Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 38

Ground Rules

Walt Gerrity calls at 6:50 in the morning, and for the first twenty seconds he does not say anything at all.

I am on the Ocean Rest’s bed in yesterday’s clothes with the withdrawal of the International’s complaint propped against the lamp, and I let him have the silence. A man who has spent forty years on other people’s picket lines learns the sound of a thing he can’t explain, and it has a texture, like a wet match.

“It closed,” he says finally. “Six o’clock, I had a voice mail from the general counsel’s secretary. The file is closed. Withdrawn by the complainant. He didn’t even say who. He said it with the voice of a man who’d been told to.”

“It was the Owners.”

“I figured. Who are the Owners?”

“I’ll tell you when I can prove it.” I rub my eyes. “Are you still holding the chair?”

“For the International, at your table, whenever there is a table.” His voice sharpens. “Odie. What did you pay?”

“Nothing yet.”

“Then you owe somebody, and it hasn’t come due.” A pause, a lighter clicks, and the sound of Walt Gerrity, who quit smoking in 2019, inhaling. “Remember what Ruth used to say about a gift from the other side.”

“Check the strings.”

“Check the strings. And then check the person who wrapped it.”

He hangs up. I sit there a minute. Then I get up, wash my face in the motel sink, and begin on the only thing that has ever made me feel better about a bad week, which is a plan.

---

Here is how you sit down with something that has no body.

You do what you do for anything with a body. People forget that the ceremony of a negotiation was never for the benefit of the people at the table. It exists so that nobody makes up the rules while they are losing.

So I write them on the back of a Tidewell safety agenda in blue ballpoint, with Mrs. Aguilar reading over my shoulder in the Hall’s front row at ten in the morning with her glasses on their chain, and I do not make them sweeping.

Ground rules. One: the session opens at the 3:12 horn and closes at its own pleasure or the Chair’s, whichever is first. Two: any party may call a caucus, and the other side leaves the room, or in this case, goes quiet. Three: no one is carried anywhere. No one is written in. No pen is lifted on either side without a vote of the whole Local.

Four: the Keeper speaks only to the Steward and the Recording Secretary pro tem, in writing, in the same ink, and may not borrow a voice, a hand, or a throat from any person present. Five: if either party says stop, we stop.

“He might not accept the fourth,” says Mrs. Aguilar.

“He’s been borrowing Lou’s voice since the thirtieth. I want to ask him first.”

“And if he says no?”

“Then he’s already told me what he is.”

She looks at me over the glasses. She is sixty-one and has the Hall’s dust on her sleeves and the finest attention to detail of any person I have ever met, and I realize that I trust her the way you trust a good level. “You do not want him to be what he is,” she says. “You want him to be a party.”

“Same thing, if you do it right.”

“It is not the same thing,” says Mrs. Aguilar mildly, “but I take your point.” She picks up the agenda and puts it in a manila folder. “I will read the minutes, if he will let me. I read a good many in the nineties, for the credit union.”

At eleven I post the ground rules on the Hall’s corkboard, under the stripe of milk-white light that has lain along the roof since Christmas. At 11:04 the paper warms, as if somebody had laid a hand on it. At 11:05, under my fifth rule, a line appears in copperplate that was not there a moment ago.

AGREED. WITH ONE AMENDMENT. SIX: THE RECORDING SECRETARY PRO TEM MAY SIT.

“Sit?” says Mrs. Aguilar.

I look at the Chair’s chair. Then, slowly, at the one beside it, the one with the arms worn smooth, the one that has been empty since 1998. It has a brass plate on the back I have never read, blackened with age. I rub it with my thumb, and the tarnish comes off in a stripe.

RECORDING SECRETARY.

“Calloway’s,” I say.

“Calloway’s,” says Mrs. Aguilar. “I have never sat in it. It did not seem mine.” She stands very still. “Are you sure?”

“He’s asking you to sit. That’s not a trick. Tricks don’t have manners.”

“In my experience,” she says, “they have nothing else.” But she squares her shoulders and goes to the chair and lowers herself onto it, and nothing happens. Nothing at all. And on her face is an expression I have seen before, on a girl in a big-box parking lot in Fall River telling me she’d switched to days: the particular look of someone who has been told that the job she is already doing has an office.

---

I spend the afternoon on the other half of the ground rules, which is the part nobody wants, namely who else is in the room.

A witness, Article Seventeen says. Someone carried across any line, who answers for you at the table. It has to be someone who can be heard.

“Me,” says Lou Pruitt.

We are standing in the Hall’s side kitchen, where she is making a pot of coffee for a meeting that will not need it. She has been very busy, all day, with a series of tasks that did not need doing. She has reorganized the card file by chair number. She has re-taped the roll book’s spine. She has not met my eyes since the hill.

“No,” I say.

“It’s the only reason I’m deputy.”

“It’s not why you’re deputy, and he’s already using your voice. I want him asked first.”

“He’s asking me now.” She sets the pot down with a click, and braces both hands on the counter. “Odie, I have a sentence in my head that I don’t remember learning. Know the books better than the bookkeeper. Last night in my sleep I said here twice. Mrs. Aguilar says she heard it through the wall.”

“We both did.”

“Then let me sit in a room where he can say it to my face, instead of from inside.” She turns, and her face, nineteen years old, is bone white and steady. “He’s a clerk, isn’t he? That’s what everybody keeps saying. An officer of a union who got locked out of his own meeting.”

“And when I was fourteen and my mother died, the one adult in my whole life who ever made me feel like I was allowed to take up room was a man at the credit union who handed me a Kleenex and a form and said, ‘Here is what you do next, in order.’”

I think about that.

“Lou. A witness is not a medium. You don’t open yourself. You sit there and you answer when I ask you. If you feel him in your head—”

“I’ll stand up and say stop.”

“Out loud.”

“Out loud,” says Lou, and she crosses the kitchen and puts her arms around me, quickly and hard, a thing she has not done before, and lets go before I can decide what to do with my hands. “It’s my rule. I made the call.”

“All right,” I say. “Witness. Coat on, shoes on.”

“Always shoes on,” she says, and almost laughs.

At two, I call Priya from the pay phone at Bev’s, because the signal at the Ocean Rest has been bad since the horn started speaking to people. I tell her all of it, the writ, the plates, the receipt, the minutes. I do not tell her about the first offer, the one with her name in it.

She is quiet on the line for a while. A monitor beeps in the background. She is on shift, and she has put me on speaker at a desk, and I can hear a woman somewhere asking for a blanket.

“Okay,” says Priya, at last. “Here is what I think. You’ve got a dead guy who has been waiting a hundred and thirty-five years to be told that his paperwork is fine.”

“That’s about it.”

“So tell him it’s fine.”

“It isn’t that simple. The minutes have to be approved by a vote of the Local, and—”

“Odie.” A drawer slams. “I’m saying you’re going to walk in there tonight and be scared of the wrong thing. You think the danger is him. I’ve worked three hundred nights with people who are dying and furious and sorry. Nobody dying has ever been the problem. It’s the ones who stop being heard.” She takes a breath. “Eat something. And call me after.”

“Okay.”

“Not okay. Say it.”

“I’ll eat something.”

“Good,” says my sister. “Because you sound like Mom when she skipped lunch.”

I stand in Bev’s hallway with the receiver against my forehead until the line goes dead and a recorded voice asks me to deposit another quarter.

---

The Hall at 3:05 in the morning is warmer than it has any business being.

Mrs. Aguilar has laid the table. A cloth, a pitcher of water, a pad of Tidewell safety agendas, the pocket Articles, a stack of cream cards. The stove glows. The thirty sit in the back rows with their hats on their knees, not a one of them wet, upright as photographs. Ansel Marsh is in his chair, number thirty. Orsolya sits in the Chair, with her hands in her apron, and in her lap, folded in its cloth like a sleeping child, my mother’s pen.

I take the Steward’s seat. Lou sits at my right hand and I put my left hand on the roll. Mrs. Aguilar takes the Recording Secretary’s chair. The brass plate catches the stove light, and the long table, which holds a hundred and forty living chairs and thirty dead ones and a gap of forty feet of empty floor, goes quiet in a particular way.

I have chaired a hundred meetings. I have never felt a room lean toward me like this one.

“The Chair recognizes,” says Orsolya, “that the session is convened. Under the ground rules posted at eleven o’clock, the Steward will address the Keeper.”

I clear my throat. “Keeper,” I say, and the word, in the warm hall, sounds smaller than I meant it. “This is a negotiation, not a trial. I’d like to start by thanking you for the amendment.”

Nothing. The stove ticks.

Then, from the safe in the corner, which Mrs. Aguilar has not opened tonight, comes the sound of a combination turning by itself. Three clicks. A thump. The iron door swings open, slow as a sleeper’s eyelid, and on the middle shelf, under the second cream card, lies a flat book bound in green cloth gone black at the corners. A small envelope sits on top of it, yellow with age, addressed in a woman’s quick hand to a man who could not answer.

“That’s the letter,” says Lou. Her voice shakes. “Constance’s mother.”

“Leave it,” I say. “It’s not ours.” And to the book: “Is that the minutes?”

A card slides out from under it, the way a drawer closes, and comes skimming along the table to stop in front of Mrs. Aguilar’s pad. She reads it first, because that is her office, and passes it to me.

THE MINUTES OF THE SEVENTH OF MAY, 1891. IN MY HAND. UNREAD. I ASK ONLY THAT THEY BE READ ALOUD, ENTIRELY, BEFORE ANY OTHER BUSINESS.

“Agreed,” I say. “Mrs. Aguilar?”

She rises. She takes the green book in both hands. She does it with the stove tongs, I notice, and then, halfway to the table, drops the tongs and takes it bare, and her palms do not burn.

She opens it. She reads.

---

I am going to tell you what the minutes say, because I think it matters. But I will tell you first what it was like to hear them.

Mrs. Aguilar reads in a flat, level voice, the way you read at a credit-union annual meeting, and the words in the book are in the clerk’s copperplate, and they are exact and nearly unbearable. Present, he writes, and lists the names. Sixty-three of them, in the order of the roll, the way a clerk writes who is proud of his handwriting and has met every person he lists.

Marsh, Ansel, smith. Marsh, Orsolya, packer, Chair. Thibodeau, Marguerite. Teller, Agnes, packer, scar on left thumb. Rudd, Elias, aged nine, present by permission of his mother as an observer, who asked to carry the pail.

Down the long rows of the Hall, I hear them. Not a sound. A change of weight in the chairs. Sixty-three dead people hearing their names called out in a living woman’s voice, in order, in the order they were ever called, and not a one of them making a sound.

Agnes puts her hands over her face. Nils sits very still, nineteen, with his chin up.

The business is plain. A report on dues. A report on the door of the smokehouse, which the Local has twice asked the Company to fix, because the bolt sticks and the iron cannot be opened from within. A motion, moved by Marsh, A., to refuse work in the smokehouse until the bolt is removed. Seconded by Marsh, O. A vote: for, thirty-three; against, thirty; carried.

“Thirty,” says Lou, barely a breath.

“Thirty against,” says Mrs. Aguilar, and her voice catches for the first time. “They voted no. In 1891, too.”

I look down the rows at the thirty who said no in October, and every one of them is looking at the floor, and I understand why they said it. They were tired. They have always been tired. They said no in 1891 to the work stoppage, and they went into the smokehouse on the night of the eleventh because the Company’s foreman said they would be paid double. And then the door stuck.

The clerk writes it all in a hand that does not shake. It is the dryness of it that undoes me. He is not there to judge. He is there to record. Item. Item. Item.

Mrs. Aguilar turns a page. She reads: “New business. Moved by the Recording Secretary of the Assembly, sitting as a guest, that the Local’s petition against the Association of Owners, regarding the bolt, the Company’s refusal, and the death of one Pruitt, Wynn senior, aged forty-one, in the same smokehouse in the winter of 1889, be forwarded to the Assembly for hearing. Seconded, Marsh, O. Carried, unanimous.”

I sit up so fast the chair legs scrape.

“Read that again,” I say.

“Moved by the Recording Secretary—”

“The date. Wynn Pruitt, senior.”

“Winter of 1889.” Mrs. Aguilar looks up, over her glasses, and every line of her face has gone clean and still. “Steward. There was a death in the smokehouse two years before the fire. The Local petitioned the Assembly about the same door. The Assembly never heard it.”

“Because the clerk died before he could carry it.”

“Because the minutes were never approved,” says Mrs. Aguilar. “And an unapproved minute is not a motion. It is a rumor.”

I think of Lou’s father, who rang a kitchen phone at two in the morning from a place he was never supposed to be. Wynn Pruitt, drowned six years ago, written on no list. A man with the same name as a man who died in a smokehouse in 1889. In a town where nothing is ever just a coincidence, the name is a stitch.

At my side, Lou has gone gray. “That’s my great-great-grandfather,” she says, in a very small voice. “Nobody ever told us he died in the plant.”

“He died at the door,” says the Chair, softly. “Of the same bolt. I never knew it was in the book.”

The long table has not made a sound. Ansel Marsh, in chair thirty, has bent his head as if under a weight, and his enormous hands lie open on his knees. He made that bolt. He made it in the spring of 1890, for a pantry.

A card slides across the table from the open safe, and Mrs. Aguilar passes it to me without reading it, because she cannot, her eyes are full.

THAT IS THE FIRST GRIEVANCE OF THIS LOCAL. IT HAS WAITED FOR A HEARING SINCE MAY OF 1891. THE OWNERS HAVE KNOWN IT WAS IN MY BOOK EVERY DAY SINCE. IT IS WHY THEY PREFER THE ASSEMBLY NEVER SIT.

I put my hand flat on the roll. It is cold as a stone. In forty minutes of a woman reading a dead man’s handwriting, a century and a quarter of local lunch and bilateral understanding has just come apart in my hands, in the form of a single petition number: Grievance No. 1, which was not mine.

The Owners did not fear the Keeper’s freedom. They feared the Keeper’s minute book.

“Keeper,” I say, and my voice is steady, which surprises me. “I have two conditions of my own.”

Another card. A beat, courteous. I CAN READ UPSIDE DOWN, STEWARD. GO ON.

“One. The minutes get read and approved by a vote of the whole Local, tonight or tomorrow, in open session, with all of them present and counted. That’s the only way they become a motion and not a rumor.”

GRANTED.

“Two. You tell me what happens to the guarantee when they’re approved.”

For a long time, no card comes. The stove ticks. Out on the headland, I can feel the lamp turning, regular and tired. And then the ink runs up through the grain of the table in a line so slow I can watch the pen think.

I WILL TELL YOU TRUTHFULLY, STEWARD, FOR I HAVE NEVER LIED TO A ROLL. I DO NOT KNOW.

“You don’t know.”

I HAVE NEVER BEEN ADJOURNED. IT MAY BE THAT THE LIGHT FAILS. IT MAY BE THAT IT PASSES TO THE NEXT HAND THAT WILL KEEP IT. IT MAY BE THAT NOTHING CHANGES AT ALL EXCEPT THAT I AM FINALLY ALLOWED TO LEAVE THE ROOM. I HAVE WRITTEN THREE THOUSAND PAGES OF THIS TOWN’S TROUBLE AND I HAVE NEVER ONCE BEEN SURE OF THE LAST LINE.

And then, below it, smaller, in a hand that I recognize at last as the hand of someone who is, under all the copperplate, extremely frightened:

I ASK FOR THE VOTE ANYWAY.

I look around the Hall. At the thirty in the back rows. At the Chair with the pen in her lap. At Ansel, who has not raised his head. At Lou, steady beside me, and Mrs. Aguilar in her new chair with the green book in her hands.

“Call a special meeting,” I say to the Chair. “Tomorrow at noon, in daylight, so everyone who can be counted can be seen. It will be the first ordinary vote of this Local to approve a document.” I stand. “Agenda: approval of the minutes of the seventh of May, 1891. And any new business arising.”

“The Chair so orders,” says Orsolya Marsh, and for the first time in my life, I hear her voice crack.

At the top of the hill, through the roof, through the ceiling plaster, from the tower, I hear the horn sound again. Not at 3:12. A second note, soft, brief, almost shy.

Then every pipe in the Hall begins to knock at once, in a clean, steady, unmistakable rhythm. Not a code. I know it from somewhere. It takes me a moment. It is the sound a room of workers makes on a table, with their knuckles, at the end of a long meeting, when the chair says that the motion has carried.

They are applauding him.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!