Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 15

Structure Test

Before you can organize a workplace, you have to draw it, and on Monday morning I draw Cutter Point on the back of a roll of butcher paper taped to the wall of the loft.

It is the oldest tool I own. You write every name you can find on a card, you pin the cards up in rows, and you run string between the ones who talk to each other. When you are done, the room looks like the inside of a spider’s head. And somewhere in the tangle, if you have done it right, there is one name with more string on it than the rest, and it almost never belongs to the person with the title.

“Fifty-eight households,” I say. “We know who lives in them. We don’t know who they listen to.”

“Pardee,” says Lou.

“Pardee is the chair. He’s the one who signs things. Ask yourself who you’d go to if your roof leaked and you didn’t want the whole island to know.”

Lou thinks. She has a gift for it, a flat practical bluntness I recognize from the best line leads. “The person who’s already seen the leak.”

“Right. That’s the whole job. I need the person who’s already seen it.”

Teo has been sorting the cards for twenty minutes, with the solemn rapid fingers of a boy who delivers lunch pails to every door on the island. He has a card for every household and the names of the old people who live alone, and he knows without being told who is related to whom by marriage and who by grievance. I have never had a better source in my life. I have also never felt worse about using one.

“You don’t have to do this, Teo.”

“It’s my island,” he says, without looking up. “Somebody should be allowed to know it.”

I grade the cards the way I always do, one to five. One is a leader, someone who will stand up first. Two is a supporter. Three is a quiet maybe, the largest group, the people who will do the right thing if enough other people do.

Four is a skeptic. Five is the boss’s friend. I never put a name on a card without a reason. By ten o’clock we have fifty-eight cards pinned to a wall, and I count them out loud, the way I count anything I am about to ask for.

“Eleven fives,” says Teo. “Twenty-six threes. Nine fours. Twelve twos.”

“And ones?”

He looks at the wall for a long time.

“I don’t know,” he says. “I think nobody’s ever had to be.”

We start with the oldest house on the street, and the one with the saddest curtains.

Mrs. Dunphy is eighty-two and the widow of a harbor pilot, and she runs the island’s one guest room out of a gray-shingled house with two stone cats on the steps. She meets us at the door in a cardigan with a handkerchief up the sleeve. She is expecting me. She has laid out three cups. In her front room, a single wooden chair has been set at the head of the dining table, with a folded napkin on its seat.

“That’s for Amos,” she says, seeing me look. “My great-grandfather. Number fourteen. I’ve set him a place at supper every night since my mother died. I don’t know that he comes. I don’t say his name, of course. I’m not a fool. I just set the place.”

“How long?”

“Sixty-one years.” She sits, with great care, as if the chair might object. “I was twenty-one the first time I heard them in the pipes. It was a Tuesday. I said to my husband, Bill, that I thought it was the heating, and Bill said no, dear, it’s the shift, and we didn’t discuss it again until he died.”

I take out my legal pad and do not write on it. Sometimes you don’t. “Mrs. Dunphy, what does the Co-operative pay you?”

“Eleven thousand, four hundred.” She says it as if it were the name of a disease. “Every December. In an envelope. I put it in the church box, the first year. They asked me not to, the second year. They said it might make the others feel poorly.” She looks down at the cats on the porch through the window. “I’ve never spent it on myself. I put it toward the pails.”

“Mrs. Dunphy. Who else feels the way you do?”

She is silent for so long that Lou, on the sofa beside me, shifts her feet.

“Everyone,” she says. “That’s the thing nobody will say. Everyone on this island feels the way I do, Ms. Brandt. We just feel it in separate houses.”

I write that down. It is the whole case, in one sentence, from a woman with a handkerchief up her sleeve, and I put a line under it and I put a one on her card. When we go out, she holds my hand a moment longer than is polite.

“Is he all right?” she says, at the door. “My Amos. If you see him. You needn’t tell him I asked.”

“I’ll tell him a Dunphy set him a place.”

“Oh, do,” says Mrs. Dunphy, very softly, and closes the door.

The next house does not hold a one.

It is a big white house at the end of the street with a lobster boat on a trailer in the yard, and Mr. Hale is out in the drive in a canvas coat with a wrench in his fist when we come up the path.

He is sixty, broad, red-faced, with the thick wrists of a man who has hauled traps for forty years and a jaw that goes forward when he is afraid. He does not put the wrench down. He looks at me, then at Lou, and then, with unmistakable love, at the pail that Teo is carrying for his own door.

“You’re the union,” he says.

“I’m Odie Brandt.”

“I know who you are. You’re the one who said the name.” He wipes the wrench against his leg. “I’ll tell you something, miss. I don’t hold with it, and I want you to hear it plain. I’ve got a boy at the college in Orono who’s got a leg that doesn’t work right.

Know who pays for it? The Co-operative. Three surgeries, a brace, a year of therapy. That’s the yard. I got a roof on this house that didn’t come out of a bank. I got a boat I never had to finance. My father had the same, and his father.”

“I understand.”

“You don’t understand a damned thing.” He is not shouting. That is what makes it hard. “You think we like it? I’ve put a pail on that shelf every night of my life. Number two hundred and forty. My great-uncle Ned.

I carried it to the gate when I was six and my father said, don’t look, Davey, and I looked, and he was standing right there with his hands out, wet through, and he looked at me like I was the first person he’d seen in a hundred years.” He lets the wrench drop to his side. “And I thanked God it wasn’t me.”

“Mr. Hale.”

“Don’t.” He turns his face away. “Don’t tell me it’s wrong. I know it’s wrong. I’ve known it since I was six. I’ve also got a boy in a brace.” He wipes his eyes with the back of his wrist, roughly, like a man wiping a windshield. “So you tell me. When you take it away. You take that away, who pays for the leg?”

It is the right question. It is the best question anyone has asked me on Cutter Point, and the only honest thing I can say in answer is the thing I always say at the end of a hard conversation with a good man.

“I don’t know yet. But if you let me work on it, I promise you it won’t be the dead.”

He looks at me for a very long moment. Then he nods, once, as if to a stranger on a dock, and goes back to the engine of his boat.

I put a four on his card. And then, because it is the truth, I cross it out and put a three.

“Who else?” I ask Teo, on the road.

“Dorothea Vance,” says Teo, at once. “Schoolteacher. She’s retired. She does the confirmation class.”

I stop walking. “She reads the bylaw to the twelve-year-olds.”

“Forty-one years.”

The Vance house is the smallest on the street, a one-story cottage with window boxes full of dead geraniums, and the old woman who opens the door is the first person in two days who looks at me as though I were exactly the thing she has been waiting for. She is seventy-four, upright, in a gray wool dress with a cameo at the neck, and her face has the dry, delicate crispness of someone who has spent her life being right at the front of a room.

“Come in,” she says. “Take your boots off. I’ve made tea, and you are going to want to take notes.”

Her parlor is a library. I have never seen so many books in so small a house, stacked in the corners and under the chairs, in the neat dense geological layers of a woman who does not throw things away. On a desk by the window, squared exactly to its edge, lies a large green ledger with a name on the cover in gold leaf: COOPERATIVE BYLAWS, 1912 TO PRESENT. Beside it is a pencil, sharpened, and a magnifying glass.

“I’ve been reading it since Thursday,” she says. “Since the Light came on. I thought it might be time.”

“You’re the only person on this island who’s read it all the way through.”

“Of course I am. I teach it.” She pours the tea and sits and folds her hands. “I have taught Bylaw Six to forty-one classes of twelve-year-olds, Ms. Brandt. Every June.

I have stood at the front of that church, and I have watched a child who has just been told that his great-grandmother is three hundred feet from his bedroom and that he must never say her name, and I have watched him learn to look at the floor. I counted. They all learn it in about a minute and a half.” She smiles very slightly. “It is the most efficient lesson I have ever taught.”

“You’ve thought about stopping.”

“I have thought about it every June for forty-one years.” She does not look away. “I’m an old woman and a coward, and I would like to be of some use before I’m neither. So. Do you want to know how to amend a bylaw?”

I put the legal pad on my knee and I lean forward until I am nearly in her lap.

“Article eleven,” says Dorothea Vance, and opens the ledger. “The bylaws of the Co-operative may be amended at any special meeting by a vote of two-thirds of member households, notice to be posted seven days in advance. There are fifty-eight households. Two-thirds is thirty-eight and two-thirds. Thirty-nine votes. You see why I say it takes courage and not merely arithmetic.” She taps the page with the end of her pencil. “No one has ever called one.”

“Why not?”

“Because it has to be signed by five households in good standing, and the five signers’ names are posted on the Co-operative door for seven days.” She meets my eyes. “And on this island, Ms. Brandt, a name posted on that door is a name that everyone will read at breakfast.”

I count it in my head. Five households. Seven days. Thirty-nine votes.

“I have a one,” I say. “Mrs. Dunphy.”

“Sophie Dunphy would sign anything you put in front of her. She’d sign it in her own blood.” Miss Vance’s mouth twitches. “She’d also faint. She’s eighty-two. Choose carefully.”

“And you?”

“I will sign last,” says Dorothea Vance, “so that no one has to be braver than I am.”

It is the best thing anyone has said to me all week. I write it down. I put it under the box, under the line, under the question I wrote on the paper at dawn on Sunday. I have a one. I have a two. I have a number, thirty-nine, and a calendar, and an old woman who has been waiting forty-one years for someone to ask her for a pencil.

It is not an answer to who pays us. But for the first time since the gate, it feels like a place to stand.

By dusk the wall is full.

I stand in the loft with a pen and the last of the daylight and look at what I have built: fifty-eight cards, eleven fives, eight fours, twenty-seven threes, eight twos. Four ones, in the end. Dunphy. Vance. The Brannock household, which is a harbormaster who has not said yes and a boy who has. And, as of three o’clock, the island’s school bus driver, who had come up behind me in the road with her hand over her mouth and whispered, “Please. Whatever it is. Count me.”

It is a count. It is not a majority. I have a long way to go to thirty-nine.

Lou comes in from the street with a paper bag from the diner. She puts it on the table and sits on the crate, and for a while neither of us says anything. Below the window, the shelf stands empty and waiting. It is 4:09 on a Monday afternoon in December. The bell will ring in five minutes.

“I keep thinking about Mr. Hale,” says Lou.

“So do I.”

“He’s right, isn’t he? About the leg.”

“He’s right that the island needs the money. He’s wrong that it needs it from them.” I rub my eyes. “That’s the whole job. Find a thing the island can have that’s not a hundred and fifteen years of other people’s labor. I’ve got a list of eleven things. I don’t like any of them.”

“What’s the first?”

“Pay them.”

“Pay them what?”

“That’s the second,” I say, and then my phone buzzes on the table beside the bag, and I look at it.

PRIYA: did you eat. she has typed it in the lowercase of a woman on a break.

I type back: Chowder. Lou made me. A second later I add, Ten days. A third later, because I am a coward: How’s the name coming?

The dots come and go and come again. PRIYA: still thinking. she hums something at the sink in my head. I think it was Marian. Marian doesn’t fit. I think I’m going to know it when I hear it. A pause. PRIYA: ten days. noon. shoes off.

I put the phone face down and sit there with my hand over it. It is not a decision I notice making. But I am a woman who has just pinned fifty-eight cards to a wall in someone else’s town, and has also promised a kitchen in Worcester at noon, and I understand with a kind of quiet horror that I am going to have to break one of them.

Nell finds me on the stairs, at nine, with the butcher paper rolled under my arm.

She has a thermos and two mugs and the look of a woman who has decided to do something and has been trying all day to talk herself out of it. Her cap is off. Her braid has come loose at the end. In the lamplight I see, for the first time, how tired she is, and that it did not begin on Thursday.

“Do you have a minute?” says Nell Brannock.

“I’ve got an hour. I’ve got ten days.”

“I want to show you something in the tide table.”

We sit on the top step with the thermos between us. The stairwell is narrow, and the paint is peeling in long strips, and below us, the harbor office is dark. She takes out the clipboard she gave me on the causeway, the same one, with its penciled columns and its ruled lines, and she turns it over, and unclips the last page from the back.

“It’s not about the tides,” she says.

It is a calendar. A month, ruled by hand, one box for each night of it, starting with the fourteenth of November. In each box there is a time, in pencil, and a small neat tally mark. 3:12. 3:12. 3:12. A column of them, thirty-one deep, and in the margin beside the first, in the tiny hand I have admired for three days, one note.

Lights??

“That’s what I wrote the first night,” says Nell. “I didn’t know what else to call it. It wasn’t the Light. The Light was dark, I’d have seen. But at 3:12, every night since the fourteenth of November, there’s been a horn. Twice. It isn’t from the headland. It’s from under the harbor. And then there’s a voice at my door.”

The stairwell seems to get very narrow.

“What does it say?”

“A man. Polite. The kind of voice you’d hope would sell you a boat.” She does not look at me. She looks at her hands on the thermos. “It says, ‘Brannock, Eleanor. Three hundred and six.’”

I do not move. It is a thing I have learned, on the worst nights, to do with my whole body: not to move, not to count, not to make any sound that might be taken for an answer.

“I haven’t said it,” she says. “Not once. Thirty-one nights. I put the radio on. I wrote it down. I’d stand there in the kitchen and say to myself, don’t. Don’t answer. You’ve read the notice. You know what it is.” Her voice has gone very quiet. “I wrote Lights, with two question marks, because I didn’t have a word.”

“How did you know not to answer?”

“I didn’t. My grandmother raised me not to open the door at night to a voice that knows my name. It’s the only part of my education I ever took seriously.” A faint rueful shadow of a smile. “I wrote that down too.”

“Nell.” I put my hand over the clipboard. “Why didn’t you tell me when I got here?”

“Because I wanted a Steward. I didn’t want to be one. I wanted somebody to come and make the Light stop calling my name, and I thought, if I say it, she’ll think it’s about me, and she won’t take the rest.” She turns the calendar over on her knee. “It’s the first thing I’ve ever done that wasn’t in a table.

I called you because I’m on the roll, Ms. Brandt. Or I will be, whenever I say it. I’m three hundred and six. That’s what the Light has already decided. And the roll in my safe has had a blank line under the last name since the first of November, and I’ve never had the nerve to look at it to see if it’s still blank.”

She looks at me, finally. Her flat gray eyes are perfectly steady, and wet.

“Tonight’s the thirty-second. I’d like to be told what happens if I don’t answer. And I’d like to be told what happens if I do.”

I open my mouth. I know the answers. I know the rule from a card in a motel and from the end of a night in a Hall, and from a table where I lost an argument with a woman who could not use contractions. If you answer, it locks.

If you don’t, you are provisional until you are entered, and the entry is somebody else’s pen. What I do not know is what the roll will do to a harbormaster who has been counted for a month and written it down in pencil, and who has kept, in that time, the only record on Cutter Point of anyone who ever refused.

“I don’t know,” I say. It is the second time in two days.

Nell nods. She has expected it.

“Thank you,” she says. “That’s honest.” She pours the coffee. It is the worst I have ever had, and I drink it. At the foot of the stairs the harbor is dark, and the pipes in the wall, behind my head, begin very softly to knock.

THANKS.

We sit and listen to it, the harbormaster and I, until it stops.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!