The Warden had left at six on Thursday, after a conversation in the foyer so polite that I felt it for a day afterward in my teeth.
He had brought the Lodge’s four lawyers, a notary public from Parma and the yellow foolscap, and he had asked, with great courtesy, whether he might say a few words standing, since he did not trust himself to do it sitting. Then he read, from a document he held in a hand that shook, the finding of the Lodge’s Board of Wardens, seven to two, that the Covenant of 1887 had been breached.
I had not known there was a Covenant. It turned out that Wend Hall stood on a lot of eleven acres that Josiah Wend had bought from the Lodge for one dollar, on a condition written in a deed that nobody had read since the nineteen-twenties: that the Close of Day be kept at the Hall in perpetuity, and that the Hall hold no commerce with the lake’s voice. If it failed, the land reverted.
“I abstained,” said Marrow, to the foyer. “Let it be entered that I abstained, and I have come here myself, because I did not think it right that the Board’s lawyers should be the ones to say it.” He put the paper into Maddox’s hand. “A hearing will be held Saturday at noon in this building, under Article Nine of the Charter, which the Lodge’s counsel assures me gives us standing. I am very sorry, Miss Lowell. I think I have been wrong for forty years. I do not think that it makes me any less obliged to be here.”
That was all. He turned, and the notary went with him, and I stood in the doorway with my hand on the cold brass of the plaque and thought: *Saturday*.
So on Friday I did the only thing I could think of, which was to call someone who was not alive and who did not like to be disturbed.
Octavia Wend had driven up from Columbus the night before with a trunk in her hatchback, and we set up in the basement of the Spin Cycle Coin Laundry on Fenner Street, which has the only dead wall phone in northeast Ohio that has ever been tested. It was Flo’s phone. Flo of Tamsin Lock had mailed it to me in July, in a padded envelope, with a note that said, *Hattie asked. Sorry about the postage.* It was a black Bakelite rotary thing with a long curly cord, and it hung on a pipe between a dryer and a stack of lost socks, and when I dialed nothing, it rang.
“It’s going to be crowded,” I said. “I’ve got Hattie, I’ve got Teays, and I’ve got the pin. I’m very nervous. I’ve asked everybody to be kind.”
“You’re in a laundromat,” said Octavia, kindly. “It’s a very good place for a family reunion.”
I held the receiver. Biscuit sat on the dryer at my elbow with his teeth quiet. On a folding chair beside me, wrapped in Billie’s flannel shirt, lay the fifth pin, which Billie had lent me for the afternoon against the opinion of four pilots and a nurse.
“Is she here?” said the pin, in the voice of a child at the door.
“She’s on the line,” I said. “Hattie? Mrs. Wend? It’s Pippa.”
*Honey.* The voice came down the wire, dry and quick and impossibly old, a voice from a thousand miles of pipe under the earth, with a click in it like a latch. *I’ve got the water, and it’s warm, and I’ve had a long day. Who’s on?*
“I’ve got Teays.”
*Hello, Teays.*
“Hello, Hattie,” said a voice that came, not from the receiver, but from the floor, and the walls, and the washing machines, a vast gentle clear contralto, and I felt the water in the pipes lean toward the sound like a field of grass. “Hello, Pippa. I have come up the line. I am not easy to hear on a telephone.”
“You’re fine,” I said. “You’re great.”
“I do not like to say *great*,” said Teays, with a trace of dryness. “I find it is not a word that is used of rivers by people who have to live next to one.”
I heard Octavia laugh, with a catch. “Is it always like this?” she whispered.
“Always,” I whispered back.
“Now,” I said, loud, to the room. “I want to introduce somebody. I don’t know if you’ll like it. I’ve been asked to ask. Teays, this is the, this is a piece of Lake Erie. She’s a child of the lake. She’s afraid.”
There was a long silence.
It was not the silence of a room. It was the silence of a very deep well, a mile of black water with a stone dropped down it, and for the length of a breath I thought that I had been wrong, and that it was a terrible thing to have done.
“Mother?” said the pin, in a very small voice.
“No,” said Teays. It was gentle. “No, little one. I am not your mother. I am your elder sister. I am a river. I am older than your mother is.” A pause. “I am, I believe, her *daughter*.”
“Oh,” said the pin.
“It is a long story,” said Teays. “I shall not tell it now. But I was a river before there was a lake. I ran north once, to the sea, and then the ice came, and the land lay down, and in the lowest place where I ended, she came. She was the water that stayed. She has been very good to me, in her way. She is very big, and she is very kind, and she does not always know where she ends.” The great voice softened. “She sang to me, once. Before the ice. I did not understand. I heard it as a hunger.”
“Is that why you’re hungry?” said the pin.
“It is part of why,” said Teays, “and I have thanked you for asking.”
*That’s manners,* said Hattie, with satisfaction.
I will tell you what I did, because I think it is the thing I am proudest of in that whole long summer. I held the telephone and did not say anything. I stood in a basement in a pair of rubber-soled shoes, with a hamster in a lint trap, and let the water do the talking, and at no point did I try to fix it.
They talked for an hour. A river, a ghost, and a piece of a lake, on a rotary phone in a laundromat. I could not tell you all of it, because it was theirs. I will tell you that Hattie told the pin that she had held a dam for eighty-eight years and that it was not as bad as people said, that you got used to the weight, but that she would not wish it on a child. I will tell you that Teays said it was the first time she had ever been in a conversation with someone who did not want to drink her. And I will tell you that the pin, after a long time, asked, very shyly, whether it might sing something, and that nobody said no.
It sang. It was a short thing, a lullaby, in a tin child’s voice, from the bottom of a cold dark bottle. I recognized it as a tune that I had heard in my head all spring, a tune that I had thought was my own. I stood with my forehead against the cold white lid of a dryer and wept as quietly as I could, and Octavia, in my ear, wept less quietly, and the pipes along the ceiling began, softly, one after another, to hum the harmony.
When it was done, there was a stillness. And in the stillness the pin said, in a different voice, slower and larger, the voice I had heard at dawn on the gallery, with a ring in it like a bell under water:
*Little river. Who is the one behind you?*
“Behind me?” said Teays.
*The third at the table. The old one, who does not speak. I have felt it since the first night, when you thanked me. It is older than you and I. It stands behind your chair like a person who has been waiting a long time to be asked in.* The voice dropped. *Did you not know it was there?*
On the line, Hattie drew in her breath.

