She comes down the stairs the way you come down to a kitchen after a fight you heard through the floor: one hand on the rail, the other holding a bag of salted almonds like a small, ridiculous shield.
She’s nineteen. She has her grandfather’s length, all knees and elbows and a neck that arrives before the rest of her, and a mass of dark hair pinned up with what I’m fairly sure is a pencil. She’s wearing a University of Vermont sweatshirt with the sleeves pushed up and a pair of rubber boots that have clearly seen a stream. There’s a field notebook in her back pocket. It’s the yellow waterproof kind that Ray bought in bulk, the kind I’d know in the dark.
“Pépé,” she says.
“Odile.” The old man’s cane hasn’t moved from the boards. “You are supposed to be in Burlington.”
“I know. I was going to tell you.” She stops on the last step. “I was going to tell you tonight. I came Sunday on the bus. I walked up from the road. I wanted to see it before you told me not to.”
“See what?”
“The hill. The one you never talk about. The one you said, once, at Christmas, when you’d had the second glass, that you’d waited a whole life to be asked into.” She swallows. “I thought, if it’s real, I’d like to stand in it. I didn’t know it was going to be this.”
“This?”
“A hole,” says Odile, miserably. “A drill rig. A town in lawn chairs. Mr. Quill said it was a study.”
Nobody says anything. In the corner, Priya has become fascinated by a window.
“A study,” says Pearl, gently.
“A water-quality study. For the Trust. He said that because I was the beneficiary I had to sign a consent to sample, every day, like a permit, so the university wouldn’t be liable. He said it was boring. He said it was a formality.”
She looks at Thad, and for the first time in the whole slow ruin of this afternoon I see someone look at that pleasant pink face and see the face and not the cardigan. “It came to my email. It said CONSENT TO TRIAL. I thought it meant a trial, like a sample. I’m a hydrology major, Pépé. I thought it was the nicest thing anyone had ever let me do.”
“Did you read it?”
“No.”
“Odile.”
“I know.” Her voice cracks. “I know what you’d say. You’d say I read nothing and sign everything. You’ve said it since I was nine.”
“I didn’t say it kindly.”
“No. You said it like it was a defect in the family.” She tries to laugh. “It is. It’s genetic. I got it from you.”
It’s the exact right thing to say to him, and the worst. I watch the old man’s face take it, in the slow way a stone takes a wave. He opens his mouth, and what comes out is a small, dry, appalled sound, like a man trying to speak underwater.
“I think,” I say, “that we should sit down.”
---
We sit. It’s a ridiculous arrangement, a dining table for eight with a chowder at one end and a catastrophe at the other, and Odile wedged between her grandfather and Pearl like a kid between two grandmothers at a funeral. Anders borrows a chair from the bar.
Mrs. Pike, the innkeeper, who has been eavesdropping from the kitchen door for forty minutes with a dish towel, comes out and puts down a pot of tea, six cups, and a plate of the pie that nobody’s asked about, and goes away without a word, which for her is a medical event.
“I’d like to see what you signed,” says Anders. “May I?”
Odile opens her laptop. Her hands are shaking, and I find, to my own surprise, that I’m angry for her, in a clean small way, the way you get angry at the person who left a gate open and then pretends to be surprised about the cows. She turns the screen to Anders. He reads it. I read it over his shoulder, because that’s our arrangement now, and I’m only a little ashamed of how much I like it.
It’s a form. It has a Trust number and a paragraph, and under the paragraph a button that says I CONSENT in a very friendly blue. At the top, where a name should be, it says only O.L.
“The portal logs a beneficiary by given names,” says Thad, when Anders looks up. “Odile Louise. It truncates the surname. It’s a very old system, and I’m told it was a point of pride to the programmer.”
Odile nods, so I put it away as a quirk and not a crime.
“This is the beneficiary consent,” says Anders. “Under Article Seven. It says the beneficiary approves the exercise of the Holder’s rights in the Memorandum for ‘trials, tests, and extraordinary uses.’ It’s—” He scrolls. “It’s per-day. Each one covers twenty-four hours. And it’s sent from the trustee’s portal. It’s got her email on it.”
“That’s right,” says Thad, with perfect courtesy. “An extra layer of protection. Mr. Marchand was particular about it. Odile’s consent is a condition of every extraordinary act of the Trust. It’s why I’ve never done one without her.”
“Julien Marchand,” I say.
It’s out before I can stop it. The old man looks at me, slowly. I see the muscles at the corner of his mouth shift.
“It’s the name on the certificate,” he says. “I’d have told you.”
“You were going to.”
“I was waiting to be asked in.” He tries a smile. It doesn’t hold. “I’d like very much now to be a person you can call Julien.”
“I’ll think about it,” I say, and he nods, as though I’d given him a good price.
“Ms. Marchand,” says Anders. He’s turned the laptop back. “Can you revoke it?”
“Revoke—”
“The consent. Today’s. The last one, the one that was received at three-nineteen. Is it in your power to withdraw it?”
She looks at him. She looks at me. And then, in a movement I’ll never forget, she looks, very quickly, at her grandfather, as if to ask permission, and sees that he’s staring at his own hands.
“Yes,” says Odile. “I think so. I’m the beneficiary. I mean, it’s mine. It’s—” She stops, and when she goes on her voice has dropped, the way a farm kid’s voice drops when she’s got to put the dog down. “I’d like to. I’d like to, please. How do I do it?”
---
Connie Duquette arrives in eleven minutes, which is a record and which she attributes entirely to Section Nine. She has her stamp in her handbag, her cheese-iron gavel in the other hand, and a look on her face that I associate with the nineteen-eighties and a man who tried to park in front of the clerk’s.
She notarizes the letter on the dining table at 4:06 by my watch. The Inn’s own clock is shaped like a rooster and wrong by about twenty minutes, in a way that is, by now, a local virtue. Odile writes it in her own hand, in the notebook, in the neat square letters of a girl who has been told that she’s allowed to be careful. It’s six lines long.
I, Odile Marchand, beneficiary of the Twelve Trust, hereby withdraw all consent, past and present and future, to any trial, test or extraordinary use of the rights under the Memorandum of Option on Lot 14 and part of Lot 15, Larkin Notch. I was not told what I was signing.
She signs. Connie stamps it. The little steel jaws come down with a sound like a very small door, and Odile jumps.
“Done,” says Connie. “That’s a legal withdrawal.”
“Then it’s off,” says Pearl. “The pump.”
“Not quite,” says Thad.
Everybody turns. He’s finished his chowder. He’s folded his napkin into a rectangle, and he’s looking at the notarized letter with real, spacious admiration, the way you’d look at a competitor’s well-made chair.
“It’s a lovely letter. I’m moved. I’d like to say it’s a cleaner revocation than her grandfather’s. But I’m afraid that Article Seven is a bit particular, Mrs. Duquette, in a way that Mr. Marchand insisted upon. A beneficiary may withdraw consent at any time. It takes effect twenty-four hours after written notice to the Trustee.”
He lays one pink hand on the page. “I’m the Trustee. I’ve been noticed. It’s—” He consults a gold watch the size of a biscuit. “It’s six minutes past four, by my watch, and I’m told your church clock is wrong, so I’ll round. Tomorrow at a quarter past four. The test will run its course.”
“You told Julien that the pump runs until Trial Three ends tomorrow at three-twenty,” says Anders.
“It does, Mr. Lund. It’s a lovely, tidy trial. But the next trial opens on the consent I hold at the time, which is hers, and her withdrawal doesn’t bite until the twenty-four hours are out. So three-twenty, and then the tidy little tail of it.” He looks, kindly, at Odile. “My dear. You mustn’t think I did it on purpose. Mr. Marchand wrote the clause.”
“I did,” says the old man.
He’s said it almost to himself. He’s looking at the tablecloth.
“It was meant to stop her being rushed. It was a safety. I didn’t want her pushed into signing, in a hurry, by a man in a nice suit.” He gives a short, unlovely laugh. “It’s the first time in my life I’ve been protected from myself by a clause.”
“You’re not to blame yourself, Pépé.”
“Of course I am. It’s what I do.” He lifts his eyes to hers. They’re wet, and he doesn’t hide it. “I’m a man who has made a great many documents to keep people from being rushed, and I’ve never once looked at who was in the room.”
He rises. It’s a slow, courteous, terrible process, with the cane doing most of it. He stands a moment with his hand on the back of the chair, looking at his granddaughter, and she says, in a voice that’s trying so hard to be brave that it makes my chest hurt, “Pépé, I’m sorry, I didn’t—”
“You should have asked me,” says Julien Marchand.
It’s not a cruel thing. It’s only the truest thing in his mouth. But I watch it land.
“You never ask anyone,” says Odile. “That’s why I didn’t.”
The silence that follows has a floor and a ceiling and nothing in between. The old man looks at her for a long moment.
Then he inclines his head to the table, to Pearl, to me, to Anders, with the same grave little bow he gave Marguerite at the flag, and he walks out of the dining room, across the porch, down the steps, and into the back of the black sedan, where the driver in the gray cap shuts the door on him as gently as you’d shut a book.
He doesn’t look back. I see Odile see it. She hasn’t cried, I notice. She’s sitting very straight, in the chair that was too big for her, with her notarized six lines in front of her, and her jaw set in a line I’ve only ever seen in an old photograph of my father.
“That’s the price, I suppose,” she says. “He’ll be like that for a year.”
“He’ll come round,” says Pearl.
“You don’t know him.”
“I don’t. I know a man who has just been taught to ask for the first time in his life, and I know he’ll hate it.” Pearl pours her a cup of tea and puts four sugars in it, without asking. “Drink that. You’ve done a great thing. Eat the pie. It’s very good.”
---
At 4:30 I should be in the milk room. It’s the third evening since the taps went dry, and Lorraine has already texted me, in her careful capitals, THE GIRLS ARE FINE, I AM BEING A PERSON ABOUT IT, so I know that she’s already got Dewey on the buckets and Calloway holding the goat. But I can’t leave. There’s one thing left.
It’s Odile who gives it to me, in the end, without knowing she has.
She’s closed her laptop. She’s put her almonds away. She’s opened her backpack and got out a green accordion folder with a label in her grandfather’s hand, TRUST 12, DO NOT LOSE, which I’d guess she’s been told for ten years to take care of and has therefore never opened.
“I brought all of it,” she says. “I thought if I was going to see the hill I should know what I owned. I mean what it owned. I read a bit on the bus.” She flips pages, and her voice has that rattly, apologetic pitch of a person who’s been given something to hold.
“It’s mostly boring. It’s mostly the trust. There’s a copy of the Memorandum. I brought it because it was in the back. Is it the same as the one in your town office, Miss Bell? I heard somebody on the porch say yours was short.”
“I said it to Connie,” says Anders. “You were eavesdropping.”
“Professionally.” She turns a page. “How short?”
The pie stops halfway to Pearl’s mouth.
“Two pages,” I say.
“Two pages and Schedule A, the map. That’s all I saw, in the vault, at three in the morning.” Anders has gone very still. “Connie?”
“It was two pages.” Connie sits forward. “Opal’s folder had two. I stamped the cover.”
“Mine’s five,” says Odile. “It says Schedule B on the fourth page. It says it’s ‘filed under separate cover, to be held by the Grantor.’ I thought it was a joke. It’s got a title. It says ADMISSION.”
She puts it on the table. It’s a photocopy of a photocopy, with an old, soft, brown edge, and Edmund Vail’s signature at the bottom in the green ink I’ve seen only once before, on the jar letter, in the Bath. And at the head of the page, in the dry capitals of a man who’d learned his law from a book:
SCHEDULE B. LAPSE OF OPTION UPON ADMISSION.
I read it three times. I read it aloud, once, and my voice does something strange at the end, and Anders takes my hand under the table without anyone seeing and holds it as if I’d been about to drop.
“This Option,” I read, “shall lapse and be of no further force upon the Holder being admitted to the premises described in Schedule A, at the threshold thereof, at the invitation of an owner of record of Lot 14 or Lot 15, in the presence of the Town Clerk, who shall record the same. No consideration shall be paid. The Holder shall not be required to accept.”
“He wrote it himself,” says Pearl, very softly. “Edmund. He put an exit in.”
“He put the ask in,” I say. “He put in the one thing the Subscriber wanted. If somebody who owns the ground says come in, in front of the clerk, the whole thing’s gone. Every right. The pump, the injection. All of it. It ends.”
“On a Wednesday morning,” says Anders, “if the right person says it.”
“Which is me.” I can hear my own voice, thin and bright, like a wire. “Lot 15. Bell. I’m an owner of record. Pearl signed it over in the spring. It’s me.”
“Then it’s you,” says Pearl, “and it’s the one thing you said no to.”
I look at the window, where the black sedan is still at the curb, and the old man’s shape in the back of it is a very small, very straight silhouette. I think of the third step. I think of a man in a camel coat saying, may I come in, and a boy in a pool who didn’t answer.
I think of myself on the flag in the heat saying, not while the taps are dry, with all the pride of a woman who has never in her life had to choose between her principles and a pump.
“I told him no,” I say. “An hour ago. In front of the whole town. I said it was the first time in my life I’d be a person who said it when it was true.”
“Yes,” says Thad Quill, pleasantly, from the end of the table.
I’d forgotten him. He’s put on his glasses. He’s sitting with his hands folded over the rooster-clock’s idea of the afternoon and a small, fond, terrible smile, and I understand, with the slow cold of a person who’s put her hand on a gate and found it electric, that he has known about Schedule B since 2009.
“Yes,” he says again. “I did wonder, Miss Bell, when you’d get to it. It’s why I was so very glad you said no.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!