The thermometer inside the door reads sixty-one degrees. It should read fifty-two.
I know before I take another step, because the smell is wrong. The cave has always smelled like rain on stone. This morning it smells like wet cardboard and warm milk, the sour, sweating smell of work gone off. Someone has propped the door, thrown the main breaker, flipped the chiller, and pulled the plug on the humidifier, and then walked away and let a spring night do the rest.
Six hours. That’s all it takes.
I go down the aisle with the flashlight, touching rinds. The Ember has started to weep. The Maple Rind is sliding off itself like a shirt off a hanger. On the top rack, the Senator’s Reserve, every wheel with Bernard’s grave portrait on the label, has gone slick and sullen and cracked at the edges, and when I press a thumb into one, it gives.
Four hundred wheels. I count what I can save in my head, and it’s seventy, maybe, if I’m lucky and fast. The rest is just forty-one thousand dollars of expensive compost.
Forty-one thousand. The note is $38,412.
That was the plan. That was the whole plan: the spring wheels were going to market in April and cover the balloon with three thousand to spare, and no one knew that either, except whoever wrote that page six.
Anders stands behind me with his hands at his sides.
“Josie.”
“Don’t.”
“I’ll get the vents open. We can move the Ember to the make room cooler—”
“I said don’t.” I sit down on an upturned crate, because my knees have made the decision for me. I put my hand on a wheel of Reserve, my father’s recipe, and the rind comes off on my palm like wet paper. “He dug this with a rented excavator and a borrowed shovel. He didn’t sleep for a week.”
“I know.”
“You don’t.”
He does what he does best, which is nothing, for exactly the right length of time. Then we move. We carry Ember wheels to the make room until my arms feel like rope. We prop every vent, and drag the fans out of the barn, and for two hours the two of us work in silence, because it’s easier than the alternative.
At 7:15, reaching up to the top shelf to rescue a rack, I put my hand on something that isn’t cheese.
It’s a camera, no larger than a deck of cards, black, clipped to the rack frame and tilted down at the door. It’s been there a while. There’s dust on the clip.
“What is this?”
Anders has gone entirely still, and that’s how I know.
“It’s a camera,” he says. “I put it up Tuesday night. Day twenty-three.”
“Day twenty-three.” I turn it over in my hand. “The day Nolan came. What had Delphine told you?”
“Josie—”
“No surprises. We shook on it. One hour, you said. That same hour.”
“Delphine found a shell company on Monday,” he says. The words come quickly, like he’s been practicing them in the dark. “Birchwater Land Partners. It bought four parcels around yours for ordinary money and sold options on them to Lund Fieldworks at triple. The man who profits is Nolan. I couldn’t prove it. And I didn’t know who in town was his hands.”
“You knew it was your company.”
“I knew who ordered it.”
“You knew my cave was on the list. You read the page. Anchor.” My voice has gone high and flat, like Bernard’s scream. “And you put a camera in my father’s cave instead of a lock on his door.”
“A lock keeps them out. I wanted to know who.”
“You wanted a movie!”
“I wanted a name.” He takes one breath. “I couldn’t be here every night. And if I’d told you, you’d have gone after Nolan with a pitchfork.”
“Damn right.”
“And then they’d have known we knew, and we’d never have caught the person who’s actually walking through your gates.”
I laugh. It’s an ugly noise. “You let them walk in.”
“I was going to tell you after the supper. I was going to—” He stops, and I watch him reach the real answer and hate it. “After last night I couldn’t. I knew what it would do to your face.”
“Don’t you use last night.”
“I’m not.”
“You are. You’re standing in my father’s cave using last night to explain why you lied.” The camera is shaking in my hand. “I told you about the cave. I told you about the eleven seconds. I told you things I’ve told no one in eight years, and the one thing you could do for me was tell me what you knew, and you decided I couldn’t take it.”
“Josie, can I ask—”
“No.”
He swallows. Then he reaches over, very gently, and takes the camera from my hand, and slides the card out with his thumbnail, and sets it on the shelf between us.
“I haven’t watched it,” he says. “I wanted to watch it with you. It’s yours, whatever it shows.” He steps back. “I have to go to Boston. Delphine says Nolan has called an emergency board meeting for nine tomorrow morning to replace me and close the deal without me. If I’m not in that room, I lose the one chance I have of getting Birchwater’s paperwork in front of someone who can’t be bought.”
“Then go.”
“Section seven, subsection d allows emergency leave with the chair’s permission, up to forty-eight hours. I’ll be back Tuesday.” He pauses. “If you’ll still allow it.”
“Go,” I say, and I don’t look at him, because if I look at him I’ll take it back.
Connie grants the leave at 8:30, in her good cardigan, with her stamp, on the porch, reading the section aloud in a voice that tells me she knows exactly what’s happened. Moses stands behind her with his ear off, which is mercy. Pearl says nothing.
The black SUV goes down the drive at 9:10. Senator Bernard follows it all the way to the road. Then he stands there at the end of the lane for a long time, a nine-year-old goat in a crocheted bow tie, staring at the place the car used to be.
I take back three goats. I’m not sure what number comes below one.
At noon, I find Pearl sitting on a crate in the cave in her good wool coat, holding a spoiled wheel in her lap like a baby.
“Your father never once told you he was proud of you either,” she says. “He told me. Every Sunday, between the pot roast and the pie.” She sets the wheel down. “Josephine, I have buried a husband and a son in that hill. I know what it is to lose a thing you’ve carried so long you can’t put it down. But that man is the first person in eight years to carry a can for you without asking for the milk.”
“He lied.”
“He did. Be furious. You’re entitled.” Her hand finds my knee. “And then go watch the card.”
I don’t, all afternoon. I scrub rinds until my knuckles crack, and run every fan we own, and keep well away from the kitchen table. At nine that night, I carry the card up to Pearl’s old laptop, set it on the kitchen table, and sit in the lamplight, where I’ve sat my whole life, to watch a man ruin my father’s cave.
There’s a note on a torn page beside the laptop in Anders’s square hand. SOUND ON. I’M SORRY. A.
The footage is green and grainy. 11:14 p.m. A figure comes through the door in a dark hood and gloves, a headlamp throwing a white hole in the picture where a face should be. It moves with the unhurried certainty of someone who has been in the cave before, who knows where the breaker is, and what it will cost. I was asleep thirty yards away, and happy.
The figure flips the main. It kicks the crate under the door. It reaches up and unplugs the humidifier, and as it works, the camera’s tiny microphone picks up a sound over the fans, soft and tuneless and absentminded, the way a man whistles when he thinks nobody can hear.
Four notes. The third is flat.
I stop the clip. I run it back. I run it again.
I know that tune. I’ve known it every Tuesday and Friday of my life. It’s the closing hymn, and the man who held my hand at my father’s funeral whistles it through his teeth when he’s thinking, flat on the third note, just like that.

