I’ll keep goats.’ Hiram said, ’See that you do.’”
“Would you say that to a judge?” Anders asks.
“I’d say it to a judge, a bishop and a goat.” Moses sets the bucket down. “I’ve been waiting fifty years to be asked.”
Back in the yard, Anders walks next to me with his hands in his pockets, and I can tell he’s rehearsing a sentence.
“Josie. I’d like to call someone. Delphine has a lawyer in Burlington, Teodora Banks. She does real estate and she is, as Delphine puts it, extremely rude about it.” He pauses. “I’m asking first. If you say no, I’ll find another way. We can do this with Connie and a library.”
I think about it. I think about the camera, and the four months of Pearl’s calendar, and a lifetime of people deciding what I can take. Then I think about an old man’s toothpick moving to the other side of his mouth.
“Call her,” I say.
“Just like that?”
“Just like that.” And I notice that it was easy. It was like stepping down off a curb I’d always measured as a cliff.
It rains on Friday night, hard, and the sound on the bunk room roof is the loudest thing for miles. I tell myself I’m checking on the space heater.
Anders is on the cot with his shoes off and a book he isn’t reading. Bernard is across the threshold with his chin on his hooves. I sit on the floor with my back against the cot, and he doesn’t say anything, and after a while I say it myself.
“Nineteen postcards.”
“Nineteen?”
“One a Christmas. I was twelve for the first one.” The rain thickens. “They’re in a shoebox. I never answered one. I used to run to the mailbox on the twenty-third, every year, even when I told myself I wasn’t. It always came on the twenty-third. Same card, I swear. Pictures of palm trees. She’d write, ’Thinking of you. Love, Mom.’ Five words. I counted once.”
“Did you want her to say more?”
“I wanted her to say it was a mistake.” I pull my knees up. “Then I got older, and I wanted her to say nothing, because I’d built a whole house on the nothing.”
His hand comes down and rests on the top of my head, heavy and warm, not asking anything. I lean back into it.
“My mother read me this farm as a bedtime story,” Anders says quietly. “All of it. The goat that ate her map, the cave that smelled like rain. I thought it was made up. Like a place in a book. I was thirty-six before I found out it had a mud problem.”
“It has a mud problem.”
“It has everything.” His thumb moves once against my hair. “I’m sorry about the nineteen. I’d like to say something wise.”
“Don’t.”
“Fair.”
We stay there till the rain thins and I fall asleep with my back against a hired man’s cot and a goat’s chin on my sock.
On Saturday, I am up the north gate hinge at five, on a ladder, greasing it, as if it’s going to matter.
By dusk I’ve done every job I’ve been avoiding since the first of April. I’m washing the milk house floor in rubber boots when I hear tires on the lane. It’s not Moses, and not a Hatch. Not the feed truck. It’s a small gray rental car, spotless except for the mud it’s collected in the last hundred yards, and it stops at the gate with the careful posture of a driver who has just seen a sign that says GOATS HAVE RIGHT OF WAY.
I stand in the milk house door with the hose in my hand.
The driver’s door opens. A woman gets out. She’s fifty-seven, slight, in a cream linen blazer and a good pair of low-heeled shoes, which go into the driveway to the ankle and stay there. She looks down at them. She doesn’t swear.
She looks up.
She has my eyes and my chin, and she stands the way I stand when I’m waiting for bad news to finish arriving.
I know that walk. It’s mine.

