Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 20

Superseding

THE CLERK: The State of Sable County versus Jude Alexander Marchand, superseding indictment, two additional counts.

THE CLERK: Count Three, obstruction of justice. Count Four, tampering with physical evidence.

THE DEFENDANT: I understand.

We are back by Sunday night, with Nell's shoebox in my lap and the pound cake wrapped in foil on the dashboard. Otis says nothing for the last hundred miles. At the Port Sable city limit he puts the car in park under a streetlight and writes the odometer reading in a small notebook, which is the most Otis thing I have ever seen.

I sleep in the sewing room, under the plastic-covered Singer, and dream of a bus.

Monday, at 8:15, Pru phones.

"Sit down," she says.

"I'm sitting."

"No. You're standing in the kitchen with a cup of coffee. Put it down and sit." I do. "Wynn took a superseding indictment to the grand jury at seven this morning. They returned it at eight. It's out on the wire now."

"Whose?"

"Jude's." She takes a breath. "Obstruction and tampering. The tampering count is the sedan. The obstruction count is five years of silence and the conversation on the ferry deck."

The coffee has gone cold in my hand.

"The ferry," I say.

"Your proffer was protected, Ada. I told you that. What you said to Wynn can't be used against you." Pru's voice is thin with fury. "It can be used to open a door, though. Everything you told him on Saturday morning, about the sedan, about the stacked hulls, about what Jude said to you on the deck, is a lead. He didn't use your words. He used your lead. He went to the tow driver, who was frightened enough to tell him the same thing. And then he subpoenaed the ferry's security tape."

"There's a tape."

"There was a camera over the stern door. It caught the two of you on the open deck. No sound. But he could read lips, or he had a lip reader." She stops. "The tow driver will testify. The camera shows Jude confessing to a witness."

"I'm that witness."

"You are that witness."

I put the cup in the sink. I run water over it, for no reason, as I have seen people do in films.

I tried so hard to tell the truth with my own life and no one else's. I thought if I said it once, the right way, in the right room, it would go where I aimed it. It does not. It runs downhill like water and takes what it takes.

"Where is he?"

"At the courthouse. His bond was revoked at nine. The judge didn't like the new counts. He turned himself in at 8:40 so the deputies wouldn't have to come to the yard." Pru's voice drops. "Doss is with him. She says he asked her to tell you not to come."

"I can't come. I'm not allowed within a hundred yards."

"I know. He knows."

There is a silence on the line, the kind in which people hold their breath without noticing.

"Ada," says Pru. "There's something else. Wynn wants to see you at ten."

"Why?"

"He says he wants you to hear it from him."

I am in Wynn's office at 10:05, in the same fourth-floor conference room, over the same parking structure. He sits straight this morning, without the cardigan. He looks like a man who knows exactly how he would be described by a person who didn't like him.

"I want to say first that I did not use a word of your proffer," he says.

"Pru told me."

"I used what it led me to, and I will use it again. This is the work." He lays his hands on the table. "You are going to be angry with me. I have decided to let that be."

"What do you want?"

"Your testimony." He says it without softness. "Jude Marchand's confession to you on the ferry is the cleanest evidence in the case. The camera shows him speaking. You heard what he said. You are the only person who can say what the words were."

"I said it in a proffer."

"You will say it again on the stand. If you refuse, I will compel you. You were not his lawyer. You are not his wife. You are, as of this morning, not even a participant in the State's case against him, because I have severed it from yours." He leans forward. "You may tell the truth, Ms. Fenner, or you may be held in contempt, and then you may tell it anyway."

"You're asking me to convict him."

"I am asking you to answer a question. The jury will do whatever it does with the answer." His eyes do not leave me. "I know what that sounds like. I am also asking you to understand that your uncle's lawyer will say, in open court, that you are a woman who has already lied once under oath. The one thing that will make the rest of what you say believable is the willingness to tell an inconvenient truth under cross. If you take the stand for the State against Jude, even once, no one can say you only tell the truth when it helps."

"It would help you," I say.

"Yes." He does not look away. "It would help the case against Raymond Fenner, because it would make you a witness who cuts both ways. It would hurt Jude. I am not pretending it won't."

"He's the one who wrote me a list of facts," I say, and stop, because it is the wrong argument entirely.

Wynn waits.

"If I do it," I say, "I will not say it was a bribe. I will not say it was obstruction. I'll say what he said, in his words, and I will say what he did after. I will say he came to me because he wanted me to know. He didn't ask me for anything."

"The jury may decide what to call it."

"You'll let me say all of it?"

"I will let you say every word he said." A pause. "I will not let you argue his defense for him."

The clock ticks. A truck backs up in the structure below, its alarm going.

"I need to think," I say.

"You have until Friday." He pushes a card across the table, his own, with a number written on the back. "I believe, Ms. Fenner, that you have already thought about nothing else for a week."

It is a fair guess, and I hate it.

Pru walks me to the stairwell. She does not say she is sorry, which I appreciate, because every sorry she could say would be a lie, and she has the decency not to waste one. She gives me a thick envelope instead.

"Doss left it with the front desk. It's from the jail."

Inside is a single sheet, torn from a legal pad. The handwriting is square and upright, with the stub of a pencil's pressure behind it. It is not signed.

I read it on the stairs.

Don't recant. Don't soften it. I've waited five years to be told the truth by someone who doesn't want anything from me. It would be a poor way to repay it if I made you lie now.

Eat something.

There are thirty-nine words, and I know exactly how I would like to answer, and I cannot answer at all.

I fold the paper into the pocket of my coat and press it flat, the way you press a flower into a book. Down in the street a ferry horn sounds, long and low, the 12:10 pulling out for Birch Landing. It is the sound of all my days.

Then I go to find something to eat, as ordered.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!