Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 5

State’s Exhibit Fourteen

MR. ROARK: Your Honor, the State offers Exhibit Fourteen.

THE COURT: Any objection?

MS. DOSS: Foundation only, Judge. I think the witness is about to lay it.

On Tuesday morning at 8:50, Judge Lyle asks me to step into chambers.

It is a small room, lined with law books gone soft at the corners. She sits behind a desk the size of a skiff and doesn’t ask me to sit. A porcelain cup of tea steams at her elbow.

“Ms. Aldous. My clerk tells me your file is in perfect order.”

“Thank you, Your Honor.”

“I like order.” She turns a page she isn’t reading. “I also like to know who is sitting in my room. In thirty years on this bench, I’ve never had a reporter who held as still as you do. Wanda fidgets. Wanda hums. You’re like a stone in a stream.” She looks up over the glasses. “I find that interesting. People who are good at being still are usually good at it for a reason.”

My mouth is dry as chalk. “I was trained to be neutral, Judge.”

“So you were.” She waits. I say nothing, because saying nothing is my one fluent language. “That will be all, Ms. Aldous. Don’t let me keep you from your work.”

I walk out of her chambers with the feeling of a woman who has gotten away with something, though I can’t tell what.

Court resumes at nine. Ray is back on the stand in a fresh blue shirt, hands folded, a model of patient grief. Roark does a short redirect, then lifts a piece of paper in a plastic sleeve.

“Mr. Fenner, I’m showing you what’s been marked State’s Exhibit Fourteen. Do you recognize it?”

“I do. It’s a page from the ledger of my company.”

“How do you know?”

“Letterhead’s ours. The columns are the way we ruled them.” He pauses. “And the handwriting is my niece’s.”

The clerk puts it on the screen above the jury box.

I do not look at it. I look at my keys. Q, A, Q, A.

“Would you read the highlighted entry for the jury, please?”

“October thirteenth,” says my uncle. He reads slowly, in that wide kind voice. “J.M., forty thousand. W.P.”

“Who is J.M.?”

“Jude Marchand.”

“And W.P.?”

“Walter Prejean.”

“And what is this entry?”

“A payment,” Ray says. “From Jude Marchand to Walter Prejean. The day before Walter disappeared.” He lowers his eyes. “Walter had been, shall we say, difficult about money. I’d always thought it was only talk.”

The jurors are all looking at the screen. They are looking at a number with two zeros and a name, set down in a neat, tight, upright hand.

I look up.

It is my handwriting.

It is not that it resembles mine. I have looked at that hand in mirrors and passport photographs and the margins of ten thousand pages. I know the way I cross my sevens and the way I loop the tail of a W like a hook on a coat. There is the bar through the 4, which my sixth-grade teacher called “old-fashioned.” There, in the corner, is the coffee ring from a mug I broke in the spring of that year.

Forty thousand dollars. J.M. W.P.

I remember writing it.

It comes back all at once, with the ugly clarity of something you’ve buried and never really lost. It is three in the afternoon on the fourteenth of October. The office smells of floor wax and cigarette smoke from the stairwell. My uncle is leaning in the doorway of the bookkeeping room with a styrofoam cup in his hand.

“Adie, honey. The auditors come Thursday. We need to catch up one line before they do.”

“Which one?”

“Marchand. Put it in on the thirteenth.” He spells it for me, like a man dictating a telegram. “J.M., forty. Then W.P. Just a late fee.”

“Jude’s been paying twenty a quarter, Ray. That’s forty? That’s double.”

“Late fee, sweetheart. It’s nothing. Put it down.”

I put it down.

I did not think about it. I want that understood. I wrote it with the same hand I used for lunch receipts and the postage ledger, and then I went home at five to feed a cat that I had not yet decided to leave.

Six and a half hours later, Walter Prejean was dead.

I did not know, then, what the line was for. I know now. It was a motive, drawn up in advance, on paper in my handwriting, so that if anyone ever found the commissioner in the wrong place, there would be a man with a reason, and a bookkeeper’s page that said so.

My uncle planned the frame at three o’clock in the afternoon.

And I held the pen.

“Ms. Doss,” says Judge Lyle. “Cross?”

“Briefly.” She walks to the lectern and doesn’t open a folder. “Mr. Fenner, that page says October thirteenth.”

“Yes.”

“Do you know what day your niece actually wrote it?”

“The thirteenth, it says.”

“It says the thirteenth. I’m asking when she wrote it.”

“I couldn’t tell you.” He turns a hand over, helpless. “I’m not a bookkeeper.”

“No. You’re the owner of the firm.” Her voice is polite, flat as a table. “Did you ever dictate entries to your niece?”

“Objection,” says Roark.

“Overruled.”

“Never,” says Ray. “I trusted her.”

“Your Honor, nothing further.”

She sits. And, as she does, I feel a small pull of attention from the side of the room. Not from Jude. He is looking at the screen, jaw set, as if it were a wall he had decided to climb.

It is from the second row of the gallery.

Evangeline Prejean is fifty-two, a slim woman with a gray bob and a pair of aluminum needles, working on a scarf of such extravagant length it pools around the bench. She has not once looked at the witness in three weeks. Today she is not looking at the screen either.

She is looking at my hands.

At the break she is in the corridor, in front of the water fountain, as if she had been waiting for it to be a coincidence.

“Forgive a nosy woman,” she says. Her accent is soft Gulf Coast, lifted at the ends. “You’re new. Wanda used to bring me ginger candy, when the testimony ran bad.”

“Mrs. Prejean, I’m not supposed to talk to anyone in the gallery.”

“I know it, dear. I won’t keep you.” She smiles. It is not quite a smile. “My husband used to say that the people who write things down are the only honest ones in a courthouse. He said the rest of us just talk.”

I say nothing.

“I noticed,” says Evangeline Prejean, “that you flinch when they say his name. Nobody on that jury has. Not once.” She resettles her scarf with elegant, shaking fingers. “I’d like very much to read your notes someday, Ms. Aldous. All of them.”

She walks away down the hall. Her scarf trails behind her over the marble like something that wants to be followed.

I find the stairwell. I sit on the third step, and I put my forehead on my machine.

It is cool, and it smells of ozone and old coffee. Somewhere in the building, Raymond Fenner is answering questions in the voice I used to trust above every other.

Here is what I know. If I stand up in that courtroom and say my uncle killed Walter Prejean, the first thing they will do is hold up that page. The ledger line is a lie, and I wrote it. I wrote it in my own hand, and I am a thief to the prosecutor, a fraud to the state board, and the one person who could tell any jury what that line was for.

The truth has a sentence in it that begins with a confession.

When I stand up, I will be saying all of it together.

The recess bell rings. I get to my feet, and in my pocket is the square of salvage-yard letterhead I took off the bait shop railing at midnight. On it, in small blunt handwriting: Tuesday night. Third Street gate.

For the first time in five years, there is somewhere I want to be.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!