It takes eleven people forty minutes to move four hundred wheels of cheese, and nobody drops one.
We do it in a chain, from the cave to the make room to the milk-house cooler, wheel to hand to hand to hand.
Dewey calling the count off a clipboard from a lawn chair because his knee has been placed under a sort of house arrest. Connie supervises. Mr. Odell has brought a hand truck.
Anders takes a place in the middle of the chain, between Odell and Moses, in a borrowed pair of work gloves, and passes forty-one wheels without dropping one or once looking at his phone. I notice, because I’m not looking at him either, and we’re both so careful about it that Moses says, “Oh, for heaven’s sake,” and swaps places with me. Bernard, who regards a moved cheese as a personal slight, follows the line the whole way, saying so.
By eight-fifty on Thursday morning the barn floor is bare, swept, and set with two hundred folding chairs in the rows we use for the Neighbor Review. Opal Strand has stamped a card that says COURT in her tidy printing and propped it on the wheel racks. At the far end, on a pallet of cheese-press weights with a horse blanket thrown over it, sits a bench, and behind it a chair, and behind that a wall hung with every goat ribbon my family has ever won.
The Honorable Imogen Pratt arrives at 8:58 in a muddy hatchback with a hay bale roped to the roof.
“I stopped for it,” she says, climbing out in her robe and a pair of rubber boots. “A farm stand, on the pike. I’m told the hay’s for a sculpture. Is this the cheese barn?” She’s about sixty-five, short, with a white braid down her back and the face of a woman who has been lied to by experts for thirty years and found it interesting.
“Understand that I have never held a hearing in a barn, and I intend to enjoy it. Who is the goat?”
“Bernard,” I say.
“Is he a party?”
“He’s in four suits.”
“Then he may stay,” says Judge Pratt, “and he may not speak.”
---
The hearing is simple, and it takes nearly four hours, which I suppose is the way of simple things.
Thad rises first, in a fresh cardigan and no hat. He says what he said in the Bath, in better order, and with the dry gentle patience of a man giving evidence against himself. The Covenant is a real instrument. The lid is breached. His family holds, under paragraph four, thirty days of exclusive right to enter, repair, and be paid.
He asks the court to order that the lock under the lowest stair be opened in his presence, that he be permitted to witness the breach, and that his right be recognized.
“What’s the right worth?” says Judge Pratt.
“Your Honor?”
“If I recognize it. What’s the number. You’ve a covenant that says ’recover the cost of such repair from the waters of the chamber.’ Tell me what a gallon of the chamber is worth, to the Quill family.”
“I’d say,” says Thad slowly, “it’s the difference between a very comfortable retirement and the thing my father hoped I’d never do.”
There’s a small stir behind me. Pearl, beside me in her good navy dress with her goat-ear hat in her lap, says very clearly, “That’s an honest answer, and I don’t like it.”
Our side goes second. We don’t have a lawyer. We have Marguerite Vail Ames, who has driven up at dawn in a white coat and has decided, to everyone’s shock, to speak for the town; we have Connie, with a binder; and we have Odile Marchand, nineteen, in a borrowed blazer two sizes too big, who rises when called and says, to the judge’s evident delight, “I’d like to talk about the email.”
“Which email?”
She’s got a laptop. Cutler Voss has given it to her, with a sheepishness the size of a barn. She puts a screen on the wall, over the goat ribbons.
It’s the message Voss read us on Wednesday morning. DO NOT CAP UNTIL PHASE TWO IS CONCLUDED. It’s from an address at Quill and Quill. It was sent on Tuesday night, and the little gray time stamp in the corner, which nobody had thought to read, says 11:52 p.m.
“Mrs. Ames’s notarized withdrawal was at 10:15 on Monday night,” says Odile. “It cancelled Phase Two. Mr. Quill knew; he’d been told. The Tuesday night email was after the pump was running on a Burlington laptop, after my own withdrawal, after the whole town had stood in a line of lawn chairs. And the covenant, paragraph six, says that no salvage right accrues to any party who caused or procured the breach.”
The barn is very quiet.
“I’ll be careful,” says Judge Pratt. “Mr. Quill, is that your signature block?”
Thad has gone a delicate pink to the top of his scalp. He stands. He looks at the screen for a long time.
“It is, Your Honor.”
“Did you send it?”
“I did.”
“Why?”
“Because,” says Thad, “I’d been advised that an uncapped casing would give the District a gauge on the level of the Quiet, and I wanted the level known.” He swallows. “I’d also wanted the lid, forgive me, to be seen. I didn’t think it would fall. I thought the casing would only drain a little, and somebody would have to look. For forty-nine years nobody has let me look. I was a coward, Your Honor. I’ll say it.
I used the paperwork to do a thing I wasn’t brave enough to do in person.”
“Which was?”
“Ask.”
It’s the strangest sound I’ve heard in that barn: two hundred people being politely stunned at once. I find that my own jaw’s gone slack. Behind me someone, I think Moses, says “Well, hell,” very softly.
---
I’d give Julien’s part in full, but it was too short and too good.
He’s called by the judge, who’s had a note from Opal. He comes up the aisle on Odile’s arm with his silver cane back in his hand, and sits in the chair they’ve set, and puts both hands on the knob. Somebody’s lent him a tie. It’s the plain wool tie of Dewey Marchand, and I realize with a start that the two men have the same long jaw. They’re cousins, third or fourth, and until this week neither had the least idea.
“State your name,” says the clerk.
“Julien Marchand. I’ve been Subscriber Twelve, but it’s a clumsy title.” He looks around the barn at two hundred faces. “I’ve something to say, Your Honor, and I’d like to say it before the lawyers get me.”
“Go on.”
“There’s a firm, Notch North Partners. It has two owners. Forty-nine percent is held by the Harbor Ridge Trust, which is Mrs. Ames and her brother. The other fifty-one is held, of record, by a Mr. Nolan Pierce, who is a young man with a good suit.” He lifts his chin. “He’s a nominee. He holds it for me.”
You’d have thought the roof had come off the barn too.
“I’m the gentleman,” says Julien Marchand, “who does not lose his parcels. I bought a piece of the project in the spring, when I read that Mr. Pierce was making an offer on Bell Hollow Farm, and I’d a notion that if I owned the offer I could, at last, stop it, or be asked. I’m told that was not a clever plan. I’m seventy-four.” He’s looking at no one.
“I wish to give my fifty-one percent to the Larkin Notch Water District. I understand it’s three people and a goat. The price is one dollar, which I’ve brought.”
He takes it from his waistcoat pocket. It’s a silver Morgan dollar, dull with a lifetime in a drawer. It isn’t the one Marguerite gave back. It’s the other one, I think. It’s Walt’s.
“Let that be recorded as a gift,” he says, “and not as a bargain. I’ve been informed that’s a distinction. I should like to be a man who learned it.”
Pearl takes a long breath beside me. Her hand finds mine in the folds of her dress.
“It’s a gift,” she says quietly. “He’s right. It’s different.”
“Is that so?” says Judge Pratt, who has put down her pen.
“A bargain’s a thing you walk away from,” says my grandmother, to the judge, in a voice that carries without being raised. “A gift’s a thing that walks after you. Walter gave a goat to a stranger and thought about it for forty-eight years. He’s not a man who’d have sold her. I’m told he’d have wanted it said.”
I’ve never loved her more. I look at the Bell Hollow ribbons on the wall behind the judge, nineteen of them, purple, gold and a single disgraceful brown, and I think that it’s going to be very difficult ever to be as brave as a small old woman in a goat-ear hat in front of a court.
---
There’s a stir at the back, and a chair goes over. A young man in a very good suit has come in through the wide doors at the end of the aisle with a phone in his fist, and I know the walk before I can place the face. It’s the walk of a person who has never once been told to wait outside.
“Your Honor.” Nolan Pierce, red to the ears, comes down the aisle at a pace that is not quite a run. “Nolan Pierce, managing partner of Notch North. I must object. Mr. Marchand has no standing to dispose of an interest that is held of record in my name. I hold it in my own right. This is a hearing about a covenant, not a corporate gift.”
“Mr. Pierce,” says Judge Pratt, with enormous mildness. “Is it your testimony that you hold fifty-one percent for yourself?”
He opens his mouth. In the second row Connie has quietly turned a page in her binder, and I see Mr. Odell lean forward on his folding chair, who has been waiting thirty years for a man to say a thing like that on the record.
“Nolan,” says Julien, from the witness chair, not loudly.
“Mr. Marchand, with respect—”
“You hold it for me. I asked you to, in March. I’m asking you now, as one asks a young man a favor, to sign the paper my granddaughter has typed. If you’d like to tell the court it’s yours, I shan’t stop you. I’d only like to mention that I’ve the e-mails.”
It’s the first thing the old man has ever said in my hearing that’s been, with great gentleness, a threat. Pierce looks at him. Then he looks at the bench, and the goat ribbons, and Bernard, who has chosen this exact moment to lie down in the aisle with a long sigh.
“I’ll sign,” says Nolan Pierce, hoarsely, to the floor.
“Thank you,” says Julien. “You’ll find it’s a great relief.”
The judge rules at twelve forty, after a recess in which she is observed eating a wedge of Maple Rind in the make room, with her robe tucked into her belt, and asking Pearl for the recipe.
“I’m not going to decide the Covenant today,” she says. “It’s an old paper and it’s a difficult one, and the only party with a clean claim to the chamber is, I gather, the water. I’m going to hold Mr. Quill’s right in abeyance. If it’s valid, it will survive a day. If it isn’t, it won’t. In the meantime.” She taps the bench. “There’s a lock, and it’s under a stair. Mrs. Ames, I believe the District holds the key.”
“The town does, Your Honor,” says Connie. “The District holds it in trust. Section Seven.”
“Then the lock will be opened tomorrow, at ten, in the presence of the Town Clerk, a commissioner of the District, a person of the Quill family, a person of the Vail family, and a person of the Bell family. And a hydrologist.” She looks at Odile over her glasses. “That’s you.”
“Your Honor, I’m nineteen.”
“It’s a good age to count things,” says the Honorable Imogen Pratt. “Mr. Quill. No one’s going into that chamber to take a drop of water or a dollar. You may look. You may measure. You may weep, if it’s in you.” She raises the gavel, which is a cheese iron. “And I’ll say that in thirty years I’ve never been asked a thing so politely by a man who’d have been better off taking it. Adjourned.”
The cheer is mostly relief. It lasts a long time. I’m standing in it, wrung out, wanting to lie down in the straw, when my phone buzzes in my pocket and I find, as if the day hadn’t done enough, a text from a number I don’t know.
It’s four lines long.
*Dear Ms. Bell. I’m Greer Aldana, trustee of the Lund Asset accounts. I’ve been asked by Mr. Lund not to contact you. I’m contacting you. At 5:00 p.m. tomorrow the accounts freeze unless he signs a one-page release relinquishing all present and future interest in Larkin Notch. It would be the end of everything he owns that isn’t a coat. He’s been told twice. He’s refused twice. I thought a person ought to know.*
I read it standing in the straw of my own cheese barn while two hundred neighbors shake each other’s hands.
---
I find him in the parlor. It’s empty, with the green armchair and the hole in the plaster where a goat once put a hoof, and he’s sitting in it with his elbows on his knees and his notebook open, not writing. He doesn’t hear me. He’s looking at the floor.
“You told me it was handled.”
He starts. He closes the notebook. For the second time in two days I watch him decide to be honest, and it looks like pulling a splinter.
“I’m sorry,” says Anders.
“I’ve a text from a stranger who says you’re about to be penniless.”
“That’s an exaggeration. I’d keep the coat.” He tries a smile and gives it up. “It’s a clause. When my mother’s brother died he left the money in a trust with a single condition, which was my idea. I was twenty-six. I didn’t want to turn into a man who bought what he wanted, so I wrote it in. If I ever acquired a stake in the one place I’d sworn to stay out of, they’d freeze it all until I signed it away.
I wrote it as a protection against *myself*, Josie. A rule so I’d keep my hands in my pockets.”
“The farm.”
“I didn’t know it was this farm. I wrote it about my mother’s stories, a goat, a cave she’d described to me in a hospital.” He lifts his hands. “The clause says if I take title to any share of a place in Larkin Notch, I’m done. A packer is a hundred feet of equipment sitting in a well and it has my name on the invoice. That’s a stake. It was my stake. It was a very good one.”
“So sign it,” I say. “It’s a page. Sign it and keep your money.”
“No.”
“Respectfully—”
“Don’t,” he says. It’s the first time he’s ever cut me off. “Please don’t. I’d like to be the person who says it, once. I’ve said it for you for months, and I’ve heard how it sounds. ’Respectfully, no.’ It’s a lovely sentence. It’s the sentence of a woman who’d rather lose her own farm than owe a man forty thousand dollars.”
I’m quite white. I can feel it.
“That isn’t fair.”
“It isn’t, and it’s true, and it’s what you’re about to do to me.” He stands. He’s so tall in that small parlor. “You’re about to tell me to sign, so that I’m safe, and you’re clean. And I’d like to say, as a man who’s been very rich, that I know what I’m for. It’s this. I’m for being one of the people who’s put something in. That’s all I’ve ever wanted. It’s why I came.”
“I don’t want to be the reason you lose it.”
“You’re not the reason.” He’s quiet. “You’re the place.”
I haven’t got an answer. My phone buzzes in my hand like a trapped bee, and I look at it because I can’t look at him, and it’s not Greer. It’s Odile, in capitals, from the Hatch hayfield, where she’s spent the night on the rig floor with her notebook and a headlamp, and means to spend the next.
*JOSIE. THE QUIET’S FALLING AGAIN. FOUR INCHES SINCE THE PACKER. IT’S NOT HOLDING. THE LID’S CRACKING FROM THE EDGE. I’D LIKE TO OPEN THE LOCK TONIGHT.*


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!