I should say no. I’ve said no to a developer, a trust, a notary and a pig. It’s the thing I’m good at.
But he’s an old man at a line in the heat, in a coat for a different climate, and he hasn’t asked me for the pad or the spring or the cave. He’s asked to look at a photograph. I take it out of my pocket. It’s warm and slightly bent from a day against my hip, and the white border has gone soft as cloth.
“You’ll have to come to me,” I say. “I’m not to cross the flag.”
“Nor am I, I think. Not that one.” He lifts his cane, an inch, and sets the silver tip against the road. “It’s an odd thing. I’ve been trying to arrive in this valley for forty-eight years, and it seems I’ve come to the one place where I’m told to stop politely at a piece of orange tape.”
“It’s a court order.”
“It’s a very good one. Mr. Pierce writes beautifully.” He holds out his hand.
I step to the flag, and he steps to the flag, and between us, on the tar, there’s a foot of hot air and a line of paint. I put the Polaroid in his palm, across it. His hand is long, and spotted, and astonishingly steady. It’s the hand of a man who has held a great many pens and never once dropped one.
He doesn’t look at the front.
He turns it over at once, as though he knew what was on the back, and reads, with his lips moving, a little, the way you read in a language you learned late. E. + W. Jan 21, 1978. Opening day. (Nobody came.)
He makes a sound. I’d call it a laugh, if it hadn’t got a crack in the middle.
“Oh, Edmund,” he says. “Oh, you fool. You wrote it in brackets.”
Behind me, a hundred and forty people have gone absolutely still. I can hear a bee in the culvert. I can hear Lorraine’s clipboard, which she’s let slide to the road.
“Mr.—” I stop. “Sir. I’m sorry. Do you want to tell me what you’re looking at?”
“Of course.” He turns the photograph over, and holds it so that I can see, and with one long finger taps the lower left of the picture, the corner where the tiles run down in a ragged edge to the water, and where, now that I look, there’s a faint, pale smear on the glossy surface that I’ve always taken for a thumbprint.
“That’s mine. I was holding the camera. It was a Christmas gift, a very good one. They had no one else to take it. I stood on the third step, in my coat, and I took it.”
“You were there.”
“I was on the stairs. I wasn’t in the water.”
“But it says nobody came.”
“It’s true. That’s what makes it so unbearable.” He lowers the photograph. “Nobody came, Miss Bell, because I was the only person they’d asked. And I was not asked in.”
The line seems to lean toward him. I feel it, a hundred and forty necks, bent.
“I’ll tell you the story,” he says, “and it’ll take three minutes, because I’ve told it to myself so often that I’ve had the time to cut it. In the autumn of 1977 a man called Edmund Vail, whom I’d met in a dining car, offered me a share in a bathhouse. Eleven others bought shares.
“I paid forty thousand dollars. I was twenty-six and I had a great deal of money that I hadn’t earned and no idea what to do with it. I’d have given it to anyone who said, with enough conviction, that a thing should be free.”
“Come cold. Go warm,” I say. I don’t mean to.
“Yes. That was Walter’s.” He smiles. “Edmund wanted to sell tickets. The other eleven wanted to sell tickets. They wanted it to be a lodge, you see, with a brochure. And I said, no, no, I’d like it to be what the ring says, and I’d like to be the first person to go in. I’d paid for the right. I’d asked for one Thursday. I was a boy who believed that a thing like that was the kind of present you gave, not the kind you sold.”
“What happened?”
“On the twenty-first of January, they finished it. Edmund and Walter. They didn’t send for me. They went in alone, in the afternoon, and when I came up the road at four, in my coat, with my little camera, they were standing in the pool to their waists, the two of them, grinning like boys. Walter called, ‘It’s cold, friend.’ Edmund called, ‘It’s not ready.’ And I stood on the stairs and said, ‘May I come in?’”
His voice doesn’t change. It’s a mild, dry baritone, and it goes on being mild, which is how I know what it costs.
“I’d like you to understand that I wasn’t asking for a thing I wasn’t entitled to. I was asking, in front of two men I’d have called friends, to be let into a room that I’d paid to build. And Edmund said, ‘Not today.’ And Walter said nothing at all. I’ve thought about it for forty-eight years. He looked at the water.”
“And you took the picture.”
“I said, ‘Hold still,’ and I took it from the third step. I thought I’d have it to remember that I’d been there.” He looks at the back. “I gave it to Edmund. In the cold, on the stairs. It seems he wrote on it. He never told me.
“He wrote the one thing I couldn’t have borne to read, and he kept it for forty-eight years in a place I’d never find. It isn’t even unkind. That’s the worst of it. I’d have liked to be angry.”
“And the option?” says Anders.
He’s come up beside me. He’s standing at the flag with his hand at his side, and he’s very quiet.
“Ah. Mr. Lund.” The old man inclines his head. “You’ll forgive me. I’m told you’re a very serious engineer. It was a legal remedy, Mr. Lund. It’s what I could do.
I wrote to Edmund within the week and said, ‘If I’m not to be let in, then I’d like what I paid for in writing.’ And he drew me an instrument, and Walter, of all people, agreed to witness it. I was a very bitter young man, and I’d like to apologize.”
“It wasn’t him,” I say.
“I beg your pardon?”
“There’s a dollar in it,” I say. I hear myself speak with a strange precision. “My grandfather came home on the second of February with a dollar and no goat. He said, ‘I got a good price.’ He sold something to somebody who asked nicely. I think it was you.”
For the first time, the old man’s face changes.
It isn’t much. It’s a small, plain, human thing, like a candle guttering in a draft. His mouth goes thin.
“Walter Bell,” he says, “came to the town office at four fifty-five that afternoon, with a goat on a lead, and walked her up the steps and into the vestibule, God help us. I was standing there. I’d come to see the paper filed, and I could not make myself go to the window. He was in a clean shirt. He said, ‘Mr. Subscriber, I’ve got a thing for you.’ And he put the lead in my hand.”
Nobody speaks.
“I said, ‘I can’t take a goat.’ He said, ‘She’s yours. She’s the best I’ve got. You can have her for a dollar. A deal wants a price, and so does a paper, and I’ll make one bill do for both.’ And I said, why. And he said—” The old man stops. He looks, for a long moment, at the wooded hill beyond me, at the ridge where the pad sits in its gray square.
“He said, ‘You didn’t get to go in. I’m sorry. It’s the best I can do. I’ll sign your paper. I’ll witness it. But I’m going to wall it up, friend, and I’m going to wait for somebody to ask.’”
“Marigold,” says Pearl.
She’s standing behind me. I hadn’t heard her get up. She’s got her cup of tea in one hand and she’s holding it, steady, like a candle.
“The doe was called Marigold. She’s got a white blaze. She was Walt’s pet.” Pearl’s voice is quite level. “I never knew where she went.”
“She lived at my house in Montreal for sixteen years,” says the old man gently. “In a garden. She had a daughter. I’ve had a Bell goat in my life ever since. Mrs. Bell, I’ve been wanting to tell you that for a very long time.”
My grandmother looks at him. She nods, once, as if a clerk had given her the correct change.
“He sold her to you for a dollar,” she says. “Because you asked nicely.”
“I’d like to think so.”
“It’s what he’d do.”
“Ma’am?”
“It’s the only way he knew to say sorry.” She sips her tea. “I’m very glad it went to a garden.”
---
Three-eighteen.
I have a watch. I hold it up, as if I could hold the time down by its collar. The line has begun to murmur. There’s a stir at the far end, by the wheelbarrow, and Marguerite has stood up, and is looking at the old man with an expression I can’t read at all, like someone who’s recognized a dream.
“I know you,” she says.
“Hello, Marguerite,” says the old man. “You were reading Jane Eyre.”
“You gave me a silver dollar.”
“I did. It was a very poor present. I had nothing better in my pocket.” He bows, very slightly, from the waist. “You told me you didn’t like Mr. Rochester. I thought it showed excellent judgment. I’ve never forgiven myself for what I said to you, at the door.”
“Everything on this hill is spoken for,” says Marguerite.
“Yes. I was twenty-six. I thought it was a clever remark. It was the cruelest thing I’ve ever said to a child.” He looks at her over the flag. “I wasn’t speaking of the hill. I was speaking of myself. I’m sorry.”
“I kept the dollar.”
“I thought you might.”
I should be moved. I am. But my watch says three-nineteen, and the world’s gone thin and bright, and the part of me that’s still a farmer thinks, with a clarity I can’t dismiss, that a man can say sorry for a very long time, in a very good coat, while a pump runs.
“Sir,” I say.
“Mr. Pierce said you were practical.”
“You hold the majority of the vehicle.”
“Yes.”
“Then I’d like to ask you something. And I’d like you to answer it as I’d answer. Plainly.” I take a breath. “Will you tell your man to stop?”
He doesn’t answer at once.
“Josie,” says Anders, under his breath.
“No. Let him say it.” I keep my eyes on the old man’s. “You’ve been very kind. You’ve told me a sad story, and I believe every word. But there’s a pump on that hill, and the Kettle’s been dropping since Sunday, and thirty-one households have no water, and a man in a gray car is about to switch it on again. I don’t need you to be sorry. I need you to say a sentence.”
“Of course,” he says.
“What sentence?”
“I’d like to be asked in,” says the old man, simply.
The line goes silent.
“It’s not a bargain. I’d like it understood that it isn’t. If you say, no, then I’ll stop the pump anyway, because it’s right, and because I haven’t the stomach to be the man who dried a village for the sake of a bath. But I’ve waited forty-eight years, Miss Bell, in the cold, on a step. I’d like, once, before I’m too old to climb it, to be asked. By somebody who lives there. In their own voice.”
I look at him. I look at the long, lined, patient face. He’s the first person all week who’s offered me a clean yes.
I think of the ring. COME COLD. GO WARM. NO ONE PAYS.
“Respectfully,” I say.
His face doesn’t change.
“No.”
There’s a gasp. I hear it ripple down the whole line. It’s Connie, I think, who makes the first small sound, and Pearl, I know, is looking at me, and I don’t turn.
“Not while the taps are dry,” I say. “I’d like to be a person who says it when it’s true. I can’t say come in, to a man whose pump’s running. It’d be a lie. It’d be a price. I won’t ask you in until there’s water in every kitchen on Cooper Lane, and the Kettle’s come up, and you’ve signed whatever it takes. And then I’ll ask. I’ll ask you myself. And I’ll mean it.”
A long silence.
“That’s what Walter said,” murmurs the old man. “Almost the same. ‘Not till it’s right.’” His eyes are bright. “Thank you. I’ll take it. I’d like to say that I accept.”
“You can accept,” says Anders, “by calling Mr. Pierce.”
“At once.” He raises a hand, and the driver in the gray cap, who has been standing like a statue at the car’s flank, produces a small black telephone, and puts it in the old man’s palm. He dials without looking. He lifts it to his ear.
It’s three-nineteen-forty.
I hear it ring. It rings in the old man’s ear, thin as a gnat. It rings again. Again. I can see, over his shoulder, up the road, the small gray figure of Calloway Vail, still at the chain, with his hand on the goat, and the big man in the hi-vis vest standing a yard away with the cutters held loose at his side, looking at his watch.
“Pierce,” says the old man at last. “It’s me. Stop the injection. I’ve revoked the—”
He stops.
His eyebrows go up. He takes the phone from his ear and looks at it.
“He’s rung off,” he says.
“Josie,” says Anders.
I turn. He’s looking at the pad.
I hear it before I see it. It’s a thick, gathering, cough-and-catch roar, like a big old engine dragging itself out of a ditch, coming down the hill on the dry air and across a quarter mile of tar. The generator. It catches, once, twice, and settles to a steady, hungry, rising drone that goes into my teeth. Beyond the chain-link, behind the hi-vis man’s shoulder, a green light comes on, small as a button, on the side of the skid.
“That’s three-twenty,” says Connie. Her voice is very thin. “By the church. That’s—”
“It’s a laptop,” says Anders. He’s already got his phone out. “It’s running from Burlington. It’s on the countersignature. It’s—”
“It’s not mine,” says the old man.
He’s said it very quietly, but in the silence, it carries.
He’s gone gray. He holds the telephone loose in his hand and the other hand, the one with the cane, has gone white at the knuckle on the silver knob, and he’s staring up the road with an expression I’ve only seen once, on my own face, in the cave on the morning I read my father’s letter.
“I revoked my proxy at noon,” he says. “I put it in a letter, by courier, to Mr. Pierce’s office. It was a clean, complete, unconditional revocation. I’d like you all to know that. It said that the units were not to be voted, on any matter, by any person, in my name, from noon on Tuesday.”
“Then who’s voting them?” says Marguerite.
“Somebody who’s read my letter,” says the old man, “and has decided it isn’t to be honored.”
“Nolan?”
“Mr. Pierce,” he says, “has never in his life made a decision he wasn’t handed. He’s a very polite man. He’s the kind of man who delivers a message.” He turns, slowly, to Calloway’s small figure at the pad. “My dear Mr. Vail. I’d like to ask you a question, from this distance, and you’ll forgive me for raising my voice. Who put Mr. Pierce in your office in May?”
Up on the hill, over the roar of the generator, and the rising whine of a pump, a thin, hoarse voice carries down the road, a long way, on the thin hot wind.
“Thad,” calls Calloway. He’s cupped both hands round his mouth. “Thad did. My lawyer. Thaddeus. He’s at the Inn, Margo, he’s been in my kitchen since Sunday, he said it was only—”
The rest is lost.
I’m not listening. I’ve turned to the flume, in my head, to the little ruler in the stone trough that I’ve been watching for three days like a pulse, and I can see it as plainly as if I stood over it, the green line of the water, the black line of the number, going down, past four, past three, into the place where nobody’s written.
It’s three twenty-one. I’m five hundred and one feet from the only thing that matters. I take out my pen, and my little book, and I write it down.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!