Eli did not sleep, and he was fairly sure Thea knew it, because at 3:10 in the morning she stopped typing and said, without turning around, “You’re doing the face.”
“I’m lying on a couch in a family lounge with a cold cloth on my eyes. I’m not doing anything.”
“You’re doing it under the cloth.”
He took the cloth off. The lounge was dark except for a brass lamp on the side table, the one Dot had left, and the glow of Thea’s laptop, which had moved there from the testing suite so she could sit near him while she worked. Lucia lay on the opposite couch under her own scarf, mouth slightly open, a rosary wound around her fingers like a bracelet. Every few minutes she said a word in her sleep. Once it was “pan.” Once it was “Hector.”
“Headache?” Thea asked.
“Four. It was five at midnight.”
“Light?”
“The lamp’s fine. The lamp’s the only thing in the building that’s fine.”
“Noted.” She finally turned. Her hair had come out of its clip. The pen was behind her ear and a second one was in her teeth, and she looked like a woman who had been awake for twenty hours and had decided to be afraid of nothing that could be written down. “Come here. I need you to read something before I send it.”
He sat up too fast, and the room tipped, politely, and righted itself. She watched him do it and wrote something on the legal pad. He did not ask what.
“Rule One,” she said, and held out the laptop.
It was the league’s gray form. Section Nine, Report of Possible Neurological Decline in a Protocol Participant. Six pages. He had expected the clinical parts, and they were there: the three index scores, the slope, the balance data, the symptom inventory, the hit at 9:14 p.m. in the third period, the on-ice check by the spotter, the headache and light sensitivity that began at 11:52. Every number was the number she had read aloud in the quiet room.
What he had not expected was the cover letter.
It was a page and a half. It said, in a plain, level voice, that Dr. Theodora Navarro had observed a pattern consistent with cumulative decline in Elias Brandt, that she was required to report it, that she was reporting it, and that she wished the Concussion Officer to know the circumstances in which she did so.
It said she had been in a romantic relationship with the player since February 27 and had disclosed it to the league and to her licensing board on March 3, and that she had recused herself from his treating team. It said that at 1:07 a.m. she had received an email from Barrett Stroud’s private address, which was attached, and that she considered it an attempt to influence the content or timing of her report. It said the report was neither softened nor sharpened because of it.
The last paragraph said: I am filing this the way I would file it for a stranger. I am asking the Officer to review it the way she would for a stranger. If that is not possible, I am asking her to say so in writing.
He read it twice. Then he put the laptop on his knees and looked at the lamp.
“You told them about us.”
“They already knew about us. The whole city knows. There was a photograph of a staircase.” She breathed out. “I told them so no one could say I hid it. If I’d hidden it for six hours, in the morning it would be the story. This way, it’s an appendix.”
“And the email.”
“The email’s the only thing in the file that isn’t ours. I want it dated and stamped before he can call it a courtesy.”
“He’ll say it was a courtesy.”
“He’ll say it was an arithmetic lesson.” She said it in Stroud’s voice, flat and lightly pleased, and in spite of everything Eli laughed, which hurt, which she saw. “I’m sending it at six. Not eleven tonight. Six. If I wait for the deadline, it’s his clock. If I send at dawn, it’s mine.”
“Thea.”
“What?”
“The team.”
She did not look away. That was the thing he had always loved about her and had never known how to say: when the worst thing in the room was in front of her, she looked at it. “I know what it costs. I’ve been doing the math since midnight.”
“If I file, the league can suspend you for fourteen days and Stroud’s lawyers can call it new evidence. If I don’t file, I’m a clinician who saw a slope in a protocol player and sat on it, and the first time anyone checks, your whole certification and every other player’s baseline in my pilot goes in the trash with my license. It isn’t a choice between saving you and losing you. It’s a choice between losing you out loud and losing you in the dark.”
“And the Lamps?”
“I don’t know.” She said it simply. “I don’t know what happens to the Lamps. I know what happens to the next kid in the Wick with a sparkle in his eye, and I know which one I want to be the person he asks. I’m sorry. I can hold both. I can’t pick the team over the kid.”
He looked at her for a long time.
“I wasn’t going to ask you to,” he said. “I want you to know I never once thought about asking you to.”
“I know.”
“Good.”
She turned the laptop back around and put her hand on the trackpad, and then she did not move it. It was 3:22 in the morning, and a decision made at 3:22 would be sent at 6:00, and between the two she had to live.
“Sit with me,” she said. “Not for the report. Just so I’m not in a chair by myself.”
So he sat. Her shoulder was warm against his arm. The lamp threw its small, steady gold. Across the room Lucia murmured in her sleep, and the building ticked and settled around them, and neither of them said anything for an hour.
At 4:30, Thea fell asleep with her head on his shoulder and the pen still behind her ear.
He did not move.
He had been in a lot of rooms in his life that felt like the last room. Hotel rooms before Game 7s, an ambulance, a hallway eight years ago in a stadium where a voice he loved had said, He needs to sit, and he had said, I’m fine, and watched her face. He knew what a last room felt like. This one didn’t. This one felt like the first room of something and he was terrified of it.
At 5:15, he picked up his phone with his free hand.
Three people. He made the calls in a whisper, in the order in which they could hurt him least.
The first was Priya Raman, who answered on the second ring, because Priya did not sleep either. He told her in four sentences. There was a silence. Then she said, in her list voice, “Three things. One, you’re calling me before the league does, which is the first correct thing anyone at this club has done in a year. Two, section fourteen of your contract. Give me an hour. Three, do not talk to Stroud.”
“I’m not planning to.”
“He’s going to plan to talk to you.”
The second was Joy Adeyemi, who ran the players’ association’s office in the city and who had once, at a charity dinner, told him that the difference between a union and a family was that a union put it in writing. She picked up on the fourth ring, groggy. By the end of the call, she was not groggy.
“Send me everything. Don’t speak to the league’s lawyers without me. Don’t speak to anyone from the club’s legal side at all. And Eli? When this is over, I’m going to want that Lantern thing in the contract language. The lamp. Don’t ask. I’ve been waiting twenty years to write that sentence.”
The third call he almost didn’t make.
Ravi Desai picked up from Palo Alto, where it was a quarter past three on Saturday morning, and said, “Please tell me you’re calling about the brisket recipe.”
“There’s no brisket recipe.”
“There’s always a brisket recipe. It’s the only thing that gets me out of bed.” The voice sharpened. “What happened.”
Eli told him. It took longer than it had with Priya, because Ravi asked questions, and because Ravi, who had known him since a dorm room in which one of them had a mini-fridge and the other a plan, did not accept the word fine even from a dead man.
When it was done, Ravi said nothing for a while. Then he said, “How much of the money would it take?”
“What?”
“Don’t what me. You know exactly what I’m asking. The club is a billion nine. The team is the city. The only reason you haven’t touched your shares in nine years is that you’re a stubborn person who thinks money is a form of confession. Tell me I’m wrong.”
“You’re not wrong.”
“Then call me Monday. Or tonight. I’ll have people in the room by Sunday.” Ravi’s voice dropped. “You told me once the only thing you ever wanted to buy was a way not to be alone in a room. Eli. It’s a hockey team. It’s a room with nineteen thousand seats. Think about it.”
He ended the call. Thea was still asleep. The lamp was still lit.
At 5:58 she woke without opening her eyes, the way people do who have trained themselves to wake on the minute, and her hand found the laptop.
“It’s six,” she said.
“It’s two minutes to.”
“Then I have two minutes.” She sat up. She looked at him in the lamplight, with the print of his sleeve on her cheek, and she said, “Are you sure you’re not going to hate me?”
“Thea.”
“I mean it. You’ll lose games. You’ll lose the room. You may lose the team and you’ll have a reason to put my face on it, and I’ll understand. I’m not asking you to say it won’t happen. I’m asking if you’ll tell me when it does, instead of going quiet and saying fine.”
“I’ll tell you the same day.”
“Say the rule.”
“I tell you every pain, and I tell you every feeling about the pain, and I do it before you have to ask.” He swallowed. “And if I ever say I’m fine and I’m not, you’re allowed to say the word.”
“Which word?”
“Goose.”
She blinked. “Goose?”
“It’s the padlock. It’s on the equipment room. Nobody argues with the goose.”
She laughed once, a small cracked breath of a laugh, and her eyes filled. “Goose,” she said, as if she were writing it down.
At 6:00 a.m., she pressed Send.
Nothing happened. No bell rang. The lamp did not flicker. The city outside went on being gray, a pale, wet, lakeshore dawn with a long foghorn somewhere far out in the harbor, saying its two notes. A truck went by. Lucia woke, saw them, and said, “Did you eat?” in a voice that made it clear she had not meant the question to be answered.
By 6:20, the first reply arrived. Automatic: Your report has been received by the Office of the Concussion Officer. By 6:45, a second, from a human being, a Dr. Renata Schaeffer, who wrote in precisely four lines that she had read the report and the attachment, that she was reviewing it with the league’s chief medical advisor, and that Mr. Brandt was to be held out of all team activity pending her determination, effective immediately.
“Immediately,” Thea said.
“It’s always immediately.”
“Hold on.” She read the fourth line. “She says she’s referring the cover letter to the league’s general counsel. For review. Of Stroud’s email.”
“That’s good.”
“It’s a sentence.” She stared at the screen. “I’ll take a sentence.”
By eight, he had showered in the visitors’ shower of the Wick with the water set to lukewarm because the lukewarm didn’t hit his eyes, and Owen had taken his vitals in the training room with his gentle, awkward hands, and Dot had come in with a thermos and a face like a stone.
“Sit,” she said.
“Dot.”
“Sit down and drink it, honey. It’s not soup. I’m trying a new thing.”
“What is it?”
“Broth.”
“That’s soup.”
“It’s broth,” Dot said, with immense dignity. “It’s a soup that has given up its ambition.” She set it on the counter and stood there with her arms folded, and he understood, slowly, that she was not angry at him, and that she was not angry at Thea.
She was angry the way she had been angry at a refrigerator once: at a machine that would not do the one thing a machine should do. “The kids are in the room. I told them nothing. They know it anyway. Gus has been looking at his phone since six. You want to tell them yourself or you want me to?”
“Myself.”
“Good.”
“Dot.” He looked at her. “Kade. Do you think he’ll...”
“I think a boy who stood on a roof and said he was sorry knows what it costs to be on the other side of that sentence.” She put a hand on his cheek, the old rough hand, smelling of skate wax and lanolin. “Tell them the truth, Elias. That’s the only thing that’s ever kept that room from being a room full of strangers. Tell them what you know and tell them what you don’t.”
He told them at 8:40.
He stood at the head of the long oak table in the players’ lounge with twenty-six men in sweatshirts and soft shoes, a few of them still with bedhead, all of them very quiet. Gus sat at the other end with his arms folded and his jaw working.
Mick had his hands flat on the table, palms down, as if keeping it from floating away. Sam Oduya sat near the door in a Lamps hoodie, looking like a boy at his own surprise party, and Kade sat three seats from the front, not at the front, not at the back, and did not look at anyone.
Eli said it plainly. He said that after the hit last night Thea had run the protocol, that the protocol had found a decline in his processing speed, that some of it was last night and some of it was a long time ago, and that he did not know how much would come back.
He said that the rules required her to file, and that she had, and that he had asked her to. He said that he would be held out of games for at least fourteen days, which meant the first round, and probably longer. He said he did not know what it meant for the team’s future. He said that he would not lie to them about that either.
“I’m not telling you this so you’ll feel sorry for me. I’m telling you because you’ve all been in this room when somebody didn’t.”
Nobody spoke. Out in the corridor, a vacuum cleaner droned and stopped.
Then Gus said, in a voice that carried and did not shake, “Cap. With respect. Are you asking us to be angry at the doctor?”
“No.”
“Good. Because I was going to say that in thirteen years in this league, I have been told by four doctors that I was fine, and the only one who ever said the number was the one who wrote it down.” Gus unfolded his arms. “I would like the room to know that I am, at this moment, extremely angry at an owner. If anyone would like to join me, I have a list.”
Somebody laughed. It was a thin, startled sound. Then somebody else did, and then Mick put his head in his hands and said, “I do not say the word. The word hears,” and the whole table dissolved. Sam was wiping his eyes with a sleeve. Even Kade was laughing, helplessly, with a hand over his mouth and a wet face.
It was the best sound Eli had ever heard in his life.
He let it run its course. When it quieted, Kade stood up.
He did it awkwardly, pushing his chair back, and the room turned. For a moment Eli thought he might say something about the C. Instead Kade walked to the front of the table, to the wall where Dot’s brass lamps hung on their hooks, and took one down. He turned it on. He carried it to Eli’s empty stall in the corner and set it on the shelf above it, where the other one had been, and lit it, and stood there with his back to everyone.
“Honestly, Cap,” he said, to the wall, not turning. “I’m not trying to take anything. I’m trying to be ready when you hand it back.”
Eli found he could not say anything for a moment.
“Noted,” he managed. It was Thea’s word. The room made a small, warm noise.
The meeting broke up at nine. Priya was waiting in the hall with a folder under her arm and a legal pad on top, her hair in an ordinary bun, her suit the same navy as always, and he could see from her face that she had counted the options and did not like the total.
“Walk with me,” she said.
They walked. The Wick’s long corridor smelled of wet rubber and rinse aid. Through a window he could see the old second sheet of ice, dark and unlit, a sheet nobody had skated on in years, where he and Thea had once stood in the dark and read an audit log.
“Section fourteen,” Priya said. “Clause three. It’s a clause nobody ever reads. I read it at three a.m. If a termination proceeding is begun against a player on medical grounds, the player has seventy-two hours to file for arbitration, and the arbitration stays the termination until it’s decided. Which is good. What’s bad is what comes before it.” She glanced at him. “The club is not obligated to wait for a determination from the Concussion Officer to initiate a termination. It’s only obligated to give notice in writing.”
“So he can start it today.”
“He can start it at any minute he likes. And because the sale closes Tuesday, I believe he will.”
“Then we file first.”
“We cannot file against something that has not been filed. That’s the law’s idea of a joke.” She stopped. They were outside the double doors of the equipment room, where the goose padlock hung open on its hasp.
“Joy Adeyemi’s office has a lawyer who will be at the Wick in an hour. A real one. Not a guild one. She did arbitrations for the other league’s pension case.” She looked at her pad. “And I have two options, and I’d like you to know that this time I mean two.”
“Go.”
“One is to let the clock run and respond when he serves. Cleaner. Less risk. We could lose a day.” She paused. “The other is the one you won’t like. We stop waiting for him. We file a petition for the full Independent Medical Board hearing on our own side, today, under your clearance of March 26, and ask that any termination proceeding be stayed until it is heard. It’s an unusual filing. It will look like a player afraid of his own club.”
“It will look like a player who read his contract.”
“Yes.” She almost smiled. “Which, for the record, is the first time I’ve ever said that sentence about a hockey player.”
“File it.”
“You haven’t heard the cost.”
“There’s always a cost.”
“The cost is that you’ll be put under oath,” Priya said. “Not Thea. You. Your medical history, the Larkin Fund, Northlight, all of it, in front of a stranger, with Stroud’s lawyer asking the questions. They’ll use every dollar you’ve ever hidden to say you were hiding the rest.”
He took a breath. He was aware of the lamp in the lounge behind him and of the sheet of dark ice through the glass.
“I’ve been hiding my whole life,” he said. “I’d like to see what the other thing feels like in a courtroom.”
Priya looked at him for a long, level moment. Then she wrote one line on the pad, underlined it twice, and tore off the page.
“Rule One,” she said. “Apparently it’s contagious.”
He went back to the lounge. Thea was at the long table with Owen and Lucia and a pot of coffee, and when he came in she looked up with a question, and he nodded: file. She put her pen behind her ear and opened her mouth, and then her phone buzzed on the table.
It was not an email.
It was a message from an unknown number, a Brindle Harbor area code, and she held it so he could see.
Dr. Navarro. This is Warren Ames, counsel for Stroud Marine Holdings and the Brindle Harbor Hockey Club. I am writing to inform you that notice of termination of Mr. Brandt’s contract under section eleven will be served at his residence at noon today. I wanted you to hear it from a courtesy, and not the paper. I do hope you’ll take that in the spirit in which it is meant.
Underneath, a second line arrived while they were still reading.
Mr. Stroud asked me to add that the club regrets the necessity. He remains available to discuss terms.
Thea set the phone face down on the table.
“Noon,” Eli said.
“Noon.” Her voice was very quiet. “It’s 9:11.”
“Then we have two hours and forty-nine minutes.”
“To do what?”
He looked at Priya in the doorway, and Owen holding a mug in both hands, and Lucia, who had stopped moving, and Dot, standing in the corridor with her arms folded, and Gus and Mick and Sam, who had drifted back to the doorway of the lounge in their soft shoes and sweatshirts and were standing there in a row like a defensive line.
He thought of Ravi’s voice. A room with nineteen thousand seats.
“To make sure that when he serves it,” Eli said, “I’m not alone at home to receive it.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!