By Friday evening, six of the nineteen units were in crates, and Nell had stopped pretending that the number meant anything.
She sat on the folding chair by the retention pond with a blanket over her knees and a paper cup of tea that Priya had wedged between her wrists like a cup in a vise. The lantern on its pole threw its yellow track across the water. The unit still sat on the bottom, three yards out, its arm raised, its fingers flat. It had not moved in three days. Rao’s deputies had stopped looking at it directly and had started looking at the weather.
Dale Rusk had been as good as his word. By noon he had crated Rowan Ridge. By two he had done Lakeline and Redfield, in each case with a rota of counters and the lid lowered at a dignified crawl, and by four he had added the Calder unit and the one from Lake Lights and a third from the county garage.
By five he had called the board’s office and told a very junior man that a hydraulic lift had failed and that the rest would have to wait for Monday. Nell had no idea whether this was true. She suspected that Rusk did not either.
All six lay quiet. Dara’s was the unit nobody had managed to crate. It was still at the bottom of the deep end at Orrin Valley, where it had gone when the lid banged, and nobody could make it come up.
“Hana says there’s a boy swimming it,” Priya said. She had a phone in her lap and a blanket of her own. “A lifeguard. Nineteen. He’s been stood by the edge all afternoon with a floating tray, telling it the score of a baseball game.”
“Does it listen?”
“He says it nods in the right places.” She looked up. “Is that good?”
“It means we’re not the only ones who’ve decided that the thing can hear.”
“Is that good?”
Nell watched the lantern’s reflection tremble on the black water. “Ask me on Monday,” she said.
---
Joan Senn-Hobbs came at ten.
Nell heard the car first, a quiet engine on the access road, and then the careful slam of one door. There was only one set of footsteps on the grass. Joan walked down the slope alone, in her navy cardigan with a long gray coat over it, with a small black purse held in both hands. The deputy by the tape half rose, saw her face, and sat down again.
Priya stood. “I’ll be at the car.”
“You don’t have to go,” said Joan.
“I think I do.” Priya looked at Nell, then at Joan, with an expression that was uncannily like a nurse’s, and went, soundless on the damp grass, as though she had been taught how.
Joan lowered herself onto the second folding chair. She smoothed her coat across her knees. For a time she watched the water, and Nell watched it with her, and the frogs, who had come back in the warmth of the afternoon, kept up their ragged chorus along the reeds.
“Alan wanted to come,” Joan said. “I asked him to wait in the hotel. He’s reading the old news stories. He says it’s his way of being useful.” She almost smiled. “He still thinks he has to prove himself to a woman who married him on the second date.”
“I have something of yours,” Nell said.
She had the brass key in her inside pocket. She could not take it out, so she tipped her shoulder, and Joan, after a pause, reached across and slid it out with two fingers, and held it up between them, small and gold in the lantern light.
“Gordon’s attic,” Joan said.
“He said there’s nothing in the trunk that matters to the court. It’s what he made her night out of.”
“I read that in the paper.” Joan closed her hand over it. “He sent me a letter, too, through his lawyer. It’s four pages. I read the first and the last and put it in a drawer.” She looked at Nell. “I’m angry with you, you know. I’m very angry. I’ve been angry since Wednesday, in the car, and in the hotel, and in the shower, which is where I do the best of it. I wanted to tell you before I said anything else.”
“I’d like you to be.”
“Della said that. She said she’d like me to be angry.” Joan turned the key over. “It’s so odd how everybody wants it. As if it were a kind of fee.”
“It’s not a fee. It’s just true.”
“Yes. That’s what I decided. It’s true, and it’s also not the only true thing.” She let out a breath that clouded. “I read the notebook six times. I read it in the lobby and in the car and in the bathroom.
I read the line about the taps, and I read it again, and then, around two o’clock this morning, I read the line before that. *Told Nell to stay on the count. She’ll do it.* And I thought, she trusted you. She *chose* you. It wasn’t an accident that you were holding the rail.”
“That makes it worse.”
“Does it?” Joan looked at her steadily. “Because it seems to me she was an experienced woman, who knew what two taps meant, who hated them, and who told you in her own handwriting that you would count. If I’m to put you in the dock, I have to put her there, too, for trusting. And I can’t. I won’t.” She stood up, holding the key like a talisman. “I’ve decided that I don’t get to choose which half of her to believe.”
Nell could not speak. She sat with her ruined hands in her lap and her face wet, and she did nothing about it, because there was nothing in the world to do.
“Show me the card,” said Joan.
---
She had brought Ruth’s tab. Of course she had. She took it from the black purse and laid it on the arm of the chair beside the other, the blank one with the writing on it, and the two lay side by side in the glow of the lantern, one in Joan’s hand, the other in Nell’s: *R. SENN*, with *NOT COMPLETE* written across the date line in Joan’s firm upright print, and *N. VOSS. Sunday. 8:29 p.m. And so will she.* in the slanted blue.
“It said it would write what I told it,” Nell said. “On the pond edge, before dawn on Wednesday. It wrote that, and then it wrote a line I didn’t say.”
“Because I’d already said it.”
“You hadn’t said anything.”
“I said it on Tuesday,” said Joan. “Alone, in the car park, at six in the morning. I said, ‘Whatever it is, I’ll be there.’ I was only talking to my own hands.” She sat down again, and with great deliberation took the stub of ballpoint, in its clear sleeve, from the tray beside Nell’s knee. “I want to try something.”
“Joan, the ink won’t take. Tessa tried, she tried four times, and it simply goes out.”
“Tessa isn’t the person who has to write it.”
She slipped the pen out of the sleeve. It was small and blue and worn at the shoulder, a pen for a pocket, and she held it with the grip of a woman who had graded eleven thousand spelling tests. She turned Nell’s tab over and set the point against the blank back of it, on her knee. “Tell it what you want it to say. I’ll write it. I’m very neat.”
“I don’t know what the card is for.”
“Yes, you do. You’ve known all along. You only needed someone to be sitting here.” Joan’s voice was kind. “You told a pond in the middle of the night that you’d be there. That’s an answer. It isn’t the answer. What do you owe my sister?”
The frogs had gone silent. Out on the water, the lantern’s yellow line lay unbroken to the raised hand.
“Six seconds,” said Nell.
“Say it as a sentence.”
“I will count Ruth Senn to one hundred.” Her voice shook. She made it steady. “On Sunday, at eight twenty-nine, out loud, at her pace. I’ll start from the beginning, not from ninety-four. I’ll keep my hand off the rail.” She swallowed. “I tapped at ninety-four. I didn’t hear her say *again.* I’m not going to say I couldn’t have. I’ll say I didn’t.”
Joan wrote. The point scratched softly. She wrote in her own square upright hand, not Ruth’s, fast and unrelenting, as she must have written a thousand comments in the margins of children’s work, and the blue went onto the paper and stayed.
*N. VOSS will count R. SENN to one hundred. Sunday, 8:29 p.m. Out loud, from the beginning. N. tapped at ninety-four and did not hear “again.” She is here.*
“Is there more?” Joan asked.
“No. That’s all.”
“There’s a place for a signature.”
“I can’t sign. You know I can’t.”
“Then I’ll sign for you. That’s what a witness is for.” Joan wrote two letters, J. S-H., in the corner, and under it, after the smallest hesitation, a third. *R.* She stared at it. “That one isn’t mine,” she said, very quietly. “I don’t know where it came from.”
The blue lines on the card did not fade. For the first time in four days, a tab held ink.
---
They stood at the water’s edge together, with the lantern pole at their shoulders.
Nell had assumed she would have to throw the card, or wade in. She had assumed, in the part of her mind that went on making plans while the rest of her wept, that some ceremony would be needed. It wasn’t. When she lifted the tab between two fingers and held it over the pond, as far as her bandaged hand could stretch, there was a ripple in the middle, and the raised arm of the unit began to rise.
It came up slowly through the black water. First the wrist, with its yellow thread, then the shoulder and the vest, then the head with its two pale rings, streaming, expressionless, entirely calm. It stood on the bottom of the pond with the water at its chest.
It had been under for three days and its orange vest was a ruin. It walked toward them in the long, even stride of a thing unhurried by any time but its own, and it stopped at the edge, in the shallows, in the reeds.
It held out its hand.
Nell laid the card in the palm. The hand closed. The unit stood there reading it, if reading was what it was doing, for the length of a long breath, with Joan beside her and the lantern’s light on the wet gray planes of its face.
“Ruth,” Joan said, to the unit. It was not a question. “You’ve heard her say it.”
The unit’s head turned to her.
For a moment nobody breathed. Then the hand opened, and the unit lifted the card, and tilted it toward the light so that they could see what had been added at the bottom, below Joan’s neat blue lines, in the other hand, the slanted one, the one that wrote fast without letting the lines rot.
It was two sentences. Nell read them aloud.
*Out loud. With all of them.*
*Nobody counts alone.*
“All of them,” said Joan. “All nineteen?”
“All nineteen,” said the unit, in Nell’s voice, and then in Joan’s, and then in a third voice that Nell had never heard and knew at once, a good clear alto with the hoarseness of cold, a patient voice, the voice of a woman who had asked twice and been told to wait. “Sunday. Everybody. Stand. Count. Don’t stop.”
“Don’t stop at a hundred?”
The unit looked at her out of its rings.
“There’s more after a hundred,” it said, in Ruth’s voice, and Joan made a tiny sound and put her hand on her mouth.
“What?” said Nell. “What comes after?”
But it only turned, with the card closed in its fist, and walked slowly back into the pond, until the water took its shoulders and its head and the last of the raised hand.
---
Brandt arrived at eleven, in his own car, off duty and unshaved. Nell had asked him to come. She told him all of it in the lantern light, in order, with Joan beside her as a witness, and she dictated a statement on his phone’s recorder that began, “I tapped twice at ninety-four on the night of Ruth Senn’s death,” and went on to the end.
“This will go to counsel,” Brandt said, quietly, when she had finished. “It’s a formal admission. They’ll hold it against your license, if you ever apply to get it back. They’ll hold it against Pinecrest.”
“I know.”
“I’m obliged to say it.”
“I’d like you to say it,” Nell said. “I’d like everybody to say it. That’s what it’s for.”
He pressed the button. The red light went out.
Joan had not moved from her chair. She said, without turning her head, “Sergeant Brandt. The man in the cell. Dennis Pike. Is he still saying it?”
“Every time anyone in the room stops talking.” Brandt sat down on the grass, heavily, in his good trousers. “The deputies have started to take turns reading him the sports page, just so there’s always a voice. He says it when the voice stops. One word. ‘Six.’ Nobody’s told him it’s anyone’s voice but his own.”
“It’s mine,” Nell said. “It’s how I say it. A beat of nothing, and then the number, flat.”
“I know. I listened to the tape.” He looked at his hands. “I think he’s holding the gap for you. He’s keeping the six seconds open, in a cell, with a sports page, because he doesn’t know what else to do with it.”
“Then Sunday’s for him too,” said Joan. “I’ll say that in the car. Everyone’s coming for someone, it seems.”
Nobody answered. Out on the water the lantern had begun to flicker as its battery went, and Tessa, who had come down the slope with a spare from the trunk, stood a moment with it in her hands, listening, before she remembered to climb up to the pole and change it.
It was Priya who heard the first sound, from the top of the grass, where she had been sitting on the hood of the car with Tessa. She came down the slope at a run. In the lantern light her face was bright and terrified.
“Nell. Nell, it’s the phones. Everybody’s phones. Rusk’s calling, it’s Hana, it’s Dara, it’s the rota chat. It’s midnight.” She was gasping. “Every one of them is standing up.”
“The crated ones?”
“The crated ones. All six. They got up inside the crates, and nobody’s touched the latches, and the lids are, Rusk says the lids are lifting off.” She held out the phone. On the screen, from Rusk’s cab, shaky and gray, a garage came into view: a long concrete room, the row of pale cases along the wall, and in each of them, slowly, with a small hiss of the struts, a lid rising to show a standing figure.
In the corner of the picture, over the door, a wall clock said eleven fifty-nine.
“It’s not Sunday,” Nell said.
“They don’t think it is,” said Joan, quite calmly. She put the brass key in her pocket. “They think it’s the first day of the count. And I believe, Nell, that you just told them you were ready to begin.”

