At eleven-forty on Monday night I turn on my own kitchen tap, and it coughs at me.
It’s a small, wet, apologetic cough, like a man clearing his throat at a funeral. Then nothing. I stand there with a saucepan under the spout and watch the faucet think about it, and I understand that I have been carrying a hope around all day without noticing the weight, the way you carry a key you forgot you were holding.
“Nothing?” says Anders, from the table.
“Air.”
“It’ll be Wednesday, Josie. I said Wednesday.”
“I know what you said. I wanted it to be wrong.”
I set the saucepan in the sink. Beside it, on the counter, are the day’s four jugs from Moses’s well, the clipboard Lorraine left me with a list of who has been issued how many gallons, and a note in Pearl’s square hand that says DO NOT USE JUG THREE, THE LABEL IS A LIE.
There is a smell of old coffee and wet wool. In the next room, Marguerite Vail Ames is asleep upright in my mother’s armchair with her shoes on, and her brother is asleep on the floor beside her with a dish towel over his eyes.
I put them there myself, an hour ago. I’d like it noted that I did not plan on hosting the Vail trust. It happened the way weather happens.
“I have to do the milk,” I say.
“It’s midnight.”
“It’s the evening milk. It’s been sitting since seven.” I don’t look at him. “I can’t make cheese tomorrow, Anders. I can’t wash a vat. I can’t rinse a line, or a bucket, or a ladle. You can’t make a Reserve wheel in a dry building. It’s a health code. It’s also common sense.”
“So the milk—”
“There’s sixty-eight gallons in the tank. Seventy-one, with the late does.” I say it quickly, the way you pull a bandage. “The Hatches have calves. Moses has pigs. I’ll run it down the lane in the truck. And tomorrow’s milk, and Wednesday’s. Three days of the herd, that’s eleven hundred dollars of milk, and I’m not putting it on the Reserve shelf. I’m putting it into a pig.”
He’s quiet for a moment.
“Can I ask a question?”
“Yes.”
“Is that the part that hurts?”
It’s a very fair question. I’m angry that he asked it. “It’s the part I can count,” I say.
He gets up, and takes the keys off the hook before I can, and says, “I’ll drive. You’ll talk to the calves,” and I don’t say respectfully, no. I find, to my irritation, that I’d like to be driven.
---
We are back by half past midnight, smelling like a dairy that has been apologizing, and Marguerite is awake.
She’s sitting in the armchair with her hands folded and her coat still buttoned, in the lamp’s yellow light, and she’s looking at the wall. It’s the wall by the stove where my mother hung the school photographs, nineteen years of me in a row, a gap-toothed kid becoming a girl becoming a tall, unsmiling teenager with a bad haircut and a calf.
“I didn’t mean to wake,” she says. “I’m sorry. I thought I’d sleep like the dead. I haven’t, in a while.”
“You can stay.”
“It’s an extraordinary thing.” She nods at the photographs. “You were all here the whole time. I think that’s what keeps catching me. We never once came up this road. We looked at your hill on a map.”
I sit on the arm of the sofa, because there’s nowhere else. Anders stays standing in the doorway, with his coat still on, as if he’s not sure of his invitation. I’ve told him a dozen times it’s permanent. It’s a habit he has. Like a dog that turns around three times before lying down.
“Mrs. Ames,” I say. “Can I ask you something?”
“Margo. I think we can afford it, after tonight.”
“Margo.” It tastes odd. “Nolan said the man who holds the other fifty-one has been waiting since 1978. You were a girl then.”
“I was thirteen.”
“Do you remember anything about that winter?”
I expect a no. I expect the polite, lacquered no she gave me in the lane, the one that sounded like a door closing on a very good hinge. She doesn’t say it. She looks at her hands.
“A man came to dinner,” she says.
I wait.
“It was after Christmas. It had been snowing for three days and the road was a trench, and my mother had been told to make a roast, which she never did, we had a cook. He came in a long car with a driver. He was young, I think, though when you’re thirteen everyone over twenty is a monument. He wore a camel coat. It was the first time I’d ever seen a man keep his coat on at a table.”
“What did he say?”
“Nothing, at dinner. He asked me what I was reading. I said Jane Eyre. He said, ‘Good. Learn what it costs to be asked into a house.’ That’s the whole of it, I’d have said, if you’d asked me yesterday. And then at the door, when he was leaving, he gave me a silver dollar. A big one, with a woman on it.”
“A Morgan,” says Anders, softly.
“And he said, ‘Everything on this hill is spoken for, young lady.’ And my father, who was standing behind me, shut the office door so hard that the glass rang.”
The stove ticks. Calloway stirs on the floor, mutters something that sounds like a spreadsheet, and sinks again.
“We never talked about it. Papa was ill after that, in the way where nobody says what’s wrong. The lodge was never mentioned. The lodge plan was put in a box in the attic, and I found it in 2016, and nobody had told me what it was.” She presses her lips together.
“And through all of it, my father had a name for the man. He didn’t say ‘Mr.’ anything. He said the Subscriber. As if it were a title. ‘Is the Subscriber in the hall.’ ‘Don’t tell the Subscriber.’ I assumed he was a magazine.”
“Subscriber,” I say.
“To the lodge. Papa sold shares. Twelve of them, I believe. In 1977.” She looks up, and for a moment she’s a different woman, someone younger and more scared, with her hair in a plait. “It doesn’t mean anything. It means a man once paid my father for something that never opened.”
“It means a man’s been paying attention for forty-eight years,” says Anders.
Nobody answers that. A moth finds the lamp.
“Where would the paper be?” I say. “If a man buys a share of a lodge. If it’s sold to twelve people.”
“The attic box is in Palm Beach. It’s a trust file. Thad’s office has the digital—”
“No,” says Anders. He’s frowning at nothing. “It wouldn’t be there. If your father was afraid of this man, he wouldn’t keep his paper in a box a lawyer could subpoena. He’d have put it somewhere that said nothing. Somewhere nobody would think of as secret, because it’s public.”
I know before he finishes. It lands in me the way a stone lands in a well, with a long, delayed, cold sound.
“The town vault,” I say.
---
Connie Duquette answers her door at ten past two in a nightgown with teapots on it, which is, I realize, the same nightgown. I’d like to believe she owns two.
“Josephine,” she says. She has her glasses on. She has, I notice, her notary stamp already in her fist, as if it might be wanted before breakfast. “I assumed it was you. Nobody else knocks like a person apologizing.”
“I’m sorry.”
“I wasn’t asleep. I’ve been sitting here thinking about Section Eleven.” She looks past me at Anders, and at Marguerite, who has followed us down the lane in her good wool coat with the hem wet to the knee. “The helicopter lady. Good. Come in. I’ll get my keys.”
The Larkin Notch town office is a white clapboard building the size of a one-car garage, with a flag, a mailbox, a bulletin board that says DOG LICENSES DUE and a bronze plaque for a man who saved a bridge. The vault is in the back.
It was a bank’s, once, in 1911, until the bank was robbed by a man who left a note apologizing, and it’s been the town’s ever since. It has a round steel door two feet thick and a dial that Connie opens by feel.
Opal is already in it.
She’s sitting cross-legged on the concrete floor in a cardigan, between two shelves of green cloth ledgers, with a flashlight in her mouth and a pencil behind each ear. She takes the flashlight out. “I heard the word vault on the fire-hall channel,” she says. “You can’t say vault at one in the morning and not expect me to come.”
“We didn’t say it on the channel,” I say.
“Mr. Odell did. He had it from Ines, who had it from the milk truck.” She pats the floor beside her. “Land records, Book thirty-one. It’s January and February, 1978. Which is the thing you want. It’s the only thing anyone’s wanted since Monday.”
“How do you know it’s the thing we want?”
“Because it’s the thing a smart person would check,” says Opal, “and nobody checked it, because it’s the town’s, and the town is boring.” She hands me the book, which weighs about what a small goat does. “I started at the front. I’ve done to January twenty-eighth.”
“Opal.”
“It’s what I do.”
So we read. Four of us on a concrete floor under a bare bulb, at three in the morning, turning pages of copperplate. It’s the least cinematic thing I’ve ever done. Warranty deeds. A gravel pit easement. A mortgage on a barn that I know burned in 1991. A dog bite settlement, two dollars. Anders reads faster than anyone, with one finger moving down the margin like a man doing a very patient crossword. Marguerite reads like a woman who is afraid of what’s on the next page.
“It’d have been recorded,” says Connie, from her folding chair. “If it was real, it was recorded. You can’t hold land without the town knowing. That’s the one thing a town is for.”
“Unless it was indexed wrong,” says Opal.
“It was indexed by Harold Pike. He was careful.”
“He was careful in February. He had a stroke in January and came back in March. I looked it up.” She turns a page. “There was a girl who filled in. She indexed everything under the first name she saw.”
Page after page. At twenty to four, I stop seeing words. At ten to four, Anders says, “Wait.”
It isn’t a word. It’s a line.
It’s an entry on a page in the middle of February, in a different hand, rounder, schoolgirl, and it says, in blue ink gone to brown: VAIL, E. Misc. instrument. See also: Lot 14. And a book and page, in the thin pencil of a person who wasn’t sure.
“That’s not a deed,” says Opal. She’s already up. “That’s a cross-reference. It’s got no grantee. It’s like she lost the name.”
“Where’s the instrument?”
“Book thirty-one, page two hundred and two,” says Connie. She’s standing now. I hadn’t seen her stand. “That’s the loose box. Oh, Lord. We put all the instruments she couldn’t index into a box. It’s in the back.”
The box is a cardboard banker’s box, soft with age, with Misc. 1978 in a pencil that has outlived its author. Inside are forty-odd papers, folded in thirds, with rusted staples. Opal lifts them out one at a time with the tips of her fingers, like a woman picking over a drawer of sleeping mice. The ninth is on heavy cream paper. It has a ribbon.
It’s a legal-size sheet, typed. A recording stamp in the upper corner says FILED FEB 2 1978 4:58 PM. And the heading, in capitals, says MEMORANDUM OF OPTION.
Anders reads it out loud. His voice is very level, which is how I know it’s bad.
“For one dollar, and other consideration, receipt of which is acknowledged, Edmund A. Vail, of Larkin Notch, Vermont, does grant to the Holder of Certificate Number Twelve of the Larkin Notch Lodge Subscription, and to the Holder’s successors and assigns, an irrevocable option to acquire, upon presentment of said Certificate, all thermal, mineral and subsurface water rights in, under and appurtenant to Lot Fourteen and so much of Lot Fifteen as lies within the footprint of the structure described in Schedule A, for a term of ninety-nine years.”
“Ninety-nine,” says Marguerite. It’s barely a sound.
“Which is 2077.” Anders turns the page over. “It’s not even exercised. It just sits. And Schedule A—” He stops.
“What’s Schedule A?”
He hands it to me. The page is a sketch in pencil, a plan, a rectangle with an oval in the middle, and in the corner of the rectangle, in a draftsman’s lettering I’ve now seen four times this week, the word BATH.
“It’s the footprint,” I say. “It’s the Bath. It’s Walt’s wall.”
“It’s Edmund selling the Bath out from under the wall,” says Anders. “Before he’d even finished sealing it. The week he sealed it.”
“He wouldn’t.” Marguerite’s face has gone gray. “He wasn’t that man.”
“He did it to protect it,” says Connie, sharply. “Look at the date. It’s after the wall. He couldn’t give the man a ticket, so he gave him a piece of paper that said, you can have the rights, and he knew the rights were behind a wall. Nobody can use a thing they can’t find.”
“Until somebody opens the wall,” says Opal.
The vault goes quiet. In the silence I can hear the old bulb ticking, and my own pulse. We opened the wall. I said yes in front of a yard of people with jars. The town asked, and I opened it, and the sentence in my father’s jar said not until somebody asks, and I never thought, not once, to wonder what else somebody might be waiting for the same door.
“Josie,” says Anders.
“I’m fine.”
“I haven’t said anything.”
“You were about to say it’s not my fault.” I don’t take my eyes off the page. “It’s a little my fault. I’d like it in the minutes.”
“It’s not your fault.”
“Then say the other thing.”
He doesn’t, so I read on myself, down the page, to the foot, where the signatures are. There are two. The first is Edmund’s: a long, careful, anxious scrawl. The second is under a line that says WITNESSED. It’s in dark blue ink, and it is a big, blunt, square hand, with a lopsided W like a man who learned to write at a hay mow.
I know it. I’ve known it since I was six. It’s on the front page of Walt’s flow register in the cave. It’s on the card in my grandmother’s Bible. It’s on a birthday card in a tin, to a girl who wasn’t yet born, that says in capitals: FOR THE BABY. FROM THE GUY WHO’S HERE.
Walter Bell.
“Walt signed it,” I say.
Nobody answers.
“Four days after the wall.” My voice sounds like somebody else’s. “He walled it up on the twenty-ninth, and he stood next to Edmund on the second of February and he put his name on a page that gave it away.”
“Josie,” says Marguerite.
“My grandfather didn’t sign things.” I hear myself say it, with a kind of ridiculous dignity, as if somebody’s accused him of something at a parish supper. “He didn’t sign a mortgage. He didn’t sign a school form. Pearl signed everything. He signed for a calf once, and he said he’d been sick for a week.”
“He signed this,” says Anders, gently.
The page lies in my hands. In the corner, under the recording stamp, in a clerk’s hand, a little line has been added in pencil, in 1978, by a girl who couldn’t index it and was too frightened to throw it away. It says: HOLDER NOT PRESENT AT FILING.
I read it twice.
Somewhere across the village, a rooster starts early, a hoarse, offended note, the way a rooster does when he suspects he’s been lied to about the time.
“Somebody,” I say, “was holding the other end of that dollar.”
It’s eight minutes to four on Tuesday morning. It’s eleven hours and thirty-two minutes to three-twenty. I fold the paper in thirds, along its old creases, and put it inside my shirt, against my skin, where Ray’s letter lives, and I walk out of the vault into the cold gray light with a town clerk, a trustee, a stubborn girl with a pencil behind each ear, and a man in a coat that isn’t his, and I find I’ve already begun to count.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!