We ate lunch in the parking structure, on the tailgate of Dee’s pickup, on the third level, in a slice of thin gray light between two concrete pillars, because it was the only place in Lakeview General where nobody was crying or being pleasant.
Mrs. Odom had packed us a paper sack of ham sandwiches and a thermos of coffee that could have stripped a boat. Dee ate with one hand and held the rope in the other. Rafe sat beside her roped, flinching at every car that came up the ramp, and each flinch made Dee shut her eyes for a second, like a woman hearing a bell. Zara had fallen asleep against a pillar with Mortimer in her coat. I sat on the bumper with my glass on my knee. Nineteen. It had come up eight points since the cafeteria, with a ham sandwich and a hundred and forty people being loudly alive upstairs.
Finch stood a little apart, against the concrete rail, with his hands behind his back, looking out at the lake.
“It was a lilac,” he said.
Ruth looked up. She had been rolling a crumb of bread between her fingers into a ball. “Aldie.”
“I am only remembering. I find that I can, without any unpleasantness. It is a little like reading a very old letter in somebody else’s hand.” He did not turn around. “There was a lilac outside the window of the room on four. It was February, so it was bare, of course. Mother had asked for the bed by the glass. She said that she would like to see whether it came out.”
“Did it?” I said.
“I did not stay to see. I was fourteen.” He turned. His face was perfectly calm. “Ms. Lowell, would you care to hear it? I should like to tell somebody. I do not think I ever have, in order. And Ruth was at school, and was not there for the evening, and I think she should like to know.”
Ruth put down the ball of bread. “Tell it,” she said.
So he told it, and she told the parts he didn’t know, and I sat on the bumper and listened to two old people, one solid and one not, tell a story to each other in the voice that you use when a thing has been shut in a drawer for fifty-five years and you are surprised to find it is still the right size.
Their mother was Marguerite Finch. She taught piano. She had a heart that had been wrong since a fever at seventeen, and in the winter of 1971 it stopped being merely wrong. The doctors at Lakeview put her on the fourth floor of the Wend Pavilion, in what the staff called, with real warmth, the peaceful floor.
“It was famous for it,” said Ruth. “People used to ask for it. If you were going to die, in Cleveland, you wanted four-east. They said nobody ever died hard up there. The nurses used to say it was the architecture.”
“Nobody was ever afraid,” said Finch. “That was the thing. It was a point of pride. The families spoke of it in the elevator. ‘Mother went so gently.’ ‘Dad wasn’t scared at all.’ I used to hear them. I thought it was the most wonderful thing in the world.”
He had been in the elevator alone. That was the part he had been circling for fifty-five years. His father worked nights at a foundry, and Ruth had a spelling bee, and the nurse on the desk had said, “Go on up, honey, you know the way,” and he had gone, a thin boy of fourteen in a school blazer, with a paper bag of oranges, and stood in front of the cage with its folding brass gate and its operator, Mr. Boniface, in white gloves. He had not been in an elevator since 1968.
“I stood there a very long time,” said Finch. “I remember counting the floors on the dial, in my head. I remember that my hands were so cold that the oranges were warmer than they. And Mr. Boniface said, quite gravely, ‘Take your time, young man. I’ve got all night.’” He smiled. “He was an extremely courteous person. It has been a model to me.”
“Did you go up?”
“I went up. I counted to four hundred and six.” He looked at the lake. “It is perhaps a strange thing to be proud of. I was more frightened than I have ever been in my life, and I rode it, with my eyes shut, in a brass cage, past three landings, to a room where my mother was dying. And when I came out into the corridor, I was so afraid, Ms. Lowell, that I could not walk. I leaned against the wall. I had a nosebleed. And a very kind nurse came and gave me a handkerchief and said, ‘Oh, honey, there’s nothing to be scared of up here.’”
“She was sitting up,” said Finch. “In the bed by the window. She had her hair done. She smiled at me. She said, ‘Aldous, don’t make that face.’ And I said, ‘Mother, are you afraid?’ I had been rehearsing it for four floors. And she looked at me with her great, kind, lovely, quiet face, and she said, ‘Why on earth would I be afraid, dear? It’s lovely. Don’t fuss.’”
His voice did not shake. That was the dreadful part. It was clear and warm and slightly amused, the voice of a man who has let go of the fear that would have made it shake.
“I stayed for three hours,” he said. “She never once said she was afraid. She never said she would miss me. She said that the oranges were a nice thought and that I should eat them, and she asked whether I had my scarf. She died at ten past nine. It was a very gentle death. The nurse said so. She said, ‘It was beautiful, honey. Nobody ever goes that peaceful.’”
“And you hated it,” I said.
I had not meant to say it. It came out of me like a hiccup.
“I did not know the word,” said Finch. “I knew that I wished, with all my heart, that she had been afraid. I wished she had held my hand and said, Aldous, I am so frightened, and I do not want to leave you. I could have carried that. I could not do anything with a lovely death. I had nowhere to put it.”
Ruth had her hand over her mouth. She was looking at her brother as if she had known the story all her life and had only now been told what was in it.
“I thought,” said Finch, “it was a very peculiar thing for a person to be so afraid of an elevator, and so unafraid of death. And I became a necromancer, Ms. Lowell, because I wanted to understand what had happened to her fear. And I made a set of rules about courtesy, because it seemed to me that if a dying woman had been politely asked, once, ‘Are you frightened?’ and had been allowed to say yes, it would all have gone otherwise.”
“The Courtesies,” I said.
“Ask before you wake. Name it. Give it work. Thank it.” He put his glasses on. “I should like very much to stand here and weep. It seems to me the entirely proper thing. And I find that I am merely, a little, interested in the lake.”
Ruth got up. She walked across the concrete, forty feet, to her brother at the rail, and she put both arms around him, through him, as far as she could reach, and held on. Her cheek lay in his shoulder. She had her eyes shut. She did not say a word, and the pale wintry light came through the two of them and fell on the cement in a long soft smear.
“Ruthie,” said Finch gently. “You are embracing the railing.”
“I know I am,” said Ruth. “Shut up. I’m embracing you.”
I got up and went and stood beside Dee’s truck, with my back to them, and ate the heel of a ham sandwich very slowly, and let myself be sad, in daylight, with company, for as long as it took.
We were nearly done when Octavia came up the ramp. She was walking fast. She had her car keys in one hand and her phone in the other, and the look of a woman who has come to a decision on a staircase, and she stopped in front of the tailgate.
“I’m going to say something and it’s going to sound crazy,” said Octavia. “I have my great-grandfather’s trunk in the car.”

