Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 24

Sealed

Thea’s mother chose, as she chose everything, over breakfast.

It was Sunday, March thirtieth, a quarter to nine, in the upstairs kitchen of the bakery. Sun slanted through the curtains onto a table covered with oilcloth printed with lemons. There was coffee, and a plate of eggs nobody had asked for, and Lucia in her good blue robe with her gray hair down, sitting very straight, with the yellowed envelope in front of her next to the salt.

Eli sat across from Thea. He had come at eight, at Lucia’s invitation, with a grocery bag of oranges and the particular wary politeness of a man entering a negotiation where he was not a party. He had told Thea about the car at midnight, by phone, in eleven careful sentences, and she had listened without speaking. Now he told Lucia.

“He said he would drop the termination,” Eli said. “Today. He said he would withdraw the notice and pay out the full contract, with a twelve-million-dollar settlement on top, if I signed the Beacon consent. Written, notarized, effective immediately. He said the club would move in the summer, but I’d have a choice of cities and my own front office. He said Thea would keep her license, and her clinic, and the pilot’s funding.”

“And the envelope?” said Lucia.

“He didn’t mention the envelope. He said there were documents on both sides, and a sensible family would let sleeping paper lie.”

“A sensible family.” Lucia gave a short hard laugh. “He has never met a Navarro.”

“I told him I’d answer in front of an arbitrator,” Eli said. “He said that was a shame. He said he’d always admired a man who knew when he was beaten. I said I’d never met one.”

Thea looked at him over her coffee. “You said that?”

“I said something with fewer syllables. It had the same shape.”

“Noted,” said Thea. She felt, absurdly, a laugh coming. She pressed it down.

Lucia put one hand flat on the envelope. “I would like to say something now. I would like you both to not say anything until I finish.”

They waited.

“For nine years I have been silent because I was told silence was what a good wife did, and then a good widow, and then a good mother. I thought: if I say nothing, no one is hurt. I was wrong. I was hurting everyone in a quiet way.” She drew a breath.

“Raymond Pryce wrote the letter because he wanted it found. He could not bring himself to give it, so he dropped it behind a cushion, and I put it in the flour, and so it was, for nine years, a thing that wanted to be found, in a house that would not look.”

“Mama...”

“I am not finished. If I give this to the arbitrator, Mr. Stroud will say I broke a contract, and perhaps he will sue me. I am sixty-two years old. I have an oven and a house and a daughter who is better than I deserve. I do not mind. I would like it very much if you would stop looking at me as if I were glass.” She pushed the envelope an inch across the oilcloth, toward Thea. “Use it.”

“Mama, I want you to talk to Tamsin Rourke first.”

“I will talk to her. And then I will sign whatever she says, and then I will go to the hearing, in my good black dress, and sit in the second row.” Her chin lifted. “Your father kept his notebook in a lantern for twenty years because he wanted someone to read it. Now someone will.”

Thea got up. She came around the table. She did not say anything, because there was nothing in her mouth that was big enough, so she sat on the arm of her mother’s chair and put her arms around her, and Lucia leaned into her shoulder, stiff, and then not stiff, and said into her sleeve, “Eat your eggs.”

Rourke came at ten. She read the letter twice, standing at the window with her glasses pushed up, then folded it back into its envelope with a gentleness that surprised Thea, and turned around.

“This is the best piece of paper I’ve held in my professional life,” she said. “I want everyone to know I hate that sentence. I’d rather it were a bad piece of paper in a good world.”

“What does it do?” said Thea.

“Several things. First, it’s a contemporaneous admission by a physician, in his own hand, that he falsified clearances for thirty-one players at the direction of the club’s then-owner. That goes to pattern. It goes to credibility. It makes everything Dr. Gordon Pryce did this winter look like inheritance and not accident. Second, it undercuts the silence clause.” She held up a finger.

“No private agreement can lawfully stop a party from disclosing evidence of fraud or concealment to a tribunal with jurisdiction. That’s what a protective seal is for. We hand it to the arbitrator under seal, in camera. Stroud’s side sees it only if she says they do. So Mrs. Navarro is not breaking anything. She’s complying with a subpoena she hasn’t been served with yet.”

“And third?” Eli said.

“Third, it’s not going to win the hearing on Monday. The hearing on Monday is about one thing: whether the club may act on a termination notice before the Board has ruled. This letter isn’t about that.” She smiled thinly. “But it changes the room. It changes the arbitrator’s face. And a face is half of any case.”

“Then we don’t spend it Monday,” Thea said.

Rourke looked at her.

“We keep it sealed in your file, and we tell her it exists. We don’t read it into the record yet. We save it for the full hearing. If Stroud wants to talk about whether the doctor can be trusted, we say: ask the court to unseal what’s under seal. Let him ask.”

“That is,” Rourke said slowly, “exactly what I would do.”

“My mother’s afraid.”

“Your mother,” said Lucia, from her chair, “is going to make everyone sandwiches.”

The hearing was at two o’clock on Monday afternoon, in a conference room on the fourteenth floor of a lakefront hotel that had been chosen because it was owned by neither side. The room had pale carpet and a view of the harbor and a long table that someone had polished that morning. A court reporter sat at one end. A water pitcher sweated on a tray.

The arbitrator was a retired judge named Marguerite Hollis, seventy, lean and straight as a poker, with iron hair, rimless glasses, and a gray suit that looked as if it had been ironed by an angry nun. She had come up from the capital on the early train. She shook no hands.

She sat at the head of the table and said, “I have read the papers. I read them on the train, which is the only place I read anything carefully. I do not like surprises, and I like theater less. If you are going to make a speech, make it short.”

Warren Ames stood. He was tall and silver-haired, in an impeccable charcoal suit, with the beautifully modulated voice of a man who had never been interrupted. Beside him sat Barrett Stroud himself, hands folded on his cane, absolutely still.

Ames spoke for eleven minutes. He was good. He spoke of a club in crisis, and a franchise with eighty employees, and a medical finding from a respected clinician that a star player’s neurological function had declined eighteen percent in five years. He spoke of a captain who, regrettably, was unable to protect himself.

He spoke of the club’s duty of care. He did not use the word sale. He used the word responsibility four times. He said, at the end, “Your Honor, the club has acted quickly because the club is concerned. A player who cannot be trusted to know his own limits cannot be left to decide them.”

Rourke stood.

“Your Honor,” she said, “the club has acted quickly because it has a closing date.”

“Ms. Rourke.”

“Section eleven-four of the contract provides that termination is effective only on a determination by the Independent Medical Board. That determination does not exist. The Board’s most recent determination is dated March twenty-sixth and declares the player fit under restrictions. The club’s notice therefore has no legal effect, and the sole purpose of serving it is to be seen to have served it, three days before the Beacon Clause lapses.” She said it flatly, without adjectives.

“We ask only that the club be ordered to take no step premised on termination until the Board has heard this matter. We are not asking you to find anything. We are asking you to leave the table as it is.”

“What’s the harm to the club?” said Hollis.

“Delay,” said Ames, rising. “The sale agreement has an outside date. Delay could cost the club nineteen hundred million dollars.”

“Delay could cost the city its team,” said Rourke, “if the delay is not allowed.”

Hollis took off her glasses. “Dr. Navarro.”

Thea stood. She had not expected to be called. She had worn a navy suit and low shoes, and she had a copy of her own declaration in her hand, with its single adjective crossed out.

“You filed this report at six a.m. Saturday.”

“Yes.”

“Why not at the last minute?”

“Because a deadline someone else chooses isn’t a deadline,” Thea said. “It’s a leash. I would rather file my own report on my own clock, in the open.”

“You’re in a relationship with the player.”

“Yes. I disclosed it to the league and my licensing board on March third. I recused myself from his treating team on March fourth. I am not his clinician. I’m the director of a league pilot that tracks his decline. He is, as of the twenty-eighth, the first protocol player to show the pattern the protocol was built to detect.” She paused. “It wasn’t a convenient result. I’d have been very glad to find something else.”

“Mr. Ames wishes me to find you biased.”

“Mr. Ames is welcome to find whatever he can prove.”

Hollis’s mouth twitched. It was the first sign of life in her face. She turned her pale eyes on Ames.

“Counsel,” she said. “Do you have anything more?”

“Your Honor, if I may, there is a second matter. The club believes the doctor’s family has a history of accepting financial inducements to remain silent about...”

“Your Honor,” said Rourke, getting smoothly to her feet, “we are prepared to address any reference to the Navarro family’s prior dealings with the club in camera, under seal, at the full hearing. We have in our possession a document relevant to that. We will produce it to the Court on request. We will not produce it to counsel until the Court directs.”

There was a small, sharp silence.

Stroud’s hands had not moved. But for the first time in all those minutes, he turned his head and looked at Thea. He looked at her the way a man looks at a stair that is not where he left it. Then, very faintly, he lifted one finger from the head of the cane. Ames sat down.

“Ms. Rourke,” Hollis said, “bring it to chambers.”

“It’s under seal. In the clerk’s possession since noon.”

“Then I will read it before breakfast.” Hollis put her glasses back on. “Here is what I am doing today. I am granting the status-quo order. The club shall take no step premised on the termination of Mr. Brandt’s contract until the Independent Medical Board or its designee has ruled. The Board shall hear the matter on Monday, April fourteenth, in this room, at nine a.m. I will preside. Both sides will file witness lists by Thursday.”

“I will read anything filed under seal personally and I will tell you whether I think it relevant. If I discover that any party has tried to affect the timing of a clinician’s report, or the sale price, or the outcome of a medical review by making a private offer to a player, I will find it. I will take a very long time finding it.”

Her gaze moved, mildly, to Stroud.

“Mr. Stroud,” she said. “I understand you are an elderly gentleman and that your arithmetic is excellent. I trust it is excellent enough to count to the fourteenth.”

“Your Honor,” said Stroud. It was the first time he had spoken. His voice was pleasant. “I wouldn’t dream of rushing a lady.”

“Excellent. We are adjourned.”

The hallway outside was cool and bright, with long windows overlooking the harbor, a carpet the color of oatmeal and a row of potted ferns. Thea walked out with Eli and Priya and Rourke in a loose, dazed, shaky knot. Lucia was behind them, on Owen’s arm, in her good black dress, with her purse clutched against her hip and her face lit like a woman at a baptism.

“She granted it,” Priya said, in a thin voice. “She actually granted it.”

“She granted it because she read the room,” said Rourke. “And because of the second matter, which, I want it noted, I did not plan. Mr. Ames over-reached.” She smiled her hard smile. “Never underestimate how much a judge hates a man who tries to ambush her.”

“Does it stop the sale?” Eli said.

“It stops the termination. The sale is a separate question. The clause is alive. The outside date is midnight tonight. What Meridian does is up to Meridian.”

“They’ll walk,” said Priya.

“Maybe.”

“There’s another possibility.”

They turned. A woman was standing by the windows, with her back to the light, in a camel coat and low heels, with a leather folio under one arm. She was perhaps forty-five, with short dark hair and dry, amused eyes. She had come out of the elevator without anyone seeing, and she waited with an air of having practiced waiting.

“Dana Kessler,” she said. “Meridian Sports Group. I was in the back row.”

Priya went rigid. Rourke said, mildly, “Ms. Kessler, I believe you know I can’t talk to you without opposing counsel.”

“Then don’t talk. I’ll talk.” Kessler held up a hand. “I’m not here to threaten anyone. I’m here, frankly, because I spent an hour this morning on the phone with my board, and at 3:40 I’m going to walk into a room and tell them whether to close tomorrow on a franchise that has a live Beacon Clause, a captain who won’t sign, an arbitrator with iron hair, and a public relations picture I’d describe as a bonfire.”

“And?” said Eli.

She looked at him. It was a long, level, assessing look, not unfriendly. “Captain Brandt. I have reviewed your public financial statements. There aren’t any. I have also reviewed a report the Ledger ran Wednesday about a Delaware trust that my analysts would like to talk about for a very long time.”

“I’m sure they would.”

“Meridian is a business. We bought this team for a price and a plan, and the plan is dead on arrival. I do not enjoy buying lawsuits.” She tapped the folio. “I’ll recommend to my board that we extend the outside date to May first. For a fee. And a condition.”

“Which is?”

“That if, before May first, a qualified buyer shows up with the full purchase price, nineteen hundred million, in escrow, we will step aside and take our deposit back, with a premium. Reasonable.” Her dry eyes lifted. “We’d like a deal. We’d just prefer to make it with someone who won’t have to be dragged.”

There was a silence in the hallway.

Eli said very softly, “You’re asking if I have nineteen hundred million dollars.”

“I’m saying a qualified buyer might. And that I would not be surprised if he had a college roommate in Palo Alto.” The corner of her mouth moved. “I read the Ledger. Don’t look at me like that, Captain. Everybody reads the Ledger.”

She turned to Thea.

“Dr. Navarro. I enjoyed the part about the leash. I’ll put it in my report.” She nodded to the group, a courteous half-nod, and walked away down the long carpeted hall, in her low heels, with her folio under her arm.

Nobody said anything until the elevator closed.

“Did that just...” said Priya.

“I think,” said Rourke, “that was a gift horse in a camel coat.”

Eli stood by the window with his hands in his pockets, looking at the harbor. The sun was out on the water. Down on the quay, tiny and bright, a Lamps flag snapped on a pole above Tidewell. Thea came to stand beside him.

“Left hip?” she said.

“Three. It’s a good day.”

“And the rest of you?”

“I’m terrified.” He said it without looking at her, to the glass. “I’ve got a billion four, give or take, in shares I’ve never sold. It isn’t nineteen hundred. It isn’t close. I’d need the city. I’d need the fans, and a bank, and a mayor. I’d need to say my name in a room.”

“That sounds like a lot of people.”

“It’s the exact number I’ve spent my whole life avoiding.” He turned, at last. His face was pale, and a little wild, and happier than she had seen it in a week. “Thea. I think I’d like to try.”

She took his hand. His fingers were icy.

Her phone buzzed against her hip.

She almost let it go. Then she looked down. A text from an unfamiliar number, with a preview that read, in full:

Candace Voss: I know who forwarded your report to Stroud’s office 14 minutes after you filed. It isn’t who you think. Call me. Not from the Wick.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!