Teddy’s closet contains one floor buffer, forty-one rolls of paper towel (I counted, twice), a desk that used to belong to a professor, a coat that used to belong to the same professor, and, by half past seven that Friday night, four people. One of them was dead. He was standing in the gravy-colored light of the bare bulb with his hands folded, apologizing to a mop.
“I do apologize for the inconvenience,” said Aldous Finch, to the mop. “I seem to be in your way.”
“He’s here?” said Zara.
“He’s by the mop.”
“Which mop?”
“The gray one. Zara, he can’t hear you, he can only hear me.” I was holding the small brown bottle in both hands, the way I had held Biscuit through the lab door that first night. “And he can only see me because I’m terrified, so could everyone please stop asking me to elaborate.”
“Respectfully, I wasn’t asking you to elaborate.” She was looking at the bottle, and her voice was the level voice she uses when her hands are not. “I was asking you to tell me what we do now. Give me a number.”
“Four.”
“Four what?”
“I don’t know. It’s the number of us.”
Teddy, who had been standing in the closet door with his cap in his hands, put a paper bag on the desk. “You eat?” he said. He had brought tamales again, and I understood that this was his way of calling a meeting to order.
We ate. It is a rule of the necromantic arts, or at least of this particular necromantic art, that you do not look at a poisoned bottle on an empty stomach.
Then Finch told it, with me relaying, and the tidy sentences kept getting lost in the middle.
He had taken one pill every morning for eleven years, at seven, with his first tea. They were small and white and oval, and they sat in the bottle like a row of teeth. On Thursday the thirtieth he had opened the bottle at seven and found them blue. He had not thought anything of it. “The pharmacy changes the manufacturer,” he said. “They always do, and one is never told, and one simply puts up with it. I took one.”
By noon his heart was going like a rabbit in a shoebox. He had blamed the tea, then the fern, then the thermostat. By two he had taken out the bottle again and looked at it properly, in the green lamplight, and understood. He had written the letter at three. He had put it in the third drawer, the one that answers only to the Tender, because he did not know whom in the Hall he could trust with a piece of paper.
“Why didn’t you stop?” I said. It came out sharper than I meant, and I said, “Sorry.”
“Pippa.” He said my name carefully, like a man setting a cup down. “It was Thursday. The residents were expecting me at nine. I had a promise to keep, and a heart that was only racing. I did not think it would stop.” He looked at the paper towel. “I thought a person could simply be afraid and go on.”
Nobody said anything for a while. Teddy turned his cap round once in his hands.
“The coat was where?” said Zara.
“My office peg, as a rule,” said Finch. “But on the Wednesday it hung in the Dean’s anteroom for the better part of an afternoon. The listening session for the Sunset Review. Eleven people, eleven coats. I slipped out at half past two for my doctor, and left my coat on the rack, and fetched it at five, on my way back from being told I had the heart of a man of fifty. I was so happy that I did not notice it felt heavier. I bought a cake.” His mouth shook. “It was a rather good cake.”
I told them that, and the closet was quiet.
“Okay,” said Zara. She had taken out a clipboard. I have never asked where she keeps the clipboard. “Here is where we are. We have a dead professor in a vault, a Dean who believes he is on leave, and a bottle. We can’t call the police until we know what we are telling them, because if I say ‘a ghost told us’ I will be the one in a room with a lamp. So first, the pills. Pippa, you hate talking to strangers.”
“I do not hate it.”
“Count the number of times you’ve rehearsed ordering coffee.”
“Four,” I said, and she wrote it down, and I felt the closet brighten around me.
Hollis Drug is on Fenner Street between a vacuum repair shop and a place that sells nothing but candles. It has a bell on the door and a rack of reading glasses that no one has bought since 1994. I went in on Saturday morning at nine, with Zara outside at the window pretending to read the cough syrup.
I had a plan. The plan had three steps. In the first step I was calm.
The pharmacist was a woman in her fifties with half-moon glasses and a name tag that said DOLORES. I put the bottle on the counter, and my hands did what they do, and the taste of pennies came up under my tongue, and I looked at the pocket glass hanging against my sweater.
Fifty-eight. Sixty. Sixty-one.
I know about that number. Finch calls it my working number. Zara calls it the sweet spot, and I call it the place where my voice shakes and my sentences still arrive. I let myself stay there. I did not fight it. It was like holding a very large dog on a very short leash, and discovering the dog wanted to help.
“Sorry,” I said. “Quick question that is actually four questions. Is this your bottle? Is this the pill that’s supposed to be in it? What is it, if it isn’t? And did anyone else ask you about it?”
Mrs. Hollis tipped the pills out onto a paper towel and looked at them for what felt like an hour, and I counted nine ceiling tiles.
“Yes,” she said. “No. And I’ll get to the other two.” She turned the bottle and read the label aloud. “Aldous Finch. Filled October twenty-seventh. That’s my label, my handwriting on the cap. What I put in there were the little white ovals. His regular.” She poked a blue pill with a pencil. “These aren’t anything I stock. This is a wake-and-hurry pill. Doctors give it to people who fall asleep on the job. You wouldn’t give it to a man with a worried heart if you had any choice in the world.”
“Could he have gotten them anywhere else?”
“Honey, I’ve lived here forty years. You can’t get them anywhere in Kettle Mill, except one place.” She tapped the imprint with the pencil. “The campus Health Center keeps a dispensary. That’s the only shelf in town that carries this one. I know because I get a sad little fax every year telling me not to.”
My ears were ringing. My working number had climbed to seventy, and I breathed in for four and held.
“And did anyone else ask about the bottle?”
“Nobody,” said Mrs. Hollis. She looked at me over her half-moons. “Is Mr. Finch all right? He hasn’t been in to complain about the parking.”
I opened my mouth. I had a plan for that, too. In the plan I was calm.
“I’ll tell him you asked,” I said, which was true, and I was not at all sure what it was true of.
I walked out onto Fenner Street holding the bottle and the pharmacist’s handwriting, a number I could use, and a shelf in a building I had been inside a hundred times. Zara fell in beside me. She did not say anything. She handed me a candle from the candle shop (it was called Wick and Mortar, and I wish I were joking), and we stood in the cold.
My phone buzzed. Then Zara’s phone buzzed. Then, across the street, the vacuum repairman’s phone buzzed, because it was an all-staff email, and I think he was somehow on the list.
From: Aldous Finch.
Subject: A brief note of reassurance.
Dear colleagues. I write to thank you for your concern, and to assure you that I am well, and merely resting. I shall return after Thanksgiving. In the meantime, Mortuary Arts remains open, and I ask that my laboratory not be searched or disturbed. With apologies for the inconvenience, A. Finch.
I read it twice. Zara read it once.
Finch, who had followed us up Fenner Street without my noticing, hovered at my shoulder with the gray November light going through him. He read it over my arm.
“I haven’t written a word,” he said, in a voice like paper tearing. “Pippa. I have not sent anything. I could not even find the keyboard.”

