“The Dray leaf is gone,” Ephraim Tull says.
He says it in the doorway of the ladies’ lounge, in a voice so soft that for a moment Josie thinks she has misheard. Behind him a woman in a sequined gown pauses at the mirror, takes in the Recorder and the matriarch and the pale new bride, and with a perfect social instinct retreats to the corridor.
“Gone,” Josie repeats.
“Cut from the Book.” Odile Vance leans both hands on her cane. She is white around the mouth, and for the first time since Josie has known her, the old woman looks every one of her seventy-eight years. “Sometime between six o’clock and nine tonight. The sequestered page was in the Chamber safe. The safe was locked. The seal was intact. The page was not.”
“Who has the key to the safe?”
“The Chair. The Recorder. Dr. Okoro, who needed access for her examination.” Odile’s eyes narrow. “And whoever stole one of the three.”
“I did not,” says Tull. He sounds close to tears.
“Ephraim, I did not say you did.”
“You did not need to.” He holds his thermos like a rosary. “I have kept the Book forty-one years. I have never once let a page leave it. I am seventy years old, Mrs. Vance, and tonight I have lost the one thing I was ever asked to keep.”
Josie’s hand, in the pocket of the midnight-blue dress, closes around the brass key until the teeth bite her palm. Wynn’s page is gone. The only copy of the true Dray record is in the hands of whoever cut it out. And the only thing still standing between the Compact and the truth is a small cold piece of metal that Celeste Arden pressed into her hand three minutes ago.
“Is Dr. Okoro all right?” she asks.
“She is in the Chair’s office, having tea. She is furious.” Odile’s mouth twitches. “She says nobody has ever stolen evidence from her before. She is thinking of taking it personally.”
“Good. I hope she does.”
Odile studies her. A long, level look. Her gaze drops to the coat Josie still holds over her arm, the navy wool Celeste pressed into her hands, and lifts again.
“That is not your coat,” Odile says.
It is a statement. Josie’s pulse thuds in her ears. She has been a mediator eight years. She has told many gentle lies to many frightened couples, and every one of them has been easier than this.
“A staff member gave it to me by mistake,” she says. “I came in here to look for the cloakroom ticket. I was feeling a little faint.”
“Faint.”
“It’s very warm in the ballroom.”
“I see.” Odile does not blink. “Ephraim, would you kindly see whether the Hunt woman has recovered from her champagne? She is sitting on the stairs.”
Tull bows, a creaky, wounded bow, and goes. The door swings shut behind him. The lounge is suddenly very quiet, and a tap drips into a marble basin.
“I will be direct, Mrs. Vance,” Odile says. “I have been lied to by experts. I have raised three children and buried two. I know what it looks like when a woman tells me something that is not true.”
“Mrs. Vance.”
“Do not interrupt. I am not going to ask you what you are hiding. If you are hiding it, you have a reason. I would only observe that the reasons women have for hiding things in this town are very rarely foolish.” She taps her cane once on the marble.
“But I will say this. If you open a door in this House and find a thing behind it that you do not like, do not close the door. Come and tell me. I would rather be angry at the truth than be kind to a lie.”
Josie looks at her. She thinks of the pencil on the back of the badge form. O. V. She thinks of Ted in the mirror, saying: she came out with a face like a closed door.
“I will,” she says.
It is the first lie she has told Odile that she does not feel in her teeth.
•
They leave the gala early. Adrian says nothing in the car. He says nothing in the front hall, or the long gallery, or the east stair. Only when they reach the door of the Peacock Room, with the house asleep around them and a single lamp burning at the end of the corridor, does he lean against the frame and say, in a very low voice:
“That was Celeste.”
“Yes.”
“She gave you something.”
Josie opens her hand. The key lies in her palm, small and brass and pitted, number 1127.
He looks at it for a long time. “A safe-deposit key.”
“At Pellham. In my sister’s maiden name. Celeste says Wynn left it with her in case anything happened.” She tells him the rest, standing in the corridor in her ballgown, whispering. The phantom spouses. The counting. Clause Twelve. The dissolution in Celeste’s name, signed by J. Larkin and witnessed by L. Fisk. The woman who came out of Chambers 4 in someone else’s blazer.
He listens without speaking. He does not touch her. When she is finished, he goes into her room and sits on the edge of the peacock bed with his elbows on his knees, a man whose long legs have decided to stop supporting him.
“Phantoms,” he says at last.
“That’s what Wynn called them.”
“Then Celeste is saying that someone has been casting Chamber votes for people who do not exist.”
“For twenty years.”
“I have sat in that chair.” His voice is flat with disbelief. “I have voted on the water charter. The vote was seven to five. If a Chamber of twelve has seven real votes and five phantoms...”
“Then the water charter might have gone the other way.”
“It might have gone the other way a hundred times.” He rubs his face with both hands. “I have been a pawn in a game I did not know was being played, and I have been proud of how well I played my part.”
“You didn’t know.”
“I did not ask.” He looks up. “That is very nearly the same thing.”
She sits beside him on the bed. It is a wide bed, and they are a careful foot apart. The lamp from the corridor throws a thin gold line across the floor.
“I told Odile I was faint,” Josie says. “She didn’t believe me.”
“She never believes anyone. It is a character trait.” He almost smiles. “Josie, I want you to hear me. I do not think my grandmother killed your sister.”
“I don’t either.”
“But I think she knows more than she says. And I think we should not tell her about the key until we know what is in the box.”
“That’s what I was going to say.”
“Good.” He pauses. “That means we are agreed on something.”
“Twice. Counting the radiator.”
This time he does smile, a full one, and it changes his whole face. For a moment he is thirty-four and tired and astonishingly young. She feels it in her chest, a small hard warmth, as if someone has lit a pilot light.
“I owe you a compliment,” he says.
“You do.”
“I said I would give it in a safer room.” He looks at the closed door, the dark window, the peacocks. “This is not very safe. But it is the best we have.”
“Go ahead.”
He turns to her fully. His eyes, gray in the lamplight, are very serious.
“You look like the first honest thing in this house,” Adrian says. “I did not know I was starving until you walked into it.”
The corridor clock ticks. Somewhere in the walls, a pipe knocks. Josie does not move. She finds that she has stopped breathing, and that it is not an unpleasant sensation.
“That is not a good compliment,” she says, unsteadily. “It’s a confession.”
“Yes. I am aware.” His mouth twists. “I have very little practice at either.”
She wants, quite suddenly and quite badly, to lean forward. She has a contract in a folder and a sister in the ground, and she is a woman who does not do this. She puts her hand flat on the bedspread, between them, and says, “Adrian. We have ninety days. And a box to open.”
“Yes.”
“I think we should do the box first.”
“Yes,” he says. He stands. His voice is a little rough. “Monday, at nine. I will have Priya meet us there. And, Josie.”
“Yes?”
“Send your friend her word. The one at ten. She will be worried.”
She laughs, startled. “How did you...”
“You said it aloud while you were waiting for the elevator. I have excellent hearing, and I am not above using it.” He opens the door. “Goodnight, Mrs. Vance.”
She sits for a long time after he has gone, her palm still flat on the bedspread, warm where it was close to his.
Then she texts Dani. *FLAMINGO.*
The reply comes in four seconds. *THANK GOD. Eat something.*
•
Pellham Bank occupies a granite block on Commerce Street, with a bronze door, a marble lobby, and a vault older than the Book.
At nine o’clock on Monday morning, Josie and Adrian and Priya Natarajan stand at the bottom of a spiral staircase that descends two floors below the street. The air is cool and dry and smells of dust and old money. At the foot, a steel door the size of a barn wall stands open, and in front of it a small, gray man in a bank blazer holds a ring of keys.
“Mrs. Vance,” says the man. “I am Mr. Whitcombe. I have kept the old vault for thirty-two years. I understand you wish to open a box held in the name of Larkin.”
“I do.”
“The customer key, please.”
She hands it over. He turns it over in his fingers, nods, and uses his own bank key in the second lock. The little steel door swings open with a sigh.
Behind them, a cool voice says, “I thought I might find you here.”
Simone Pellham comes down the spiral stair in a camel coat and boots, with a thermos in one hand and a look of polite mischief. “Don’t worry. I’m not here to stop you. I merely wanted to be present when the great Larkin box was opened. The vault records show it hasn’t been touched in three years and seven months.”
“You know about the box?”
“I know about every box in this building. It is, regrettably, my job.” Simone leans a shoulder against the cold wall. “I have never known what was in this one. The rental was under a customer name that did not match any Compact file. I assumed it was a sentimental thing. A letter. A ring. Some girl’s secret.”
“It might be.”
“It might.” Simone’s gaze rests on Adrian. “Hello, darling. You look like you haven’t slept.”
“I haven’t.”
“Good. A little guilt is good for a man’s complexion.”
Mr. Whitcombe slides the box out and sets it on a green-felt table in a small viewing room. It is a long gray metal tray, the size of a shoebox. He withdraws, with a murmur, and closes the door.
Josie lifts the lid.
There are three things inside.
On top is a thick manila envelope, sealed with red wax, with her name on it in Wynn’s handwriting. Small, quick, a little sloped. A handwriting she has not seen in three years, and her whole body goes weightless.
Beneath it, a black notebook, the cheap school kind, with a marbled cover and a rubber band. And beneath that, a single sheet of paper folded in three, with the Compact’s black seal at the top.
“Open the envelope,” Adrian says gently.
Her hands are shaking. She breaks the wax. Inside is a letter, two pages, in blue ink. She reads the first line aloud, because she cannot make herself read it silently.
“’Jo. If you’re reading this, I was right to be scared, and you were right about the machine.’” Her voice breaks. She stops. Priya, without a word, hands her a tissue.
She reads on in silence.
*I’m sorry about the last thing I said to you. I didn’t mean it. I want you to know I never stopped being proud of you. I’ve started counting, Jo. It started as a game. It isn’t one anymore. There are people in the Book who don’t exist, and the people who put them there are very careful, and I think they know I know.*
*The notebook has everything. Dates, names, vote counts. I’ve tried to be exact. I don’t have the last page yet. When I get it, I’ll take it to Beatrix. If you’re reading this, I didn’t.*
*The paper in the box is a rider. I signed it the day after I entered the Dray Term, in front of Mr. Whitcombe, who is the only honest man in the building. It names you as my successor. It means if I die, you aren’t a sister. You are a House. You’ll have a voice in the Book. They can’t shut you out. It was the only thing I could think of.*
*Don’t trust anyone who tells you it was a fall. Don’t trust anyone who tells you it wasn’t. Trust the numbers.*
*I love you. Pet the cat for me.*
The last line makes her laugh and sob in the same breath, a wet, helpless sound. The cat was a gray stray named Duchess who lived in their mother’s yard. Duchess has been dead for six years.
Adrian’s hand is on her shoulder. She does not remember him moving. She leans into it, and for one long moment lets herself be held up by something that is not her own spine.
“Josie,” Priya says quietly. “The rider.”
Josie unfolds it. It is a half page, formal, brief, under the Compact seal. In a beautiful clear hand: *I, Winifred Larkin Dray, being of sound mind, declare my sister Josephine Anne Larkin my Successor of Term, with all standing, privilege, and estate appertaining, in the event of my death or dissolution. Witnessed: Aldous Whitcombe, Pellham Bank. Dated: the fifth of June.*
“She was twenty-two,” Josie whispers. “She was twenty-two and she wrote a will.”
“She wrote a shield,” Priya says. “Josie, do you understand what this means? Clause Twelve says a spouse’s estate goes to the House unless a successor is named in a sealed rider within one year. She named you within a day. On its face, the Dray patents, the glassworks shares, the whole estate, are yours. The House of Dray will say the year to disclose it has lapsed. We will say a forged renewal and a vanished leaf stopped that clock.”
“I don’t want it.”
“It is not a matter of wanting. It is a matter of the law, and there are people who would very much like it not to exist.” Priya looks at the notebook. “Is that what I think it is?”
Josie takes it. It is a battered, ordinary thing. She slips the rubber band off and opens to the first page.
Columns. Dates. Names, a hundred of them, in small neat handwriting. Next to each name, a House, a Term, a vote. And a code in the margin, a small letter. P. For phantom. Or perhaps for paper.
At the top of the first page, in Wynn’s blocky capitals, a heading: *WHO VOTES?*
“My God,” Adrian says softly. “She did it. She kept the whole count.”
Simone has come to stand in the doorway. She is no longer smiling. She holds her thermos in both hands, and her green eyes, fixed on the notebook, are very wide.
“There’s a name on the third page,” she says slowly. “In the Pellham column.”
Josie turns the page. Halfway down, in Wynn’s neat hand, is an entry she has to read twice.
*Anselm Pellham, 4th Term, Pellham. Never seen. Never photographed. Voted nine times.*
“Anselm Pellham is my uncle,” Simone says. “He died in a car accident when I was six.”
“Then somebody is still voting for him.”
“Somebody has been voting for him for twenty-six years.” Simone’s voice is barely above a whisper. “In my chair.”
A knock sounds on the glass of the viewing-room door, sharp and urgent. Whitcombe’s face appears, gray and sweating. He opens it a hand’s width.
“Miss Pellham. Forgive me. There are men upstairs. County officers, with a Chamber writ. They have a paper.” His throat works. “They say it is a Writ of Seizure against the Larkin box and its contents, signed by the Chair. They say they have been sent to retrieve a stolen item.”
Priya swears, softly and fluently, in two languages.
“How long?” Adrian asks.
“They are at the top of the stair. Two minutes. I told them I must retrieve the box from the viewing room under the Compact’s rules. It will not hold them longer.”
Josie looks at the notebook in her hand. She looks at the letter, the rider, the key. She looks at Adrian. He has already taken out his phone.
“Page by page,” he says. “Quickly. Priya, the rider. Simone, I’m sorry. You’re about to be an accessory.”
“My darling Adrian,” says Simone Pellham, and takes the notebook out of Josie’s hands, and slides it, with astonishing grace, into the front of her camel coat, “I’ve been waiting my entire life to be an accessory.”

